Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AnalogyBackfire / ComicBooks

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Red Skull:''' You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?â—‹â—‹

to:

'''Red Skull:''' You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?â—‹â—‹feet?\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "ComicBook/{{Commando}}": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich has capitulated. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident by this point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." Private points out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.

to:

* "ComicBook/{{Commando}}": ''ComicBook/{{Commando}}'': In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich has capitulated. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident by this point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." Private points out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.



-->'''Lukin:''' This isn't what we agreed on, Skull. Our pact was highly specific in the details.
'''Red Skull:''' So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
'''Lukin:''' Yes, with the death of [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler your master]] and the rise of the Motherland.
'''Red Skull:''' You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?

to:

-->'''Lukin:''' This isn't what we agreed on, Skull. Our pact was highly specific in the details.
details.\\
'''Red Skull:''' So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
ended.\\
'''Lukin:''' Yes, with the death of [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler your master]] and the rise of the Motherland.
Motherland.\\
'''Red Skull:''' You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?feet?â—‹â—‹
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Whitey:''' So weird. And Pugs was just saying animals can't change--\\

to:

-->'''Whitey:''' --->'''Whitey:''' So weird. And Pugs was just saying animals can't change--\\



* "ComicBook/Commando": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich has capitulated. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident by this point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." Private points out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.

to:

* "ComicBook/Commando": "ComicBook/{{Commando}}": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich has capitulated. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident by this point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." Private points out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.



-->'''Lukin''': This isn't what we agreed on, Skull. Our pact was highly specific in the details.
-->'''Red Skull''': So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
-->'''Lukin''': Yes, with the death of [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler your master]] and the rise of the Motherland.
-->'''Red Skull''': You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?
-->'''Lukin''': And how is your Glorious Thousand-Year Reich faring, then?

to:

-->'''Lukin''': -->'''Lukin:''' This isn't what we agreed on, Skull. Our pact was highly specific in the details.
-->'''Red Skull''': '''Red Skull:''' So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
-->'''Lukin''': '''Lukin:''' Yes, with the death of [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler your master]] and the rise of the Motherland.
-->'''Red Skull''': '''Red Skull:''' You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?
-->'''Lukin''': '''Lukin:''' And how is your Glorious Thousand-Year Reich faring, then?



* ''ComicBook/UltimateMarvel''

to:

* ''ComicBook/UltimateMarvel''''ComicBook/UltimateMarvel'':



--> It wasn't until the 1970's that someone looked up from the drawing table and said, "You know, maybe if we're trying to sell the idea of the X-Men being hated and feared for being different, we shouldn't have a team [[MonochromeCasting made up entirely of young, handsome, middle class white people]]."

to:

--> It --->It wasn't until the 1970's that someone looked up from the drawing table and said, "You know, maybe if we're trying to sell the idea of the X-Men being hated and feared for being different, we shouldn't have a team [[MonochromeCasting made up entirely of young, handsome, middle class white people]]."



Added: 310

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updating links


* ''Comicbook/{{Lucifer}}'' has a scene wherein the titular character has a philosophical debate about determinism with Destiny of the Endless. In this, Lucifer compares God's creation to a prison; Destiny, in turn, compares Lucifer's own creation to an asylum, and says that a prison would be preferable. Lucifer responds violently to this.

to:

* ''Comicbook/{{Lucifer}}'' ''ComicBook/{{Lucifer}}'' has a scene wherein the titular character has a philosophical debate about determinism with Destiny of the Endless. In this, Lucifer compares God's creation to a prison; Destiny, in turn, compares Lucifer's own creation to an asylum, and says that a prison would be preferable. Lucifer responds violently to this.



