Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Expy / LiveACtionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** RusselTDavies seems to have carried over a lot of charactaristics from his own shows as well. Jack has a lot of features from Davies' version of DoctorWho and Gwen's role comes close to that of his companions. But there are also a lot of heavy influences from his breakthough show, QueerAsFolk: Jack shares personality, libido and magnetism with Stuart, while Ianto seems to get his somewhat romantic, cheery outlook, his snark and his devotion to Jack from Stuart's counterpart Vince.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You could argue that Kabuto's protagonist is basically Stronger's turned UpToEleven.

Changed: 26

Removed: 28

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Repair Dont Respond; up with capitalism;


* The character of Doyle on ''{{Angel}}'' is rather similar to Whistler, a character who appeared in the season 2 finale of ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer''. Both are Irish, both are demons, both help Angel out, both serve [[spoiler: {or served, in Doyle's case)]] as intermediaries for The PowersThatBe, both are frequently sarcastic... WordOfGod in fact says Whistler was originally intended as Angel's sidekick, but schedule conflicts with the actor caused them to use Doyle instead. Which creates a certain amount of overlap with SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute.
** ... Whistler isn't Irish.

to:

* The character of Doyle on ''{{Angel}}'' is rather similar to Whistler, a character who appeared in the season 2 two finale of ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer''. Both are Irish, both are demons, both help Angel out, both serve [[spoiler: {or served, in Doyle's case)]] as intermediaries for The PowersThatBe, both are frequently sarcastic... WordOfGod in fact says Whistler was originally intended as Angel's sidekick, but schedule conflicts with the actor caused them to use Doyle instead. Which creates a certain amount of overlap with SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute.
** ... Whistler isn't Irish.
SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute.



** then again this is part of Whedon's Signature style, Xander also filled a role similar to the above two. in fact whedon called Wash [[RecycledINSPACE the Space Xander]]

to:

** then Then again this is part of Whedon's Signature style, Xander also filled a role similar to the above two. in In fact whedon Whedon called Wash [[RecycledINSPACE the Space Xander]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ... Whistler isn't Irish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Edited for redlinks and other formatting issues.


* For ''StarTrekVoyager'' the creators wanted to bring back Nicholas Locarno, a character from a TNG episode. However, the character had been created by the writer of that episode and not by TNG's creators or executive producers (as was the case for recurring characters such as O'Brien or Worf, which could be reused). Because of this, the creators of ''Voyager'' thought they'd have to pay royalties to the writer of that episode every time they used the character, and that led them to create a new character similar to Locarno's named Tom Paris with a similar back story and who would be played by the same actor. To cover the transparent change, the creators said that they decided Locarno was unredeemable due to his actions in the episode, but Tom Paris's actions (which were more like Wesley's in the original episode) were less culpable. [[hottip:*:However, the only difference between Locarno's actions and Paris's, as heard onscreen, is that ''three'' died in the Paris version instead of ''one'' as in the Locarno version!]] Interestingly, many years later a California court ruled that producers in a similar situation didn't have to pay royalties to a writer who created a character; had the producers of ''Voyager'' chosen to take the matter to court, they might have been cleared to use the character Locarno.
** B'Elanna was supposed to be Ro Laren. Apparently they wanted her to be on DS9 (later replaced with Kira) and then tried again with Voyager (later replaced with B'Elanna) but the actress kept saying no.

to:

