Follow TV Tropes

Following

History FanFic / WhatsHPDoesItTasteGood

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yamato expects anyone without a devil fruit to be able to swim to safety if they are tossed into the ocean.


Added DiffLines:

* SquishTheCheeks: Luffy does this Nami when trying to get through to her that she doesn't have to make deals in order to get help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13777231/1/What-s-HP-Does-it-taste-good What's HP? Does it Taste Good?]] by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 xolef225]] is a ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' fanfiction in which Luffy has the powers of ''Webcomic/TheGamer''. What makes this unique is that Luffy has no idea what a video game is and doesn't understand most of what the "mystery boxes" he can see are trying to tell him.

to:

[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13777231/1/What-s-HP-Does-it-taste-good What's HP? Does it Taste Good?]] by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 xolef225]] is a ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' fanfiction in which Luffy has the powers of ''Webcomic/TheGamer''. What makes this unique is that it is a parody of other Gamer stories. Luffy has no idea what a video game is and doesn't understand most of what the "mystery boxes" he can see are trying to tell him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExactWords: Zoro tells Luffy he can’t join his crew because Zoro promised to serve out his punishment in the Marine base. Luffy counters that the base isn’t going to be there anymore when Luffy gets done with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnderestimatingBadassery: Almost no one takes Luffy seriously at first. They call him a foolish boy playing at being a pirate until he shows them what he can do.

to:

* UnderestimatingBadassery: Almost no one takes Luffy seriously at first. They call him a foolish boy playing at being a pirate until he shows them what he can do.do.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: The two things driving most events of this story are how Luffy has leveled up far past his canon counterpart at the start of the journey, and how amazingly dense he is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* ComicallyInvincibleHero: Between the effects of the Gamer system and having Yamato as a sparring partner, Luffy is hilariously overpowered relative to everything else the East Blue when he starts out.

to:

* ComicallyInvincibleHero: Between the effects of the Gamer system and having Yamato as a sparring partner, Luffy is hilariously overpowered relative to everything else in the East Blue when he starts out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KillerGameMaster: Eventually, the game menu gets actively aggressive in trying to thwart Luffy’s efforts to go OffTheRails, going so far as to bend reality to block his path. Luffy doesn’t take that lying down.


Added DiffLines:

* OffTheRails: The Gamer menu attempts to enforce plot rails. That really doesn’t work on Luffy.


Added DiffLines:

* SequenceBreaking: The Gamer system tries to enforce TheStationsOfTheCanon or certain plot structures. Luffy wants the world to be his WideOpenSandbox.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Railroading}}: The Gamer menu system tries to do this to Luffy, either to follow TheStationsOfTheCanon or because it is programmed to structure quests in a certain way. The key word here is “tries”.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Note: Yamato initially introduces themselves as Kaido’s son, but after a three year time skip, Luffy uses female pronouns to refer to Yamato. Yamato hasn’t had dialogue yet that indicates their preference in this story after that time skip. “She/her” is the current default in the entries below, but this may be subject to change later and YMMV.

to:

Note: Yamato initially introduces themselves as Kaido’s son, but after a three year time skip, Luffy uses female pronouns to refer to Yamato. Yamato hasn’t had dialogue Yamato’s interactions and appearances since the time skip have been limited and they haven’t yet that indicates indicated their preference in this story after that time skip.story. “She/her” is the current default in the entries below, but this may be subject to change later and YMMV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
After rereading, that trope didn’t apply as I thought it did.


* AdaptationPersonalityChange: While most of the setting seems to be based on the Anime, some of the characters seem to be based on, or at least influenced by, their live action Netflix versions.

Added: 430

Changed: 239

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IThoughtEveryoneCouldDoThat: After years spent training with Yamato, his grandfather, and whatever the Gamer menu came up with, Luffy’s views on what a normal person can do are a bit skewed. Or at least as “normal” is defined in the East Blue. He is confused when people are shocked by his strength. He is also confused when people tell him things are dangerous or impossible, because they aren’t either of those things to him.



