Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Animation / WaltzWithBashir

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film.

to:

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film.film, and the second R-rated animated film to receive recognition from the Academy of Arts and Sciences with an Oscar nomination in 2009 for Best Foreign Language Film (which it lost to ''Film/{{Departures}}'').



** {{Deconstructed}}/{{subverted}}. Pretty much all of the soldiers shown are just scared kids who would rather be back home. Frenkel does have his moments, though.

to:

** {{Deconstructed}}/{{subverted}}.{{Deconstructed|Trope}}/{{subverted|Trope}}. Pretty much all of the soldiers shown are just scared kids who would rather be back home. Frenkel does have his moments, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no critical reception in the description. See How To Create A Works Page under "Things not to include"


The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award (Changed to "Best International Feature Film" after 2020), and is the first animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.

to:

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award (Changed to "Best International Feature Film" after 2020), and is the first animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
quotes edit


The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award (Changed to Best International Feature Film after 2020), and is the first animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.

to:

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award (Changed to Best "Best International Feature Film Film" after 2020), and is the first animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Category name changed, and it's no longer the only animated film to be nominated in the category (Flee, 2021)


The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award, and is thus-far the only animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.

to:

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award, Award (Changed to Best International Feature Film after 2020), and is thus-far the only first animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in Adobe Flash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award, and is thus-far the only animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.

to:

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in Adobe Flash.UsefulNotes/AdobeFlash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award, and is thus-far the only animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FliesEqualsEvil: The sound of fies during the dead horses scene.

to:

* FliesEqualsEvil: The sound of fies flies during the dead horses scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShellShockedVeteran: The Israeli soldiers.

to:

* ShellShockedVeteran: The Pretty much all of the Israeli soldiers.soldiers, effects on the group range from being tormented by reocurring nightmares to completely forgetting chunks of the war due to severe TraumaInducedAmnesia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeirdnessCensor: Happens to Ari at the Beirut International Airport on his second tour. As he walks through the terminal everything seems lovely, like being on a trip abroad... until suddenly he realizes that the airport is abandoned and the planes sitting outside have all been bombed to pieces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 479

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 2006, more than 20 years after the war, Ari meets up for drinks with his old friend Boaz. Boaz reveals that he's been having recurring nightmares about the dogs he had killed during the war as a marksman. Ari realizes that he can't remember any of his own experiences during the war. That night Ari experiences his first flashback - [[OrWasItADream a bizarre scene]] of himself emerging out of the sea at night, naked, to see stars falling out of the sky over Beirut. This begins his journey to rediscover his own past by seeking out the men who were with him in the memory, and deciphering the meaning of the memory itself - a memory of the night of the Sabra and Shatila massacres near the very end of the war.

to:

In 2006, more than 20 years after the war, Ari meets up for drinks with his old friend Boaz. Boaz reveals that he's been having recurring nightmares about the dogs he had killed during the war as a marksman. Ari realizes that he can't remember any of his own experiences during the war. That night Ari experiences his first flashback {{Flashback}} - [[OrWasItADream a bizarre scene]] of himself emerging out of the sea at night, naked, to see stars falling out of the sky over Beirut. This begins his journey to rediscover his own past by seeking out the men who were with him in the memory, and deciphering the meaning of the memory itself - a memory of the night of the Sabra and Shatila massacres near the very end of the war.


Added DiffLines:

* SelfServingMemory: Used as the main component of the plot, when Ari has a bizarre flashback about emerging naked from the sea near Beirut - a distorted memory that his mind conjures in order to protect itself from the realization that [[spoiler:he may have indirectly participated a massacre]]. The rest of the movie is mostly a [[{{Discussed}} discussion]] [=/=] [[{{Deconstructed}} deconstruction]] of the trope to explain why this happens [[TruthInTelevision in real life]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MurderByInaction: [[spoiler: the true source of Folman's guilt. He and the other Israeli soldiers didn't participate in the Sabra and Shatila massacres - but they stood aside quietly and watched while Lebanese phalangists butchered the refugees, even knowingly continuing to launch flares into the sky despite knowing that the light was allowing the phalangists to find fleeing victims.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Folman:''' I don't know if it lasted an eternity or a minute, but I watched Frenkel in that intersection with a hail of bullets whistling past him from every direction; and instead of running to the other side of the junction, he suddenly started dancing. He was in a real trance. He was showing them that he had no intention to leave that intersection, that he wants to stay there forever. He wants to dance a waltz between their bullets, surrounded by giant posters of Bashir."

to:

-->'''Folman:''' I don't know if it lasted an eternity or a minute, but I watched Frenkel in that intersection with a hail of bullets whistling past him from every direction; and instead of running to the other side of the junction, he suddenly started dancing. He was in a real trance. He was showing them that he had no intention to leave of leaving that intersection, that he wants to stay there forever. He wants to dance a waltz between their bullets, surrounded by giant posters of Bashir."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The English subtitles are trash. Here's a direct translation.


