Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Ashes, Ashes'' (French: ''Ravage'') is a Post-Apocalyptic [[FrancoBelgianComics French graphic novel]] by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
to:
''Ashes, Ashes'' (French: ''Ravage'') is a Post-Apocalyptic [[FrancoBelgianComics French graphic novel]] by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2016 and seeing an English version in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 20 (click to see context) from:
* DwindlingParty: Of the original group that joined Francois and Blanche in escaping Paris, only a small handful make it to Provence.
to:
* DramaticIrony: Albert, the young idealistic teenager who joins Francois' group and initially one of his most ardent admirers [[spoiler:winds up among the last to stand up to the Patriarch a century later]].
* DwindlingParty: Of the original group thatjoined join Francois and Blanche in escaping Paris, only a small handful make it to Provence.
* DwindlingParty: Of the original group that
Deleted line(s) 23 (click to see context) :
* LuddWasRight: Averted. From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]] and discomfort over the apparent shallowness of futuristic Paris, however, devolves over time into the Patriarch's [[EvilLuddite nigh-maniacal obsession]] with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing a status quo that's outright medieval out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.
to:
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. As his group's trek southward progresses, however, he starts growing more authoritarian while goading his companions to be more ruthless. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing a status quo that's outright medieval out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.pure and safe from decadence.
Added DiffLines:
* LonelyAtTheTop: Francois is shown to have had friends and companionship among his group when they leave Paris. By the time he's the Patriarch, however, it's made clear that he's rules alone, viewing his own sons as barely more than vassals, and his own loyal, beloved Blanche is implied to be treated little better.
* LuddWasRight: Averted. From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]] and discomfort over the apparent shallowness of futuristic Paris, however, devolves over time into the Patriarch's [[EvilLuddite nigh-maniacal obsession]] with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.
* MoralMyopia: At first, Francois' disdain for the modern world seems relatable and his solutions pragmatic enough that it doesn't really raise eyebrows. As the story progresses, however, it becomes evident that's only because his ideas, and his ''alone'' are ever considered.
* LuddWasRight: Averted. From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]] and discomfort over the apparent shallowness of futuristic Paris, however, devolves over time into the Patriarch's [[EvilLuddite nigh-maniacal obsession]] with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.
* MoralMyopia: At first, Francois' disdain for the modern world seems relatable and his solutions pragmatic enough that it doesn't really raise eyebrows. As the story progresses, however, it becomes evident that's only because his ideas, and his ''alone'' are ever considered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:It takes about a century, but civilization finally gets a chance to properly rebuild, with Blanche renouncing the Patriarch's vision over his grave. Though she admits that freedom and progress will be hard, but as least it means she can die free.]]
Changed line(s) 33 (click to see context) from:
* YouCannotKillAnIdea: What ultimately brings the Patriarch [[BerserkButton to the edge]] isn't just that his enemies were protecting a dangerous object [[spoiler:a steam engine, but that the one who made it didn't rely on old world material but simple observation and intuition. The realization that humanity ''will'' find a way to rediscover what had been lost is one that he cannot accept.]]
to:
* YouCannotKillAnIdea: What ultimately brings the Patriarch [[BerserkButton to the edge]] isn't just that the "infernal machine" his enemies were are protecting a dangerous object [[spoiler:a steam engine, but that the one who made it didn't rely on old world material but simple observation and intuition. The realization that humanity ''will'' find a way to rediscover what had been lost is one that he cannot accept.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* TheDogBitesBack: [[spoiler:At the Patriarch's funeral, an aging Blanche reveals that while she's long forgiven Francois, she refuses to carry on his regime, and will see to it that his vision dies with him.]]
Added DiffLines:
* RuleOfSymbolism: The Patriarch is portrayed as bearing more than a passing resemblance to Literature/DonQuixote, especially with his beard and padded, knightly outfit. [[spoiler:And similarly to him, he's fighting an ultimately futile battle.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AdaptationPersonalityChange: Compared to the original novel, Blanche is not only shown to be more of a pronounced ActionSurvivor [[spoiler:but is ultimately far less of a [[StayInTheKitchen docile wife to Francois]]. She even goes so far as to renounce the Patriarch's vision in his funeral.]]
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* FromNobodyToNightmare: Few would suspect that a young graduate named Francois Deschamps would one day become the Patriarch, a feared visionary lording over the post-apocalyptic wastes.
to:
* FromNobodyToNightmare: Few would suspect suspected that a young graduate named Francois Deschamps would one day become the Patriarch, a feared visionary lording over the post-apocalyptic wastes.
