Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / TellingLiesNoMama

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ContrivedCoincidence: By a stroke of luck, Sabrina was in one of the bathroom stalls during the time Lila was threatening Marinette. ''And recorded the whole thing.''

Changed: 631

Removed: 656

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not enough context (ZCE), Misuse


* DiplomaticImpunity: Like many fics of this kind, Lila tries to claim this [[spoiler:after her alliance with Hawkmoth is made public. Unsurprisingly, her mother revokes it]].

to:

* DiplomaticImpunity: Like many fics of this kind, Lila tries to claim this [[spoiler:after her alliance with Hawkmoth Hawk Moth is made public. Unsurprisingly, her mother revokes it]].



** Later on, the heroes do this against [[spoiler: Façade's Lila-half by getting her to blast herself with her mother's [[TruthSerums unmasking beams]], forcing her to say that all her lies about everything are just that, lies]].

to:

** Later on, the heroes do this against [[spoiler: Façade's [[spoiler:Façade's Lila-half by getting her to blast herself with her mother's [[TruthSerums unmasking beams]], forcing her to say that all her lies about everything are just that, lies]].



*** In chapter 7, [[spoiler: the akumatized Lila snidely calls out Ladybug and Chat Noir for sneaking up on her, saying that it's rude to attack someone when their back is turned. Ladybug tells her that's hypocritical coming from someone who always strikes when someone's guard is down. Credit where it's due, [[HypocrisyNod Lila doesn't deny this]], but points out that it means more when they do it because, as Paris' Champions, they're supposed to be above such tactics.]]
*** In the same chapter, [[spoiler: Chat Noir calls Lila/Facade [[MaliciousMisnaming Masquerade]] to get her attention, and Lila asks if he thinks he can honestly piss her off by getting her name wrong. Then Chat Noir calls her [[CompulsiveLiar Liar-la]], after which she screams that she's not a liar.]]
*** [[RuleofThree Also in chapter 7]], [[spoiler: after Chloé appears pelts her with some rubble, Lila expresses her surprise at seeing her, believing she'd be hiding and waiting for her father to save her like the coward she is. As Chloé wastes no time retorting, Lila has no business calling ''anyone'' a coward since her reaction to people calling her out on her lies was to ''willingly'' get herself akumatized.]]
** Alya accuses Kim of being this in chapter 2, stating that he acts like some stand-up guy who fights against bullies, but had no problem picking on Ivan at the start of the year, making him Hawk Moth's very first victim. She also calls out the class for rallying to Lila's defence like "some kind of protection squad" simply because Lila claims Marinette is bullying her, when they never did anything similar for Marinette during all the years Chloé bullied her.
** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says that someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or believes stalking someone ''is'' flattering.

to:

*** In chapter 7, [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the akumatized Lila snidely calls out Ladybug and Chat Noir for sneaking up on her, saying that it's rude to attack someone when their back is turned. Ladybug tells her that's hypocritical coming from someone who always strikes when someone's guard is down. Credit where it's due, [[HypocrisyNod Lila doesn't deny this]], but points out that it means more when they do it because, as Paris' Champions, they're supposed to be above such tactics.]]
*** In the same chapter, [[spoiler: Chat [[spoiler:Chat Noir calls Lila/Facade [[MaliciousMisnaming Masquerade]] to get her attention, and Lila asks if he thinks he can honestly piss her off by getting her name wrong. Then Chat Noir calls her [[CompulsiveLiar Liar-la]], after which she screams that she's not a liar.]]
*** [[RuleofThree Also in chapter 7]], [[spoiler: after [[spoiler:after Chloé appears pelts to pelt her with some rubble, Lila expresses her surprise at seeing her, believing she'd be hiding and waiting for her father to save her like the coward she is. As Chloé wastes no time retorting, Lila has no business calling ''anyone'' a coward since her reaction to people calling her out on her lies was to ''willingly'' get herself akumatized.]]
** Alya accuses Kim of being this in chapter 2, stating that he acts like some stand-up guy who fights against bullies, but had no problem picking on Ivan at the start of the year, making him Hawk Moth's very first victim. She also calls out the class for rallying to Lila's defence defense like "some kind of protection squad" simply because Lila claims Marinette is bullying her, when they never did anything similar for Marinette during all the years Chloé bullied her.
** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says that someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or believes stalking someone ''is'' flattering.
her.