* For ''StarTrekVoyager'' the creators wanted to bring back Nicholas Locarno, a character from a TNG ''[[StarTrekTheNextGeneration Next Generation]]'' episode. However, the character had been created by the writer of that episode and not by TNG's ''TNG'''s creators or executive producers (as was the case for recurring characters such as O'Brien or Worf, which could be reused). Because of this, the creators of ''Voyager'' thought they'd have to pay royalties to the writer of that episode every time they used the character, and that led them to create a new character similar to Locarno's named Tom Paris with a similar back story and who would be played by the same actor. To cover the transparent change, the creators said that they decided Locarno was unredeemable due to his actions in the episode, but Tom Paris's actions (which were more like Wesley's in the original episode) were less culpable. [[hottip:*:However, the only difference between Locarno's actions and Paris's, as heard onscreen, is that ''three'' died in the Paris version instead of ''one'' as in the Locarno version!]] Interestingly, many years later a California court ruled that producers in a similar situation didn't have to pay royalties to a writer who created a character; had the producers of ''Voyager'' chosen to take the matter to court, they might have been cleared to use the character Locarno.
** B'Elanna was supposed to be Ro Laren. Apparently they wanted her to be on DS9 ''[[StarTrekDeepSpaceNine Deep Space Nine]]'' (later replaced with Kira) and then tried again with Voyager ''Voyager'' (later replaced with B'Elanna) but the actress kept saying no.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The "Assignment Earth" episode of [[StarTrekTOS the Original Series]] featured Gary Seven. Let's see... enigmatic time traveller, [[FanService hot]] [[TheWatson assistant chick]], [[MagicTool pen-shaped do-anything multitool]], interest in keeping Earth's history on the right track... [[IncrediblyLamePun Who]] [[DoctorWho does that sound like?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Some people claim that the characters in ''TheMiddle'' are like the characters of ''MalcolmInTheMiddle''. Axl (awkward teenager who's not that smart) would be Reese, Brick (little kid who is a little bit too smart) would be Dewey, and so forth. Even the setting is similar (somewhere in the middle of suburbia).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The angel Castiel on ''{{Supernatural}}'' is an Expy of [[{{Hellblazer}} John Constantine]]. The show's creator, Eric Kripke, said that he wanted to be able to bring Constantine in for a couple of episodes and work with the Winchester brothers on a case, but it seems that idea fell through, so he created Castiel instead. Castiel's actor, Misha Collins, has even admitted that the character is based on Constantine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
You are. And please don\'t use first person in the main articles.


* Try watching iCarly side-by-side with Reba and tell me that Spencer dosen't resemble Van in the least. They look kind somewhat similar, they're voices sound virtually identical, both are loveable goodball characters who have similar strange interests and CloudCuckooLander moments, PLEASE tell me i'm not the only person who sees the similarities!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[MightyMorphinPowerRangers Dragonzord]]/[[KyoryuSentaiZyuranger Dragon Caesar]] is an expy of {{Godzilla}} ''and'' Mecha Godzilla

Added: 598

Changed: 190

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


****While not 100% matches ([[CaptainErsatz covered elsewhere]]) it's the same role. You have the Doctor type (Nine/Ten, Sarah Jane, Eleven), the main, female companion (Rose, Maria, Amy) and the somewhat buffoonish (neither of the latter to the degree of day-one Mickey, but if anyone's gonna be the butt of a joke, or have the comedy of the moment come of their reaction to something, guess who?) male secondary one (Mickey, Clyde, Rory.) All three begin to grow out of it over time, though; Clyde in particular becomes more of a snarker.



* For ''StarTrekVoyager'' the creators wanted to bring back Nicholas Locarno, a character from a TNG episode. However, the character had been created by the writer of that episode and not by TNG's creators or executive producers (as was the case for recurring characters such as O'Brien or Worf, which could be reused). Because of this, the creators of ''Voyager'' thought they'd have to pay royalties to the writer of that episode every time they used the character, and that led them to create a new character similar to Locarno's named Tom Paris with a similar back story and who would be played by the same actor. To cover the transparent change, the creators said that they decided Locarno was unredeemable due to his actions in the episode, but Tom Paris's actions (which were more like Wesley's in the original episode) were less culpable. Interestingly, many years later a California court ruled that producers in a similar situation didn't have to pay royalties to a writer who created a character; had the producers of ''Voyager'' chosen to take the matter to court, they might have been cleared to use the character Locarno.

to:

* For ''StarTrekVoyager'' the creators wanted to bring back Nicholas Locarno, a character from a TNG episode. However, the character had been created by the writer of that episode and not by TNG's creators or executive producers (as was the case for recurring characters such as O'Brien or Worf, which could be reused). Because of this, the creators of ''Voyager'' thought they'd have to pay royalties to the writer of that episode every time they used the character, and that led them to create a new character similar to Locarno's named Tom Paris with a similar back story and who would be played by the same actor. To cover the transparent change, the creators said that they decided Locarno was unredeemable due to his actions in the episode, but Tom Paris's actions (which were more like Wesley's in the original episode) were less culpable. [[hottip:*:However, the only difference between Locarno's actions and Paris's, as heard onscreen, is that ''three'' died in the Paris version instead of ''one'' as in the Locarno version!]] Interestingly, many years later a California court ruled that producers in a similar situation didn't have to pay royalties to a writer who created a character; had the producers of ''Voyager'' chosen to take the matter to court, they might have been cleared to use the character Locarno.