* UnderestimatingBadassery: Luffy is confused by people who tell him things are dangerous, or risky, or most of the people who try to threaten him. He’s so overpowered for the East Blue that these things aren’t dangerous to him.

to:

* UnderestimatingBadassery: Almost no one takes Luffy is confused by people who tell seriously at first. They call him things are dangerous, or risky, or most of the people who try to threaten him. He’s so overpowered for the East Blue that these things aren’t dangerous to him.a foolish boy playing at being a pirate until he shows them what he can do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BarehandedBarBending: Luffy walks out of a marine prison cell after casually moving the bars out of his way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


UnderestimatingBadassery: Luffy is confused by people who tell him things are dangerous, or risky, or most of the people who try to threaten him. He’s so overpowered for the East Blue that these things aren’t dangerous to him.

to:

* UnderestimatingBadassery: Luffy is confused by people who tell him things are dangerous, or risky, or most of the people who try to threaten him. He’s so overpowered for the East Blue that these things aren’t dangerous to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TerrifyingRescuer: Luffy, and later Zoro, have a tendency to rush in and save the day while announcing they are pirates and laying waste to everything in their path. Reactions from bystanders and rescued victims range from frightened to confused.

to:

* TerrifyingRescuer: Luffy, and later Zoro, have a tendency to rush in and save the day while announcing they are pirates and laying waste to everything in their path. Reactions from bystanders and rescued victims range from frightened to confused.confused.
UnderestimatingBadassery: Luffy is confused by people who tell him things are dangerous, or risky, or most of the people who try to threaten him. He’s so overpowered for the East Blue that these things aren’t dangerous to him.

Added: 245

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EntertaininglyWrong: A lot of characters have theories and speculation about where Luffy is from, his goals, and the reasons behind his actions. Most of them are reading way too much into things and seeing cunning plans when there is no plan.



* TheMole: [[spoiler:Yamato]] gets separated from Luffy when they start out. She uses her [[spoiler:zoan devil fruit to pose as a dog]] and spy on the marines tasked to find him.

to:

* TheMole: [[spoiler:Yamato]] gets separated from Luffy when they start out. She uses her [[spoiler:zoan devil fruit to pose as a dog]] and spy on dog]]. She is taken in by the marines and spies on the people tasked to find him.Luffy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Note: Yamato initially introduces themselves as Kaido’s son, but after a three year time skip, Luffy uses female pronouns to refer to Yamato. Yamato hasn’t had dialogue yet that indicates their preference in this story after that time skip. “She/her” is the current default in the entries below, but this may be subject to change later and YMMV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InnocentInnuendo: The Gamer system initially sets one of Luffy’s respawn points in Yamato’s bedroom. Both of them give people the wrong impression when talking about how he got there and what they were doing.

Added: 141

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DungeonBypass: The game menu keeps trying to assign and manage quests that have multiple steps and requirements to fulfill before one gets to the end. Luffy tends to skip to the part where he punches the main bad guy.

to:

* DungeonBypass: The game menu keeps trying to assign and manage quests that have multiple steps and requirements to fulfill before one gets to the end. Luffy tends to either skip to the part where he punches the main bad guy.guy, or grab what he wants and leave.
** He also treats gates, prison bars, and other physical barriers as something to casually move out of the way when they become inconvenient.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OffstageVillainy: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.

to:

* OffstageVillainy: (Assumed) When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArbitrarySkepticism: [[spoiler:Smoker]] doesn't believe a dog can learn to play card games. He lives in a world where animals sometimes display intelligent behavior far beyond that. This might be explained by the fact he is stationed in the East Blue where the fantastical elements of the ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' setting are toned down significantly.

to:

* ArbitrarySkepticism: [[spoiler:Smoker]] doesn't believe a dog can learn to play card games. He lives in a world where animals sometimes display intelligent behavior far beyond that.a starfish can be a noteworthy fashion designer. This might be explained by the fact he is stationed in the East Blue where the fantastical elements of the ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' setting are toned down significantly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DungeonBypass: The game menu keeps trying to assign and manage quests that have multiple steps and requirements before one gets to the end. Luffy tends to skip to the part where he punches the main bad guy.

to:

* DungeonBypass: The game menu keeps trying to assign and manage quests that have multiple steps and requirements to fulfill before one gets to the end. Luffy tends to skip to the part where he punches the main bad guy.



