History DethroningMoment / EdEddnEddy

* Tropers/Marioking98341: What about "[[Recap/EdEddnEddyS4E1IfItSmellsLikeAnEd If It Smells Like An Ed]]"? This absolute gem of an episode had:
## KarmaHoudini {{Jerkass}} Jimmy. (No, that wasn't a typo.) Jimmy caused all 3 Eds pain by making them look like bad guys: He plants a stolen paintbrush on Ed, gets the hockey stick in the [[BuffySpeak Friendship Day Heart Thing of Symbolism]] blamed on Eddy, and plants a rag he used to wipe off Plank's mouth on Edd. He even pulled a GambitRoulette!
## The Plot. It was Friendship Day! And on said day, Eddy gave Jimmy a wedgie when Jimmy offers a token of friendship and Jimmy targets him and both his friends? That doesn't make sense; If Jimmy is going for revenge, just make it Eddy! Don't turn all three Eds into the laughing stock of the goddamn cul-de-sac and have the Kankers use BlackComedyRape in a G rated manner.
## Edd. As always, he does nothing wrong, nor has much evidence against him. And also, if they think Jimmy is innocent due to timidness, then should Edd get a automatic skip of being guilty? Sheesh, no wonder I hate this episode so much!
*** Psi Basilisk: Rolf did not know of Jimmy's plan; he basically says near the end that he just thought that Jimmy was giving him free candy for some reason. Not that this makes the episode any better. In fact, Using Rolf as an unknowing patsy actually makes Jimmy's actions in this horrendous episode even worse.
*** Tropers/{{MsCC93}}:I used to be one of the few who didn’t have a problem with this episode, but now my opinion has changed simply because of the ending when Ed and Edd got pelted by fruits and when the Kankees dragged them off screen to get raped. I do agree with the fans that Ed and Edd didn’t deserve the shared punishment that they got, but I have zero sympathy for Eddy. Am I supposed to feel sorry for him because he’s the protagonist? I mean come on guys, none of this would have happened if Eddy didn’t give Jimmy a wedgie, and he doesn’t deserve a pass for it since Jimmy did nothing to provoke Eddy at the moment (Jimmy came off as a JerkassWoobie to me). Eddy shouldn’t be applauded for being a bully, and neither should the kids. Still, this episode is problematic.

* fluffything: On behalf of my fellow EENE fans, I'd like to add "[[Recap/EdEddnEddyS4E12YourEdHere Your Ed Here]]" as a DMOS for being the absolute [[MoralEventHorizon low point]] for Kevin. In the episode, Kevin finds Eddy's ID card and finds out his middle name is Skipper. Horrified, Eddy tries to convince Kevin to keep it a secret and Kevin says he will... but only if Eddy will do a few "favors" for him. Cue Eddy doing some absolutely humiliating tasks (Including an infamous scene where he kisses Double D) just to keep Kevin from revealing his secret. And, how does Kevin repay him? He tells everyone Eddy's middle name anyway. In other words, Kevin just made Eddy do all of those things for his own sick pleasure rather than keep his word. Keep in mind that Eddy had done nothing to spite Kevin in this episode (at least in others, Eddy actually directly causes Kevin's rage). Because of it, Kevin went from a JerkJock [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold with some noble tendencies]] to a JerkWithAHeartOfJerk who harasses the Eds for no reason other than they exist in the eyes of the fandom.

** Tropers/TreyColori: Don't forget about the end of the episode where Double D tells Eddy that his middle name is Marion, and Eddy pulls the hypocrite card by announcing that out loud to the cul-de-sac, thus making Double D the new target of ridicule. I mean, what the hell, Eddy?

* No RealLife examples, including ExecutiveMeddling. [[InternetBackdraft It only invites a flame war.]]

*** Tropers/{{MsCC93}}:I used to be one of the few who didn’t have a problem with this episode, but now my opinion has changed simply because of the ending when Ed and Edd got pelted by fruits and when the Kankees dragged them off screen to get raped. I do agree with the fans that Ed and Edd didn’t deserve the shared punishment that they got, but I have zero sympathy for Eddy. Am I supposed to feel sorry for him because he’s the protagonist? I mean come on guys, none of this would have happened if Eddy didn’t give Jimmy a wedgie, and he doesn’t deserve a pass for it since Jimmy did nothing to provoke Eddy at the moment (he came off as a JerkassWoobie to me). Eddy shouldn’t be applauded for being a bully, and neither should the kids. Still, this episode is problematic.

