Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Awesome / BandOfBrothers

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As an even better "fuck you" to the man, Winters takes Sobel's own pen, corrects his misspelling of the word "court martial," offers it as his endorsement, and salutes him--all while making it very clear just how little respect he has for the jerk sitting in front of him.

to:

** As an even better "fuck you" to the man, Winters takes Sobel's own pen, corrects his misspelling of the word "court martial," offers it as his endorsement, and salutes him--all while making it very clear just [[WithDueRespect how little respect respect]] he has for the jerk sitting in front of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which would go on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty), thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.

to:

* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment of a denial of 48 hour pass for 60 days (which would go on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty), thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice.choice (as Winters was known for always spending his time on base). Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.



* ''All'' of Easy's noncoms banding together to mutiny against Sobel, knowing fully well that this could result in them getting ''shot,'' but doing it anyway because they obviously don't want any of the men under them, as well as themselves, to be killed in battle.

to:

* ''All'' of Easy's noncoms banding together to mutiny against Sobel, knowing fully well that this could result in them getting ''shot,'' but doing it anyway because they obviously don't want any of the men under them, as well as themselves, to be killed in battle.battle under Sobel's command.

Added: 562

Removed: 562

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As the Germans make their march of defeat, Webster delivers an enraged ReasonYouSuckSpeech that becomes [[TearJerker/BandOfBrothers surprisingly poignant]] at the end.
--> '''Webster:''' Hey, you! That's right, you stupid Kraut bastards! That's right! Say hello to Ford, and General fuckin' Motors! You stupid fascist ''pigs!'' Look at you! You have ''horses!'' What were you thinking? [...] Dragging our asses half way around the world, interrupting our lives, for ''what?'' You ignorant, servile ''scum!'' What the ''fuck'' are we doing here?! '''''Huh?!'''''



* As the Germans make their march of defeat, Webster delivers an enraged ReasonYouSuckSpeech that becomes [[TearJerker/BandOfBrothers surprisingly poignant]] at the end.
--> '''Webster:''' Hey, you! That's right, you stupid Kraut bastards! That's right! Say hello to Ford, and General fuckin' Motors! You stupid fascist ''pigs!'' Look at you! You have ''horses!'' What were you thinking? [...] Dragging our asses half way around the world, interrupting our lives, for ''what?'' You ignorant, servile ''scum!'' What the ''fuck'' are we doing here?! '''''Huh?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The cool thing is, in the series, the grenade hits the German in the back. In real life, Buck threw the grenade the equivalent distance between home plate and second base on a baseball diamond with no arc[[note]]a grenade is significantly heavier than a baseball and it's possible to wrench a shoulder even when lobbing one normally[[/note]] and it hit the German IN THE HEAD. That's right: they had to tone Buck's awesomeness ''down'' because it would've been too damn unbelievable.

to:

*** The cool thing is, in the series, the grenade hits the German in the back. In real life, Buck threw the grenade the equivalent distance between home plate and second base on a baseball diamond with no arc[[note]]a grenade is significantly heavier than a baseball and it's possible to wrench a shoulder even when lobbing one normally[[/note]] baseball[[/note]] and it hit the German IN THE HEAD. That's right: they had to tone Buck's awesomeness ''down'' because it would've been too damn unbelievable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No meta moment, see this query.


-->'''Maj. Winters:''' This morning, President Truman received the unconditional surrender of the Japanese. War's over.

[[AC: Meta]]
* When you realize that everything that happened in the series, happened in real life, minus heresay and possible exaggeration.
** When you realize that some things had to be TONED DOWN because, despite them actually happening, people thought that no one would believe that they actually did.

to:

-->'''Maj. Winters:''' This morning, President Truman received the unconditional surrender of the Japanese. War's over.

[[AC: Meta]]
* When you realize that everything that happened in the series, happened in real life, minus heresay and possible exaggeration.
** When you realize that some things had to be TONED DOWN because, despite them actually happening, people thought that no one would believe that they actually did.
over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As the Nazis make their march of defeat, Webster delivers an enraged ReasonYouSuckSpeech that becomes [[TearJerker/BandOfBrothers surprisingly poignant]] at the end.
--> '''Webster:''' Hey, you! That's right, you stupid Kraut bastards! That's right! Say hello to Ford, and General fuckin' Motors! You stupid fascist ''pigs''! Look at you! You have ''horses''! What were you thinking? [...] Dragging our asses half way around the world, interrupting our lives...for ''what''? You ignorant, servile ''scum''! What the ''fuck'' are we doing here?! '''''Huh?!'''''

to:

* As the Nazis Germans make their march of defeat, Webster delivers an enraged ReasonYouSuckSpeech that becomes [[TearJerker/BandOfBrothers surprisingly poignant]] at the end.
--> '''Webster:''' Hey, you! That's right, you stupid Kraut bastards! That's right! Say hello to Ford, and General fuckin' Motors! You stupid fascist ''pigs''! ''pigs!'' Look at you! You have ''horses''! ''horses!'' What were you thinking? [...] Dragging our asses half way around the world, interrupting our lives...lives, for ''what''? ''what?'' You ignorant, servile ''scum''! ''scum!'' What the ''fuck'' are we doing here?! '''''Huh?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* As the Nazis make their march of defeat, Webster delivers an enraged ReasonYouSuckSpeech that becomes [[TearJerker/BandOfBrothers surprisingly poignant]] at the end.
--> '''Webster:''' Hey, you! That's right, you stupid Kraut bastards! That's right! Say hello to Ford, and General fuckin' Motors! You stupid fascist ''pigs''! Look at you! You have ''horses''! What were you thinking? [...] Dragging our asses half way around the world, interrupting our lives...for ''what''? You ignorant, servile ''scum''! What the ''fuck'' are we doing here?! '''''Huh?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spoilers shouldn't be marked on Awesome subpages.


* Bill Guarnere running out of his foxhole after a German assault when he hears one of his best friends, Joe Toye, crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag Toye to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.

to:

* Bill Guarnere running out of his foxhole after a German assault when he hears one of his best friends, Joe Toye, crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag Toye to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]].amputating. Even so he's still worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Winters defying Colonel Sink's orders and not sending out the patrol a second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. He feeds them the exact (fake) report they are to give him the next morning, explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners, and tells them all to get a good night's rest.

to:

* Winters defying Colonel Sink's orders and not sending out the patrol a second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. [[note]]Due to the raid the previous night and the river starting to ice over from the cold, the patrol would have been easily spotted and possibly killed, meaning that sending them would be a huge risk for almost no chance of success.[[/note]] He feeds them the exact (fake) report they are to give him the next morning, explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners, and tells them all to get a good night's rest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* When [[CrazyAwesome Welsh]] sees an MG firing at Shifty, he immediately runs out into the open, armed with only a grenade, lobs it into the German soldier's hiding place, and takes cover beneath the exploding building.

to:

* When [[CrazyAwesome Welsh]] Welsh sees an MG firing at Shifty, he immediately runs out into the open, armed with only a grenade, lobs it into the German soldier's hiding place, and takes cover beneath the exploding building.

Added: 101

Changed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The assault on Brecourt Manor, with Easy taking out four heavy guns so successfully that ''to this day,'' the maneuver is still taught at West Point as an ideal assault on a fixed position.

to:

* The assault on Brecourt Manor, with Easy taking out four heavy guns so successfully that ''to this day,'' the maneuver is still taught at West Point as an ideal assault on a fixed position.position to this very day.



* Resident sharpshooter Shifty managing to shoot not one, but ''two'' snipers, all while being pinned down behind a wall.
* When [[CrazyAwesome Welsh]] sees Shifty being pinned, he immediately ''runs out into the open,'' armed with only a grenade, lobs it into the German soldier's hiding place, ''and takes cover beneath it.''

to:

* Resident sharpshooter Shifty managing to shoot not one, but ''two'' two snipers, all while being pinned down behind a wall.
* When [[CrazyAwesome Welsh]] sees Shifty being pinned, an MG firing at Shifty, he immediately ''runs runs out into the open,'' open, armed with only a grenade, lobs it into the German soldier's hiding place, ''and and takes cover beneath it.''the exploding building.



-->'''Roe:''' "You two are officers! You are grownups! You oughtta know!"

to:

-->'''Welsh:''' We're sorry, Doc. He was in a lot of pain. We didn't know what to do--
-->'''Roe:''' "You two Yeah, well, you oughta! You know, you are officers! You officers, you are grownups! You oughtta know!"grown-ups, you oughta know!



* The ending title cards of "Bastogne"

to:

* The ending title cards of "Bastogne""Bastogne:"



* Shifty Powers taking down the sniper hiding in a bell tower with ease. The best part? When Lip and Popeye Wynn, Shifty's best friend, went to check on the body, the bullet ''was right between the man's eyes.''

to:

* Shifty Powers taking down the sniper hiding in a bell tower with ease. The best part? When What's truly amazing is that, in the book, when Lip and Popeye Wynn, Shifty's best friend, went to check on the body, the bullet ''was right between the man's eyes.''



** The shocked look on Nix's face as he whips off his aviators and takes in all the liquor. The man looks like he'd just died and gone to heaven! And to make things even better, it's ''''''V-E Day,''''' giving them all a very good reason indeed to celebrate.

to:

** The shocked look on Nix's face as he whips off his aviators and takes in all the liquor. The man looks like he'd just died and gone to heaven! And to make things even better, it's ''''''V-E '''''V-E Day,''''' giving them all a very good reason indeed to celebrate.

Added: 4343

Changed: 4753

Removed: 1485

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''All'' of Easy's NCOs banding together to mutiny against Sobel, knowing fully well that this could result in them getting ''shot,'' but doing it anyway because they obviously don't want any of the men under them, as well as themselves, to be killed in battle.

to:

* ''All'' of Easy's NCOs noncoms banding together to mutiny against Sobel, knowing fully well that this could result in them getting ''shot,'' but doing it anyway because they obviously don't want any of the men under them, as well as themselves, to be killed in battle.



