History DethroningMoment / SouthPark

20th Sep '17 11:52:06 PM jonathan-sherwin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of.
* gene0129: [[HateSink Skankhunt42]] [[spoiler: [[KarmaHoudini Not paying for his crimes.]] Yes, Bedrager ended up being the greater of two evils, but it was still total bullshit how they expected us to forget that he was the reason for dooming all of the world, for his selfish fun.]] What a miserable way to end, season 20 which looked as if it could be redeemed.




to:

* Tropers/JonathanSherwin: The episode "Put It Down" has a running gag (or as I'd like it call it "driving anti-gag") featuring distracted drivers running over a kid named Gary something-ovic in graphic detail, with the same thing happening to other kids... [[UpToEleven and even in the amusement park where Craig takes Tweek to distract him from North Korea!]] What the actual fuck, Trey and Matt?! That's gotta be the most horrifying and disgusting moments I've ever seen on the show recently! Speaking of Craig and Tweek, the latter's constant freaking out and obsessing over NK even had Craig losing control over his emotions after one time too many, and it matched my reaction perfectly. I never thought I'd have to hate a character to the point that another one matches my feelings exactly.
17th Sep '17 9:44:58 AM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/{{monkeyman224}}: As someone with AspergersSyndrome, this troper wasn't fond of them making fun of it without doing any research on it. First off, it's not a disease. I'd liken it more to a social dyslexia. You cannot catch it from anyone or anything. Second, they had the balls to make a statement signifying that it's the fucking same as being retarded. Last time I checked, someone with Asperger's is not retarded. To me it looks like all they did was decide that Asperger's Syndrome has a funny name to make fun of and went with that idea whilst having absolutely no idea what it really is.

to:

** Tropers/{{monkeyman224}}: As someone with AspergersSyndrome, UsefulNotes/AspergersSyndrome, this troper wasn't fond of them making fun of it without doing any research on it. First off, it's not a disease. I'd liken it more to a social dyslexia. You cannot catch it from anyone or anything. Second, they had the balls to make a statement signifying that it's the fucking same as being retarded. Last time I checked, someone with Asperger's is not retarded. To me it looks like all they did was decide that Asperger's Syndrome has a funny name to make fun of and went with that idea whilst having absolutely no idea what it really is.
14th Sep '17 1:54:27 PM jonathan-sherwin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of. All I'm hoping for is for Cartman to take revenge on them in Season 21, because, let's face it, they all deserve what's coming to them. [[ForWantOfANail Also, if all that didn't happen, then Cartman probably wouldn't have gotten together with Heidi Turner in the first place]].

to:

** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of. All I'm hoping for is for Cartman to take revenge on them in Season 21, because, let's face it, they all deserve what's coming to them. [[ForWantOfANail Also, if all that didn't happen, then Cartman probably wouldn't have gotten together with Heidi Turner in the first place]].
30th Aug '17 9:33:23 PM jonathan-sherwin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of. All I'm hoping for is Cartman to take revenge on them in Season 21, because, let's face it, they all deserve what's coming to them. [[ForWantOfANail Also, if all that didn't happen, then Cartman probably wouldn't have gotten together with Heidi Turner in the first place]].

to:

** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of. All I'm hoping for is for Cartman to take revenge on them in Season 21, because, let's face it, they all deserve what's coming to them. [[ForWantOfANail Also, if all that didn't happen, then Cartman probably wouldn't have gotten together with Heidi Turner in the first place]].
30th Aug '17 9:32:17 PM jonathan-sherwin
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/JonathanSherwin: Speaking of "Skank Hunt", the boys suspect that Cartman is the titular troll, because what SkankHunt42 did is something that's usually associated with him. Problem is, it's not actually him this time. That didn't stop them from luring him and his electronics to a cabin under false pretenses, then murdering all of his electronics (yes, I'm using the term "murdering" because the manner they destroyed the electronics is akin to flat-out murdering Cartman) despite his genuine pleads that he's not Skankhunt and his mother bought them for him. Never since "The Death of Eric Cartman" did I have to feel for Cartman because his friends had to emotionally fuck him up either because of something he did [[DisproportionateRetribution that wasn't a big deal]] (like him eating all the KFC chicken skins, for instance) or, in this case, something that he really wasn't a part of. All I'm hoping for is Cartman to take revenge on them in Season 21, because, let's face it, they all deserve what's coming to them. [[ForWantOfANail Also, if all that didn't happen, then Cartman probably wouldn't have gotten together with Heidi Turner in the first place]].
30th Aug '17 9:19:38 PM jonathan-sherwin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/When Did I Get Stabbed?: For me, a DMOS of the show is the beginning of "Dances with Smurfs". A ginger kid does the morning announcements but is interrupted when a gun-toting maniac busts into the office, claiming that he slept with his wife. To clarify: he heard that a middle-age truck driver named Gordon Saltsi slept with her; the ginger's name is Gordon Stoltski. So after killing a person who happened to intervene, he starts beating the kid up and then murders him, then himself. All heard over a P.A. system. [[DudeNotFunny That is the most fucked-up opening to an episode in television history.]] [[HarsherInHindsight Worse, the Sandy Hook Elementary shootings make this extremely grim.]] I mean, if the episode would've opened with his funeral and explained the reason why he died, then it would've been fine. It'd still be messed up because of the reason behind his death explained, but it would've been better than hearing the spectacle in horrifying detail. It's just the show once again rubbing in our faces: "Gingers are creepy and weird. Therefore, we do not like them." But this episode adds in: "To get our point across, let's kill a minor recurring ginger that you've only seen a few times."