Added DiffLines:

**In terms of the suits. The characters are nothing alike.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The cast of {{Glee}} have many similarities to the cast of Ryan Murphy's other high school drama {{Popular}}, as shown by this [[http://chicago.metromix.com/movies/essay_photo_gallery/smackdown-glee-vs-popular/1850602/photo/1850744 article]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Malcolm Reynolds from ''{{Firefly}}'' is in many ways an {{Expy}} of Han Solo from ''{{Star Wars}}'', and many critics have noted the similarities. Both are LovableRouge / JerkWithAHeartOfGold smugglers who command [[WhatAPieceOfJunk old, rustbucket freighters]] and try to make a living beyond the reach of the law. As well, both are prone to [[WhyDontYaJustShootHim ruthless pragmatism]], [[GoodOldFisticuffs brawling]] and [[ChaoticGood anti-authoritarian]]/StrawAtheist tendencies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Malcolm Reynolds from ''{{Firefly}}'' is in many ways an {{Expy}} of Han Solo from ''{{Star Wars}}'', and many critics have noted the similarities. Both are LovableRouge/JerkWithAHeartOfGold smugglers who command [[WhatAPieceOfJunk old, rustbucket freighters]] and try to make a living beyond the reach of the law. As well, both are prone to [[WhyDontYaJustShootHim ruthless pragmatism]], [[GoodOldFisticuffs brawling]] and [[ChaoticGood anti-authoritarian]]/StrawAtheist tendencies.

to:

* Malcolm Reynolds from ''{{Firefly}}'' is in many ways an {{Expy}} of Han Solo from ''{{Star Wars}}'', and many critics have noted the similarities. Both are LovableRouge/JerkWithAHeartOfGold LovableRouge / JerkWithAHeartOfGold smugglers who command [[WhatAPieceOfJunk old, rustbucket freighters]] and try to make a living beyond the reach of the law. As well, both are prone to [[WhyDontYaJustShootHim ruthless pragmatism]], [[GoodOldFisticuffs brawling]] and [[ChaoticGood anti-authoritarian]]/StrawAtheist tendencies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Malcolm Reynolds from ''{{Firefly}}'' is in many ways an {{Expy}} of Han Solo from ''{{Star Wars}}'', and many critics have noted the similarities. Both are LovableRouge/JerkWithAHeartOfGold smugglers who command [[WhatAPieceOfJunk old, rustbucket freighters]] and try to make a living beyond the reach of the law. As well, both are prone to [[WhyDontYaJustShootHim ruthless pragmatism]], [[GoodOldFisticuffs brawling]] and [[ChaoticGood anti-authoritarian]]/StrawAtheist tendencies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Until he hit that. Now she's all up in his jock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* KamenRiderStronger was basically [[KamenRiderKabuto Kabuto]]'s prototype.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is an odd one, because the original characters never actually made it to screen without substantial revisions, but reading Joss Whedon's first draft script of ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'' shows some definite parallels with the main characters of Whedon's later TV series ''{{Firefly}}''. Both feature a crew of smuggler outlaws on a small, sturdy old ship (the ''Betty'' in ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'', and ''Serenity'' in ''{{Firefly}}''), and some characters are written similarly as well: Johner and Jayne are quite similar even in the final film, Elgyn is written as quite similar to Mal, Zoe seems to be a composite of the original conceptions of Hillard and Christie, and a character from the script called Rane (apparently [[CompositeCharacter combined]] with Hillard in later drafts) is sort of similar to Wash.

to:

