Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / Alien

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another issue is regarding what kind of situations the aliens would be used for. If the Engineers simply want to wipe out a population without any kind of occupation, then they're pretty effective. But, they would be useless for any other kind of military action, like colonization, since the planet would be uninhabitable after infection. So if they were used for biowarfare, it was probably only done for extreme situations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The self-destruct refusing to abort in the first film after Ripley tries turning the coolant back on may seem like shoddy ship design and a bit of AIIsACrapshoot on Mother's part, but a close examination of the instructions on the lid of the console shows an important piece of information that Ripley completely fails to notice: that the abort sequence will only work if the safety interlocks (the two levers that Ripley has to pull to open the lid) are engaged ''prior'' to inputting the abort code, not after, meaning the cut-off system was never going to work even if Ripley still had plenty of time left, simply because she performed the abort sequence in the wrong order.

to:

* The self-destruct refusing failing to abort in the first film after Ripley tries turning the coolant back on may seem like shoddy ship design and a bit of AIIsACrapshoot on Mother's part, but a close examination of the instructions on the lid of the console shows an important piece of information that Ripley completely fails to notice: that the abort sequence will only work if the safety interlocks (the two levers that Ripley has to pull to open the lid) are engaged reengaged ''prior'' to inputting the abort code, not after, meaning the cut-off system was never going to work even if Ripley still had plenty of time left, simply because she performed the abort sequence in the wrong order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The self-destruct override refusing to activate in the first film after Ripley tries aborting the sequence may seem like shoddy ship design and a bit of AIIsACrapshoot on Mother's part, but a close examination of the instructions on the lid of the self-destruct console shows an important piece of information that Ripley completely fails to notice: that the abort code will not work if the safety interlocks (the two levers that Ripley has to pull to open the console) are disengaged, meaning the self-destruct was never going to be stopped even if Ripley had plenty of time left, simply because she did the abort sequence in the wrong order.

to:

* The self-destruct override refusing to activate abort in the first film after Ripley tries aborting turning the sequence coolant back on may seem like shoddy ship design and a bit of AIIsACrapshoot on Mother's part, but a close examination of the instructions on the lid of the self-destruct console shows an important piece of information that Ripley completely fails to notice: that the abort code sequence will not only work if the safety interlocks (the two levers that Ripley has to pull to open the console) lid) are disengaged, engaged ''prior'' to inputting the abort code, not after, meaning the self-destruct cut-off system was never going to be stopped work even if Ripley still had plenty of time left, simply because she did performed the abort sequence in the wrong order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The self-destruct override refusing to activate in the first film after Ripley tries aborting the sequence may seem like shoddy ship design and a bit of AIIsACrapshoot on Mother's part, but a close examination of the instructions on the lid of the self-destruct console shows an important piece of information that Ripley completely fails to notice: that the abort code will not work if the safety interlocks (the two levers that Ripley has to pull to open the console) are disengaged, meaning the self-destruct was never going to be stopped even if Ripley had plenty of time left, simply because she did the abort sequence in the wrong order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** None of the crew knew Ash was an android until he attacked Ripley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is a little fuzzy because we're never told where xenomorph queens come from, but with a reliable way to grow new queens xenomorphs can breed extremely quickly. Additionally, they tend to act as ambush predators and seem to build their hives in hidden or reinforced locations, so gunning them down from range or bombing them is very hard to do. You have to send troops in to hunt them down (which lets the bugs hunt them in turn) or else hit them with absolutely spectacular levels of overkill to be sure you got them. And if the enemy has to nuke their own cities to get rid of them, that counts as an effective weapon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** There's a lot of hints that the government would be very ticked with this endeavor. You can't just launch a ship for covert ops, because the ship ''would'' be noticed, and "Why are you sending a ship to the middle of nowhere?" is not a question they want to answer. However, "This crew of hick space truckers accidentally picked up some sort of creature investigating a distress call." would be fair more believable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Why did Weyland-Yutani go to all this trouble to set up the Nostromo and trick the crew? Since bringing back an alien lifeform was illegal, why not just send a covert operation? They are a rich mega-corporation so bribing officials and doing things off the record seems like it would have been easier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The trick is to think of them as biological mines, designed to harass and cause havoc in military communication and logistics areas. Yes, in open ground without support they can be killed. But a few or many dropped into rear echelon zones, causing panic and fear and denying the areas to an enemy until they divert frontline resources to combat it. (A bug-hunt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* There’s something about the [[UncannyValley oddly-human mouth]] of the Xenomorph that’s very troubling. That “something” probably being its usual expression before it strikes: it looks ''angry.'' Let that sink in a little. Not only does this monster want to kill you/use you for breeding stock, '''[[OhCrap it absolutely fucking hates you.]]'''