* Dick Winters, unarmed, walks up to Bill Guarnere, the most aggressive man in Easy Company, shoves him back, and chews him out for disobeying his orders. Bill, defiant yet obviously knowing he's being put in his place, only manages a gruff, "Yes, sir."



* During the battle to take Carentan, a German machine gun is firing up the road that Easy Company is using for their attack. The men take shelter in a ditch to avoid being shot. Dick Winter stands ''in the middle of the road'' screaming at the men to press the attack. And he doesn't get a scratch on him as bullets fly by. In fact, the only injury he takes is from a ricochet at the end of the battle.



** Another Welsh moment: firing at an ''oncoming tank'' with only a bazooka and McGrath for help. It's no wonder the men are so delighted when he runs back to them.

to:

** Another Welsh moment: firing at an ''oncoming tank'' with only a bazooka and McGrath [=McGrath=] for help.backup. It's no wonder the men are so delighted when he runs back to them.




to:

[[AC: Episode 5 - "Crossroads"]]
* Winters leading a single platoon against two entire companies of German troops and [[CurbStompBattle manages to rout them with only one man dead and a few wounded]]. Winters even made the initial assault on his own as a diversionary tactic, with his men coming up several seconds behind. Winters doesn't even bat an eye at how many Germans he's facing. He just raises his rifle and starts shooting. [[OneManArmy The first thing the Germans do when they realize Winters is firing at them is to run for their lives.]]
* After the main battle, Easy Company captures a number of German prisoners and tasks Liebgott with escorting them back to base. Liebgott's enthusiastic reply makes Winters worry that he might just execute the prisoners instead, so he orders Liebgott to drop all of his ammo and leaves him with only a single bullet, telling him that if he decides to kill a prisoner, he'd have no way to defend himself from the others. The book mentions that one of the prisoners overheard the conversation, and Winters muses that he probably understood English due to the look of relief on his face.
* All 100 or so of the Red Devils (British Airborne) somehow managing to get within spitting distance of Easy without any of them noticing.
** Subsequently, the victory party that they throw when the rescue operation is successful:
-->'''Commander:''' Moose Heyliger and the American 101st have done the Red Devils a great service. Making it possible for us to return and fight the enemy on another day. To Easy Company: victory...and Currahee!
-->'''Easy:''' [[{{Battlecry}} CURRAHEE!!!]]
* Eugene "Doc" Roe giving an ''EPIC'' WhatTheHellHero to Winters and Welsh after he sees the WorstAid they gave Moose when he was shot.
-->'''Roe:''' "You two are officers! You are grownups! You oughtta know!"
** That's right: [[BewareTheQuietOnes quiet, gentle Roe]] absolutely ''unleashes hell'' on his superior officers, and neither of them reprimand him for it.
* This exchange from the end of "Crossroads":
-->'''Lt. Rice:''' A panzer division's about to cut the road south. Looks like you'll be surrounded.
-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]

[[AC: Episode 6 - "Bastogne"]]
* The ending title cards of "Bastogne"
-->''"The story of the Battle of the Bulge told today is one of General Patton and his Third Army coming to the rescue of the encircled 101st." [next card] "No member of the 101st has ever agreed that the division needed to be rescued."''



* Bill Guarnere running out of his foxhole after a German assault when he hears one of his best friends, Joe Toye, crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag Toye to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.
-->'''Bill:''' Hey, Joe, I told you I'd beat you back to the States.