* MsCC93: My moment would be the episode "X Marks The Ed" when Eddy discovers that a pimple is growing on top of his head. Out of all people, Johnny, who is annoying, but yet he has his moments of kindness, decides to become a complete jerk to Eddy by making fun of Eddy along with Ed and eventually getting the kids to pay to see Eddy's pimple. The kids were complete assholes because Eddy didn't do anything to anyone in this episode to deserve the humiliation he endured. To make it even worse, when Eddy tries to walk to Rolf's house, the kids still try to harass Eddy and their harassing is only shown with pictures. The most irritating picture I saw was the picture of Sarah, the [[SpoiledBrat brat]], pulling off Eddy's towel to expose his pimple! The ending didn't even make it better because Eddy still didn't look like his normal self.

* Tropers/{{Supreme-X15}}: "Look Before You Ed", the supposed final episode of the series, left me bitter. Winter rolls around, and the only one not happy about it is Jimmy, who unsurprisingly, is at his most vulnerable during this season. Double D is sympathetic towards Jimmy and the two decide to make a safety club to make sure everyone is "safe". Admirable? Yes. Necessary? Debatable at best, as Eddy stated that no one was interested in Double D's safety club idea for the past two years, so that would mean accidents in the snow are few and far between, but Jimmy's the only one more accident prone than anyone else, so naturally he'd be interested. The only problem is that Eddy and Ed keep screwing around while Double D and Jimmy try to take their safety club efforts seriously. Eventually, Jimmy gets fed up with the Eds, quits, and makes his own successful safety club. The episode ends with everyone going home and leaving the Eds being stuck in an ice cage, because Jimmy perceives them to be the main threat to safety. And this is supposed to be the final episode?! This rubbed me the wrong way more than almost anything else in the series. Jimmy, although nowhere near evil as he was in his infamous revenge scheme in "If It Smells Like An Ed", becomes completely unsympathetic the moment he left the Eds in that ice cage, and as mentioned several times before, Double D is the [[NiceGuy nice guy]], and didn't deserve this treatment. I get that most things don't go right for the Eds, but this is a cruel way to end the series. Not that I liked him much to begin with, but this episode just paints [[BitchInSheepsClothing Jimmy]] in an even more negative light than before. Jimmy has almost always been a wimp, but how can making a snow angel hurt that badly? Nearly every episode where Jimmy has the spotlight seems to only sour his character. "May I Have This Ed", the segment before this one at least had a happier ending, since the Eds for once managed to escape unscathed. It should have been the last episode, not this poor excuse for a finale. At least we got the [[BigDamnMovie Big Picture Show]] as the real finale to the series, since the Eds are [[EarnYourHappyEnding finally accepted by the kids]], minus Jonny.

* No RealLife examples, including ExecutiveMeddling. It only invites a flame war.

* No RealLife examples, including ExecutiveMeddling. [[InternetBackdraft It only invites a flame war.]]

* heartauthor: The endings of all three of the holiday specials left a bad taste in my mouth, but the worst ending belongs to "Ed Edd n Eddy's Boo Haw Haw". Ed's Halloween-related visions have been causing trouble for all the other kids all night, and they end up chasing the Eds into a hole. While Eddy and Double D cower in fear, Ed [[AssPull dresses up in a robe and begins reading a newspaper]], proclaiming his work is done. The other kids then proceed to viciously beat Eddy and Double D, and Ed has one last vision...of Eddy and Double D frolicking in flowers. That's seriously how it ends. Sure, I know the Eds [[StatusQuoIsGod are never supposed to win]], but the most infuriating part is that [[CantGetAwayWithNuthin Eddy and Double D]] didn't do anything but got the punishment, while Ed got off [[KarmaHoudini scot-free]]! Sure, Eddy was more than willing to take Jimmy's candy, but only after Ed took it from him! Like I said, I know the Eds aren't usually supposed to win, but following that formula for the holiday specials just didn't work for me.
** Wkenneth334: I agree that the ending is an AssPull as well, because of how [[TheDitz Ed]], the one who has hallucinations, is suddenly cured in the final scene. He would believe that the kids are monsters, but when his friends are in grave danger, he just sits there.
* {{NTroper}}: "Cry Ed", the episode where all the kids from the Cul de Sac (Minus the Eds of course) take care of Jimmy after an injury. An injury caused by a clothespin that lightly pokes at Jimmy's foot, which prompts Jimmy to react as if his foot broke. Seriously? A clothespin grazes your foot and you act for half the episode as if you had just come out of a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown? There's MinorInjuryOverreaction, and there is this. It elevates Jimmy's FragileFlower credentials to a sickening level.