* ItsPersonal: Zoro accuses Nami of just wanting to claim Arlong's bounty. She makes it clear how much she just wants him dead.
* KidnappedByTheCall: Luffy and crew didn't go anywhere near [[spoiler:Sanji]] and so didn't have the change to recruit him. However, [[spoiler:Yamato]] needs a guide to show her the way when she finds out where Luffy is going. [[spoiler:Sanji]] isn't given a choice in the matter.

to:

* ItsPersonal: Zoro accuses Nami of just wanting to claim Arlong's bounty. She makes it clear how much pain he has caused her and how much she just wants him dead.
* KidnappedByTheCall: Luffy and crew didn't go anywhere near [[spoiler:Sanji]] and so didn't have the change chance to recruit him. However, [[spoiler:Yamato]] needs a guide to show her the way when she finds out where Luffy is going. [[spoiler:Sanji]] isn't given a choice in the matter.



* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Nami's behavior towards Luffy changes completely once she sees his bounty. She puts on a cheerful face, but is constantly terrified of the unstoppable monster she things he is.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Nami's behavior towards Luffy changes completely once she sees his bounty. She puts on a cheerful face, but is constantly terrified of the unstoppable monster she things thinks he is.



* TakeAThirdOption: If you present Luffy with a puzzle or a SadisticChoice, the result is likely to be something other than what you were expecting.

to:

* TakeAThirdOption: If you present Luffy with a puzzle or a SadisticChoice, choice with limited options, the result is likely to be something other than what you were expecting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CostumePorn: [[spoiler:Yamato]] steals a set of clothing from a high-end boutique. When she learns where Luffy is and reveals herself, she looks fabulous.

to:

* CostumePorn: [[spoiler:Yamato]] steals a set of clothing from a high-end boutique. When she learns where Luffy is and reveals herself, she looks fabulous.'''fabulous'''.



* CuttingTheKnot: Luffy tend to take a direct approach or third option whenever the gamer menu tries to present him with a puzzle or dilemma.
* DealWithTheDevil: When Nami asks Luffy to get rid of Arlong, she thinks she's making one of these.
* DidWeJustHaveTeaWithCthulhu: Once people become aware of how powerful Luffy is and how high his bounty is, relative to everyone else in the area, all their social interactions with Luffy have an element of this.

to:

* CuttingTheKnot: Luffy tend tends to take a direct approach or third option whenever the gamer menu tries to present him with a puzzle or dilemma.
* DealWithTheDevil: When Nami offers to join Luffy's crew and asks Luffy him to get rid of Arlong, she thinks she's making one of these.
* DidWeJustHaveTeaWithCthulhu: Once people become aware of how powerful Luffy is and how high his bounty is, relative to everyone else in the area, all their social interactions with Luffy have take on an element of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KidnappedbytheCall: Luffy and crew didn't go anywhere near [[spoiler:Sanji]] and so didn't have the change to recruit him. However, [[spoiler:Yamato]] needs a guide to show her the way when she finds out where Luffy is going. [[spoiler:Sanji]] isn't given a choice in the matter.

to:

* KidnappedbytheCall: KidnappedByTheCall: Luffy and crew didn't go anywhere near [[spoiler:Sanji]] and so didn't have the change to recruit him. However, [[spoiler:Yamato]] needs a guide to show her the way when she finds out where Luffy is going. [[spoiler:Sanji]] isn't given a choice in the matter.

Added: 115

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcheivementsInIgnorance: Luffy has no concept of video games or RPG mechanics. He keeps breaking the rules and smashing through the plot contrivances because he doesn't understand them.

to:

* AcheivementsInIgnorance: AchievementsInIgnorance: Luffy has no concept of video games or RPG mechanics. He keeps breaking the rules and smashing through the plot contrivances because he doesn't understand them.


Added DiffLines:

* AnimalEspionage: [[spoiler:Yamato]] isn't really a [[spoiler:dog]], but she uses that form to spy on the marines.