* In "Crossroads", Winters leads a single platoon against two entire companies of German troops and [[CurbStompBattle manages to rout them with only one man dead and a few wounded]]. Winters even made the initial assault on his own as a diversionary tactic, with his men coming up several seconds behind. Winters doesn't even bat an eye at how many Germans he's facing. He just raises his rifle and starts shooting. [[OneManArmy The first thing the Germans do when they realize Winters is firing at them is to run for their lives.]]
* After the main battle in "Crossroads", Easy Company captures a number of German prisoners and tasks Liebgott with escorting them back to base. Liebgott's enthusiastic reply makes Winters worry that he might just execute the prisoners instead, so he orders Liebgott to drop all of his ammo and leaves him with only a single bullet, telling him that if he decides to kill a prisoner, he'd have no way to defend himself from the others. The book mentions that one of the prisoners overhears the conversation, and Winters muses that he probably understood English due to the look of relief on his face.
* A small but memorable one in the final episode, "Points": while witnessing the official surrender of a group of German soldiers, Winters, now a major, encounters Sobel, still a captain. When Sobel curtly acknowledges Winters as he walks by, Winters coldly says, "Captain Sobel! We salute the rank, not the man." Deeply reluctant, Sobel salutes Winters. Winters keeps his cool, but Nixon and Liebgott, watching nearby, can barely suppress their smiles at this victory over their hated former CO. Winters himself considers this one of the most satisfying moments of his life.
* Dick Winters, unarmed, walks up to Bill Guarnere, the most aggressive man in Easy Company, shoves him against a wall, and chews him out for disobeying his orders. Bill, defiant yet obviously knowing he's being put in his place, only manages a gruff, "Yes, sir."
* During the battle to take Carentan, a German machine gun is firing up the road that Easy Company is using for their attack. The men take shelter in a ditch to avoid being shot. Dick Winter stands ''in the middle of the road'' screaming at the men to press the attack. And he doesn't get a scratch on him as bullets fly by. In fact, the only injury he takes is from a ricochet at the end of the battle.
* Eugene "Doc" Roe giving an ''EPIC'' WhatTheHellHero to Winters and Welsh after he sees the WorstAid they gave Moose when he was shot.
-->'''Roe:''' "You two are officers! You are grownups! You oughtta know!"
* One has to go to the Red Devils (British Airborne) when Easy come rescue them after they are cut of during Market Garden all 100 or so of the Brits manage to get within spitting distance of Easy without them noticing.
* Bill Guarnere runs out of his foxhole during a German assault when he hears Joe Toye crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag his friend to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.
* Upon securing Herman Goering's house in Berchtesgaden, Easy Company "impounds" the massive, and incredibly well-stocked, wine cellar. Nixon thought he died and went to heaven.
* The ending title cards of "Bastogne"
-->''"The story of the Battle of the Bulge told today is one of General Patton and his Third Army coming to the rescue of the encircled 101st." [next card] "No member of the 101st has ever agreed that the division needed to be rescued."''
* The scenes with Nixon and the German Officer's Widow. The two do not speak a word to each other, but the looks they give speak volumes:

to:

\n\n\n\n\n* In "Crossroads", Winters leads Shifty Powers taking down the sniper hiding in a single platoon against two entire companies of German troops and [[CurbStompBattle manages to rout them bell tower with only one man dead ease. The best part? When Lip and a few wounded]]. Winters even made Popeye Wynn, Shifty's best friend, went to check on the initial assault on his own as a diversionary tactic, with his men coming up several seconds behind. Winters body, the bullet ''was right between the man's eyes.''
-->'''Popeye:''' You know, it just
doesn't even bat an eye pay to be shootin' at how many Germans Shifty when he's facing. He just raises his rifle got a rifle.
** As with Buck's grenade toss in Episode 2, the distance with which Shifty shot the man was even further in real life.

[[AC: Episode 8 - "The Last Patrol"]]
* Throughout the episode, everyone writes off Lt. Jones as useless since he's fresh out of West Point
and starts shooting. [[OneManArmy The first thing the Germans do when they realize Winters is firing at them is to run for their lives.]]
* After the main
has no battle in "Crossroads", Easy Company captures experience. He then proves himself to be a number of German prisoners capable leader when Private Vest freaks out over Jackson's injury, draws his sidearm, and tasks Liebgott with escorting them back to base. Liebgott's enthusiastic reply makes Winters worry that he might just execute points it at the prisoners instead, so he orders Liebgott to drop all of his ammo and leaves him with only a single bullet, telling him that if he decides to kill a prisoner, he'd Easy have no way to defend himself from just captured. Jones slams Vest against the others. The book mentions that one of the wall, easily disarms him, and tells him they're not going to go back for more prisoners overhears because he killed the conversation, and ones they had.
*
Winters muses that he probably understood English due to defying Colonel Sink's orders and not sending out the look of relief on his face.
* A small but memorable one in the final episode, "Points": while witnessing the official surrender of
patrol a group of German soldiers, Winters, now a major, encounters Sobel, still a captain. When Sobel curtly acknowledges Winters as he walks by, Winters coldly says, "Captain Sobel! We salute the rank, not the man." Deeply reluctant, Sobel salutes Winters. Winters keeps his cool, but Nixon and Liebgott, watching nearby, can barely suppress their smiles at this victory over their hated former CO. Winters himself considers this one of the most satisfying moments of his life.
* Dick Winters, unarmed, walks up to Bill Guarnere, the most aggressive man in Easy Company, shoves him against a wall, and chews him out for disobeying his orders. Bill, defiant yet obviously knowing he's being put in his place, only manages a gruff, "Yes, sir."
* During the battle to take Carentan, a German machine gun is firing up the road that Easy Company is using for their attack. The men take shelter in a ditch to avoid being shot. Dick Winter stands ''in the middle of the road'' screaming at the men to press the attack. And he doesn't get a scratch on him as bullets fly by. In fact, the only injury he takes is from a ricochet at the end of the battle.
* Eugene "Doc" Roe giving an ''EPIC'' WhatTheHellHero to Winters and Welsh after he sees the WorstAid they gave Moose when he was shot.
-->'''Roe:''' "You two are officers! You are grownups! You oughtta know!"
* One has to go to the Red Devils (British Airborne) when Easy come rescue them
second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. He feeds them the exact (fake) report they are cut of during Market Garden to give him the next morning, explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners, and tells them all 100 or so of the Brits manage to get within spitting distance of Easy without them noticing.
* Bill Guarnere runs out of his foxhole during
a German assault when he hears Joe Toye crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag his friend to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.
* Upon securing Herman Goering's house in Berchtesgaden, Easy Company "impounds" the massive, and incredibly well-stocked, wine cellar. Nixon thought he died and went to heaven.
* The ending title cards of "Bastogne"
-->''"The story of the Battle of the Bulge told today is one of General Patton and his Third Army coming to the rescue of the encircled 101st." [next card] "No member of the 101st has ever agreed that the division needed to be rescued."''
good night's rest.

