Follow TV Tropes

Following

History DiesDifferentlyInAdaptation / LiveActionFilm

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/AntonyAndCleopatra'', as Creator/WilliamShakespeare wrote it, Enobarbas [[DeathByDespair dies of despair]] over having abandoned Antony for Caesar, as does Cleopatra's handmaiden Iras as Cleopatra is about to [[DrivenToSuicide kill herself]]. In the 1972 film version starring Creator/CharltonHeston and Hildegarde Neil in the title roles, however, both of these deaths are changed to [[DrivenToSuicide suicides]]: Enobarbus throws himself from a cliff into the sea, and Iras stabs herself.

to:

* In ''Theatre/AntonyAndCleopatra'', as Creator/WilliamShakespeare wrote it, Enobarbas Enobarbus [[DeathByDespair dies of despair]] over having abandoned Antony for Caesar, as does Cleopatra's handmaiden Iras as Cleopatra is about to [[DrivenToSuicide kill herself]]. In the 1972 film version starring Creator/CharltonHeston and Hildegarde Neil in the title roles, however, both of these deaths are changed to [[DrivenToSuicide suicides]]: Enobarbus throws himself from a cliff into the sea, and Iras stabs herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/AntomyAndCleopatra'', as Creator/WilliamShakespeare wrote it, Enobarbas [[DeathByDespair dies of despair]] over having abandoned Antony for Caesar, as does Cleopatra's handmaiden Iras as Cleopatra is about to [[DrivenToSuicide kill herself]]. In the 1972 film version starring Creator/CharltonHeston and Hildegarde Neil in the title roles, however, both of these deaths are changed to [[DrivenToSuicide suicides]]: Enobarbus throws himself from a cliff into the sea, and Iras stabs herself.

to:

* In ''Theatre/AntomyAndCleopatra'', ''Theatre/AntonyAndCleopatra'', as Creator/WilliamShakespeare wrote it, Enobarbas [[DeathByDespair dies of despair]] over having abandoned Antony for Caesar, as does Cleopatra's handmaiden Iras as Cleopatra is about to [[DrivenToSuicide kill herself]]. In the 1972 film version starring Creator/CharltonHeston and Hildegarde Neil in the title roles, however, both of these deaths are changed to [[DrivenToSuicide suicides]]: Enobarbus throws himself from a cliff into the sea, and Iras stabs herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Theatre/AntomyAndCleopatra'', as Creator/WilliamShakespeare wrote it, Enobarbas [[DeathByDespair dies of despair]] over having abandoned Antony for Caesar, as does Cleopatra's handmaiden Iras as Cleopatra is about to [[DrivenToSuicide kill herself]]. In the 1972 film version starring Creator/CharltonHeston and Hildegarde Neil in the title roles, however, both of these deaths are changed to [[DrivenToSuicide suicides]]: Enobarbus throws himself from a cliff into the sea, and Iras stabs herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While Nedry is killed by a ''Dilophosaurus'' in both novel and film, the film merely has one maul him to death inside his car. The novel is ''exceptionally'' more brutal - after he's blinded by its venom, the ''Dilophosaurus'' [[GuttedLikeAFish disembowels him]], with Nedry briefly holding his own innards before collapsing, after which it lifts him into the air by his head and finishes him off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/MaxPayne'', Jack Lupino has a smaller role than in the game and is killed by BB instead of Max. BB has a bigger role and is killed at the end, whereas his death in the game is closer to the middle.

Added: 655

Changed: 357

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/DoctorStrangelove'': In the original novel, ''Red Alert,'' the crew of the bomber wing, Alabama Angel, is a DwindlingParty whose members gradually die from Soviet missile strikes, including Captain Brown, who succumbs to his wounds from one such strike. The film's SignatureScene, meanwhile, has Brown's counterpart, Major Kong, [[RidingTheBomb plummet to thermonuclear annihilation while straddling one of the bombs]].