-->'''Folman:''' Whether an eternity or just a minute, there was Frenkel at the junction with bullets flying past him in every direction. Without crossing the junction, I saw him dancing, as if in a trance. He cursed the shooters, like he wanted to stay there forever. As if he wanted to show off his waltz amid the gunfire, with the posters of Bashir above his head."

to:

-->'''Folman:''' Whether I don't know if it lasted an eternity or just a minute, there was but I watched Frenkel at the junction in that intersection with a hail of bullets flying whistling past him in from every direction. Without crossing direction; and instead of running to the other side of the junction, I saw him dancing, as if he suddenly started dancing. He was in a real trance. He cursed the shooters, like was showing them that he wanted had no intention to leave that intersection, that he wants to stay there forever. As if he wanted He wants to show off his dance a waltz amid the gunfire, with the between their bullets, surrounded by giant posters of Bashir above his head.Bashir."

Added: 130

Removed: 210

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreestateAmsterdam: The NationalStereotypes about Israelis going to (or ''moving'' to) the Netherlands just to get legally high.



* NationalStereotypes: In the Netherlands you smoke joints at any occasion.
** This is probably more of a national stereotype about Israelis going to (or ''moving'' to) the Netherlands just to get legally high.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is probably more of a national stereotype about Israelis going to (or ''moving'' to) the Netherlands just to get legally high.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He doesn't masturbate at all. In fact he's almost indifferent to the movie, which is kinda the point.


* ADateWithRosiePalms: An officer gives Folman instructions while watching a German porn movie and engaging in this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpiphanyTherapy: {{Averted}}, as the entire film is about unlocking a repressed memory through conversations and self-exploration, ultimately leading Ari to remember that [[spoiler: he was present in Beirut during the Sabra and Shatila massacres, and perhaps indirectly assisted them]]. No actual psychological therapy is shown to have occurred, however.

to:

* EpiphanyTherapy: {{Averted}}, as the entire film is about unlocking a repressed memory through conversations and self-exploration, ultimately leading Ari to remember that [[spoiler: he was present in Beirut during the Sabra and Shatila massacres, and perhaps indirectly assisted them]]. No actual psychological therapy is shown to have occurred, however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EpiphanyTherapy: {{Averted}}, as the entire film is about unlocking a repressed memory through conversations and self-exploration, ultimately leading Ari to remember that [[spoiler: he was present in Beirut during the Sabra and Shatila massacres, and perhaps indirectly assisted them]]. No actual psychological therapy is shown to have occurred, however.

Added: 1084

Changed: 395

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanded


''Waltz with Bashir'' (Hebrew: '''ואלס עם באשיר‎''' - ''Vals Im Bashir'') is a 2008 Israeli animated documentary film written and directed by Ari Folman. It depicts [[UsefulNotes/IsraelisWithInfraredMissiles Folman]] in search of his lost memories from the 1982 Lebanon War.

to:

''Waltz with Bashir'' (Hebrew: '''ואלס עם באשיר‎''' - ''Vals Im Bashir'') is a 2008 Israeli animated documentary film written and directed by Ari Folman. It depicts [[UsefulNotes/IsraelisWithInfraredMissiles Folman]] in search of his lost memories from The movie deals with the 1982 strange nature of human memory, through interviews with several Israeli soldiers who took part in the First Lebanon War.
War of 1982; visceral visual re-enactments of their memories; and conversations with psychologists about [[RepressedMemories repressed memories]], [[FakeMemories invented memories]], and [[ShellShockedVeteran post-traumatic stress disorder]].

In 2006, more than 20 years after the war, Ari meets up for drinks with his old friend Boaz. Boaz reveals that he's been having recurring nightmares about the dogs he had killed during the war as a marksman. Ari realizes that he can't remember any of his own experiences during the war. That night Ari experiences his first flashback - [[OrWasItADream a bizarre scene]] of himself emerging out of the sea at night, naked, to see stars falling out of the sky over Beirut. This begins his journey to rediscover his own past by seeking out the men who were with him in the memory, and deciphering the meaning of the memory itself - a memory of the night of the Sabra and Shatila massacres near the very end of the war.