to:

* There’s something about the [[UncannyValley oddly-human mouth]] mouth of the Xenomorph that’s very troubling. That “something” probably being its usual expression before it strikes: it looks ''angry.'' Let that sink in a little. Not only does this monster want to kill you/use you for breeding stock, '''[[OhCrap it absolutely fucking hates you.]]'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Crew Expendable'''. The order is so simple, banal and comes across as a bit of an afterthought. You, your hopes dreams, aspirations and life boiled down to quantifiable asset to be disposed of to increase the companies sales figures.

to:

* '''Crew Expendable'''. The order is so simple, banal and comes across as a bit of an afterthought. You, your hopes hopes, dreams, aspirations and life boiled down to a quantifiable asset to be disposed of to increase the companies company's sales figures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* '''Crew Expendable'''. The order is so simple, banal and comes across as a bit of an afterthought. You, your hopes dreams, aspirations and life boiled down to quantifiable asset to be disposed of to increase the companies sales figures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Also, Ash doesn't get violent and "twitchy" until after Ripley slams him against the wall of the computer room...and he hits the back of his head against the wall. Considering how Aliens made a note of how shoddy his model was, it's entirely possible Ripley might have accidentally damaged something in his head. Coupled with her figuring out he's TheMole, he might have decided enough was enough...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And, for another example of Fridgey Ash's equipment choices: the scanner he provides for the search is designed to detect air movement, rather than heat, sound, odors, or other subtle hints of life. Of course it does, because any other type of sensor he might've come up with would probably also discern that ''Ash himself'' doesn't register the same as the human crew members, thus exposing him as an android ringer.

to:

** And, for another example of Fridgey Ash's equipment choices: the scanner he provides for the search is designed to detect air movement, disturbances, rather than body heat, sound, vibrations, odors, or other subtle hints of life. Of course it does, because any other ''other'' type of sensor he might've come up with would probably also discern that ''Ash himself'' doesn't register the same as registers differently from the human crew members, thus exposing him as an android ringer.
ringer. But his shape displaces air exactly as a human's would.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And, for another example of Fridgey Ash's equipment choices: the scanner he provides for the search is designed to detect air movement, rather than heat, sound, odors, or other subtle hints of life. Of course it does, because any other type of sensor he might've come up with, would probably also discern that ''Ash himself'' doesn't register the same as the human crew members, thus exposing him as an android ringer.

to:

** And, for another example of Fridgey Ash's equipment choices: the scanner he provides for the search is designed to detect air movement, rather than heat, sound, odors, or other subtle hints of life. Of course it does, because any other type of sensor he might've come up with, with would probably also discern that ''Ash himself'' doesn't register the same as the human crew members, thus exposing him as an android ringer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And, for another example of Fridgey Ash's equipment choices: the scanner he provides for the search is designed to detect air movement, rather than heat, sound, odors, or other subtle hints of life. Of course it does, because any other type of sensor he might've come up with, would probably also discern that ''Ash himself'' doesn't register the same as the human crew members, thus exposing him as an android ringer.

Added: 323

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even moreso, if you consider what ''Prometheus'' reveals about the Xenomorph's derivation ''from Engineer science'' gone wrong. Studying them doesn't just provide a weapon proven to have taken out Engineer vessels at least twice in the past, but also potential insight into the threat posed by the Engineers themselves.



* Robots are difficult to build and expensive AF in the Alien Franchise... If ''Film/{{Prometheus}}'' is canon, robots were already a thing some 30 years before the first ''Alien'' film. But David seems to be a novelty and works as some sort of personal assistant for millionaire Peter Weyland. Then, in ''Alien'', Ash doesn't come across as a more advanced robot than David. Moreover, howcome humans are still necessary to man the ''Nostromo'' ship instead of just putting there a couple of robots to run the whole operation? If Ash can pass for a science officer, why not some other robot(s) as a navigator or ship engineer? Then in ''Aliens'', again only Bishop is a robot. I can sort of understand that robots may not be trusted to function as colonial marines, but why isn't there any mention of robots as colonists? Instead of sending dozens of humans to colonize, why not send a handful of robots as an avantgarde? Centuries later, in ''Resurrection'', Call is again the only robot in the film, not only that, but the models seem to be getting worse and worse, since by now they question orders. But the real people don't even seem to keep any Ash, David or Bishop models (Bishop being so far the only seemingly trust-worthy model in the entire franchise universe). This implies that the field of robotics is more difficult than thought, and also that robots are super-expensive despite decades of progress between the films, so much so, that they still haven't really replaced humans in menial/dangerous jobs.
* As noted on the page for the first film, the Nostromo's systems start venting excess heat into the crew spaces when they shut off the cooling system as part of the self-destruct, noting that it's poor design for venting heat. Except it's ''not''- since self-destructing the Nostromo requires putting the reactor into a thermally-induced death spiral, venting the heat back into the ship is going to speed the process up by heating up the air around it.

