Follow TV Tropes

Following

History BlatantLies / Literature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character [[ExactWords technically'' only lies about one thing...).

to:

** ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character [[ExactWords technically'' ''[[ExactWords technically]]'' only lies about one thing...).

Added: 1388

Changed: 224

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character ''[[ExactWords technically]]'' only lies about one thing...).

to:

** ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character ''[[ExactWords technically]]'' [[ExactWords technically'' only lies about one thing...).



** And then there's this little gem [[UnreliableNarrator from Harry's narration]] in ''Literature/GhostStory'':

to:

** And In ''Literature/GhostStory'': Harry states Agatha's pocket dimension burned down...and then there's this little gem [[UnreliableNarrator from Harry's narration]] in ''Literature/GhostStory'':he hurriedly adds that it was not his fault:



* ''Literature/LeftBehind'': The Antichrist uses a lot of transparent lies. It only works since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up.

to:

* ''Literature/LeftBehind'': The Antichrist uses a lot of transparent lies. It only works lies, which work since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/LumbanicoTheCubicPlanet'': After arriving in the hidden Enchanted Valley, the main characters are summoned before the Great Guardian to explain why Pirela -an Outsider girl- had one chunk of Astrolita, a mineral which could only be found in the Arista's lost capital city, Astrópolis. Unwilling to reveal that they found the forgotten mountain tunnels leading into the hidden valley, Pirela hurriedly tells it is a gift from her grandmother. Pirreno Zyr -another Guardian- immediately shouts that Pirela previously stated she found it somewhere. Pirela angrily retorts she found it in her grandmother's jewel case, which she saw no reason to mention. When Zyr questions why an Outsider would keep chunks of an Aristan mineral, Ustrum suggests their ancestors picked some stones when they passed through the city on their journey back home. Later, Pirreno Zyr and other Guardians find their story ridiculous, and the Great Guardian agrees that it is full of holes. The Outsiders who were going back home after spending months hiding in the mountains knew they were going to find their Valleys devastated by an environmental disaster. Surely, they were feeling too depressed to gather mineral samples. And if someone had picked one stone and their family had treasured it for seven hundred years, they would not have given it to a thirteen-year-old child as it was a new toy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Everything Shin-tsu of ''LightNovel/TheLongingOfShiinaRyo'' says is taken as this, even though he's telling the truth. It's not his fault the Universe made him its [[CosmicPlaything plaything]].

to:

* Everything Shin-tsu of ''LightNovel/TheLongingOfShiinaRyo'' ''Literature/TheLongingOfShiinaRyo'' says is taken as this, even though he's telling the truth. It's not his fault the Universe made him its [[CosmicPlaything plaything]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheFamousFive'': Although the Five generally consider themselves to be truthful, especially George, in ''Five Go To Smuggler's Top'', Julian tells a couple of whoppers just after Sooty and Uncle Quentin have disappeared in the night. When the maid Sarah brings Uncle Quentin his morning tea in bed, she is amazed to find Julian and Dick there instead; to get rid of Sarah, Julian says that he might be in his and Dick's bedroom. Later, Mr Lenoir tries to ask them what happened; Julian says they know nothing, but it is obvious he is lying by omission.
--> '''Julian:''' Marybelle, I think ''I'' had better take charge of the telling. (To Mr Lenoir) Uncle Quentin vanished from his bed last night, and so did Sooty. They may turn up, of course.
--> '''Mr Lenoir:''' Julian! You are keeping back something.
--> '''Marybelle:''' (wailing) Tell him, Julian, tell him!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Remember, Grover doesn’t use contractions.