Added: 1277

Changed: 251

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeIsAPower: Luffy starts his journey having unlocked and mastered [[spoiler:Haki]]. Including the [[spoiler:Colors of the Conquerer]]. That's a power that pretty much runs on this principle.

to:

* AwesomeIsAPower: AcheivementsInIgnorance: Luffy has no concept of video games or RPG mechanics. He keeps breaking the rules and smashing through the plot contrivances because he doesn't understand them.
* AdaptationPersonalityChange: While most of the setting seems to be based on the Anime, some of the characters seem to be based on, or at least influenced by, their live action Netflix versions.
* ArbitrarySkepticism: [[spoiler:Smoker]] doesn't believe a dog can learn to play card games. He lives in a world where animals sometimes display intelligent behavior far beyond that. This might be explained by the fact he is stationed in the East Blue where the fantastical elements of the ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' setting are toned down significantly.
* AwesomenessIsAForce:
Luffy starts his journey having unlocked and mastered [[spoiler:Haki]]. Including the [[spoiler:Colors of the Conquerer]]. That's a power that pretty much runs on this principle.



* KidnappedbytheCall: Luffy and crew didn't go anywhere near [[spoiler:Sanji]] and so didn't have the change to recruit him. However, [[spoiler:Yamato]] needs a guide to show her the way when she finds out where Luffy is going. [[spoiler:Sanji]] isn't given a choice in the matter.



* TakeAThirdOption: If you present Luffy with a puzzle or a SadisticChoice, the result is likely to be something other than what you were expecting.

to:

* TakeAThirdOption: If you present Luffy with a puzzle or a SadisticChoice, the result is likely to be something other than what you were expecting.expecting.
* TerrifyingRescuer: Luffy, and later Zoro, have a tendency to rush in and save the day while announcing they are pirates and laying waste to everything in their path. Reactions from bystanders and rescued victims range from frightened to confused.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeIsAPower: Luffy starts his journey having unlocked and mastered [[spoiler:Haki]]. Including the [[spoiler:Colors of the Conquerer]]. That's a power that pretty much runs on this principle.



* DealWithTheDevil: When Nami asks Luffy to get rid of Arlong, she thinks she's making one of these.



* EmpathicWeapon: Yamato's kanabo, Takeru, has an aura about it that gives experienced characters an impression of its wielder. Zoro muses on how this is true of most weapons in the world with impressive users or histories.



* TheMole: [[spoiler:Yamato]] gets separated from Luffy when they start out. She uses her [[spoiler:zoan devil fruit to pose as a dog]] and spy on the marines tasked to find him.
* NotTheWayItIsMeantToBePlayed: ''Webcomic/TheGamer'' menu system is trying to impose RPG rules and plot rails. Luffy exists to break rules.



* ScriptBreaking: The menu system of ''Webcomic/TheGamer'' keeps trying to follow TheStationsOfTheCanon and make Luffy do things in certain ways in a certain order. When this comes up against Luffy's determination to be free to do what he wants, things get...glitchy.

to:

* ScriptBreaking: The menu system of ''Webcomic/TheGamer'' keeps trying to follow TheStationsOfTheCanon and make Luffy do things in certain ways in a certain order. When this comes up against Luffy's determination to be free to do what he wants, things get...glitchy.glitchy.
* TakeAThirdOption: If you present Luffy with a puzzle or a SadisticChoice, the result is likely to be something other than what you were expecting.

Added: 1318

Changed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CuttingTheKnot: Luffy tend to take a direct approach or third option whenever the gamer menu tries to present him with a puzzle or dilemma.



* DirtyBusiness: Nami, at least for a while, is under the impression that Luffy is just as much a monster as Arlong, just on a bigger scale. In spite of this, she'll join his crew and do whatever he asks as long as it gets rid of Arlong and saves her hometown.