* KillItWithFire: At one point, the other students notice Alix having pulled out an aerosol can and a lighter, clearly intending to make a flame thrower to burn Lila with.
* LadyOfWar: Vespa, the new Bee hero. [[spoiler:Actually Chloé using the Bee Miraculous under a new alias.]]
* LaserGuidedKarma: What happens to Lila during the whole fic, from her classmates losing faith in her to her mother humiliating and exposing her in front of friends and foes alike, all the way to [[spoiler:getting caught trying to grab an akuma and getting arrested and deported as an accomplice of Hawkmoth]].

to:

* KillItWithFire: At one point, the other students notice Alix having pulled out an aerosol can and a lighter, clearly intending to make a flame thrower to burn Lila with.
* LadyOfWar: Vespa, the new Bee hero. [[spoiler:Actually [[spoiler:[[MeaningfulRename Actually Chloé using the Bee Miraculous under a new alias.alias]].]]
* LaserGuidedKarma: What happens to Lila during the whole fic, from her classmates losing faith in her to her mother humiliating and exposing her in front of friends and foes alike, all the way to [[spoiler:getting caught trying to grab an akuma and getting arrested and deported as an accomplice of Hawkmoth]].Hawk Moth]].



* MoreThanMindControl: {{Discussed}} by the heroes post-battle; while Hawkmoth's victims generally aren't held responsible for what they did while akumatized, as they aren't themselves at the time, Ladybug suggests that circumstances might be different with [[spoiler:Lila, who ''willingly'' works with him. As a result, she can't confidently say that the choices she made as Façade weren't her own]].

to:

* MoreThanMindControl: {{Discussed}} {{Discussed|Trope}} by the heroes post-battle; while Hawkmoth's Hawk Moth's victims generally aren't held responsible for what they did while akumatized, as they aren't themselves at the time, Ladybug suggests that circumstances might be different with [[spoiler:Lila, who ''willingly'' works with him. As a result, she can't confidently say that the choices she made as Façade weren't her own]].



* SecretKeeper: [[spoiler:Chloé reveals to Marinette partway through the story that she's known that she's Ladybug for a while, and promises to keep the secret. She then sees Adrien transforming into Chat Noir a chapter later and reveals this to him offscreen after Lila's defeat.]]

to:

* SecretKeeper: [[spoiler:Chloé reveals to Marinette partway through the story that she's known that she's Ladybug for a while, and promises to keep the secret. She then sees Adrien transforming into Chat Noir a chapter later and reveals this to him offscreen off-screen after Lila's defeat.]]



* SmallRoleBigImpact: Aurore and Mireille, who only appear at the end of the first chapter, and aren't even named, (though the narration makes clear it's them), yet play the crucial role of unwittingly revealing to Mrs. Rossi all the lies her daughter has been spreading around the school, setting the plot in motion.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Aurore and Mireille, who only appear at the end of the first chapter, and aren't even named, (though the narration makes clear it's them), [[SpannerInTheWorks yet play the crucial role of unwittingly revealing to Mrs. Rossi all the lies her daughter has been spreading around the school, setting the plot in motion.motion]].



* SureLetsGoWithThat: When Sabrina reveals to the class that she was in the bathroom where Lila threatened Marinette during the events of "Chameleon", she mentions that before Lila entered, Marinette was talking with someone and assumed she was on the phone. Marinette realizes that Sabrina had overheard her talking with Tikki and is in no hurry to correct her, even going along with it when it turns out that Sabrina had recorded part of Marinette and Tikki's conversation while recording proof that Lila had threatened Marinette.
* ThousandYardStare: Mrs. Rossi sports one as she informs Lila that [[spoiler:she's waiving her diplomatic immunity]]. Can't really blame her, considering that she's learned in the past few hours that not only is her daughter a {{consummate liar}} that's willingly aiding a terrorist, but that said daughter also attempted to [[spoiler:commit {{matricide}} just minutes prior]].
* ToxicFriendInfluence: Lila would be this if she was actually friends with any celebrities since she is always promising the class favors from [[CelebrityLie stars she claims to be close with]], but, [[JerkassHasAPoint as Chloé points out]], this would make her a bad friend for taking advantage of her 'celebrity friends' and their fame for trying to get them to do huge favors for random kids who they don’t even know.

