Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Awesome / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanDeadMenTellNoTales

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After many requests and complaints from fans, the EnsembleDarkhorse Barbossa finally gets his own {{leitmotif}}, which he shares with [[spoiler: his daughter Carina]].

to:

* After many requests and complaints from fans, the EnsembleDarkhorse Barbossa finally gets his own {{leitmotif}}, which he shares with [[spoiler: his daughter Carina]].Carina]].
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Although a blunder, Jack and his crew's attempt to rob a bank is undeniably one ''epic'' blunder. In attempting to run away with a safe, they steal the whole goddamn building and drag it through town!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].

to:

!Meta
* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].daughter]].
* After many requests and complaints from fans, the EnsembleDarkhorse Barbossa finally gets his own {{leitmotif}}, which he shares with [[spoiler: his daughter Carina]].

Added: 223

Changed: 255

Removed: 193

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the cruel-hearted BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]

to:

* [[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this [[BigDamnHeroes by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]]]
** One-upped by what he does next: [[spoiler: Committing himself to do a HeroicSacrifice, especially
once you consider how far he's come from being the cruel-hearted BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]



* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].
* [[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: [[BigDamnHeroes by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]]]

to:

* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].
* [[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: [[BigDamnHeroes by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]]]
daughter]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Upon boarding [[spoiler: the ''Black Pearl'' in the midst of a battle with Salazar's men, Mr. Gibbs and the remainder of Jack's crew bravely decide that after losing the Pearl once, they'll gladly fight for it again!]]


Added DiffLines:

** And once again, [[spoiler: Jack tricks Salazar! As Salazar seemingly stabs Jack with the trident, it turns out the latter had Carina's journal placed [[BatmanGambit right over his heart]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Before then, Jack taunting Salazar the same way he did all those years ago, claiming that he'll "let" him live if he surrenders. After seeing him as a wash-out in the beginning of the movie, we see a trace of the brave rogue he was before.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Before then, Jack taunting Salazar the same way he did all those years ago, claiming that he'll "let" him live if he surrenders. After seeing him as a wash-out in And this is just after Salazar demonstrated the beginning of the movie, we multiple ways he can use Poseidon's Trident to throw Jack around like a helpless ragdoll. It's so refreshing to see a trace of the brave rogue he was before.Jack's roguish courage resurface again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Along with being a CrowningMomentOfFunny, Carina's [[EstablishingCharacterMoment escape from prison]] counts as this. [[spoiler: While she was confessing to the bishop, she picked the lock in the span of her confession. And she doesn't hesitate to make a run for it.]]

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the [[CompleteMonster cruel-hearted]] BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the [[CompleteMonster cruel-hearted]] cruel-hearted BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler: Plus how Barbossa finishes off Salazar: By stabbing him with a sword as he falls from the anchor.]]

to:

*** [[spoiler: **[[spoiler: Plus how Barbossa finishes off Salazar: By stabbing him with a sword as he falls from the anchor.]]

Added: 114

Changed: 18

Removed: 177

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


****[[spoiler: Plus how Barbossa finishes off Salazar: By stabbing him with a sword as he falls from the anchor.]]



* [[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]
* [[spoiler: Doubles as a TearJerker as well, but Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice. He lets go of the anchor and stabs Salazar with his sword before falling peacefully into the sea.]]

to:

* [[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: [[BigDamnHeroes by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]
* [[spoiler: Doubles as a TearJerker as well, but Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice. He lets go of the anchor and stabs Salazar with his sword before falling peacefully into the sea.]]
]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].

to:

* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].daughter]].
*[[BigDamnHeroes Captain Barbossa rescuing Jack, Carina and Henry]] [[spoiler: by lowering himself down on the Black Pearl's anchor in the middle of the parted ocean water.]]
*[[spoiler: Doubles as a TearJerker as well, but Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice. He lets go of the anchor and stabs Salazar with his sword before falling peacefully into the sea.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the climax, [[spoiler: Henry and Carina's combine forces to destroy the Trident.]]