[[AC: Episode 9 - "Why We Fight"]]
* The scenes with Nixon and the German Officer's Widow. The two do not speak even exchange a single word to each other, during their scenes together, but the looks they give share speak volumes:



** When he sees her being forced to move bodies at Dachau, it is his turn to give her the "how dare you" look.

to:

** When he sees her being forced to move bodies at Dachau, Landsberg, it is his turn to give her the "how dare you" look.




[[AC: Episode 10 - "Points"]]
* Upon securing Herman Goering's house in Berchtesgaden, Easy Company "impounds" the massive, and incredibly well-stocked, wine cellar.
** The shocked look on Nix's face as he whips off his aviators and takes in all the liquor. The man looks like he'd just died and gone to heaven! And to make things even better, it's ''''''V-E Day,''''' giving them all a very good reason indeed to celebrate.
* Even in the face of an angry Liebgott, Webster is still as unflappable as ever, calmly saying, "No" when Lieb screams at him to shoot the escaping Nazi commandant[[note]]Web wasn't sympathizing with the Nazi, and was only restraining because they had no solid proof of his supposed background.[[/note]].



* Throughout "The Last Patrol", everyone writes off Lt. Jones as useless since he's fresh out of West Point and has no experience. He then proves himself to be a capable leader when Private Vest freaks out over Jackson's injury, draws his sidearm, and points it at the prisoners Easy just captured. Jones slams Vest against the wall, disarms him, and tells him they're not going to go back for more prisoners because he killed the ones they had.
* Winters defying Colonel Sink's orders in "The Last Patrol" and not sending out the patrol a second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. He gives them the exact (fake) report they are to give him the next morning explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners.
* This exchange from the end of "Crossroads":
-->'''Lt. Rice:''' A panzer division's about to cut the road south. Looks like you'll be surrounded.
-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]


to:

* Throughout "The Last Patrol", everyone writes off Lt. Jones as useless since he's fresh out of West Point and has no experience. He then proves himself to be a capable leader when Private Vest freaks out over Jackson's injury, draws his sidearm, and points it at the prisoners Easy just captured. Jones slams Vest against the wall, disarms him, and tells him they're not going to go back for more prisoners because he killed the ones they had.
* Winters defying Colonel Sink's orders in "The Last Patrol" and not sending out the patrol a second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. He gives them the exact (fake) report they are to give him the next morning explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners.
* This exchange from
A small but memorable moment towards the end of "Crossroads":
-->'''Lt. Rice:''' A panzer division's about to cut
the road south. Looks like you'll be surrounded.
-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]

episode: while witnessing the official surrender of a group of German soldiers, Winters, now a major, encounters Sobel, still a captain. When Sobel curtly acknowledges Winters as he walks by, Winters coldly says, "Captain Sobel! We salute the rank, not the man." Deeply reluctant, Sobel salutes Winters. Winters keeps his cool, but Nixon and Liebgott, watching nearby, can barely suppress their laughter at this victory over their hated former CO. Winters himself considers this one of the most satisfying moments of his life.
* The moment the men of Easy have all been waiting for:
-->'''Maj. Winters:''' This morning, President Truman received the unconditional surrender of the Japanese. War's over.

Added: 2683

Changed: 2844

Removed: 180

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "The Breaking Point", Easy Company is pinned down and Lieutenant Dike is completely frozen, Speirs runs in, immediately takes control of the situation, and the proceeds to run THROUGH a town full of German troops, hooks up with I Company before running BACK to reassume command of Easy. This really happened and Lipton muses that the only reason why Speirs managed to survive was because his mad dash was so insane that the Germans had a hard time believing it was actually happening.
** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed badass calling up another confirmed badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]][[note]]In the actual event, Winters did start to charge down the field, but stopped himself when he realized that he had command responsibilities and couldn't risk getting pinned down with a single company (he had responsibility for the battalion). The rest of the scene otherwise plays out accurately[[/note]].
* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty), thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.

to:

[[AC: Episode 1 - "Currahee"]]
* In "The Breaking Point", During the infamous spaghetti run, Sobel repeatedly taunts Easy Company is pinned down and Lieutenant Dike is completely frozen, Speirs runs in, immediately takes control of the situation, and the proceeds to run THROUGH a town full of German troops, hooks up with I Company before running BACK to reassume command of Easy. This really happened and Lipton muses that the only reason why Speirs managed to survive was because his mad dash was so insane that the Germans Co. for being weak. Luz, having had a hard time believing it was actually happening.
** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters
enough, starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink singing a marching song. Even when Sobel glares at him and tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' block his superior officer path, the [[OOCIsSeriousBusiness normally easy-going Luz]] simply ignores him and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed badass calling up another confirmed badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save sings ''louder,'' prompting the day]][[note]]In the actual event, Winters did start other men to charge down the field, but stopped himself when he realized that he had command responsibilities and couldn't risk getting pinned down with a single company (he had responsibility for the battalion). The rest of the scene otherwise plays out accurately[[/note]].
join in as well.
* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes would go on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty), thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.



* When you realize that everything that happened in the series, happened in real life, minus heresay and possible exaggeration.
** When you realise that some things had to be TONED DOWN because, despite them actually happening, people thought that no one would believe that they actually did.
* The assault on Brecourt Manor, taking out four heavy guns so successfully that to this day it's taught at West Point as an ideal assault on a fixed position.

to:

* When you realize ''All'' of Easy's NCOs banding together to mutiny against Sobel, knowing fully well that everything that happened this could result in them getting ''shot,'' but doing it anyway because they obviously don't want any of the series, happened in real life, minus heresay and possible exaggeration.
** When you realise that some things had
men under them, as well as themselves, to be TONED DOWN because, despite them actually happening, people thought killed in battle.
-->'''Lipton:''' We all better be clear of the consequences.\\
'''Martin:''' I don't care about the consequences.\\
'''Lipton:''' John, [[SeriousBusiness we could be lined up against a wall and shot]]. Now, I'm ready to face that. And every one of us had better be too.\\
(beat)\\
'''Guarnere:''' I will ''not'' follow
that no one would believe that they actually did.
man into combat. \\
'''Bull:''' Me neither.\\
'''Lipton:''' All right. Then let's do it.
--> ''(They all begin writing their resignation letters)''

[[AC: Episode 2 - "Day of Days"]]
* The assault on Brecourt Manor, with Easy taking out four heavy guns so successfully that to ''to this day it's day,'' the maneuver is still taught at West Point as an ideal assault on a fixed position.



*** The cool thing is, in the series, the grenade hits the German in the back. In real life, Buck threw the grenade the equivalent distance between home plate and second base on a baseball diamond with no arc[[note]]a grenade is significantly heavier than a baseball and it's possible to wrench a shoulder even when lobbing one normally[[/note]] and it hit the German IN THE HEAD.

to:

*** The cool thing is, in the series, the grenade hits the German in the back. In real life, Buck threw the grenade the equivalent distance between home plate and second base on a baseball diamond with no arc[[note]]a grenade is significantly heavier than a baseball and it's possible to wrench a shoulder even when lobbing one normally[[/note]] and it hit the German IN THE HEAD. That's right: they had to tone Buck's awesomeness ''down'' because it would've been too damn unbelievable.

[[AC: Episode 3 - "Carentan"]]
* Resident sharpshooter Shifty managing to shoot not one, but ''two'' snipers, all while being pinned down behind a wall.
* When [[CrazyAwesome Welsh]] sees Shifty being pinned, he immediately ''runs out into the open,'' armed with only a grenade, lobs it into the German soldier's hiding place, ''and takes cover beneath it.''
** Another Welsh moment: firing at an ''oncoming tank'' with only a bazooka and McGrath for help. It's no wonder the men are so delighted when he runs back to them.
-->'''Liebgott:''' ''[smiling cheekily]'' You hit a homerun, huh?




[[AC: Episode 4 - "Replacements"]]





[[AC: Episode 7 - "The Breaking Point"]]
* During the Battle of Foy, Easy Company is pinned down in the open and Lieutenant Dike is completely frozen. Speirs runs in, immediately takes control of the situation, and then proceeds to run THROUGH a town full of German troops, hooking up with I Company before running BACK to reassume command of Easy. Keep in mind that this ''actually happened'' in real life. Lipton muses that the only reason why Speirs managed to survive was because his mad dash was so insane that the Germans had a hard time believing it was actually happening.
** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. When Sink tries to talk Winters down with "Now, Dick, I understand your attachment to Easy Company, but..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS! GET YOURSELF OVER HERE!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed badass calling up another confirmed badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]][[note]]In the actual event, Winters did start to charge down the field, but stopped himself when he realized that he had command responsibilities and couldn't risk getting pinned down with a single company (he had responsibility for the entire battalion). The rest of the scene otherwise plays out accurately[[/note]].