* This is an odd one, because the original characters never actually made it to screen without substantial revisions, but reading Joss Whedon's first draft script of ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'' Resurrection]]'' shows some definite parallels with the main characters of Whedon's later TV series ''{{Firefly}}''. Both feature a crew of smuggler outlaws on a small, sturdy old ship (the ''Betty'' in ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'', Resurrection]]'', and ''Serenity'' in ''{{Firefly}}''), and some characters are written similarly as well: Johner and Jayne are quite similar even in the final film, Elgyn is written as quite similar to Mal, Zoe seems to be a composite of the original conceptions of Hillard and Christie, and a character from the script called Rane (apparently [[CompositeCharacter combined]] with Hillard in later drafts) is sort of similar to Wash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* This is an odd one, because the original characters never actually made it to screen without substantial revisions, but reading Joss Whedon's first draft script of ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'' shows some definite parallels with the main characters of Whedon's later TV series ''{{Firefly}}''. Both feature a crew of smuggler outlaws on a small, sturdy old ship (the ''Betty'' in ''[[Film/{{Alien}} Alien Resurrection'', and ''Serenity'' in ''{{Firefly}}''), and some characters are written similarly as well: Johner and Jayne are quite similar even in the final film, Elgyn is written as quite similar to Mal, Zoe seems to be a composite of the original conceptions of Hillard and Christie, and a character from the script called Rane (apparently [[CompositeCharacter combined]] with Hillard in later drafts) is sort of similar to Wash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not to mention {{Green Arrow}} who shifts between a more or less a version as he appears in the comics, and DC's [[{{Batman}} more prominent non-powered super hero]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also subverted with the 'Percy' character - in series two he's like the later series' Darling another McKinnery character, but in series 4 Percy is an expy of Prince George (both being Hugh Laurie)
** In fact it's less the characters being expys, as the actors 'themselves' being expys of their previous roles...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Controversial example from ''{{Farscape}}'': late-period recurring villain Mele-On Grayza was a very obvious Expy for Servalan, the BigBad of ''BlakesSeven''. Unfortunately, the concept of the Expy was based on the idea "what if Servalan actually was an airheaded tart whose sole talent was having sex with people, instead of just dressing like one so that people would underestimate her?". Hence the many ''Blakes Seven'' fans who are also into ''Farscape'' tend to have [[Understatement somewhat negative]] reactions to the character.

to:

* Controversial example from ''{{Farscape}}'': late-period recurring villain Mele-On Grayza was a very obvious Expy for Servalan, the BigBad of ''BlakesSeven''. Unfortunately, the concept of the Expy was based on the idea "what if Servalan actually was an airheaded tart whose sole talent was having sex with people, instead of just dressing like one so that people would underestimate her?". Hence the many ''Blakes Seven'' fans who are also into ''Farscape'' tend to have [[Understatement [[{{Understatement}} somewhat negative]] reactions to the character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Controversial example from ''{{Farscape}}'': late-period recurring villain Mele-On Grayza was a very obvious Expy for Servalan, the BigBad of ''BlakesSeven''. Unfortunately, the concept of the Expy was based on the idea "what if Servalan actually was an airheaded tart whose sole talent was having sex with people, instead of just dressing like one so that people would underestimate her?". Hence the many ''Blakes Seven'' fans who are also into ''Farscape'' tend to have [[Understatement somewhat negative]] reactions to the character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It's a stretch, but the character of Gary Allen in ''the Adventures of Superman'' episode, "The Deadly Rock" is a detective with whom Clark is friends, and is played by Robert Lowery who played {{Batman}} in the 1949 serial ''Batman & Robin''. Thus, he could be seen as a very, very, very loose quasi-expy of Ba... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Every character in Beverly Hills 90210 has an almost perfect parallel character in the new 90210. Kelly is now Naomi, David (or, alternatively interpreted, Donna) is Navid, Dylan is Liam, and so on into infinite.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Considering how much HouseMD was based on the Sherlock Holmes stories, clearly the expies are there. House is Sherlock obviously, the InsufferableGenius with his DeadpanSnarker side. Wilson is Watson, the Straight Man to House's Wise Guy. Stretching it a little further, Dr. Cuddy is Inspector Lestrade, who used to do House's legwork and has the same "I hate you, but you're too valuable to get rid of" tone we see in Lestrade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Richard Armitage's portrayal of Guy of Gisbourne in the BBC's ''[[Series/RobinHood]]'': give him an eyepatch, and he'd ''be'' [[BlakesSeven Space Commander Travis]].

to:

* Richard Armitage's portrayal of Guy of Gisbourne in the BBC's ''[[Series/RobinHood]]'': ''[[Series/RobinHood Robin Hood]]'': give him an eyepatch, and he'd ''be'' [[BlakesSeven Space Commander Travis]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Richard Armitage's portrayal of Guy of Gisbourne in the BBC's ''[[Series/RobinHood]]'': give him an eyepatch, and he'd ''be'' [[BlakesSeven Space Commander Travis]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not to mention that they have the same fake British accent (Marsters is American, hard to believe, I know) and the ability to be CrazyAwesome at the drop of a hat. Oh, and former writer for Buffy, Jane Espenson will be writing three episodes. I'd be willing to bet money that at least one will contain John.

Top