to:

* In the climax, [[spoiler: Henry and Carina's Carina combine forces to destroy the Trident.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's all in how you use the word "just"


* Carina is a role model, not for being smart and brave, but because [[spoiler: she's living proof that children don't have to turn out exactly like their parents. Her father was Barbossa, a pirate who only gave her the ruby and journal to earn herself a small fortune. But she didn't know that. Under the assumption he was a scientist who left her the journal as a dying wish, Carina followed her own path and went on to be highly educated (despite others accusing her as a "witch" for it).]]

to:

* Carina is a role model, not ''just'' for being smart and brave, but because [[spoiler: she's living proof that children don't have to turn out exactly like their parents. Her father was Barbossa, a pirate who only gave her the ruby and journal to earn herself a small fortune. But she didn't know that. Under the assumption he was a scientist who left her the journal as a dying wish, Carina followed her own path and went on to be highly educated (despite others accusing her as a "witch" for it).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The way Salazar's crew is first introduce is both this and nightmare fuel.

to:

* The way Salazar's crew is first introduce introduced is both this and nightmare fuel.

Added: 186

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While on a rowboat with Salazar's crew [[MakesSenseInContext running towards him]], Jack uses a mini-anchor to rope one of Salazar's undead sharks and speeds away on it like it were a sled pulled by a husky. [[PlayedForLaughs And thus,]] [[SarcasmMode Captain Jack Sparrow invented the speedboat.]]

to:

* While on a rowboat with Salazar's crew [[MakesSenseInContext running towards him]], Jack uses a mini-anchor to rope one of Salazar's undead sharks and speeds away on it like it were a sled pulled by a husky.escapes from his pursuers. [[PlayedForLaughs And thus,]] [[SarcasmMode Captain Jack Sparrow invented the speedboat.]]


Added DiffLines:

* When advised by the witch to stay on land, safe from Salazar and his ghostly crew, [[spoiler: Barbossa decides he'd rather risk it all than spend his days safely retired on dry land.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].

to:

* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].Jones]].
* Meta: Kudos to Creator/GeoffreyRush for so powerfully conveying, with a minimum of words, the sheer ''emotion'' of Barbossa [[spoiler: realizing Carina is his long-lost daughter]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Carina is a role model, not for being smart and brave, but because [[spoiler: she's living proof that children don't have to turn out exactly like their parents. Her father was Barbossa, a pirate who only gave her the ruby and journal to earn herself a small fortune. But she didn't know that. Under the assumption he was a scientist who left her the journal as a dying wish, Carina followed her own path and went on to be highly educated (despite that it marked her as a witch).]]

to:

* Carina is a role model, not for being smart and brave, but because [[spoiler: she's living proof that children don't have to turn out exactly like their parents. Her father was Barbossa, a pirate who only gave her the ruby and journal to earn herself a small fortune. But she didn't know that. Under the assumption he was a scientist who left her the journal as a dying wish, Carina followed her own path and went on to be highly educated (despite that it marked others accusing her as a witch)."witch" for it).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Carina is a role model, not for being smart and brave, but because [[spoiler: she's living proof that children don't have to turn out exactly like their parents. Her father was Barbossa, a pirate who only gave her the ruby and journal to earn herself a small fortune. But she didn't know that. Under the assumption he was a scientist who left her the journal as a dying wish, Carina followed her own path and went on to be highly educated (despite that it marked her as a witch).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
speedboat Jack

Added DiffLines:

* While on a rowboat with Salazar's crew [[MakesSenseInContext running towards him]], Jack uses a mini-anchor to rope one of Salazar's undead sharks and speeds away on it like it were a sled pulled by a husky. [[PlayedForLaughs And thus,]] [[SarcasmMode Captain Jack Sparrow invented the speedboat.]]


Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: This may be what ultimately gets Jack out of his crisis where he tries to relive the past by having his crew pay tribute as they once did. By reliving what ''earned'' him tribute in the first place.]]