* ''Literature/TheMonsterAtTheEndOfThisBook'', in the ''Series/SesameStreet'' Golden Book children's literature series. The story is about Grover, who tries to convince the reader to not finish the book because there is a horrifying, evil monster lurking on the final page. A series of obstacles (e.g., tying the pages together with Army rope, brick walls, etc.) of course don't work. The trope comes at the end: the "scary" monster at the end of the book is merely Grover! ("Oh, I'm so embarrassed!" he says sheepishly.) One of the earliest and most successful ''Sesame Street'' books to date, a rewrite was commissioned in 1996, with Grover finding Elmo as the "horrifying monster" at the end of the updated version. (Although to some, Elmo would avert the trope, believing ''him'' to indeed be a scary monster.)

to:

* ''Literature/TheMonsterAtTheEndOfThisBook'', in the ''Series/SesameStreet'' Golden Book children's literature series. The story is about Grover, who tries to convince the reader to not finish the book because there is a horrifying, evil monster lurking on the final page. A series of obstacles (e.g., tying the pages together with Army rope, brick walls, etc.) of course don't work. The trope comes at the end: the "scary" monster at the end of the book is merely Grover! ("Oh, I'm I am so embarrassed!" he says sheepishly.) One of the earliest and most successful ''Sesame Street'' books to date, a rewrite was commissioned in 1996, with Grover finding Elmo as the "horrifying monster" at the end of the updated version. (Although to some, Elmo would avert the trope, believing ''him'' to indeed be a scary monster.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Dursleys claim Harry has gone to "St Brutus' Secure Centre for Incurably Criminal Boys" to their fellow Muggle neighbors to explain his long absences at Hogwarts. Aunt Marge approves, and asks whether they still use the cane. And Harry, needing the Dursleys' to sign a permission form, jumps in on the blatant lying to the point Marge offers that if he can talk so lightly about St. Brutus, then they're not beating him hard enough.

to:

** The Dursleys claim Harry has gone to "St "[[DustbinSchool St. Brutus' Secure Centre for Incurably Criminal Boys" Boys]]" to their fellow Muggle neighbors to explain his long absences at Hogwarts. Aunt Marge approves, and asks whether they still use the cane. And Harry, needing the Dursleys' to sign a permission form, jumps in on the blatant lying to the point Marge offers that if he can talk so lightly about St. Brutus, then they're not beating him hard enough.

Added: 634

Changed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[Literature/JohnnyMaxwellTrilogy Johnny and the Bomb]]'' shows that it's possible to appear out of thin air, claim you're looking for the pottery club, and let everyone's WeirdnessCensor do the rest.

to:

* ''[[Literature/JohnnyMaxwellTrilogy Johnny ''Literature/JohnnyMaxwellTrilogy'':
** ''Johnny
and the Bomb]]'' Bomb'' shows that it's possible to appear out of thin air, claim you're looking for the pottery club, and let everyone's WeirdnessCensor do the rest.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheSurprisingAdventuresOfBaronMunchausen'': After telling how he and his companions escaped from a remote island inhabited by giant kingfishers, and visited a strange land inhabited by one-horned men and oxen, Munchausen says he arrived in a country where (tall)-taletellers are hanged; but he was not worried for his own safety, since he has never told a lie.
-->'''Munchausen:''' ''"This gave me no concern, as I have ever confined myself to facts".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/DiaryOfAWimpyKid'': Rodrick tells Greg about "sewer wasps" that come out of the toilet. Greg believes him and is very cautious when he goes to the bathroom.

Added: 274

Changed: 236

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/HarryPotter''

to:

* ''Literature/HarryPotter'' ''Literature/HarryPotter'':



* ''Literature/AHoleInTheFence'': When brigadier Beauras catches Grisón trying to sneak into the Epnoi Forest, the kid claims he was only gathering strawberries. Beauras replies that both know that nobody told him to go to a restricted zone to gather strawberries in winter.



* ''Literature/LeftBehind'': The Antichrist, despite supposedly being the agent (and later, living avatar) of the [[{{Satan}} Prince Of Lies]], uses a lot of transparent lies. It only works since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up.

to:

* ''Literature/LeftBehind'': The Antichrist, despite supposedly being the agent (and later, living avatar) of the [[{{Satan}} Prince Of Lies]], Antichrist uses a lot of transparent lies. It only works since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up.



