Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheGreatDictator

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ironically, for all of the controversy surrounding it, ''The Great Dictator'' was not the first American anti-Nazi comedy film -- Chaplin was upstaged by Film/TheThreeStooges with the short film ''Film/YouNaztySpy'' by nine months. It also wasn't the first anti-Hitler film of any sort -- that honor goes to ''Hitler's Reign of Terror'', released [[OlderThanTheyThink all the way back in 1934]].[[note]]Not many films attacking the Nazi regime were released before America's entry into the war. UsefulNotes/TheHayesCode technically forbade lampoons against public figures or world leaders and the studios were loathe at any rate to make any statements that might cause Hitler to ban their films in Germany, a lucrative market.[[/note]]

to:

Ironically, for all of the controversy surrounding it, ''The Great Dictator'' was not the first American anti-Nazi comedy film -- Chaplin was upstaged by Film/TheThreeStooges with the short film ''Film/YouNaztySpy'' by nine months. It also wasn't the first anti-Hitler film of any sort -- that honor goes to ''Hitler's Reign of Terror'', released [[OlderThanTheyThink all the way back in 1934]].[[note]]Not many films attacking the Nazi regime were released before America's entry into the war. UsefulNotes/TheHayesCode UsefulNotes/TheHaysCode technically forbade lampoons against public figures or world leaders and the studios were loathe at any rate to make any statements that might cause Hitler to ban their films in Germany, a lucrative market.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ironically, for all of the controversy surrounding it, ''The Great Dictator'' was not the first American anti-Nazi comedy film -- Chaplin was upstaged by Film/TheThreeStooges with the short film ''Film/YouNaztySpy'' by nine months.

to:

Ironically, for all of the controversy surrounding it, ''The Great Dictator'' was not the first American anti-Nazi comedy film -- Chaplin was upstaged by Film/TheThreeStooges with the short film ''Film/YouNaztySpy'' by nine months. \n It also wasn't the first anti-Hitler film of any sort -- that honor goes to ''Hitler's Reign of Terror'', released [[OlderThanTheyThink all the way back in 1934]].[[note]]Not many films attacking the Nazi regime were released before America's entry into the war. UsefulNotes/TheHayesCode technically forbade lampoons against public figures or world leaders and the studios were loathe at any rate to make any statements that might cause Hitler to ban their films in Germany, a lucrative market.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz is a courtly and well-mannered officer who doesn't fit in with Hynkel and his thugs, and as a consequence is sent to a concentration camp
* OppressedMinorityVeteran: The Barber is a Jewish World War I veteran living in a parody of Nazi Germany.

to:

* OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz is a courtly and well-mannered officer who doesn't fit in with Hynkel and his thugs, and as a consequence is sent to a concentration camp
camp.
* OppressedMinorityVeteran: The Barber is a Jewish World War I veteran living in a parody of Nazi Germany.UsefulNotes/NaziGermany.

Added: 106

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz is a courtly and well-mannered officer who doesn't fit in with Hynkel and his thugs, and as a consequence is sent to a concentration camp.

to:

* OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz is a courtly and well-mannered officer who doesn't fit in with Hynkel and his thugs, and as a consequence is sent to a concentration camp.camp
* OppressedMinorityVeteran: The Barber is a Jewish World War I veteran living in a parody of Nazi Germany.

Added: 82

Changed: 1184

Removed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Hannah''': ''(sees herself in the mirror post-makeover)'' Ain't I ''cute''!



%%* TheGeneralissimo: Hynkel.

to:

%%* * TheGeneralissimo: Hynkel.Hynkel, the militaristic dictator of an evil fascist Central European state.



%%* GlovedFistOfDoom: [[http://colewebbharter.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/great-dictator-4.jpg Parodied (sans glove)]] by Creator/CharlieChaplin as Hynkel.

to:

%%* * GlovedFistOfDoom: [[http://colewebbharter.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/great-dictator-4.jpg Parodied (sans glove)]] by Creator/CharlieChaplin as Hynkel.Hynkel, who often raises his fist in an intimidating manner when he's trying to look tough during his speech.



%%* HufflepuffHouse: Bacteria.

to:

%%* * HufflepuffHouse: Bacteria.Bacteria, the Italy stand-in that seems to be a FriendlyEnemy to Tomania, much like Italy and Mussolini were friendly enemies to Germany and Hitler in the pre-war years (after the war started it was more like VileVillainLaughableLackey with Italy as the ButtMonkey of the Axis). In this movie Bacteria exists to allow a sequence where Mussolini stand-in "Napaloni" makes a state visit and Hynkel bumbles around trying to impress/intimidate him.