to:

* SureLetsGoWithThat: When Sabrina reveals to the class that she was in the bathroom where Lila threatened Marinette during the events of "Chameleon", she mentions that before Lila entered, Marinette was talking speaking with someone and assumed she was on the phone. Marinette realizes that Sabrina had overheard her talking with Tikki and is in no hurry to correct her, even going along with it when it turns out that Sabrina had recorded gotten part of Marinette and Tikki's conversation while recording proof that Lila had threatened Marinette.
* ThousandYardStare: Mrs. Rossi sports one as she informs Lila that [[spoiler:she's waiving her diplomatic immunity]]. Can't really blame her, considering that she's learned in the past few hours that not only is her daughter a {{consummate liar}} ConsummateLiar that's willingly aiding a terrorist, but that said daughter also attempted to [[spoiler:commit {{matricide}} just minutes prior]].
* ToxicFriendInfluence: Lila would be this if she was actually friends with any celebrities since she is always promising the class favors from [[CelebrityLie stars she claims to be close with]], but, [[JerkassHasAPoint as Chloé points out]], this would make her a bad friend for taking advantage of her 'celebrity friends' "celebrity friends" and their fame for trying to get them to do huge favors for random kids who they don’t even know.



* VillainHasAPoint: Lila tells Marinette she has no room to criticize her behaviour towards Adrien since she's a stalker. Marinette doesn't even try to refute that because she knows Lila's right.

to:

* VillainHasAPoint: Lila tells Marinette she has no room to criticize her behaviour behavior towards Adrien since she's a stalker. Marinette doesn't even try to refute that because she knows Lila's right.



* WhamLine: At the end of Chapter 5, Chloé locks Marinette and herself within the classroom, and tells this to Marinette:
-->'''Chloé''': Correct me if I'm wrong, but shouldn't you [[spoiler:be transforming? You've got an akuma to purify]].

to:

* WhamLine: At the end of Chapter 5, Chloé locks Marinette and herself within the classroom, and tells says this to Marinette:
her:
-->'''Chloé''': Correct me if I'm wrong, but shouldn't you [[spoiler:be [[spoiler:[[SecretSecretKeeper be transforming? You've got an akuma to purify]].purify.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PointOfDivergence: The entire plot happens because Lila didn't clean the butter knife after using it, leaving breadcrumbs on the butter, causing the fussy Mrs. Rossi to skip her breakfast toast and buy something to eat on her way to work. She stops at the Dupain-Cheng bakery, where a lot of students of Françoise Dupont go as well due to its proximity to school. And two of those students, upon hearing her name, unwittingly reveal to her what Lila has been doing in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Identified source material


''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/18968110 Telling Lies? No, Mama]]'' by [[https://archiveofourown.org/users/Aishling/pseuds/Aishling Aishling]] is yet another fanfiction in reaction to the infamous [[Recap/MiraculousLadybugS03E01Chameleon "Chameleon"]] episode. However, what really makes this one a gem among dirty rocks is that instead of [[RonTheDeathEater writing the whole class, plus Alya, Nino and Adrien, off as selfish, heartless villains who side with Lila at the drop of a hat]], it actually [[DeconstructionFic deconstructs and explains their behaviors]], and how Lila is able to get them to do her bidding.

to:

''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/18968110 Telling Lies? No, Mama]]'' by [[https://archiveofourown.org/users/Aishling/pseuds/Aishling Aishling]] is yet another ''WesternAnimation/MiraculousLadybug'' fanfiction in reaction to the infamous [[Recap/MiraculousLadybugS03E01Chameleon "Chameleon"]] episode. However, what really makes this one a gem among dirty rocks is that instead of [[RonTheDeathEater writing the whole class, plus Alya, Nino and Adrien, off as selfish, heartless villains who side with Lila at the drop of a hat]], it actually [[DeconstructionFic deconstructs and explains their behaviors]], and how Lila is able to get them to do her bidding.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says the someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or believes stalking someone ''is'' flattering.

to:

** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says the that someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or believes stalking someone ''is'' flattering.