* Played straight by the villains and their propaganda in ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. Averted by the heroes, though interestingly more for MoralPragmatist reasons than because of HonorBeforeReason: Lies backfire when they are found out, whereas a ''true'' propaganda is invulnerable.

to:

* ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'': Played straight by the villains and their propaganda in ''Literature/{{Victoria}}''. propaganda. Averted by the heroes, though interestingly more for MoralPragmatist reasons than because out of HonorBeforeReason: pragmatism: Lies backfire when they are found out, whereas a ''true'' propaganda is invulnerable.



** In ''Literature/WatchersOfTheThrone'', [[spoiler:Asterion Moloc]] claims that he and his men came to Terra to recuperate after their fotress-monastery was heavily damaged in the attack. Pretty much everyone in the room realizes immediately that they're lying - [[spoiler:the Minotaurs]] are fleet-based, and their "fortress-monastery" is a warship currently in orbit above Terra, visible to all.

to:

** In ''Literature/WatchersOfTheThrone'', [[spoiler:Asterion Moloc]] claims that he and his men came to Terra to recuperate after their fotress-monastery fortress-monastery was heavily damaged in the attack. Pretty much everyone in the room realizes immediately that they're lying - [[spoiler:the Minotaurs]] are fleet-based, and their "fortress-monastery" is a warship currently in orbit above Terra, visible to all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''LightNovel/{{Baccano}}'': In ''Drugs & the Dominoes'', when Luck Gandor [[PullingThemselvesTogether pulls himself together after]] near-decapitation in front of a witness, there's no possible plausible lie, so he goes for a blatant one:

to:

* ''LightNovel/{{Baccano}}'': ''Literature/{{Baccano}}'': In ''Drugs & the Dominoes'', when Luck Gandor [[PullingThemselvesTogether pulls himself together after]] near-decapitation in front of a witness, there's no possible plausible lie, so he goes for a blatant one:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/AdrianMole:'' In ''Cappuccino Years'', Adrian's son William lies that a goat ate his lunch, but he was CaughtOnTape throwing his lunch at the goat. Adrian admits to himself that his son is a convincing liar, and tells his own blatant lie: that if William does not behave in future, a man called Jack Straw (then Home Secretary) would get him, and put him in prison.

Added: 316

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheAmulet'', Sarah asks Jo where she got a cursed amulet that's been slaughtering its way across town. Jo says she bought it in a Sears-Roebuck catalog. Sarah checks anyway and confirms that Jo is lying.

to:

* In ''Literature/TheAmulet'', ''Literature/TheAmulet'': Sarah asks Jo where she got a cursed amulet that's been slaughtering its way across town. Jo says she bought it in a Sears-Roebuck catalog. Sarah checks anyway and confirms that Jo is lying.



'''Luck:''' [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Oh right, I have to repay you for this book...]]

to:

'''Luck:''' [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveMoney Oh right, I have to repay you for this book...]]



* TheAntiChrist in ''Literature/LeftBehind'', despite supposedly being the agent (and later, living avatar) of the [[{{Satan}} Prince Of Lies]], uses a lot of these. It only works since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up, and more importantly because the authors portray the entire population of the planet after the Rapture [[IdiotPlot as morons]].

to:

* TheAntiChrist in ''Literature/LeftBehind'', ''Literature/LeftBehind'': The Antichrist, despite supposedly being the agent (and later, living avatar) of the [[{{Satan}} Prince Of Lies]], uses a lot of these. transparent lies. It only works since he has some ill-defined MindControl powers to back him up, and more importantly because the authors portray the entire population of the planet after the Rapture [[IdiotPlot as morons]].up.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheLordOfBembibre'': None of Don Alonso's servants believes his claims that his daughter Beatriz is leaving for the convent of Villabuena because she owes her aunt a visit. Everybody knows he is banishing Beatriz to punish her for refusing an arranged marriage, no matter how much he claims otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Once upon a time, there was a massive civil war in the Seven Kingdoms (the Dance of the Dragons) for which any unbiased accounts about either side are rather thin on the ground. Except, there is that one chronicle recorded by the court fool, Mushroom. Problem is, he mixes truth, liable, tall tales, gossip and outright unbelievable lies in with his unabashedly negative portrayal of both sides of the conflict. Maesters use his accounts when writing about the period, since they're the best they've got, but they always comment about the dodginess.