%%* MindScrew: Hynkel and Garbitsch try to psychologically dominate Benzino. It doesn't work. (How is this a mind screw?)



%%* OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz.

to:

%%* * OfficerAndAGentleman: Commander Schultz.Schultz is a courtly and well-mannered officer who doesn't fit in with Hynkel and his thugs, and as a consequence is sent to a concentration camp.



%%* PatrickStewartSpeech: The ending.

to:

%%* * PatrickStewartSpeech: The ending.ending, in which the barber (well, really Charlie Chaplin) delivers a passionate speech defending the dignity of the human race and appealing to man's better nature as part of the fight against fascism.



%%* {{Ruritania}}: Tomainia, Osterlich and Bacteria. AKA Germany, Austria, and Italy respectively. (How are they like Ruritanias?)

to:

%%* * {{Ruritania}}: Tomainia, Osterlich and Bacteria. AKA Bacteria, three vaguely Central European countries that are really stand-ins for Germany, Austria, and Italy respectively. (How are they like Ruritanias?)



%%* SpockSpeak: Garbitsch.

to:

%%* * SpockSpeak: Garbitsch.Garbitsch speaks with an excessively precise, formal diction.

Added: 542

Changed: 541

Removed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* ArmiesAreEvil: The Tomanian Army. (What makes the army evil?)



%%* TheCaligula: Hynkel

to:

%%* * TheCaligula: Hynkel Hynkel, who is obviously unhinged, playing with balloons when he isn't flying into rages or sending people to concentration camps.



%%* DarkerAndEdgier: Compared to Chaplin's other work. Especially when viewed with hindsight. (How is the movie darker?)

to:

%%* * DarkerAndEdgier: Compared to Chaplin's other work. Especially when viewed Chaplin's prior films were bittersweet romances with hindsight. (How slapstick comedy; this one is about a fascist dictator who persecutes Jews and wants to take over the movie darker?)world.



%%* TheEeyore: One of the Jewish men at the ghetto. (How is he being an Eeyore.



%%* EvilutionaryBiologist: Garbitsch again.

to:

%%* * EvilutionaryBiologist: Garbitsch. Right before the barber's famous RousingSpeech that closes the film, Garbitsch again.gives an evil speech in which he preaches about how might makes right and the strong will conquer the weak.
--> '''Garbitsch''': Victory shall come to the worthy. Today, democracy, liberty, and equality are words to fool the people. No nation can progress with such ideas. They stand in the way of action. Therefore, we frankly abolish them. In the future, each man will serve the interest of the State with absolute obedience. Let him who refuses beware! The rights of citizenship will be taken away from all Jews and other non-Aryans. They are inferior and therefore enemies of the state. It is the duty of all true Aryans to hate and despise them.



%%* FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and UsefulNotes/FascistItaly.

to:

%%* * FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and UsefulNotes/FascistItaly.



%%* SpeakingSimlish: The FakeGerman.

to:

%%* * SpeakingSimlish: The FakeGerman.FakeGerman that Hynkel speaks is actually Teutonic-sounding nonsense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SkunkStripe: The barber sports one of these in his hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RomanAClef: The movie is essentially a thinly veiled, fictionalized version of Germany's Anschluss with Austria and of ''Kristallnacht'', the pre-war German pogrom that preceded TheHolocaust.

to:

* RomanAClef: The movie is essentially a thinly veiled, fictionalized version of Germany's Anschluss with Austria and of ''Kristallnacht'', the pre-war German pogrom that preceded TheHolocaust.UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"Aut Caesar aut nullus. Emperor of the world. My world."

to:

-->"Aut Caesar aut nullus.nullus[[note]]Either a Caesar or a nobody; Emperor or nothing[[/note]]. Emperor of the world. My world."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpinningPaper: To show the passage of time.

to:

* SpinningPaper: To The printing press variety is used to show the passage of time.

Added: 421

Changed: 292

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MythologyGag: As the Stormtroopers start searching for Schultz, the Barber tries to warn him, but does so in mime, without speaking, and immediately afterwards claims to have "told" him about the danger. This is in reference to the Tramp's silent movie past, where he would only speak through title cards.

to:

* MythologyGag: MythologyGag:
**
As the Stormtroopers start searching for Schultz, the Barber tries to warn him, but does so in mime, without speaking, and immediately afterwards claims to have "told" him about the danger. This is in reference to the Tramp's silent movie past, where he would only speak through title cards.cards.
** Later in the movie, Hynkel mistakes Napaloni's moving mouth (as he is eating) for silent speech, and asks what he is saying.