Added: 79

Changed: 20

Removed: 79

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The flashback showing a very young Jack defeating Salazar. He's just been given command of ''The Wicked Wench'' by the dying captain. What does he do? He sees the Devil's Triangle and his mind begins to work. ''taunts'' the pirate butcher to follow him. He orders his crew to throw the rigging around a rocky outcrop which allows the Wench to safely bypass the Triangle, while the ''Silent Mary'' is too far in its course to do maneuver around it and is headed for a straight on collision clash. The look on Salazar's face is ''priceless'' when he realizes he's been out smarted by this upstart.
** And this was back ''before'' he owned the Black Pearl.

to:

* The flashback showing a very young Jack defeating Salazar. He's just been given command of ''The Wicked Wench'' by the dying captain. What does he do? He sees the Devil's Triangle and his mind begins to work. work, ''taunts'' the pirate butcher to follow him. He orders his crew to throw the rigging around a rocky outcrop which allows the Wench ''Wench'' to safely bypass the Triangle, while the ''Silent Mary'' is too far in its course to do maneuver around it and is headed for a straight on collision clash. The look on Salazar's face is ''priceless'' when he realizes he's been out smarted by this upstart.
** And this was back ''before'' he owned the Black Pearl.''Black Pearl''.



* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].



* The way Salazar crew is first introduce is both this and nightmare fuel.

to:

* The way Salazar Salazar's crew is first introduce is both this and nightmare fuel.



* The return of [[spoiler: The Black Pearl]]. Nuff said.
* In the climax, [[spoiler: Henry and Karina's combine forces to destroy the Trident.]]

to:

* The return of [[spoiler: The Black Pearl]].the ''Black Pearl'']]. Nuff said.
* In the climax, [[spoiler: Henry and Karina's Carina's combine forces to destroy the Trident.]]



* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the [[CompleteMonster cruel-hearted]] BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the [[CompleteMonster cruel-hearted]] BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]]]
* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adjusting bullet points


* And this was back ''before'' he owned the Black Pearl.

to:

* ** And this was back ''before'' he owned the Black Pearl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just saw the movie, must contribute


* And this was back ''before'' he owned the Black Pearl.



* A young Henry being able to determine where his father was. This show us that even at a young age, his studies of ocean myths have worked for him.

to:

* A young Henry being able to determine where his father was. This show us that even at a young age, his studies of ocean myths have worked for him.him.
* The return of [[spoiler: The Black Pearl]]. Nuff said.
* In the climax, [[spoiler: Henry and Karina's combine forces to destroy the Trident.]]
** [[spoiler: Before then, Jack taunting Salazar the same way he did all those years ago, claiming that he'll "let" him live if he surrenders. After seeing him as a wash-out in the beginning of the movie, we see a trace of the brave rogue he was before.]]
* [[spoiler: Barbossa's HeroicSacrifice can count as this once you consider how far he's come from being the [[CompleteMonster cruel-hearted]] BigBad in the first movie. CharacterDevelopment indeed.]]

Added: 222

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Elizabeth kinda gets a more indirect moment. Jack has been, through out the seires, built up as an irresistable charmer. In the scene where Henry meets him for the first time, Jack reveals that he's harbors feelings for her still, considerds Will unworthy of her and assumes she must, like all women, secretly long for him. But Henry, Elizabeth's son to Will, tells him to his face that she's never even bothered to ''mention'' him. She wasn't even there and she got him.

to:

* Elizabeth kinda gets a more indirect moment. Jack has been, through out the seires, series, built up as an irresistable irresistible charmer. In the scene where Henry meets him for the first time, Jack reveals that he's harbors feelings for her still, considerds considers Will unworthy of her and assumes she must, like all women, secretly long for him. But Henry, Elizabeth's son to Will, tells him to his face that she's never even bothered to ''mention'' him. She wasn't even there and she got him.
* The way Salazar crew is first introduce is both this and nightmare fuel.
* A young Henry being able to determine where his father was. This show us that even at a young age, his studies of ocean myths have worked for
him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The flashback showing a very young Jack defeating Salazar. He's just been given command of ''The Wicked Wench'' by the dying captain. What does he do? He sees the Devil's Triangle and his mind begins to work. ''taunts'' the pirate butcher to follow him. He orders his crew to throw the rigging around a rocky outcrop which allows the Wench to safely bypass the Triangle, while the ''Silent Mary'' is too far in it's course to do maneuver around it and is headed for a straight on collision clash. The look on Salazar's face is ''priceless'' when he realizes he's been out smarted by this upstart.

to:

* The flashback showing a very young Jack defeating Salazar. He's just been given command of ''The Wicked Wench'' by the dying captain. What does he do? He sees the Devil's Triangle and his mind begins to work. ''taunts'' the pirate butcher to follow him. He orders his crew to throw the rigging around a rocky outcrop which allows the Wench to safely bypass the Triangle, while the ''Silent Mary'' is too far in it's its course to do maneuver around it and is headed for a straight on collision clash. The look on Salazar's face is ''priceless'' when he realizes he's been out smarted by this upstart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Elizabeth kinda gets a more indirect moment. Jack has been, through out the seires, built up as an irresistable charmer. In the scene where Henry meets him for the first time, Jack reveals that he's harbors feelings for her still, considerds Will unworthy of her and assumes she must, like all women, secretly long for him still. But Henry, Elizabeth's son to Will, tells him to his face that she's never even bothered to mention him. She wasn't even there and she got him.

to:

* Elizabeth kinda gets a more indirect moment. Jack has been, through out the seires, built up as an irresistable charmer. In the scene where Henry meets him for the first time, Jack reveals that he's harbors feelings for her still, considerds Will unworthy of her and assumes she must, like all women, secretly long for him still. him. But Henry, Elizabeth's son to Will, tells him to his face that she's never even bothered to mention ''mention'' him. She wasn't even there and she got him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].

to:

* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].Jones]].
* Elizabeth kinda gets a more indirect moment. Jack has been, through out the seires, built up as an irresistable charmer. In the scene where Henry meets him for the first time, Jack reveals that he's harbors feelings for her still, considerds Will unworthy of her and assumes she must, like all women, secretly long for him still. But Henry, Elizabeth's son to Will, tells him to his face that she's never even bothered to mention him. She wasn't even there and she got him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hair beads. He ''earned'' his role as captain. The best part he's completely flabbergasted by all of this. A far cry from the drunken washout we see at the beginning.

to:

** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hair beads. He ''earned'' his role as captain. The best part he's completely flabbergasted by all of this. A far cry from the drunken washout we see at the beginning.beginning.
* The post-credits scene, which features [[spoiler: the return of Davy Jones]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hair beads. He ''earned'' his role as captain. The best part he's completely flabbergasted by all of this. A

to:

** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hair beads. He ''earned'' his role as captain. The best part he's completely flabbergasted by all of this. AA far cry from the drunken washout we see at the beginning.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hairs. He ''earned'' his role as captain.

to:

** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hairs.hair beads. He ''earned'' his role as captain. The best part he's completely flabbergasted by all of this. A
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The flashback showing a very young Jack defeating Salazar. He's just been given command of ''The Wicked Wench'' by the dying captain. What does he do? He sees the Devil's Triangle and his mind begins to work. ''taunts'' the pirate butcher to follow him. He orders his crew to throw the rigging around a rocky outcrop which allows the Wench to safely bypass the Triangle, while the ''Silent Mary'' is too far in it's course to do maneuver around it and is headed for a straight on collision clash. The look on Salazar's face is ''priceless'' when he realizes he's been out smarted by this upstart.
** And Jack's crew? They pay tribute to him giving him amongst other things his icon hat and hairs. He ''earned'' his role as captain.

Top