* Tropers/{{Frankiefoster}}: For my Moment, it has to be "Mission Ed Possible". Why? Double D was a fat jerk to Ed and Eddy, and their friendship seemed to fly out the window in favor of "his duty was to send report cards". The smug look on his face and the comment he made as Eddy and Ed were being dragged off by their parents threw me off. He was supposed to be the smart, nice kid, not the obnoxious jerk. It was like they were just totally bored with the series and decided to Flanderize Edd for fun. I could take all the examples above, but THAT one made me swear off of Ed, Edd n' Eddy for the rest of the season.

## KarmaHoudini {{Jerkass}} Jimmy. (No, that wasn't a typo.) Jimmy caused all 3 Eds pain by making them look like bad guys: He plants a stolen paintbrush on Ed, gets the hockey stick in the [[BuffySpeakTalk Friendship Day Heart Thing of Symbolism]] blamed on Eddy, and plants a rag he used to wipe off Plank's mouth on Edd. He even pulled a GambitRoulette!

* Tropers/{{TheUnknownUploader}}: For me, the ending to For Your Ed Only is this. Here's how the episode starts: The Eds are giving Jonny a balloon ride. That's it. Then kevin rides up, and pops the balloon, nearly killing them. Don't believe me? Jonny falls head first on the ground and ends up in China! This is what causes them to find Sarah's diary. Then when the kids are looking for Sarah's diary, Kevin doesn't give a crap. And at the end of the episode, the Eds--and Jonny--get punished. Yeah, Eddy took the diary, but Ed and Edd wanted to return. And Jonny wasn't even there! So why the hell is he getting punished and not Kevin? Once again, Kevin gets off scot-free. I hate that bastard.

** Tropers/E1craZ4life: The Eds did manage to tie Kevin to a tree in the middle of the episode, so he did get some comeuppance to some degree.

* Tropers/MelancholyUtopia: Surprised no one has added it yet, I'm withdrawing my previous addition to "Your Ed Here" and making an entry for the fans' unanimously agreed bad episode, "Sorry, Wrong Ed". What's so bad about it? Edd is an uncharacteristic, smug asshole who rivals [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Lisa Simpson]] in the [[TheFundamentalist fundamentalist]] department, that's what. To put this JerkassBall into context: It begins with Rolf burying a telephone in the belief that it's cursed. Eddy, ignoring the "cursed" part and thinks "free phone!" decides to take it home. A series of accidents happen in which Eddy is seriously injured, but only upon answering the phone, and after a while, begins to believe it really is cursed. Now, each time Eddy gets hurt, Edd is either making self-righteous quips about the phone not being superstitious, or sarcastic, insensitive remarks. Oh, and Eddy makes a reasonable suggestion that maybe one should test it before putting down a verdict, and Edd just gets confused, as if it was completely past him to do that. Who's the smart one here again? The worst part has got to be the ending, however. After ridding the phone off on Jonny, Eddy is happy because now none of the phone's "curses" will get him any longer. Then he gets into a series of accidents again, including getting hit by a falling tree, struck by lightning and crushed by a freaking house. Instead of showing concern for Eddy, Double D begins to rub the "the phone is not here so this must be a coincidence" facts right in his harmed face. In the last one, with Eddy being crushed by the house, Edd just shouts "Coincidence, Eddy!" I know that the show is {{Slapstick}}, but there is a damn limit! The episode made it look like he was more concerned about being right rather than the welfare of his friend. Double D wouldn't, and shouldn't, do something like that to anyone; that's not the type of person he is. This whole episode is so stupid.

** TreBreeze: Don't forget about the end of the episode where Double D tells Eddy that his middle name is Marion, and Eddy pulls the hypocrite card by announcing that out loud to the cul-de-sac, thus making Double D the new target of ridicule. I mean, what the hell, Eddy?

* No ALLCAPS, no [[AC:asscaps]], no '''bold''', and no ''italics'' unless it's the title of a work. We are not yelling the [=DMoSs=] out loud.

## KarmaHoudini {{Jerkass}} Jimmy. (No, that wasn't a typo.) Jimmy caused all 3 Eds pain by making them look like bad guys: He plants a stolen paintbrush on Ed, gets the hockey stick in the [[BuffySpeakTalk Friendship Day Heart Thing of Symbolism]] blamed on Eddy, and plants a rag he used to wipe off Plank's mouth on Edd. CharacterDerailment for him! He even pulled a GambitRoulette!

** TreBreeze: You forgot about the end of the episode where Double D tells Eddy that his middle name is Marion, and Eddy pulls the hypocrite card by announcing that out loud to the cul-de-sac, thus making Double D the new target of ridicule. I mean, what the hell, buddy?