Added: 220

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreezeFrameBonus: While the movie replaces Germany with the fictional Tomainia, on the newsreel you can still see the name Germany printed under the "Armistice" headline.

to:

* FreezeFrameBonus: FreezeFrameBonus:
**
While the movie replaces Germany with the fictional Tomainia, on the newsreel you can still see the name Germany printed under the "Armistice" headline.headline.
** Another newsreel fragment has the line "Stop press bulletins".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: As the Stormtroopers start searching for Schultz, the Barber tries to warn him, but does so in mime, without speaking, and immediately afterwards claims to have "told" him about the danger. This is in reference to the Tramp's silent movie past, where he would only speak through title cards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MickeyMousing: An astonishing scene where the Jewish Barber shaves a customer in perfect time with the Hungarian Dance #5. Supposedly the intent was to record multiple takes and piece it together in editing; instead Chaplin brought the phonograph to the set, played the music, and nailed the entire routine on the first practice take.

to:

* MickeyMousing: An astonishing scene where the Jewish Barber shaves a customer in perfect time with the [[Creator/JohannesBrahms Brahms']] Hungarian Dance #5. Supposedly the intent was to record multiple takes and piece it together in editing; instead Chaplin brought the phonograph to the set, played the music, and nailed the entire routine on the first practice take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreezeFrameBonus: While the movie replaces Germany with the fictional Tomania, on the newsreel you can still see the name Germany printed under the "Armistice" headline.

to:

* FreezeFrameBonus: While the movie replaces Germany with the fictional Tomania, Tomainia, on the newsreel you can still see the name Germany printed under the "Armistice" headline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FreezeFrameBonus: While the movie replaces Germany with the fictional Tomania, on the newsreel you can still see the name Germany printed under the "Armistice" headline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KnightOfCerebus: Most of the villainous characters are too goofy to be scary; but this does not apply to Garbitsch, the Minister of Propaganda. Aside from his name, there is very little that is in any way funny about this character. He almost always acts much more seriously than the other characters, and he constantly encourages Hynkel to persecute the Jews and to act like a treacherous and hateful egomaniac. While the other 'children of the double-cross' can be viewed as parodies; Garbitsch goes above and beyond to earn his name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasyCounterpartCulture: The film has Osterlich, the pacifist country next to Tomainia. It's an obvious parallel to Austria down to the name with a different spelling: Österreich is the German/Austrian name for Austria.
%%* FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for NaziGermany and UsefulNotes/FascistItaly.

to:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: The film has Osterlich, the pacifist country next to Tomainia. It's an obvious parallel to Austria UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} down to the name with a different spelling: Österreich is the German/Austrian name for Austria.
%%* FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for NaziGermany UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and UsefulNotes/FascistItaly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Facepalm}}: Mr Jaeckel watches from his balcony when the troops arrive to lynch the barber. As they go to action, he facepalms in the background.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for NaziGermany and FascistItaly.

to:

%%* FictionalCountry: Tomainia and Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for NaziGermany and FascistItaly.UsefulNotes/FascistItaly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: The barber quotes Literature/TheBible (specifically Luke 17:20-21) in his RousingSpeech: "In the seventeenth chapter of Saint Luke it is written " the kingdom of God is within man " - not one man, nor a group of men - but in all men - in you, the people!"

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: The barber quotes Literature/TheBible (specifically Luke 17:20-21) in his RousingSpeech: "In the seventeenth chapter of Saint Luke it is written " the 'the kingdom of God is within man " man' - not one man, nor a group of men - but in all men - in you, the people!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: The barber quotes Literature/TheBible (specifically Luke 17:20 - 17:21) in his RousingSpeech: "In the seventeenth chapter of Saint Luke it is written " the kingdom of God is within man " - not one man, nor a group of men - but in all men - in you, the people!"