to:

** Once upon a time, there was a massive civil war in the Seven Kingdoms (the Dance of the Dragons) for which any unbiased accounts about either side are rather thin on the ground. Except, there is that one chronicle recorded by the court fool, Mushroom. Problem is, he mixes truth, liable, libel, tall tales, gossip and outright unbelievable lies in with his unabashedly negative portrayal of both sides of the conflict. Maesters use his accounts when writing about the period, since they're the best they've got, but they always comment about the dodginess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the first book of ''Literature/WelkinWeasels'', Mawk the weasel tries to claim he was "just passing" when caught snooping around a mole tunnel. The moles don't buy it: "Where were you going? The antipodes?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed YMMV pothole


** In ''Literature/BlackLegion'', Khayon reassures Lheor that travelling through sorcerers' gate is "just like teleportation". As it turns out, it's ''not'', as you have to fight your way through scores of daemons. Upon passing the gate, Lheor [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments decks Khayon for this]].

to:

** In ''Literature/BlackLegion'', Khayon reassures Lheor that travelling through sorcerers' gate is "just like teleportation". As it turns out, it's ''not'', as you have to fight your way through scores of daemons. Upon passing the gate, Lheor [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments decks Khayon for this]].this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheCatWhoSeries'': In book #5 (''The Cat Who Played Brahms''), it's revealed that Fanny Klingenschoen told many of them, but the biggest would have to be the various fibs she told about how to get into her will (e.g. she would leave money to anyone who was named after her). When she dies and leaves everything to Qwill, the locals are rather understandably angry until the next book, where he sets up the foundation that disperses the money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/SpaceGlass'', Amy pulls this number twice, first lying to Ratroe saying she doesn't have feelings for Bob, and then lying to Bob saying she does have feelings for Ratroe.

Added: 691

Changed: 290

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'': In ''Literature/BlackLegion'', Khayon reassures Lheor that travelling through sorcerers' gate is "just like teleportation". As it turns out, it's ''not'', as you have to fight your way through scores of daemons. Upon passing the gate, Lheor [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments decks Khayon for this]].

to:

* ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'': ''TabletopGame/Warhammer40000'':
**
In ''Literature/BlackLegion'', Khayon reassures Lheor that travelling through sorcerers' gate is "just like teleportation". As it turns out, it's ''not'', as you have to fight your way through scores of daemons. Upon passing the gate, Lheor [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments decks Khayon for this]].this]].
** In ''Literature/WatchersOfTheThrone'', [[spoiler:Asterion Moloc]] claims that he and his men came to Terra to recuperate after their fotress-monastery was heavily damaged in the attack. Pretty much everyone in the room realizes immediately that they're lying - [[spoiler:the Minotaurs]] are fleet-based, and their "fortress-monastery" is a warship currently in orbit above Terra, visible to all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order.

to:

%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order. Thanks!


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/SevenStars'', Charles Beauregard finds one of Declan Mountmain's mooks in Declan Mountmain's house, dying of a wound inflicted by the reanimated {{Mummy}}. Mountmain claims the man is a complete stranger who happened to be hit by a carriage outside his house; Charles mentally notes that he's making no effort whatever to be convincing, because he know Charles won't believe him anyway and doesn't care.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheFateOfPaulTwister'', a fellow bard asks Paul where in the world he ended up with a special breed of horse that's strongly associated with paladins. He flippantly remarks that he won her off a paladin in a gambling game, and then in the narration, explains that telling obvious but entertaining lies is proper social etiquette among bards to get them to drop a question you don't feel like answering.

to:

* In ''Literature/TheFateOfPaulTwister'', a fellow bard asks Paul where in the world he ended up with a special breed of horse that's strongly associated with paladins. He flippantly remarks that he won her off a paladin in a gambling game, something which would never actually happen in-universe, and then in the narration, narration explains that telling obvious but entertaining lies is proper social etiquette among bards to get them to drop a question you don't feel like answering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/TheFateOfPaulTwister'', a fellow bard asks Paul where in the world he ended up with a special breed of horse that's strongly associated with paladins. He flippantly remarks that he won her off a paladin in a gambling game, and then in the narration, explains that telling obvious but entertaining lies is proper social etiquette among bards to get them to drop a question you don't feel like answering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not examples, those are plausible lies