The entire movie, including the in-person interviews, is fully animated - much of it in Adobe Flash. It was the first feature-length animated Israeli film. It was nominated for the "Best Foreign Film" Academy Award, and is thus-far the only animated film to ever be nominated in that category. It was listed by multiple film critics among the top 10 best films of 2008.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SecondaryCharacterTitle: President Bashir is referred to but doesn't actually appear in the movie except on posters.

to:

* SecondaryCharacterTitle: President Bashir is referred to but doesn't actually appear in the movie except on posters. [[spoiler: In fact, he was already dead by the time of the titular waltz]].

Added: 66

Removed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BugBuzz: During the dead horses scene.


Added DiffLines:

* FliesEqualsEvil: The sound of fies during the dead horses scene.

Added: 342

Changed: 40

Removed: 114

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ATeamFiring: The IDF soldiers that invade Lebanon fire at everything. Not everything that moves. ''Everything''.



* BloodFromTheMouth: Ronny Dayag's commander after he gets lethally wounded and dragged down into the tank.



* ChildSoldiers: Frenkel tells the director how he and his troop were attacked by a child with an RPG in an orchard and had to shoot him.

to:

* ChildSoldiers: Frenkel tells the director how he and his troop were attacked by a child boy with an RPG in an orchard and had to shoot him.



* MediumBlending: The final scene is real footage of the aftermath.

to:

* MediumBlending: RealPersonEpilogue: The final scene is real footage of the aftermath.aftermath.
* MoreDakka: The IDF soldiers that invade Lebanon fire at everything. Not everything that moves. ''Everything''.



* TrivialTitle: The waltzing scene is just a minor event in the recollection of the war but becomes the title of the movie.



* TheWorfEffect: On the IDF, constantly.

to:

* %%* TheWorfEffect: On the IDF, constantly.
constantly. - ZCE
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no critical reception on work pages


''Waltz with Bashir'' (Hebrew: '''ואלס עם באשיר‎''' - ''Vals Im Bashir'') is a 2008 Israeli animated documentary film written and directed by Ari Folman. It depicts [[UsefulNotes/IsraelisWithInfraredMissiles Folman]] in search of his lost memories from the 1982 Lebanon War and won numerous awards, including being nominated for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film.

to:

''Waltz with Bashir'' (Hebrew: '''ואלס עם באשיר‎''' - ''Vals Im Bashir'') is a 2008 Israeli animated documentary film written and directed by Ari Folman. It depicts [[UsefulNotes/IsraelisWithInfraredMissiles Folman]] in search of his lost memories from the 1982 Lebanon War and won numerous awards, including being nominated for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film.
War.

Added: 938

Changed: 136

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There.


* BlackComedy: Folman and Boaz remarking that car bombs are "a blast."
%%** Occasionally. The red car montage sticks out as one example.

to:

* BlackComedy: BlackComedy:
**
Folman and Boaz remarking that car bombs are "a blast."
%%** Occasionally. ** The red Mercedes montage. It starts with a group of soldiers trying to hitch a ride on a Huey helicopter by holding on to the skids, but one guy slips and gets left behind. As he's shouting for the helicopter to come back around, a red Mercedes drives past and a man with an AK-47 standing in the sunroof shoots him in the head. The Mercedes then does another, much gorier drive-by shooting on a street in broad daylight, killing another five soldiers. In the next shot, an IDF sniper attempts to shoot the driver of the Mercedes, but the car montage sticks just happens to pass by some random farmer on a donkey who gets shot instead. Next, an IDF artillery battery has a go at the Mercedes, but they keep missing the car and blowing up a whole row of houses behind it. Finally an F-4 jet targets the Mercedes from above and drops a big bomb right on top of it, taking out as one example.an entire street... and the Mercedes emerges from the cloud and drives away.

Added: 866

Changed: 998

Removed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtShift: The film abruptly changes to live-action news footage at the end of the film when [[spoiler: Folman comes face to face with his memories of the Sabra and Shatila Massacre. This is a CallBack to earlier in the film when Folman is interviewing the psychologist: Like the soldier that viewed the war as if "through a camera", the film's animated style can be interpreted as representing Folman's dissociation from the events of the war. When he is confronted with the grieving relatives of the massacre's victims, Folman can no longer diminish the reality of the atrocity he is witnessing.]]

to:

* ArtShift: ArtShift:
**
The film abruptly changes to live-action news footage at the end of the film when [[spoiler: Folman comes face to face with his memories of the Sabra and Shatila Massacre. This is a CallBack to earlier in the film when Folman is interviewing the psychologist: Like the soldier that viewed the war as if "through a camera", the film's animated style can be interpreted as representing Folman's dissociation from the events of the war. When he is confronted with the grieving relatives of the massacre's victims, Folman can no longer diminish the reality of the atrocity he is witnessing.]]