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: The barber quotes Literature/TheBible (specifically Luke 17:20 - 17:21) 17:20-21) in his RousingSpeech: "In the seventeenth chapter of Saint Luke it is written " the kingdom of God is within man " - not one man, nor a group of men - but in all men - in you, the people!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The film is also a landmark for Chaplin himself - it was his first all-sound film, released over a decade after the rest of Hollywood transitioned to sound. (In the meantime Chaplin had stubbornly made ''Film/CityLights'' and ''Film/ModernTimes'' as silent films.) And although the barber is explicitly ''not'' the Tramp character, he nonetheless has the Tramp's physical appearance - baggy clothes, big shoes, cane, and that moustache - and thus this film marks the final time Chaplin would invoke some version of this character on screen.

to:

The film is also a landmark for Chaplin himself - it was his first all-sound film, released over a decade after the rest of Hollywood transitioned to sound. (In the meantime Chaplin had stubbornly made ''Film/CityLights'' and ''Film/ModernTimes'' as silent films.) And although the barber is explicitly ''not'' the Tramp character, he nonetheless has the Tramp's physical appearance - baggy clothes, big shoes, cane, bowler hat and that moustache - and thus this film marks the final time Chaplin would invoke some version of this character on screen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommissarCap: Chaplin lampoons Adolph Hitler and wears a wonderful Commissar Cap with a XX logo in place of the swastika.

to:

* CommissarCap: Chaplin lampoons Adolph Hitler and wears a wonderful Commissar Cap with a XX (the "Double-Cross") logo in place of the swastika.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CasualDangerDialogue: When the Jewish Barber is hanging to an upside-down plane by just the control stick, he never even raises his voice. When the plane starts to dive, Schultz rambles about his beloved and daffodils, and continues ''even after the plane crashes''.

to:

* CasualDangerDialogue: When the Jewish Barber is hanging to an upside-down plane by just the control stick, he never even raises his voice. When the plane starts to dive, Schultz (who's been shot and is delirious with blood loss) rambles about his beloved and daffodils, and continues ''even after the plane crashes''.



--> '''Jewish Barber''': Absolutely not.

to:

--> '''Jewish Barber''': Absolutely not.Impossible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Great Dictator'' was (of course) banned in UsefulNotes/NaziGermany, although prints of the film still found their way into occupied Europe. According to an eyewitness, UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler obtained a copy of the film and watched it twice; when Chaplin found this out, he said that he would give anything to know what he thought of it. Britain had announced that they were going to ban the film while the film was in production (so that it wouldn't interfere with the country's appeasement policy with Nazi Germany), but when the film was released, Britain had entered the war against the Nazis, and the film couldn't be brought in fast enough; it ended up providing some badly needed laughs at a time where laughs were in short supply for Britain (and most of Europe).

to:

''The Great Dictator'' was (of course) banned in UsefulNotes/NaziGermany, although prints of the film still found their way into occupied Europe. According [[note]]According to an eyewitness, UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler obtained a copy of the film and watched it twice; when Chaplin found this out, he said that he would give anything to know what he thought of it. it.[[/note]] Britain had announced that they were going to ban the film while the film was in production (so that it wouldn't interfere with the country's appeasement policy with Nazi Germany), but when the film was released, Britain had entered the war against the Nazis, and the film couldn't be brought in fast enough; it ended up providing some badly needed laughs at a time where laughs were in short supply for Britain (and most of Europe).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Heel-Face Turn: Schultz has one after rescuing the barber from the storm troopers.

to:

* Heel-Face Turn: HeelFaceTurn: Schultz has one after rescuing the barber from the storm troopers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurLawyersAdvisedThisTrope: Parodied - the film begins with the notice: "[[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed Any resemblance between Hynkel the dictator and the Jewish barber is purely co-incidental]]".

to:

* OurLawyersAdvisedThisTrope: Parodied - the film begins with the notice: "[[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed "[[IdenticalStranger Any resemblance between Hynkel the dictator and the Jewish barber is purely co-incidental]]".



%%* RomanAClef: The intro references this.

to:

%%* * RomanAClef: The intro references this.movie is essentially a thinly veiled, fictionalized version of Germany's Anschluss with Austria and of ''Kristallnacht'', the pre-war German pogrom that preceded TheHolocaust.



-->'''Translator''': [[{{Understatement}} His Excellency has just made reference to the Jewish people.]]

to:

-->'''Translator''': [[{{Understatement}} His Excellency has just made reference referred to the Jewish people.]]



%%* ThoseWackyNazis

to:

%%* ThoseWackyNazis* ThoseWackyNazis: UrExample before the world experienced or understood the full extent of Nazi evil. Chaplin even claimed he would not have made the movie had he known the true nature of the Nazi concentration camps.



%%* WideEyedIdealist: Hannah.

to:

%%* * WideEyedIdealist: Hannah.Hannah never loses her innocence despite her life in the Jewish ghetto.