** Animeking1108: Unlike everyone else, I actually sympathize with Jimmy. My problem with this episode was how the kids reacted to Jimmy's humiliation. While I expected [[JerkAss Eddy, Kevin]], and maybe [[TheDitz Ed and Jonny]] to laugh at Jimmy, the fact that [[NiceGuy Edd, Rolf,]] [[NiceGirl and Nazz]] were laughing too was just sickening. It's especially jarring with Nazz since she actually called out everyone else for laughing at Jimmy after he got chased by Victor. This episode was one big OutOfCharacterMoment.

* No [[JustifyingEdit contesting entries]]. This is subjective and the entry is their opinion.

* Tropers/MelancholyUtopia: Surprised no one has added it yet, I'm withdrawing my previous addition to "Your Ed Here" and making an entry for the fans' unanimously agreed bad episode, "Sorry, Wrong Ed". What's so bad about it? Edd is an uncharacteristic, smug asshole who rivals [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Lisa Simpson]] in the [[TheFundamentalist fundamentalist]] department, that's what. To put this JerkassBall into context: It begins with Rolf burying a telephone in the belief that it's cursed. Eddy, ignoring the "cursed" part and thinks "free phone!" decides to take it home. A series of accidents happen in which Eddy is seriously injured, but only upon answering the phone, and after a while, begins to believe it really is cursed. Now, each time Eddy gets hurt, Edd is either making self-righteous quips about the phone not being superstitious, or sarcastic, insensitive remarks. Oh, and Eddy makes a reasonable suggestion that maybe one should test it before putting down a verdict, and Edd just gets confused, as if it was completely past him to do that. Who's the smart one here again? The worst part has got to be the ending, however. After ridding the phone off on Jonny, Eddy is happy because now none of the phone's "curses" will get him any longer. Then he gets into a series of accidents again, including getting hit by a falling tree, struck by lightning and crushed by a freaking house. Instead of showing concern for Eddy, Double D begins to rub the "the phone is not here so this must be a coincidence" facts right in his harmed face. In the last one, with Eddy being crushed by the house, Edd just shouts "Coincidence, Eddy!" I know that the show is {{Slapstick}}, but there is a damn limit! Not to mention Edd is supposed to be a concerning TeamMom who's genuinely nice to everyone, not a dagnab {{Jerkass}}. Double D wouldn't, and shouldn't, do something like that to anyone. This whole episode is so stupid.

* Tropers/{{Komatsuzaki}}: Is nobody going to point out the [[UnfortunateImplications Unfortunate Implications]] of what the Kankers do to the Eds several times throughout the series? Ostensibly it's "just kissing". In reality, it's sexual assault. And it's [[PlayedForLaughs Played For Laughs]]. If [[DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale the genders were switched, something tells me nobody would be laughing]].

* Tropers/{{Supreme-X15}}: "Look Before You Ed", the supposed final episode of the series, left me bitter. Winter rolls around, and the only one not happy about it is Jimmy, who unsurprisingly, is at his most vulnerable during this season. Double D is sympathetic towards Jimmy and the two decide to make a safety club to make sure everyone is "safe". Admirable? Yes. Necessary? Debatable at best, as Eddy stated that no one was interested in Double D's safety club idea for the past two years, so that would mean accidents in the snow are few and far between, but Jimmy's the only one more accident prone than anyone else, so naturally he'd be interested. The only problem is that Eddy and Ed keep screwing around while Double D and Jimmy try to take their safety club efforts seriously. Eventually, Jimmy gets fed up with the Eds, quits, and makes his own successful safety club. The episode ends with everyone going home and leaving the Eds being stuck in an ice cage, because Jimmy perceives them to be the main threat to safety. And this is supposed to be the final episode?! This rubbed me the wrong way more than almost anything else in the series. Jimmy, although nowhere near evil as he was in his infamous revenge scheme in "If It Smells Like An Ed", becomes completely unsympathetic the moment he left the Eds in that ice cage, and as mentioned several times before, Double D is the [[NiceGuy nice guy]], and didn't deserve this treatment. I get that most things don't go right for the Eds, but this is a cruel way to end the series. Not that I liked him much to begin with, but this episode just paints [[BitchInSheepsClothing Jimmy]] in an even more negative light than before. Jimmy has almost always been a wimp, but how can making a snow angel hurt that badly? "May I Have This Ed", the segment before this one at least had a happier ending, since the Eds for once managed to escape unscathed. It should have been the last episode, not this poor excuse for a finale. At least we got the [[BigDamnMovie Big Picture Show]] as the real finale to the series, since the Eds are [[EarnYourHappyEnding finally accepted by the kids]], minus Jonny.