* In "Currahee", when the sergeants are discussing whether they should go through with their mutiny to get Winters back and free Easy company of Sobel.
-->'''Lipton:''' We all better be clear of the consequences.\\
'''Martin:''' I don't care about the consequences.\\
'''Lipton:''' John, [[SeriousBusiness we could be lined up against a wall and shot]]. Now, I'm ready to face that. And every one of us had better be too.\\
(beat)\\
'''Guarnere:''' I will ''not'' follow that man into combat. \\
'''Bull:''' Me neither.\\
'''Lipton:''' All right, then let's do it. (They all begin writing their resignation letters)

to:



[[AC: Meta]]
* In "Currahee", when When you realize that everything that happened in the sergeants are discussing whether series, happened in real life, minus heresay and possible exaggeration.
** When you realize that some things had to be TONED DOWN because, despite them actually happening, people thought that no one would believe that
they should go through with their mutiny to get Winters back and free Easy company of Sobel.
-->'''Lipton:''' We all better be clear of the consequences.\\
'''Martin:''' I don't care about the consequences.\\
'''Lipton:''' John, [[SeriousBusiness we could be lined up against a wall and shot]]. Now, I'm ready to face that. And every one of us had better be too.\\
(beat)\\
'''Guarnere:''' I will ''not'' follow that man into combat. \\
'''Bull:''' Me neither.\\
'''Lipton:''' All right, then let's do it. (They all begin writing their resignation letters)
actually did.

Added: 275

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty) thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.

to:

* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty) guilty), thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.it.
** As an even better "fuck you" to the man, Winters takes Sobel's own pen, corrects his misspelling of the word "court martial," offers it as his endorsement, and salutes him--all while making it very clear just how little respect he has for the jerk sitting in front of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Bill Guarnere runs out of his foxhole during a German assault when he hears Joe Toye crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag his friend to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worring more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.

to:

* Bill Guarnere runs out of his foxhole during a German assault when he hears Joe Toye crying for help. A second round of artillery starts to hit while he's trying to drag his friend to safety and he ends up [[spoiler:having his right leg wounded so badly it needs amputating]]. Even so he's still worring worrying more about Toye and cracks jokes when others come to help them.



* Winters accepting the German colonel's formal surrender in Austria. While he doesn't share the colonel's fondness for war, he does respect the cononel's professionalism and decorum, so much so that he allows him to keep his sidearm and returns his salute.

to:

* Winters accepting the German colonel's formal surrender in Austria. While he doesn't share the colonel's fondness for war, he does respect the cononel's colonel's professionalism and decorum, so much so that he allows him to keep his sidearm and returns his salute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
it's a colonel, not a major


* Winters accepting the German Major's formal surrender in Austria. While he doesn't share the Major's fondness for war, he does respect the Major's professionalism and decorum, so much so that he allows him to keep his sidearm and returns his salute.

to:

* Winters accepting the German Major's colonel's formal surrender in Austria. While he doesn't share the Major's colonel's fondness for war, he does respect the Major's cononel's professionalism and decorum, so much so that he allows him to keep his sidearm and returns his salute.

Added: 813

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty) thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''himself''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.
** It indirectly leads to Sink - who figures the court martial would go badly for the Army - reassigning Sobel to a non-combat role and sweeping the whole matter under the rug. Sobel is [[AlasPoorVillain genuinely broken by the loss]] of his chance at a battlefield command, but it frees Easy Company to receive more competent leadership (eventually under Winters).

to:

* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty) thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''himself'').''[[DidntThinkThisThrough himself]]''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.
** It indirectly leads to Sink - who figures the court martial would go badly for the Army - reassigning Sobel to a non-combat role and sweeping the whole matter under the rug. Sobel is [[AlasPoorVillain genuinely broken by the loss]] of his chance at a battlefield command, but it frees Easy Company to receive more competent leadership (eventually under Winters). Winters).
** The real life version of what happened is even more ridiculous. Sobel sets up Winters the same way (gives him a duty, then writes him up for court-martial by changing the duty orders without telling Winters), and Winters requests trial by court-martial. Sobel is surprised, but goes forward with it, until battalion officers work out a way to avoid the matter entirely with obscure rules because they don't need the distraction a couple of months before the invasion. Sobel then ''writes up Winters again'', for basically a different aspect of the same "infraction", and Winters ''demands'' court-martial. Sink transfers Winters out of the company to kitchen patrol (which Winters resented) and, after the sergeants mutiny and threaten to turn in their stripes, Sink transfers Sobel out of the company as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed badass calling up another confirmed badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]].

to:

** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed badass calling up another confirmed badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]].day]][[note]]In the actual event, Winters did start to charge down the field, but stopped himself when he realized that he had command responsibilities and couldn't risk getting pinned down with a single company (he had responsibility for the battalion). The rest of the scene otherwise plays out accurately[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "Crossroads", Winters leads a single platoon against two entire companies of German troops and manages to rout them with only one man dead and a few wounded. Winters even made the initial assault on his own as a diversionary tactic, with his men coming up several seconds behind. Winters doesn't even bat an eye at how many Germans he's facing. He just raises his rifle and starts shooting. [[OneManArmy The first thing the Germans do when they realize Winters is firing at them is to run for their lives.]]

to:

* In "Crossroads", Winters leads a single platoon against two entire companies of German troops and [[CurbStompBattle manages to rout them with only one man dead and a few wounded.wounded]]. Winters even made the initial assault on his own as a diversionary tactic, with his men coming up several seconds behind. Winters doesn't even bat an eye at how many Germans he's facing. He just raises his rifle and starts shooting. [[OneManArmy The first thing the Germans do when they realize Winters is firing at them is to run for their lives.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is definitely evoked several times in the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** To which she responds by starting to help, while trying to retain as much dignity as possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]

to:

-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]]]
* In "Currahee", when the sergeants are discussing whether they should go through with their mutiny to get Winters back and free Easy company of Sobel.
-->'''Lipton:''' We all better be clear of the consequences.\\
'''Martin:''' I don't care about the consequences.\\
'''Lipton:''' John, [[SeriousBusiness we could be lined up against a wall and shot]]. Now, I'm ready to face that. And every one of us had better be too.\\
(beat)\\
'''Guarnere:''' I will ''not'' follow that man into combat. \\
'''Bull:''' Me neither.\\
'''Lipton:''' All right, then let's do it. (They all begin writing their resignation letters)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Winters defying Colonel Sink's orders in "The Last Patrol" and not sending out the patrol a second night after they lost a man on the first patrol. He gives them the exact (fake) report they are to give him the next morning explaining how they conducted the patrol and did not secure any prisoners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A small but memorable one in the final episode, "Points": while witnessing the official surrender of a group of German soldiers, Winters, now a major, encounters Sobel, still a captain. When Sobel curtly acknowledges Winters as he walks by, Winters coldly says, "Captain Sobel! We salute the rank, not the man." Deeply reluctant, Sobel salutes Winters. Winters keeps his cool, but Nixon and Liebgott, watching nearby, can barely suppress their smiles at this victory over their hated former CO.

to:

* A small but memorable one in the final episode, "Points": while witnessing the official surrender of a group of German soldiers, Winters, now a major, encounters Sobel, still a captain. When Sobel curtly acknowledges Winters as he walks by, Winters coldly says, "Captain Sobel! We salute the rank, not the man." Deeply reluctant, Sobel salutes Winters. Winters keeps his cool, but Nixon and Liebgott, watching nearby, can barely suppress their smiles at this victory over their hated former CO. Winters himself considers this one of the most satisfying moments of his life.



-->'''Winters:''' We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.

to:

-->'''Winters:''' [[BadassBoast We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass is no longer a trope.


** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed {{Badass}} calling up another confirmed {{Badass}} to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]].

to:

** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed {{Badass}} badass calling up another confirmed {{Badass}} badass to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It indirectly leads to Sink - who figures the court martial would go badly for the Army - reassigning Sobel to a non-combat role and sweeping the whole matter under the rug. Sobel is [[AlasPoorVillain genuinely broken by the loss]] of his chance at a battlefield command, but it frees Easy Company to receive more competent leadership (eventually under Winters).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During the first episode, Sobel's attempts to break Winters leads to a spiteful attempt to accuse Winters of insubordination over latrine duty. He tries to stick Winters between two harsh choices: accept the punishment (which goes on Winters' record) or request a court martial (which could make things worse for Winters if found guilty) thinking the lieutenant would take the lesser choice. Winters' own sense of justice compels him to request the court martial, which stuns Sobel (who suddenly realizes the court martial would look bad on ''himself''). The [[OhCrap look on]] Sobel's face alone is worth it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Horrified by how poorly the attack falls apart when Dike freezes up, Winters starts charging in to take direct control of the company. He ''has to be ordered back'' by Col. Sink who insists Winters has to fulfill his captain's duties outside of the firefight. While Sink tries to talk Winters down with "I know you're attached to Easy Company..." Winters ''ignores'' his superior officer and calls out "SPEIRS!" to give him command of Easy Company. It's one confirmed {{Badass}} calling up another confirmed {{Badass}} to [[BigDamnHeroes save the day]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Throughout "The Last Patrol", everyone writes off Lt. Jones as useless since he's fresh out of West Point and has no experience. He then proves himself to be a capable leader when Private Vest freaks out over Jackson's injury, draws his sidearm, and points it at the prisoners Easy just captured. Jones slams Vest against the wall, disarms him, and tells him they're not going to go back for more prisoners because he killed the ones they had.

to:

* Throughout "The Last Patrol", everyone writes off Lt. Jones as useless since he's fresh out of West Point and has no experience. He then proves himself to be a capable leader when Private Vest freaks out over Jackson's injury, draws his sidearm, and points it at the prisoners Easy just captured. Jones slams Vest against the wall, disarms him, and tells him they're not going to go back for more prisoners because he killed the ones they had.had.
* This exchange from the end of "Crossroads":
-->'''Lt. Rice:''' A panzer division's about to cut the road south. Looks like you'll be surrounded.
-->'''Winters:''' We're paratroopers, lieutenant. We're supposed to be surrounded.

Top