Added: 104

Changed: 592

Removed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* TheEmpire: Hynkel and Garbitsch's ultimate vision for Tomainia

to:

%%* * TheEmpire: Hynkel and Garbitsch's ultimate vision for Tomainia



%%* FictionalCountry: Germania and Bacteria.

to:

%%* FictionalCountry: Germania Tomainia and Bacteria.Bacteria are [[{{Expy}} expies]] for NaziGermany and FascistItaly.



%%* Heel-Face Turn: see [trope] is not context

to:

%%* * Heel-Face Turn: see [trope] is not contextSchultz has one after rescuing the barber from the storm troopers.



%%* ANaziByAnyOtherName: The sons and daughters of the Double Cross are [[{{Expy}} clear expies]] for the Nazi Party.
%%* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Asserted at the beginning on the film.

to:

%%* * ANaziByAnyOtherName: The sons and daughters of the Double Cross are [[{{Expy}} clear expies]] for the Nazi Party.
%%* NoCelebritiesWereHarmed: Asserted at the beginning on the film.
Party.



%%* NoSwastikas: The [[MeaningfulName Double Cross]].

to:

%%* * NoSwastikas: The symbol of Hynkel's regime is the [[MeaningfulName Double Cross]].



* OurLawyersAdvisedThisTrope: Parodied - the film begins with the notice: "Any resemblance between Hynkel the dictator and the Jewish barber is purely co-incidental".

to:

* OurLawyersAdvisedThisTrope: Parodied - the film begins with the notice: "Any "[[NoCelebritiesWereHarmed Any resemblance between Hynkel the dictator and the Jewish barber is purely co-incidental".co-incidental]]".



%%* PrinceAndPauper: The dictator and the barber in this case.

to:

%%* * PrinceAndPauper: The dictator This accidentally happens to Hynkel and the barber, when Hynkel goes missing while fishing and the barber is [[DressingAsTheEnemy dressed in this case.a military uniform]]. Until then [[FailedASpotCheck no one notices the resemblance between the barber and der Phooey]].



* StupidJetpackHitler: Made fun of. Herring is very enthusiastic about various inventions that all fail hilariously in ways that kills their inventors. Fuehrer Adenoid Hynkel is less enthusiastic and finally tells him to just stop, please.
%%* TactfulTranslation: Done with the dictator's speech [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4UhJpviVYg here]].

to:

* StupidJetpackHitler: Made fun of.Parodied. Herring is very enthusiastic about various inventions that all fail hilariously in ways that kills their inventors. Fuehrer Adenoid Hynkel is less enthusiastic and finally tells him to just stop, please.
%%* * TactfulTranslation: Done with Hynkel's translator does this throughout the dictator's speech [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4UhJpviVYg here]].opening speech]]. It is especially evident after Hynkel's rant about "der Juden."
-->'''Translator''': [[{{Understatement}} His Excellency has just made reference to the Jewish people.]]

Added: 82

Changed: 328

Removed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdolfHitlarious: Came pretty close to being the UrExample and TropeMaker, but was beaten out by Film/TheThreeStooges' ''Film/YouNaztySpy''.

to:

* AdolfHitlarious: Came pretty close to being the UrExample and TropeMaker, but was beaten out by Film/TheThreeStooges' ''Film/YouNaztySpy''.



%%* AuthorFilibuster: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kbn-GjL6WLA "Look up, Hannah".]] (

to:

%%* * AuthorFilibuster: The barber's final speech as Hynkel expresses Chaplin's own views about fascism and militarism.
-->'''Barber''':
[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kbn-GjL6WLA "Look up, Hannah".]] (]]



%%* TheCaligula: Hynkel.

to:

%%* TheCaligula: Hynkel.Hynkel



%%* DefectorFromDecadence: Commander Schultz.

to:

%%* * DefectorFromDecadence: Commander Schultz.Schultz abandons Hynkel's regime when he sees the barber fighting the storm troopers.



%%* TheEmpire: Tomainia.

to:

%%* TheEmpire: Tomainia.Hynkel and Garbitsch's ultimate vision for Tomainia



%%* EvilChancellor: Garbitsch.



%%* ANaziByAnyOtherName: The sons and daughters of the Double Cross. (How are they like Nazis?)

to:

%%* ANaziByAnyOtherName: The sons and daughters of the Double Cross. (How Cross are they like Nazis?)[[{{Expy}} clear expies]] for the Nazi Party.

Top