** ''Film/CasinoRoyale1967'': While Vesper Lind commits suicide in the novel, the parody film has her among the casualties when Jimmy Bond, having earlier ingested an [[ItMakesSenseInContext atomic pill, explodes and destroys the Casino]].

to:

** ''Film/CasinoRoyale1967'': While Vesper Lind Lynd commits suicide in [[Literature/CasinoRoyale the novel, the book]], leaving a note behind explaining her ties to SMERSH. The parody film has her among the casualties when Jimmy Bond, having earlier ingested an [[ItMakesSenseInContext atomic pill, explodes and destroys the Casino]].



** ''Film/CasinoRoyale2006'': Vesper commits suicide in [[Literature/CasinoRoyale the book]], leaving a note behind explaining her ties to SMERSH. The final sequence is actionized in the film, in which Vesper drowns.

to:

** ''Film/CasinoRoyale2006'': While Vesper still commits suicide in [[Literature/CasinoRoyale suicide, the book]], leaving a note behind explaining her ties to SMERSH. The final sequence is actionized in film [[ActionizedAdaptation actionizes the film, in which novel's climax]] by having Vesper drowns.allow herself to drown in a sinking Venetian palace.



* Minor examples in ''Franchise/LandOfOz'':

to:

* Minor A few examples concerning the Wicked Witch of the West in ''Franchise/LandOfOz'':


Added DiffLines:

** While the stage version of ''Theatre/TheWiz'' follows the book's confrontation closely, the [[Film/TheWiz reworked film]] has Dorothy simply pull the fire alarm at the Witch's sweatshop and let the sprinklers do their thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Film/CasinoRoyale1967'': While Vesper Lind commits suicide in the novel, the parody film has her among the casualties when Jimmy Bond, having earlier ingested an [[ItMakesSenseInContext atomic pill, explodes and destroys the Casino]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to Multimedia.


* In ''ComicBook/BatmanDarkVictory'', former GCPD commissioner Gillian Loeb was killed by Sofia Falcone hanging him during her killing spree as [[SamusIsAGirl the Hangman]]. In ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', Loeb, still commissioner, is poisoned by the Joker tampering with his alcohol.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''ComicBook/BatmanDarkVictory'', former GCPD commissioner Gillian Loeb was killed by Sofia Falcone hanging him during her killing spree as [[SamusIsAGirl the Hangman]]. In ''Film/TheDarkKnight'', Loeb, still commissioner, is poisoned by the Joker tampering with his alcohol.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the novel, ''The Executioners'', [[TheSociopath Max Cady]] is killed by a lucky shot from Sam Bowden after a failed ambush at the latter's home. While the 1962 film, ''Film/CapeFear'', has [[SparedByTheAdaptation Cady sent to jail instead]], the 1991 remake has Cady [[CombatBreakdown worn down from a long fight]] with Bowden and is swept away by the titular river.

to:

* In the novel, ''The Executioners'', [[TheSociopath Max Cady]] is killed by a lucky shot from Sam Bowden after a failed ambush at the latter's home. While the 1962 film, ''Film/CapeFear'', has [[SparedByTheAdaptation Cady sent to jail instead]], the 1991 remake has Cady swept away by the titular river after being [[CombatBreakdown worn down from a long fight]] with Bowden and is swept away by the titular river.Bowden.

Added: 427

Changed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheShining'': While Jack Torrance dies in the novel when the Overlook Hotel goes boom (see above), he dies in the movie when he freezes in the hedge maze during his pursuit of Danny.

to:

* ''Film/TheShining'': ''Film/TheShining'':
** Dick Hallorann gets a DeathByAdaptation when Jack drives an ax into his chest. His novel counterpart is struck with a croquet mallet, which he survives, and eventually passes away from natural causes many years later by the time ''Doctor Sleep'' begins.
**
While Jack Torrance dies in the novel when the Overlook Hotel goes boom (see above), he dies in the movie when he freezes in the hedge maze during his pursuit of Danny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Don Ciccio, who [[NoNameGiven isn't named in the novel]], is killed by Vito's father Antonio in a public struggle. ''Part II'' downgrades it to Ciccio being insulted when Antonio denies him tribute, allowing a grown Vito [[YouKilledMyFather to personally slay him in revenge]].

to:

** Don Ciccio, who [[NoNameGiven isn't named in the novel]], is killed by Vito's father Antonio in a public struggle. ''Part II'' downgrades it to Ciccio being insulted when Antonio denies him tribute, allowing with both scenarios ending with Antonio getting murdered by Ciccio's men. This allows a grown Vito [[YouKilledMyFather to personally slay him Ciccio in revenge]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheLittleMermaid2023'': Both the [[WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaid1989 animated film]] and its live-action remake have Ursula impaled with a shipwreck's broken bowsprit. The difference is who steers the ship into Ursula, with Eric doing so in the former, and Ariel in the latter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Strawberry Shortcake Murder'', Boyd Watson was killed by a single blow to the head with a ball peen hammer. In "Murder She Baked: Just Desserts", Leonard Bishop (his new name) was killed by being hit with a truck, and then suffocated with a football Jjersey when the truck didn't kill him. That could ''not'' have been fun.

to:

** In ''Strawberry Shortcake Murder'', Boyd Watson was killed by a single blow to the head with a ball peen hammer. In "Murder She Baked: Just Desserts", Leonard Bishop (his new name) was killed by being hit with a truck, and then suffocated with a football Jjersey jersey when the truck didn't kill him. That could ''not'' have been fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/Godzilla'':

to:

* ''Franchise/Godzilla'':''Franchise/{{Godzilla}}'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Vertigo}}'': Judy accidentally falls to her death from a belltower, much like Madeline, whom she impersonated, [[spoiler:was presumed to have been]]. In the original novel, ''The Living and the Dead'', Renee (Judy's counterpart) is strangled to death by an enraged Roger Flavières (Scottie's counterpart) after she revealed the plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/LesDiaboliques'': The 1956 film concerns an elaborate plot by a man and his mistress to scare his wife to death. The murder plot is tweaked from the original novel, ''She Who Was No More'', and replicated by the 1996 remake, ''Diaboliques''. While the 1956 film's Michel's plot succeeds, his novel and remake counterparts aren't lucky. In the novel, Farnand is DrivenToSuicide when he sees his wife is NotQuiteDead; in the remake, Guy is drowned for real by his wife and mistress.

to:

* ''Film/LesDiaboliques'': The 1956 film concerns an elaborate plot by a man and his mistress to scare his wife to death. The murder plot is tweaked from the original novel, ''She Who Was No More'', in which the man and mistress try to kill his wife straight away, and replicated by the 1996 remake, ''Diaboliques''. While the 1956 film's Michel's plot succeeds, his novel and remake counterparts aren't lucky. In the novel, Farnand is DrivenToSuicide when he sees his wife is NotQuiteDead; in the remake, Guy is drowned for real by his wife and mistress.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the first ''Literature/LeftBehind'' book, Dirk Burton dies by a gun shot that was made to look like a suicide. In ''Film/LeftBehindRiseOfTheAntichrist'', Dirk dies by a car bombing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/DDay'', a ForeignRemake of ''Film/{{Commando}}'':
** The original film opens with an assassination where two of the hero's ex-colleagues in the military were killed by hitmen disguised as garbage collectors and getting run over by a car. While the remake retains the garbage-collecting gunmen, the second victim was simply sniped and drowned.
** Subverted with Sully and his remake's equivalent, Stasik. Both of them are dropped to their deaths, however Stasik was dropped from a balcony naked (where his nude corpse will probably be uncovered later) while Sully was chucked off a cliff (and becomes fish food).
** The BigBad in the original was killed by being shotgunned out a window, while his remake equivalent was blown up via IED.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Theatre/CyranoDeBergerac'': The 1950 film version changes Cyrano's fatal injuries from getting struck by a falling log to getting struck by a carriage.

to:

* ''Theatre/CyranoDeBergerac'': ''Film/{{Cyrano de Bergerac|1950}}'': The 1950 film version changes Cyrano's fatal injuries from getting struck by a falling log to getting struck by a carriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/CocaineBear'': In real life, Andrew C. Thornton II, after jettisoning a supply of cocaine from a crashing plane, died jumping out of the plane and getting caught in his parachute. The opening of the film adds the wrinkle of him banging his head on the door while trying to jump out, knocking him unconscious as he falls to his death.