Added: 532

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterizationMarchesOn: Mrs. Rossi in the first chapter is shown to be a [[ObsessivelyOrganized rather meticulous and persnickety person]]; her morning routine is perfect down to the positioning of the newspaper, she refuses to have her breakfast because the butter has crumbs in it, and she doesn't just clean it because she wants to confront the perpetrator later with evidence. Also, on her way to find breakfast, she fusses about having to leave early because she thinks that arriving early is a sign of desperation for praise. However, other than this being the [[ForWantOfANail nail]] that gets her into a position to hear Lila's lies, it doesn't come up in the rest of the story, probably because she has bigger things to be concerned about. The author acknowledges that they dropped that trait of hers in later chapters and that it was a failing on their part.

to:

* CharacterizationMarchesOn: Mrs. Rossi in the first chapter is shown to be a [[ObsessivelyOrganized rather meticulous and persnickety person]]; her morning routine is perfect down to the positioning of the newspaper, she refuses to have her breakfast because the butter has crumbs in it, and she doesn't just clean it because she wants to confront the perpetrator later with evidence. Also, on her way to find breakfast, she fusses about having to leave early because she thinks that arriving early is a sign of desperation for praise. However, other than this being the [[ForWantOfANail nail]] nail that gets her into a position to hear Lila's lies, it doesn't come up in the rest of the story, probably because she has bigger things to be concerned about. The author acknowledges that they dropped that trait of hers in later chapters and that it was a failing on their part.



'''Chloé:''' [[ArmorPiercingResponse Because Ladybug would never be friends with someone who uses her!]] ''[{{beat}}]'' Think about it! All Lila's done since she got here is brag about how close her and Ladybug are. What has it gotten her? Attention, special treatment, your respect. But what proof has she provided for any of it? None! Lila uses Ladybug to make herself popular. A real friend wouldn't do that to her; not after all she'd done for this city. Just like a friend to all these celebrities and artist and singers wouldn't abuse their friendship by promising they’ll do favors for a bunch of kids they don’t even know. What’s that subreddit online? The one where artists talk about the [[FalseFriend poser friends in their lives who ask for free stuff 'because they're friends']]. That's what Lila sounds like. If she was really friends with any of them I doubt she'd be [[ToxicFriendInfluence expecting them to do anything for any of you just because she told them to]]. So I find it hard to believe that Ladybug would ever befriend a pathetic attention seeker who’s done nothing but try to ride her coattails!\\

to:

'''Chloé:''' [[ArmorPiercingResponse Because Ladybug would never be friends with someone who uses her!]] ''[{{beat}}]'' Think about it! All Lila's done since she got here is brag about how close her and Ladybug are. What has it gotten her? Attention, special treatment, your respect. But what proof has she provided for any of it? None! Lila uses Ladybug to make herself popular. A real friend wouldn't do that to her; not after all she'd done for this city. Just like a friend to all these celebrities and artist and singers wouldn't abuse their friendship by promising they’ll they'll do favors for a bunch of kids they don’t don't even know. What’s What's that subreddit online? The one where artists talk about the [[FalseFriend poser friends in their lives who ask for free stuff 'because they're friends']]. That's what Lila sounds like. If she was really friends with any of them I doubt she'd be [[ToxicFriendInfluence expecting them to do anything for any of you just because she told them to]]. So I find it hard to believe that Ladybug would ever befriend a pathetic attention seeker who’s done nothing but try to ride her coattails!\\