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused serum to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural, but also augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels. He's also not afraid to arm his loyal warriors with scavenged modern body armor and scope-mounted crossbows, [[LoopholeAbuse since they're not technically considered heretical]].
Changed line(s) 24 (click to see context) from:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused serum to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural, but also augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels. He's also not afraid to arm his loyal warriors with scavenged modern body armor and scope-mounted crossbows, [[LoopholeAbuse since they're not technically considered heretical]].
to:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For KarmicDeath: [[spoiler:The Patriarch is finally impaled upon falling from the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, steam engine he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused serum had tried to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural, but also augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels. He's also not afraid to arm his loyal warriors with scavenged modern body armor and scope-mounted crossbows, [[LoopholeAbuse since they're not technically considered heretical]]. destroy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AntiHero: Francois, at least at first, given how he's willing to do whatever it takes to survive in the long term. Gradually, however, his drive to forge a different path for humanity takes him down an ever darker path.
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
* LuddWasRight: From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]], however, devolves into the Patriarch's nigh-maniacal obsession with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.
to:
* LuddWasRight: Averted. From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]], village]] and discomfort over the apparent shallowness of futuristic Paris, however, devolves over time into the Patriarch's [[EvilLuddite nigh-maniacal obsession obsession]] with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.suffering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Much of Francois ideas, especially as he becomes the Patriarch, can come across as the mantra ''Travail, famille, patrie'' being taken to their (il)logical conclusion. This is carried over from the original Barjavel novel, which was written under the auspices of the Vichy regime.
to:
* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Much of Francois Francois' ideas, especially as he becomes the Patriarch, can come across as the mantra ''Travail, famille, patrie'' being taken to their (il)logical conclusion. This is carried over from the original Barjavel novel, which was written under the auspices of the Vichy regime.regime.
* DwindlingParty: Of the original group that joined Francois and Blanche in escaping Paris, only a small handful make it to Provence.
* DwindlingParty: Of the original group that joined Francois and Blanche in escaping Paris, only a small handful make it to Provence.
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* YeGoodeOldeDays: The Patriarch's medieval rule tries to give this impression, as conceptually it is giving humanity back its vigor and purity, free of the corrupting influences of the modern world. ''In practice'', however, it's also shown to be a dreary existence, where only the strong thrive and everyone else can barely survive into the next day.
to:
* YeGoodeOldeDays: The Patriarch's medieval rule tries to give this impression, as conceptually it is giving humanity back its vigor and purity, free of the corrupting influences of the modern world. ''In practice'', however, it's also shown to be a dreary existence, where only the strong thrive and everyone else can barely survive into the next day.day.
* YouCannotKillAnIdea: What ultimately brings the Patriarch [[BerserkButton to the edge]] isn't just that his enemies were protecting a dangerous object [[spoiler:a steam engine, but that the one who made it didn't rely on old world material but simple observation and intuition. The realization that humanity ''will'' find a way to rediscover what had been lost is one that he cannot accept.]]
* YouCannotKillAnIdea: What ultimately brings the Patriarch [[BerserkButton to the edge]] isn't just that his enemies were protecting a dangerous object [[spoiler:a steam engine, but that the one who made it didn't rely on old world material but simple observation and intuition. The realization that humanity ''will'' find a way to rediscover what had been lost is one that he cannot accept.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ApocalypseAnarchy: Within only a few days from the end, most signs of civil order have already broken down, with some citizens turning to looting and pillaging a burning Paris to survive. Before long, there seems to be barely any sense of society at all in what had been France.
Added DiffLines:
* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Much of Francois ideas, especially as he becomes the Patriarch, can come across as the mantra ''Travail, famille, patrie'' being taken to their (il)logical conclusion. This is carried over from the original Barjavel novel, which was written under the auspices of the Vichy regime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Ashes, Ashes'' is a Post-Apocalyptic [[FrancoBelgianComics French graphic novel]] by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
to:
''Ashes, Ashes'' (French: ''Ravage'') is a Post-Apocalyptic [[FrancoBelgianComics French graphic novel]] by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
* LuddWasRight: From the very beginning, Francois is shown to have a disdain for advanced technology and the modern world, which he blames for robbing humanity of its purity and drive. What's initially shown as simply a longing for [[GoodOldWays the rural traditionalism of his home village]], however, devolves into the Patriarch's nigh-maniacal obsession with keeping society perpetually in medieval standards, which is only causing more suffering.