** The Dursleys also told Harry that Lily and James Potter died in a car crash. They seem to have told Marge that as well.
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': When Harry is upset with Ron:
--->''"'I dreamed I was watching you lot play Quidditch,' Harry lied brutally. 'I was trying to get you to stretch out a bit further to grab the Quaffle.'\\
Ron's ears went red. Harry felt a kind of vindictive pleasure; he had not, of course, dreamed anything of the sort."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Discworld/MenAtArms'': When the rest of the Watch finds out Angua is a werewolf, they ask Colon if Vimes knew. Colon cagily claims he "sort of implied it", but when pressed admits his exact words were "She's a bloody werewolf, Fred."
** In ''Discworld/MakingMoney'', Moist asks why Mrs. Lavish keeps two loaded crossbows on her desk. The answer is "family heirlooms". He notes that a lie so blatant is clearly meant to make a statement rather than be believed. Considering the rest of her family, it's more of a [[MetaphoricallyTrue Jedi Truth]]. If any of her family tries anything funny, the crossbow bolts will be heirlooms, after they've been...''forcibly gifted'' upon the family member in question.
** In ''Discworld/{{Thud}}'', a fight nearly breaks out between a troll and a dwarf officer. Commander Vimes enters the room to find a table overturned, and the potential combatants being restrained by their fellow officers. He asks who's going to be the first to "tell me a huge whopper". Nobby Nobbs obliges by offering up an utterly preposterous explanation about how the dwarf almost drank some (dangerously chemical) troll coffee, and the others rushed to stop him. Vimes pretends to buy it, and the others pretend to believe that he buys it.

to:

** ''Discworld/MenAtArms'': ''Literature/MenAtArms'': When the rest of the Watch finds out Angua is a werewolf, they ask Colon if Vimes knew. Colon cagily claims he "sort of implied it", but when pressed admits his exact words were "She's a bloody werewolf, Fred."
** In ''Discworld/MakingMoney'', ''Literature/MakingMoney'', Moist asks why Mrs. Lavish keeps two loaded crossbows on her desk. The answer is "family heirlooms". He notes that a lie so blatant is clearly meant to make a statement rather than be believed. Considering the rest of her family, it's more of a [[MetaphoricallyTrue Jedi Truth]]. If any of her family tries anything funny, the crossbow bolts will be heirlooms, after they've been...''forcibly gifted'' upon the family member in question.
** In ''Discworld/{{Thud}}'', ''Literature/{{Thud}}'', a fight nearly breaks out between a troll and a dwarf officer. Commander Vimes enters the room to find a table overturned, and the potential combatants being restrained by their fellow officers. He asks who's going to be the first to "tell me a huge whopper". Nobby Nobbs obliges by offering up an utterly preposterous explanation about how the dwarf almost drank some (dangerously chemical) troll coffee, and the others rushed to stop him. Vimes pretends to buy it, and the others pretend to believe that he buys it.



** ''Discworld/FeetOfClay'' has Vimes and Detritus discussing who possibly could have threatened Chrysophrase's drug smuggler, Hardcore, while a new applicant looks on in disbelief as Detritus's assurances that none of HIS trolls would ever do such a thing (and yet he knew who was threatened and why) are accepted.

to:

** ''Discworld/FeetOfClay'' ''Literature/FeetOfClay'' has Vimes and Detritus discussing who possibly could have threatened Chrysophrase's drug smuggler, Hardcore, while a new applicant looks on in disbelief as Detritus's assurances that none of HIS trolls would ever do such a thing (and yet he knew who was threatened and why) are accepted.



** ''Discworld/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character ''[[ExactWords technically]]'' only lies about one thing...).

to:

** ''Discworld/MonstrousRegiment''.''Literature/MonstrousRegiment''. Roughly every other spoken line (though one specific character ''[[ExactWords technically]]'' only lies about one thing...).

Top