Added: 577

Changed: 237

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[Film/Godzilla1954 the original Godzilla movie]], Godzilla is killed by a special weapon called the Oxygen Destroyer. In [[Film/Godzilla1998 the 1998 American version]], the army just keeps firing missiles at Godzilla until he's dead.

to:

* ''Franchise/Godzilla'':
**
In [[Film/Godzilla1954 the original Godzilla movie]], Godzilla is killed by a special weapon called the Oxygen Destroyer. In [[Film/Godzilla1998 the 1998 American version]], the army just keeps firing missiles at Godzilla until he's dead.dead.
** Dr. Serizawa in the original film [[HeroicSacrifice sacrifices himself]] to activate the Oxygen Destroyer to ensure both his research and the Big G both perish. The Film/MonsterVerse Dr. Serizawa sacrifices himself in [[Film/GodzillaKingOfTheMonsters2019 the 2019 film]] to activate a nuclear warhead to speed up Godzilla's recovery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I was right


%%** In ''Film/AntMan1'', Darren Cross is killed when his Yellowjacket suit (tampered with by Scott Lang) crushes him to death, but in the comics, he dies of natural causes (essentially a heart attack) during a fight with Scott.

to:

%%** ** In ''Film/AntMan1'', Darren Cross is seemingly killed when his Yellowjacket suit (tampered with by Scott Lang) crushes him to death, but in the comics, death. ''Quantumania'' shows he actually survived [[CompositeCharacter to become Modok]], who ultimately dies [[HeroicSacrifice heroicly]] wounding Kang. His comic counterpart dies of natural causes (essentially a heart attack) during a fight with Scott.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Since Cross is back as Modok in Quantumania, he's not dead, though I'm still commenting out the example in case he's Killed Off For Real there.


** In ''Film/AntMan1'', Darren Cross is killed when his Yellowjacket suit (tampered with by Scott Lang) crushes him to death, but in the comics, he dies of natural causes (essentially a heart attack) during a fight with Scott.

to:

** %%** In ''Film/AntMan1'', Darren Cross is killed when his Yellowjacket suit (tampered with by Scott Lang) crushes him to death, but in the comics, he dies of natural causes (essentially a heart attack) during a fight with Scott.

Added: 607

Changed: 314

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/AllQuietOnTheWesternFront2022'': In the novel, Paul is killed under unspecified circumstances on an otherwise quiet and uneventful day a month before the armistice. Here, Paul is sent on a pointless charge against a French position in the last minutes of the war and bayonetted through the heart ''mere seconds'' before the armistice takes effect.

to:

* ''Film/AllQuietOnTheWesternFront2022'': ''Film/AllQuietOnTheWesternFront2022'':
**
In the novel, Paul is killed under unspecified circumstances on an otherwise quiet and uneventful day a month before the armistice. Here, Paul is sent on a pointless charge against a French position in the last minutes of the war and bayonetted through the heart ''mere seconds'' before the armistice takes effect. The previous films had Paul shot by a Sniper while admiring a butterfly (1930 film) or a bird (1979 TV movie).
** Kat is fatally wounded by shrapnel in the novel and 1930 film. The 2022 film has him gunned down by the young son of a farmer he and Paul frequently robbed throughout the film.

Added: 328

Changed: 328

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Separate examples, separate bullet points.


** ''Film/ForYourEyesOnly'': In [[Literature/ForYourEyesOnly the short story]] ''Ricisco'', Bond shoots Kristatos. In the film, Colombo kills him via knife to the back. Also, the opening sequence has Bond dropping a LawyerFriendlyCameo version of Blofeld down a smokestack; in the novels (specifically, ''Literature/YouOnlyLiveTwice''), Bond strangles him.

to:

** ''Film/ForYourEyesOnly'': ''Film/ForYourEyesOnly'':
***
In [[Literature/ForYourEyesOnly the short story]] ''Ricisco'', Bond shoots Kristatos. In the film, Colombo kills him via knife to the back. Also, the back.
*** The
opening sequence has Bond dropping a LawyerFriendlyCameo version of Blofeld down a smokestack; in the novels (specifically, ''Literature/YouOnlyLiveTwice''), Bond strangles him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added LA Confidential