Changed line(s) 19,20 (click to see context) from:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused serum to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural, but augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris.
to:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused serum to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural, but also augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels.
levels. He's also not afraid to arm his loyal warriors with scavenged modern body armor and scope-mounted crossbows, [[LoopholeAbuse since they're not technically considered heretical]].
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris. It's tellingly after his demise that Francois really starts becoming more unhinged.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris. It's tellingly after his demise that Francois really starts becoming more unhinged.
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* WellIntentionedExtremist: Francois Deschamps, whether as a young man or as the Patriarch, consistently believes that he's doing what is best for mankind by abandoning the weakness enabled by technological civilization. Whether others agree with him or not.
to:
* WellIntentionedExtremist: Francois Deschamps, whether as a young man or as the Patriarch, consistently believes that he's doing what is best for mankind by abandoning the weakness enabled by technological civilization. Whether others agree with him or not.not.
* YeGoodeOldeDays: The Patriarch's medieval rule tries to give this impression, as conceptually it is giving humanity back its vigor and purity, free of the corrupting influences of the modern world. ''In practice'', however, it's also shown to be a dreary existence, where only the strong thrive and everyone else can barely survive into the next day.
* YeGoodeOldeDays: The Patriarch's medieval rule tries to give this impression, as conceptually it is giving humanity back its vigor and purity, free of the corrupting influences of the modern world. ''In practice'', however, it's also shown to be a dreary existence, where only the strong thrive and everyone else can barely survive into the next day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AdvertOverloadedFuture: 2052 Paris is portrayed as brimming with holographic displays of all kinds, which all flicker out the moment the apocalypse strikes.
Changed line(s) 11,12 (click to see context) from:
* CozyCatastrophe: Averted in the flashback. Any semblance of civil order in Paris all but crumbles within a few days of the solar flare. While even in the comparatively unharmed French countryside, society is shown to have largely broken down, as roving gangs haunt the highways and once-picturesque towns with utter abandon. One notable exception, however, is Francois' ancestral village in Provence, and even ''that'' required a lot of sacrifice.
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not only any traces of advanced technology he could find, but also books and any shred of knowledge from the old world, believing that they would bring back the decadence and corruption of old.
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not only any traces of advanced technology he could find, but also books and any shred of knowledge from the old world, believing that they would bring back the decadence and corruption of old.
to:
* ChildhoodFriendRomance: Francois and Blanche are shown to have had this before the latter's sudden rise to stardom. Coincidentally, it's when Francois is rushing to save her from an exploitive producer that the collapse of civilization occurs.
* CozyCatastrophe: Averted in theflashback.flashbacks. Any semblance of civil order in Paris all but crumbles within a few days of the solar flare. While even in the comparatively unharmed French countryside, society is shown to have largely broken down, as roving gangs haunt the highways and once-picturesque towns with utter abandon. One notable exception, however, is Francois' ancestral village in Provence, and even ''that'' required a lot of sacrifice.
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not onlyany whatever traces of advanced technology he could find, but also books and any shred of knowledge from the old world, believing that they would bring back the decadence and corruption of old.old.
* FromNobodyToNightmare: Few would suspect that a young graduate named Francois Deschamps would one day become the Patriarch, a feared visionary lording over the post-apocalyptic wastes.
* GreyGoo: Francois and his group stumble upon an abandoned institute where transhumanist scientists were experimenting with nanomachines to create a serum that could enhance and prolong an average human. They find that the researchers were not only successful but had made enough caches for them to carry along.
* CozyCatastrophe: Averted in the
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not only
* FromNobodyToNightmare: Few would suspect that a young graduate named Francois Deschamps would one day become the Patriarch, a feared visionary lording over the post-apocalyptic wastes.
* GreyGoo: Francois and his group stumble upon an abandoned institute where transhumanist scientists were experimenting with nanomachines to create a serum that could enhance and prolong an average human. They find that the researchers were not only successful but had made enough caches for them to carry along.
Changed line(s) 15 (click to see context) from:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses nanomachine-infused injections to keep himself alive far longer than is natural.
to:
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses a nanomachine-infused injections serum to not only keep himself alive far longer than is natural.natural, but augment his strength to nigh-superhuman levels.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris.