* OffstageVillainy: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.

to:

* DungeonBypass: The game menu keeps trying to assign and manage quests that have multiple steps and requirements before one gets to the end. Luffy tends to skip to the part where he punches the main bad guy.
* FearlessFool: This tends to be people's first impression of Luffy. Eventually they learn he has no fear because nothing in this part of the world could possibly be a threat to him.
* ItsPersonal: Zoro accuses Nami of just wanting to claim Arlong's bounty. She makes it clear how much she just wants him dead.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Nami's behavior towards Luffy changes completely once she sees his bounty. She puts on a cheerful face, but is constantly terrified of the unstoppable monster she things he is.
* OffstageVillainy: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.bounty.
* ScriptBreaking: The menu system of ''Webcomic/TheGamer'' keeps trying to follow TheStationsOfTheCanon and make Luffy do things in certain ways in a certain order. When this comes up against Luffy's determination to be free to do what he wants, things get...glitchy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13777231/1/What-s-HP-Does-it-taste-good What's HP? Does it Taste Good?]] by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 xolef225]] is a ''Manga/{{OnePiece}}'' fanfiction in which Luffy has the powers of ''WebComic{{TheGamer}}''. What makes this unique is that Luffy has no idea what a video game is and doesn't understand most of what the "mystery boxes" he can see are trying to tell him.

to:

[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13777231/1/What-s-HP-Does-it-taste-good What's HP? Does it Taste Good?]] by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 xolef225]] is a ''Manga/{{OnePiece}}'' ''Manga/{{One Piece}}'' fanfiction in which Luffy has the powers of ''WebComic{{TheGamer}}''.''Webcomic/TheGamer''. What makes this unique is that Luffy has no idea what a video game is and doesn't understand most of what the "mystery boxes" he can see are trying to tell him.



* ComedicInvincibleHero: Between the effects of the Gamer system and having Yamato as a sparring partner, Luffy is hilariously overpowered relative to everything else the East Blue when he starts out.

to:

* ComedicInvincibleHero: ComicallyInvincibleHero: Between the effects of the Gamer system and having Yamato as a sparring partner, Luffy is hilariously overpowered relative to everything else the East Blue when he starts out.



* OffstageVillany: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.

to:

* OffstageVillany: OffstageVillainy: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-> From the [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 Author]] "I'll give it to you straight, Doc. This is by far (and I can't stress this enough) the stupidest fucking idea I've ever had for a story. Not only did I write it, but I also went ahead and posted it.

->"Why?" you may ask. Now, if you take a glance at the character tags, you'll immediately realize that I'm a shameless individual and that I'll do terrible, terrible things in order to get something that I want.

->In this case, the "terrible thing" is making Luffy a Gamer protagonist, and "What I want" is having Yamato in my story before the Onigashima arc.''

[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13777231/1/What-s-HP-Does-it-taste-good What's HP? Does it Taste Good?]] by [[https://www.fanfiction.net/u/4665214/xolef225 xolef225]] is a ''Manga/{{OnePiece}}'' fanfiction in which Luffy has the powers of ''WebComic{{TheGamer}}''. What makes this unique is that Luffy has no idea what a video game is and doesn't understand most of what the "mystery boxes" he can see are trying to tell him.

Also available on [[https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/whats-hp-does-it-taste-good-illustrated-one-piece.1012596/ SpaceBattles]] with illustrations from the author.

!!This fanfic contains examples of:
* BewareTheSillyOnes: This applies to Luffy even more so than usual.
* ComedicInvincibleHero: Between the effects of the Gamer system and having Yamato as a sparring partner, Luffy is hilariously overpowered relative to everything else the East Blue when he starts out.
* CostumePorn: [[spoiler:Yamato]] steals a set of clothing from a high-end boutique. When she learns where Luffy is and reveals herself, she looks fabulous.
* CurbStompBattle: Luffy is starting out on his journey with abilities comparable to what the canon version of the character had after the two-year time skip. Every battle in the East Blue is this if he takes it at all seriously.
* DidWeJustHaveTeaWithCthulhu: Once people become aware of how powerful Luffy is and how high his bounty is, relative to everyone else in the area, all their social interactions with Luffy have an element of this.
* DodgeTheBullet: In canon, Luffy at this stage in the story tended to just let bullets and blunt attacks hit him and let his rubber-body powers negate the damage. This version dodges everything and thinks it's obvious that he would do that.
* OffstageVillany: When people see how high Luffy's bounty is, they tend to assume he's done horrible things in the past to get that bounty.

Top