'''Chloé''': Did I say you could talk?! [[AtLeastIAdmitIt I've haven't been the nicest to Marinette. I won't deny that. We don’t get along and I’m not going to pretend we do]]. [[EvenEvilHasStandards But at least I haven’t tried to turn everyone against her. I certainly never tried to pit her and her friends against each other. Have you ever seen me try and break up her and Cesaire's friendship?]]\\

to:

'''Chloé''': Did I say you could talk?! [[AtLeastIAdmitIt I've haven't been the nicest to Marinette. I won't deny that. We don’t don't get along and I’m I'm not going to pretend we do]]. [[EvenEvilHasStandards But at least I haven’t haven't tried to turn everyone against her. I certainly never tried to pit her and her friends against each other. Have you ever seen me try and break up her and Cesaire's friendship?]]\\



'''Chloé''': Yeah, and I got told off for what an awful thing that was. The point is I've tried to ruin Marinette’s day, maybe even her week, but not her life. But her, ''[points at Lila]'' she comes in and starts spouting [[CelebrityLie some fairytales about celebrities and charity work]] and you're all ready to throw Marinette to the wolves at the snap of Lie-la’s fingers.

to:

'''Chloé''': Yeah, and I got told off for what an awful thing that was. The point is I've tried to ruin Marinette’s Marinette's day, maybe even her week, but not her life. But her, ''[points at Lila]'' she comes in and starts spouting [[CelebrityLie some fairytales about celebrities and charity work]] and you're all ready to throw Marinette to the wolves at the snap of Lie-la’s Lie-la's fingers.



** Madame Bustier noticed Lila’s flirtation but thought that Adrien would have told her if it was bothering him. She thought he was fine with it because Chloé touches him in a similar manner all the time.

to:

** Madame Bustier noticed Lila’s Lila's flirtation but thought that Adrien would have told her if it was bothering him. She thought he was fine with it because Chloé touches him in a similar manner all the time.



** In most salt fics, Mme. Bustier easily excuses all of Lila’s misdeeds, no matter how horrible they are, and pressures Marinette and the class to forgive her. She does no such thing in this story.

to:

** In most salt fics, Mme. Bustier easily excuses all of Lila’s Lila's misdeeds, no matter how horrible they are, and pressures Marinette and the class to forgive her. She does no such thing in this story.



* SureLetsGoWithThat: When Sabrina reveals to the class that she was in the bathroom where Lila threatened Marinette during the events of "Chameleon", she mentions that before Lila entered, Marinette was talking with someone and assumed she was on the phone. Marinette realizes that Sabrina had overheard her talking with Tikki and is in no hurry to correct her, even going along with it when it turns out that Sabrina had recorded part of Marinette and Tikki's conversation while recording proof that Lila had threatened Marinette.



* WasItAllALie: {{Discussed}}; after Lila's been dealt with, Vespa expresses sympathy for Mrs. Rossi, musing about how she's got to be questioning everything she ''thought'' she knew about her daughter, and how much of their relationship was a lie.

to:

* WasItAllALie: {{Discussed}}; {{Discussed|Trope}}; after Lila's been dealt with, Vespa expresses sympathy for Mrs. Rossi, musing about how she's got to be questioning everything she ''thought'' she knew about her daughter, and how much of their relationship was a lie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguation.


* ForWantOfANail: The entire plot happens because Lila didn't clean the butter knife after using it, leaving breadcrumbs on the butter, causing the fussy Mrs. Rossi to skip her breakfast toast and buy something to eat on her way to work. She stops at the Dupain-Cheng bakery, where a lot of students of Françoise Dupont go as well due to its proximity to school. And two of those students, upon hearing her name, unwittingly reveal to her what Lila has been doing in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says the someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or truly believes stalking ''is'' flattering.

to:

** Juleka, as mentioned in DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale, says the someone violating your personal space isn't flattering but creepy, but in canon, not only is she perfectly aware of Marinette's [[StalkerWithACrush behavior]] toward Adrien, but has also helped and enabled her. She's either this or truly believes stalking someone ''is'' flattering.

Top