Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / WarOfTheWorlds2005

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BystanderActionHorrorDissonance: During [[spoiler: Ray's murder of Ogilvy]] we only hear the sound of the fight as we focus on a blindfolded Rachel singing herself a lullaby.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When the first Tripod emerges, the ground doesn't simply rise up, but instead begins slowly rotating, similar to the unscrewing of the cylinder's lid in the original novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Ogilvy isn't that sane to begin with, but he really loses it when he finds out about the tripods harvesting humans.

to:

* GoMadFromTheRevelation: Ogilvy isn't that sane to begin with, [[GoMadFromTheApocalypse but he really loses it when he finds out about the tripods harvesting humans.humans]].

Added: 236

Removed: 190

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MurderIsTheBestSolution: As Ogilvy's behavior becomes more unstable, Ray fears that he'll get them caught by the aliens. When Ogilvy ignores Ray's warnings to quiet down, [[spoiler: Ray decides to kill him to protect Rachel's life]].






* ViolenceReallyIsTheAnswer: As Ogilvy's behavior becomes more unstable, Ray keeps trying to reason with him, [[spoiler: but finally has no choice but to kill him to protect Rachel's life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PottyEmergency: Rachel has one and stops to relieve herself by a river, but before she can go she's traumatized when she sees a bunch of bodies, and starts to panic until Ray gets her out of there. Since she doesn't have to go afterwards, it's implied that the shock of seeing this [[PottyFailure caused her to go in her pants]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IKissYourHand: Ray kisses Rachel's hands when getting her to sing [[spoiler: so she won't hear his murder of Ogilvy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigDamnHug: Ray hugs Rachel intensely [[spoiler: just before he kills Ogilvy to protect her]].

Added: 1079

Changed: 450

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example(s)


* AdaptationInspiration: As with all of the movie adaptations of the book, this one updates the setting and time period, and frames it in the tensions of the day. It also draws down the focus to a single family and takes on something of a war documentary feel. An allegory of the original [[TheGayNineties 1898]] novel was imperialism and colonialism (the Martians representing the British Empire), while the 1953 film paralleled the UsefulNotes/ColdWar and the RedScare and the 2005 version comments on 9/11[[invoked]] and the War on Terror.

to:

* AdaptationInspiration: As with all of the movie adaptations of the book, this one updates the setting and time period, and frames it in the tensions of the day. It also draws down the focus to a single family and takes on something of a war documentary feel. An allegory of the original [[TheGayNineties 1898]] novel was imperialism and colonialism (the Martians representing the British Empire), while the 1953 film paralleled the UsefulNotes/ColdWar and the RedScare and the 2005 version comments on 9/11[[invoked]] 9/11 and the overall War on Terror.Terror[[invoked]].



* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: The alien invasion has many deliberate similarities to 9/11. The shot of the vaporized victims' clothes floating down recalls the paper falling from the sky after the towers went down, the shot of Ray covered head-to-toe in grey ash after escaping the first tripod, and there's a pretty deliberate shot of a wall covered by pictures of missing people. When she sees the heat ray, Rachel even asks "Is it the terrorists?"

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything:
**
The initial alien invasion has many deliberate similarities to 9/11. The shot of the vaporized victims' clothes floating down recalls the paper falling from the sky after the towers went down, the shot of Ray covered head-to-toe in grey ash after escaping the first tripod, and there's a pretty deliberate shot of a wall covered by pictures of missing people. When she sees the heat ray, Rachel even asks "Is it the terrorists?"terrorists?"
** By the second act, however, the aliens then become eerily reminiscent of the American military forces following 9/11. The shots of displaced civilians marching for safety, towns and cities being in complete ruins, and the transformation of a once-healthy environment into a desolate barren hellhole bring to mind the Iraq and Afghanistan wars and the chaos that subsequently ensued in the Middle East. The use of blood harvesting can also be seen as a metaphor for the numerous war crimes committed by soldiers during the war. This fact was made abundantly clear by Spielberg and David Koepp who both described the film as being 'anti-Iraq war'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no computers in it, has an entirely mechanically operated powertrain and in theory likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without and generally avoided this trope. Its handwaved by the writers in that Robbie took it for a joyride and it nonsensically died during the EMP attack, despite the aforementioned.

to:

** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no computers in it, has an entirely mechanically operated powertrain and in theory likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without and generally avoided this trope. Its handwaved by the writers in that Robbie took it for a joyride and it nonsensically died during the EMP attack, despite the aforementioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no advanced electronics in its powertrain and in theory likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without requiring such an AssPull in the script. Its handwaved by the writers in that Robbie took it for a joyride and it nonsensically died during the EMP attack, despite the aforementioned.

to:

** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no advanced electronics computers in its it, has an entirely mechanically operated powertrain and in theory likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without requiring such an AssPull in the script.and generally avoided this trope. Its handwaved by the writers in that Robbie took it for a joyride and it nonsensically died during the EMP attack, despite the aforementioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no advanced electronics in its powertrain and likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without requiring such an AssPull in the script.

to:

** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no advanced electronics in its powertrain and in theory likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without requiring such an AssPull in the script. Its handwaved by the writers in that Robbie took it for a joyride and it nonsensically died during the EMP attack, despite the aforementioned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1993 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked. Also, Manny showcases that the Voyager's starter was fried to a crisp by the EMP attack, which honestly defies explanation. You could argue the whole "replace the solenoid" line was simply an AssPull from the writers.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1993 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked. Also, Manny showcases that the Voyager's starter was fried to a crisp by the EMP attack, which honestly defies explanation.explanation, as well as how its radio is still functional. You could argue the whole "replace the solenoid" line was simply an AssPull from the writers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The immediate aftermath of the EMP attack is reminiscent of the 2003 northeast blackout, which affected the area the film is set in. Particularly the scenes of the [[https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/98/2003_New_York_City_blackout.jpg streets being crowded with foot traffic]] as most transportation has been grounded and dead cars[[note]]In the RealLife scenario, they ran out of gas due to most gas stations in affected areas being knocked offline[[/note]] are being pushed off of the road.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Minor example - Ray honks the Voyager's horn by hitting the center of the steering wheel. On a 1993 Plymouth Voyager the horn is operated by buttons on the bottom steering wheel spokes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked. Also, Manny showcases that the Voyager's starter was fried to a crisp by the EMP attack, which honestly defies explanation. You could argue the whole "replace the solenoid" line was simply an AssPull from the writers.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 1993 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked. Also, Manny showcases that the Voyager's starter was fried to a crisp by the EMP attack, which honestly defies explanation. You could argue the whole "replace the solenoid" line was simply an AssPull from the writers.

Added: 432

Changed: 218

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems fried by the EMP even though they were powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked. Also, Manny showcases that the Voyager's starter was fried to a crisp by the EMP attack, which honestly defies explanation. You could argue the whole "replace the solenoid" line was simply an AssPull from the writers.
** To that point, the film depicts Ray as owning a 1967 Ford Mustang, a car that has no advanced electronics in its powertrain and likely would have still functioned after the EMP attack, even if it required popping the clutch to get it started in case the EMP fried the starter in the same way it fried the Voyager's starter. Ray could have utilized the Mustang as a getaway vehicle without requiring such an AssPull in the script.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems bricked by the EMP even though they were shut off and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems bricked fried by the EMP even though they were shut off powered down and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseCars: You won't be able to get a 1992 Plymouth Voyager (or any fuel injected car with electronic engine controls) that had just been bricked by a massive EMP running again just by replacing the starter solenoid. At the very minimum the Voyager's engine and body computers would have had to have been replaced. Given how even parked cars got their electrical systems bricked by the EMP even though they were shut off and had their rubber tires insulating their bodies from the ground, its highly unlikely that Manny would have been able to locate a good SMEC and BCM for the Plymouth Voyager, install them and get it running again in the short period of time before the tripods attacked.

Added: 258

Changed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A panicked mob rampages to take possession of a working vehicle as in the 1953 film.
** When the first tripod is emerging from the ground, there's a brief glimpse of a street sign reading "Van Buren", which is the last name of the heroine in the 1953 film.



** A panicked mob rampages to take possession of a working vehicle as in the 1953 film.

to:

** A panicked mob rampages to take possession of a working vehicle as in the 1953 film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambig


* DaylightHorror: The first tripod attack, Rachel's discovery of a river full of corpses, and [[spoiler: Ray's murder of Ogilvy]] all take place during the day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ARealManIsAKiller: Rachel seems to fully accept Ray as her father after [[spoiler: he kills Ogilvy to protect her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ARealManIsAKiller: Rachel seems to fully accept Ray as her father after [[spoiler: he kills Ogilvy to protect her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SleepCute: Ray and Rachel as they sleep together on the couch [[spoiler: after Ray kills Ogilvy]].

Top