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/LAConfidential'':
** In the film, Ed Exley's father Preston gets shot dead by a mugger prior to the events of the film. In the book [[spoiler:he commits suicide before Ed can expose him as a murderer.]]
** In the film, [[spoiler:Jack Vincennes]] gets shot dead by [[spoiler:Dudley Smith]]. In the book, he gets killed during a raid on a train carrying numerous prison inmates.
** In the film, [[spoiler:Sid Hudgens]] gets strangled to death by [[spoiler:Dudley Smith]]. In the book, he gets dismembered by [[spoiler:one of the "Dr. Frankenstein" killers]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Naomi Misora is DrivenToSuicide by Light in both manga/anime and film, but under different circumstances. It's unknown how Naomi kills herself in the source material, other than Light making sure they'll [[NeverFoundTheBody never find her body]]. In the movie, she shoots herself on-screen right after being driven to shoot and kill [[CanonForeigner Shiori]] by Light.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Audience Reactions do not belong here.


** The novel's Donald Gennarro makes it off the island, while DirtyCoward Ed Regis is devoured by a juvenile T-Rex. The film's Donald Gennarro [[CompositeCharacter combines the two characters]], who gets [[SignatureScene memorably]] [[TheCanKickedHim and humiliatingly devoured]] by the adult T-Rex. Death would eventually come for novel Gennarro by way of dysentery before ''Literature/{{The Lost World|1995}}'' happens.

to:

** The novel's Donald Gennarro makes it off the island, while DirtyCoward Ed Regis is devoured by a juvenile T-Rex. The film's Donald Gennarro [[CompositeCharacter combines the two characters]], who gets [[SignatureScene memorably]] [[TheCanKickedHim and humiliatingly devoured]] by the adult T-Rex. Death would eventually come for novel Gennarro by way of dysentery before ''Literature/{{The Lost World|1995}}'' happens.



* ''Film/{{Psycho}}'''s {{signature|scene}} shower scene played out differently compared to the novel. While Marion Crane was repeatedly stabbed to death by "mother," [[AdaptationNameChange Mary Crane]] was [[OffWithHisHead beheaded]] instead.

to:

* ''Film/{{Psycho}}'''s {{signature|scene}} shower scene played out differently compared to the novel. While Marion Crane was repeatedly stabbed to death by "mother," [[AdaptationNameChange Mary Crane]] was [[OffWithHisHead beheaded]] instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the novel, after Esmeralda is hanged, Quasimodo steals away to the mass grave for criminals and dies there holding Esmeralda's body. Since most film adaptations [[SparedByTheAdaptation spare Esmeralda's life]], those that still have Quasimodo die find different ways to kill him off. In both [[Film/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame1923 the 1923 silent film]] with Creator/LonChaney and the 1997 TV film with Creator/MandyPatinkin, he's stabbed by Frollo [[MutualKill just before throwing the latter from Notre Dame's parapet]], while in the 1982 film with Creator/AnthonyHopkins, he falls off the cathedral parapet himself. Only [[Film/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame the 1956 film]] with Creator/AnthonyQuinn keeps his original fate. (All other major versions have him SparedByTheAdaptation.)

to:

** In the novel, after Esmeralda is hanged, Quasimodo steals away to the mass grave for criminals and dies there holding Esmeralda's body. Since most film adaptations [[SparedByTheAdaptation spare Esmeralda's life]], those that still have Quasimodo die find different ways to kill him off. In both [[Film/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame1923 the 1923 silent film]] with Creator/LonChaney and the 1997 TV film with Creator/MandyPatinkin, he's stabbed by Frollo [[MutualKill just before throwing the latter from Notre Dame's parapet]], while in the 1982 film with Creator/AnthonyHopkins, he falls off the cathedral parapet himself. Only [[Film/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame [[Film/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame1956 the 1956 film]] with Creator/AnthonyQuinn keeps his original fate. (All other major versions have him SparedByTheAdaptation.)

Top