** MsCC93: My moment would be the episode "X Marks The Ed" when Eddy discovers that a pimple is growing on top of his head. Out of all people, Johnny, who is annoying, but yet he has his moments of kindness, decides to become a complete jerk to Eddy by making fun of Eddy along with Ed and eventually getting the kids to pay to see Eddy's pimple. The kids were complete assholes because Eddy didn't do anything to anyone in this episode to deserve the humiliation he endured. To make it even worse, when Eddy tries to walk to Rolf's house, the kids still try to harass Eddy and their harassing is only shown with pictures. The most irritating picture I saw was the picture of Sarah, the local [[SpoiledBrat brat]], pulling off Eddy's towel to expose his pimple! The ending didn't even make it better because Eddy still didn't look like his normal self.

* Tropers/{{Komatsuzaki}}: Is nobody going to point out the [[UnfortunateImplications Unfortunate Implications]] of what the Kankers do to the Eds several times throughout the series? Ostensibly it's "just kissing". In reality, it's sexual assault. And it's [[PlayedForLaughs Played For Laughs]]. If [[DoubleStandardAbuseFemaleOnMale the genders were switched, something tells me nobody would be laughing]].

* Tropers/{{Supreme-X15}}: "Look Before You Ed", the supposed final episode of the series, left me bitter. Winter rolls around, and the only one not happy about it is Jimmy, who unsurprisingly, is at his most vulnerable during this season. Double D is sympathetic towards Jimmy and the two decide to make a safety club to make sure everyone is "safe". Admirable? Yes. Necessary? Debatable at best, as Eddy stated that no one was interested in Double D's safety club idea for the past two years, so that would mean accidents in the snow are few and far between, but Jimmy's the only one more accident prone than anyone else, so naturally he'd be interested. The only problem is that Eddy and Ed keep screwing around while Double D and Jimmy try to take their safety club efforts seriously. Eventually, Jimmy gets fed up with the Eds, quits, and makes his own successful safety club. The episode ends with everyone going home and leaving the Eds being stuck in an ice cage, because Jimmy perceives them to be the main threat to safety. And this is supposed to be the final episode?! This rubbed me the wrong way more than almost anything else in the series. Jimmy, although nowhere near evil as he was in his infamous revenge scheme in "If It Smells Like An Ed", becomes completely unsympathetic the moment he left the Eds in that ice cage, and as mentioned several times before, Double D is the [[NiceGuy nice guy]], and didn't deserve this treatment. I get that most things don't go right for the Eds, but this is a cruel way to end the series. Not that I liked him much to begin with, but this episode just paints [[BitchInSheepsClothing Jimmy]] in an even more negative light than before. Jimmy has almost always been a wimp, but how can making a snow angel hurt that badly? "May I Have This Ed", the segment before this one at least had a happier ending, since the Eds for once managed to escape unscathed. It should have been the last episode, not this poor excuse for a finale. At least we got the [[BigDamnMovie Big Picture Show]] as the real finale to the series, since the Eds are [[EarnYourHappyEnding finally accepted by the kids]], minus Jonny.

* Tropers/{{Supreme-X15}}: "Look Before You Ed", the supposed final episode of the series, left me bitter. Winter rolls around, and the only one not happy about it is Jimmy, who unsurprisingly, is at his most vulnerable during this season. Double D is sympathetic towards Jimmy and the two decide to make a safety club to make sure everyone is "safe". Admirable? Yes. The only problem is that Eddy and Ed keep screwing around while Double D and Jimmy try to take their efforts seriously. Eventually, Jimmy gets fed up with the Eds, quits, and makes his own successful safety club. The episode ends with everyone going home and leaving the Eds being stuck in an ice cage, because Jimmy perceives them to be the main threat to safety. And this is supposed to be the final episode?! This rubbed me the wrong way more than almost anything else in the series. Jimmy, although nowhere near evil as he was in his infamous revenge scheme in "If It Smells Like An Ed", becomes completely unsympathetic the moment he left the Eds in that ice cage, and as mentioned several times before, Double D is the [[NiceGuy nice guy]], and didn't deserve this treatment. I get that most things don't go right for the Eds, but this is a cruel way to end the series. Not that I liked him much to begin with, but this episode just paints [[BitchInSheepsClothing Jimmy]] in an even more negative light than before. "May I Have This Ed", the segment before this one at least had a happier ending, since the Eds for once managed to escape unscathed. It should have been the last episode, not this poor excuse for a finale. At least we got the [[BigDamnMovie Big Picture Show]] as the real finale to the series, since the Eds are [[EarnYourHappyEnding finally accepted by the kids]], minus Jonny.