** Tropers/Clark Nomah: Related to the Tyler Perry running gag, there's the unfortunate implication that only black people find him funny, as explained when Token is the only one to laugh at Madea's jokes. My white mother and a white friend of mine find Madea to be funny, so in the words of Stan Smith, T&M, your argument is invalid.



** Tropers/Jenko My Name Is Jeff: In the same episode, for me, it's the implication that Broadway is basically a brothel, complete with nonstop repetitions about blowjobs. It manages to be worse than Disney being handled that way in "The Ring". In other words, it's in very poor taste. Also, first Trey and Matt managed to get "shit" uncensored, and now "blowjob" (which was shortened to BJ in "The Ring"). After ''The Stick of Truth'' video game featured graphic female nudity, "The Magic Bush" features a sex scene complete with uncensored female breasts. What I'm saying is, Trey and Matt are coming ''very damn close'' to getting "fuck" and frontal male adult nudity uncensored--or, in other words, making Comedy Central their number-one bitch by having everything uncensored, thus fulfilling their prophecies.
5th Jun '17 12:59:55 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/fairygirl567: Oh, thank heavens I thought I was the only one who disliked the goth kids. For a show that makes fun of everyone and is good at doing it, the goth kids are the only people who they make fun and it's not funny! They are so one note to the point where I feel insulted and not just because I'm into goth culture, but because that's the whole joke for these characters. We get it, some goths can be hypocritical and moody, but they could've done more with this. Heck, Kyle and his cousin Kyle are great examples of this! As well as Token. I think Matt and Trey have gotten the hint though since the goth kids haven't made a major appreance in a while.
5th Jun '17 12:52:24 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** Tropers/{{fairygirl567}}: It was very obvious that they wanted or planned for Hilary to win as it was reported they had already written episodes involving her winning the election, it was never stated if they fully supported Hilary, but they didn't like Trump. The moment that went south and Trump surprisingly won, they had to do a bunch of rewrites to go with Trump winning and it was obvious... like a teenager rewriting a paper a day before it's due obvious. They also apparently really hate Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Now, this troper gets not everyone loves the Force Awakens, but Matt and Trey went out their way to apparently blame the director for Trump winning and why he had so many supporters... it made no sense at all. They just kept bashing it to the point where I yelled, "Okay we get it, you didn't think it was the best movie! It's not the reason Trump won though!" I'm surprised the director of the movie didn't call them out on this. They eventually stopped doing the "joke", but it was too late by then. I haven't watched any Star Wars movies and I was insulted and the member berries causing mind control came and went nowhere! We see the Marsh family, Mr. Garrison, and Katalin Jenner being affected just for it never be addressed again because they went back to focusing on the trolling incident... which was a way better arc.
3rd Jun '17 12:51:08 PM Gene0129
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* gene0129: [[HateSink Skankhunt42]] [[spoiler: [[KarmaHoudini Not paying for his crimes.]] Yes, Bedrager ended up being the greater of two evils, but it was still total bullshit how they expected us to forget that he was the reason for dooming all of the world, for his selfish fun.]] What a miserable way to end the otherwise decent season 20.

to:

* gene0129: [[HateSink Skankhunt42]] [[spoiler: [[KarmaHoudini Not paying for his crimes.]] Yes, Bedrager ended up being the greater of two evils, but it was still total bullshit how they expected us to forget that he was the reason for dooming all of the world, for his selfish fun.]] What a miserable way to end the otherwise decent end, season 20.20 which looked as if it could be redeemed.
26th May '17 10:05:09 AM mlsmithca
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/Metalheadfan2500 The episode "Go Fund Yourself" really bugged me, aside from not getting a strong laugh out of me, this episode is just ignorant. Matt and Trey bash on Kickstarter and crowdfunding in general, by commenting on the several people that abuse it for free money with weak ideas, sure that's ok for a cheap laugh, but what really annoyed me is that there is no mention of any positive contributions that crowdfunding has done. Aside from perhaps one poster mentioning a film festival, they failed to comment on all the cool indie games, animation, comics, short films, or whatever, which to me tells me such an ignorant viewpoint that I feel this hurts the perspective on crowdfunding for the several people that don't know that much and will just be misinformed. To me this makes Matt Stone and Trey Parker seem extremely ignorant as award winning millionaires that can pretty much do whatever creative product they want, but fuck anyone else who ask for a donation. I leave this vid on crowdfunding from the wonderful people of Extra Credit on the South Park Studios message board on the episode, just to inform what Crowdfunding really is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0ljzAi5DuA

to:

* Tropers/Metalheadfan2500 The episode "Go Fund Yourself" really bugged me, aside from not getting a strong laugh out of me, this episode is just ignorant. Matt and Trey bash on Kickstarter and crowdfunding in general, by commenting on the several people that abuse it for free money with weak ideas, sure that's ok for a cheap laugh, but what really annoyed me is that there is no mention of any positive contributions that crowdfunding has done. Aside from perhaps one poster mentioning a film festival, they failed to comment on all the cool indie games, animation, comics, short films, or whatever, which to me tells me such an ignorant viewpoint that I feel this hurts the perspective on crowdfunding for the several people that don't know that much and will just be misinformed. To me this makes Matt Stone and Trey Parker seem extremely ignorant as award winning millionaires that can pretty much do whatever creative product they want, but fuck anyone else who ask for a donation. I leave this vid on crowdfunding from the wonderful people of Extra Credit on the South Park Studios message board on the episode, just to inform what Crowdfunding really is https://www.[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0ljzAi5DuAcom/watch?v=l0ljzAi5DuA this vid on crowdfunding]] from the wonderful people of Extra Credit on the South Park Studios message board on the episode, just to inform what Crowdfunding really is.
This list shows the last 10 events of 570. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=DethroningMoment.SouthPark