* BadassIsraeli: {{Deconstructed}}/{{subverted}}. Pretty much all of the soldiers shown are just scared kids who would rather be back home. Frenkel does have his moments, though.

to:

* BadassIsraeli: BadassIsraeli:
**
{{Deconstructed}}/{{subverted}}. Pretty much all of the soldiers shown are just scared kids who would rather be back home. Frenkel does have his moments, though.



* BlackComedy: Occasionally. The red car montage sticks out as one example.
** Also, Folman and Boaz remarking that car bombs are "a blast."
* BottomlessMagazines: Frenkel, the MAG shooter, doesn't seem to run out of ammunition wile dancing in the street and firing around.

to:

* BlackComedy: Folman and Boaz remarking that car bombs are "a blast."
%%**
Occasionally. The red car montage sticks out as one example.
** Also, Folman and Boaz remarking that car bombs are "a blast."
* BottomlessMagazines: Frenkel, the MAG shooter, doesn't seem to run out of ammunition wile while dancing in the street and firing around.



* CantBatheWithoutAWeapon: When an IDF soldier is shown in a bath, his rifle is resting on the edge of the tub.



* SoundtrackDissonance: In a few scenes, the film uses classical music and rocking 80's singles over scenes of war.
** Some of those songs seem to be written specifically about the Lebanon War, however.

to:

* SoundtrackDissonance: In a few scenes, the film uses classical music and rocking 80's singles over scenes of war.
**
war. Some of those songs seem to be written specifically about the Lebanon War, however.

Added: 172

Removed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadDreams: The film starts with Boaz, Ari Folman's long time friend, recounting a recurring dream in which he is menaced by the dogs he shot during the war.


Added DiffLines:

* PastExperienceNightmare: The film starts with Boaz, Ari Folman's long time friend, recounting a recurring dream in which he is menaced by the dogs he shot during the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:The graphic novel adaptation switches to photographs of the massacre, with only one photo of a wailing survivor.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[IntrepitReporter Journalist]] Ron Ben-Yishai is portrayed this way, as he [[UnflinchingWalk walks calmly and upright]] through an intense firefight between the IDF and Palestinian snipers, while his cameraman crawls along next to him on his hands and knees. Ben-Yishai covered several wars in person throughout his career, including traveling to Damascus, Syria - an enemy country!

to:

** [[IntrepitReporter [[IntrepidReporter Journalist]] Ron Ben-Yishai is portrayed this way, as he [[UnflinchingWalk walks calmly and upright]] through an intense firefight between the IDF and Palestinian snipers, while his cameraman crawls along next to him on his hands and knees. Ben-Yishai covered several wars in person throughout his career, including traveling to Damascus, Syria - an enemy country!

Added: 427

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Journalist Ron Ben-Yishai is portrayed this way, as he walks calmly and upright through an intense firefight between the IDF and Palestinian snipers, while his cameraman crawls along next to him on his hands and knees. Ben-Yishai covered several wars in person throughout his career, including traveling to Damascus, Syria - an enemy country!

to:

** Journalist [[IntrepitReporter Journalist]] Ron Ben-Yishai is portrayed this way, as he [[UnflinchingWalk walks calmly and upright upright]] through an intense firefight between the IDF and Palestinian snipers, while his cameraman crawls along next to him on his hands and knees. Ben-Yishai covered several wars in person throughout his career, including traveling to Damascus, Syria - an enemy country!country!
** Frenkel is also portrayed this way in the titular scene, where he dances with a [=MAG=] in the middle of a firefight (the same firefight Ben-Yishai walked through). Furthermore, we are first introduced to Frenkel doing martial arts practice in a black-belted robe. Soon after, he imparts a pro tip for combat infantry leaders: Use a pungent cologne so that your soldiers can keep track of your location in the dead of night.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Journalist Ron Ben-Yishai is portrayed this way, as he walks calmly and upright through an intense firefight between the IDF and Palestinian snipers, while his cameraman crawls along next to him on his hands and knees. Ben-Yishai covered several wars in person throughout his career, including traveling to Damascus, Syria - an enemy country!

Top