* SettingUpdate: The cause of the apocalypse is changed from a South American superweapon attack gone horribly wrong in the novel, to a very powerful solar flare in the comic.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: Dr. Fauque, Francois' mentor and his party's resident medic, serves as a moderating influence until dying during the trip south from Paris.
* SettingUpdate: The cause of the apocalypse is changed from a South American superweapon attack gone horribly wrong in the novel, to a very powerful solar flare in the comic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
''Ashes, Ashes'' is a Post-Apocalyptic French graphic novel by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
to:
''Ashes, Ashes'' is a Post-Apocalyptic [[FrancoBelgianComics French graphic novel novel]] by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
* AdaptationExpansion: The comic not only puts more focus on the Patriarch's dystopian rule, which was only touched upon as the epilogue of Barjavel's book, but also spends more time building upon the characters.
Changed line(s) 10 (click to see context) from:
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing nigh-medieval standards out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.
to:
* CozyCatastrophe: Averted in the flashback. Any semblance of civil order in Paris all but crumbles within a few days of the solar flare. While even in the comparatively unharmed French countryside, society is shown to have largely broken down, as roving gangs haunt the highways and once-picturesque towns with utter abandon. One notable exception, however, is Francois' ancestral village in Provence, and even ''that'' required a lot of sacrifice.
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not only any traces of advanced technology he could find, but also books and any shred of knowledge from the old world, believing that they would bring back the decadence and corruption of old.
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcingnigh-medieval standards a status quo that's outright medieval out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.
* FuturePrimitive: As the Patriarch, Francois forges a civilization greatly resembling Dark Ages Europe. He ruthlessly enforces this by destroying not only any traces of advanced technology he could find, but also books and any shred of knowledge from the old world, believing that they would bring back the decadence and corruption of old.
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
* AfterTheEnd: Like the novel, the comic takes place after the breakdown of modern society, heavily implied to have been caused by a powerful solar flare.
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing nigh-medieval standards out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.
* JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope: Francois early on expresses admiration for the Age of Enlightenment as the "ideal" era for humanity to hearken back to, away from the decadence of modernity. Over a century later, this has devolved into ruthlessly enforcing nigh-medieval standards out of the belief that it would keep mankind pure.
Changed line(s) 11 (click to see context) from:
Preview
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
''Ashes, Ashes'' is a Post-Apocalyptic French graphic novel by Jean-David Morvan. First published in 2021, the series is an adaptation of a 1943 novel of the same name by René Barjavel, which is cited as one of the top-100 most influential Francophone novels written.
130 years in the future, all traces of technology have seemingly disappeared from the surface of the Earth. In what was once France, two surviving bands face off against each other in tribal combat, while the Patriarch of the larger clan plans his attack to destroy the “infernal machine” designed by his opponent. Meanwhile in 2052, a near future Utopia filled with breathtaking technological advancements falls to its knees, almost instantaneously, and a bright young man named Francois Deschamps finds himself entering the annals of history.
A cautionary tale told from both sides of the downfall, the series explores both the lengths one man will go prevent the past from repeating itself, and humankind's tenacity even in the face of total collapse.
----
!!''Ashes, Ashes'' contains examples of:
* JustBeforeTheEnd: The flashback sequences in 2052 begin almost before the collapse of modern civilization.
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses nanomachine-infused injections to keep himself alive far longer than is natural.
Preview
130 years in the future, all traces of technology have seemingly disappeared from the surface of the Earth. In what was once France, two surviving bands face off against each other in tribal combat, while the Patriarch of the larger clan plans his attack to destroy the “infernal machine” designed by his opponent. Meanwhile in 2052, a near future Utopia filled with breathtaking technological advancements falls to its knees, almost instantaneously, and a bright young man named Francois Deschamps finds himself entering the annals of history.
A cautionary tale told from both sides of the downfall, the series explores both the lengths one man will go prevent the past from repeating itself, and humankind's tenacity even in the face of total collapse.
----
!!''Ashes, Ashes'' contains examples of:
* JustBeforeTheEnd: The flashback sequences in 2052 begin almost before the collapse of modern civilization.
* {{Hypocrite}}: For the all the Patriarch's grandstanding about the evils of modern civilization and advanced technology, he nonetheless uses nanomachine-infused injections to keep himself alive far longer than is natural.
Preview