to:

* Robots are difficult to build and expensive AF in the Alien Franchise... If ''Film/{{Prometheus}}'' is canon, robots were already a thing some 30 years before the first ''Alien'' film. But David seems to be a novelty and works as some sort of personal assistant for millionaire Peter Weyland. Then, in ''Alien'', Ash doesn't come across as a more advanced robot than David. Moreover, howcome how come humans are still necessary to man the ''Nostromo'' ship instead of just putting there a couple of robots to run the whole operation? If Ash can pass for a science officer, why not some other robot(s) as a navigator or ship engineer? Then in ''Aliens'', again only Bishop is a robot. I can sort of understand that robots may not be trusted to function as colonial marines, but why isn't there any mention of robots as colonists? Instead of sending dozens of humans to colonize, why not send a handful of robots as an avantgarde? Centuries later, in ''Resurrection'', Call is again the only robot in the film, not only that, but the models seem to be getting worse and worse, since by now they question orders. But the real people don't even seem to keep any Ash, David or Bishop models (Bishop being so far the only seemingly trust-worthy model in the entire franchise universe). This implies that the field of robotics is more difficult than thought, and also that robots are super-expensive despite decades of progress between the films, so much so, that they still haven't really replaced humans in menial/dangerous jobs.
* As noted on the page for the first film, the Nostromo's ''Nostromo'''s systems start venting excess heat into the crew spaces when they shut off the cooling system as part of the self-destruct, noting that it's poor design for venting heat. Except it's ''not''- since self-destructing the Nostromo ''Nostromo'' requires putting the reactor into a thermally-induced death spiral, venting the heat back into the ship is going to speed the process up by heating up the air around it.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Film fans have been giving whoever came up with the famous tag-line too much credit. Instead of being read as "In space, no-one can '''hear''' you scream", which of course is because there is no medium in space to transmit soundwaves through, the person was probably thinking "Space, space, space... it's empty, it's vast, assistance isn't close at hand... What about 'In space, '''no-one''' can hear you scream'?. Yes, that's a brilliant idea."

Changed: 554

Removed: 605

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed natter


** If you're fighting a stand-up war, sure. But Xenomorphs clearly aren't a weapon of war, they're a weapon of terror. They're designed to be as frighteningly efficient at killing as possible, and even if you can defend yourself against them, their acid blood will do a good job at damaging or destroying nearby infrastructure. They may make an easy target clustered in hives, but first you have to find the hive, and Xenomorphs are sneaky above all else. Adding all this up means that, while Xenomorphs might not win you a war, they'll certainly distract and disrupt your enemy, giving you the advantage.



** Because you contaminate everything between the airlock and the medbay just getting them there. And there's no guarantee that they'd be able to neutralise any dangerous contaminate even if they managed to restrict it to the medbay.
** Also, Ash wasn't known to be an android initially. He was a last-second replacement by the Company (because they wanted TheMole to help them get the Alien). Just keeping the potentially infected crewmember outside the ship for 24 hours while you run every decontamination protocol known to man is far more effective.

to:

** Because you contaminate everything between the airlock and the medbay just getting them there. And there's no guarantee that they'd be able to neutralise any dangerous contaminate even if they managed to restrict it to the medbay.
** Also, Ash wasn't known to be an android initially. He was a last-second replacement by the Company (because they wanted TheMole to help them get the Alien). Just keeping the potentially infected crewmember outside the ship for 24 hours while you run every decontamination protocol known to man is far more effective.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the Analysis page.

Added DiffLines:

* Ash states that the organism has a habit of "turning it's cells to polarized silicon." That means a bond between silicon and stable atoms, likely carbon. The real world equivalent to this is called silicon carbide, and is used in brake pads and bullet proof vests. This would help to explain why Ash suggests to use flamethrowers: he knows they'll be useless, ensuring the organism's safe capture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not canon


** Development on androids was probably slowed due to a lot of red tape -- their predecessors, the Replicants, caused a lot of problems when they rebelled and nobody wanted a repeat of the Roy Batty incident.

Top