* In one ''Comicbook/Superboy1994'' storyline, S-Boy's friends are worried about how much he's hanging out with Knockout, a former Female Fury who has been implicated in a murder. When Tanya remonstrates with him, she calls him "kid", and he angrily responds that Knockout is the only person who doesn't call him that, or think of him as being one. He then flies off before Tanya can point out that Knockout's name for him is "pup", which doesn't exactly imply she thinks of him as an adult.

to:

* In one ''Comicbook/Superboy1994'' ''ComicBook/Superboy1994'' storyline, S-Boy's friends are worried about how much he's hanging out with Knockout, a former Female Fury who has been implicated in a murder. When Tanya remonstrates with him, she calls him "kid", and he angrily responds that Knockout is the only person who doesn't call him that, or think of him as being one. He then flies off before Tanya can point out that Knockout's name for him is "pup", which doesn't exactly imply she thinks of him as an adult.



* The ComicBook/XMen, who were famously built around the FantasticRacism trope, were created in the '60s but never took off until Creator/ChrisClaremont [[MyRealDaddy heavily revamped the franchise in the '70s]]. Writer Jesse Schedeen pointed out one of the big reasons why the premise didn't work up until that point:

to:

* ''ComicBook/XMen'':
**
The ComicBook/XMen, X-Men, who were famously built around the FantasticRacism trope, were created in the '60s but never took off until Creator/ChrisClaremont [[MyRealDaddy heavily revamped the franchise in the '70s]]. Writer Jesse Schedeen pointed out one of the big reasons why the premise didn't work up until that point:



* In an early '80s ''ComicBook/XMen'' story, [[ComicBook/{{Magik}} Illyana Rasputin]] is pressing her best friend ComicBook/KittyPryde for details regarding Kitty's teenage romance with Illyana's brother [[ComicBook/{{Colossus}} Piotr]], commenting, "Juliet was younger than you when she met Romeo." Kitty countered, "And look what happened to her!"
* In the mini-series ''X-Men: True Friends'', Kitty and ComicBook/RachelSummers find themselves transported to 1930s Great Britain, at the start of the Blitz. At one point, a handsome German officer chats up a skeptical Kitty, saying in regard to the Nazi party that she shouldn't "judge a book by its cover." Kitty answers, "I read the book. ''Literature/MeinKampf''. Still gives me nightmares."

to:

* ** In an early '80s ''ComicBook/XMen'' story, [[ComicBook/{{Magik}} Illyana Rasputin]] is pressing her best friend ComicBook/KittyPryde for details regarding Kitty's teenage romance with Illyana's brother [[ComicBook/{{Colossus}} Piotr]], commenting, "Juliet was younger than you when she met Romeo." Kitty countered, "And look what happened to her!"
* ** In the mini-series ''X-Men: True Friends'', Kitty and ComicBook/RachelSummers find themselves transported to 1930s Great Britain, at the start of the Blitz. At one point, a handsome German officer chats up a skeptical Kitty, saying in regard to the Nazi party that she shouldn't "judge a book by its cover." Kitty answers, "I read the book. ''Literature/MeinKampf''. Still gives me nightmares."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
improved phrasing on Commando example


* "ComicBook/Commando": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich capitulates. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident at his point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." He responds by pointing out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.

to:

* "ComicBook/Commando": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich capitulates.has capitulated. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident at his by this point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." He responds by pointing Private points out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don't include the original dialogue because I only have Finnish translated version.

Added DiffLines:

*"ComicBook/Commando": In one issue, British platoon is sent to hunt German "Werwulfs" after Third Reich capitulates. [[note]]The comic plays into common misconception: while [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Werwolf Werwulfs]] were a real unit, they were intended to fight in parallel with Wehrmacht behind Allied lines, not as guerrillas after the war.[[/note]] After few days of combing a forest, the men get nervous (they've had multiple false alarms and a friendly fire incident at his point.) Sergeant tries to remind main character, a superstitious private who is starting to believe in literal wolf-men, of "Boy who cried wolf." He responds by pointing out that in the end of the story, a real wolf appears.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


::Shortly after that, they run into Digger, whose face fur has turned from black to white with shock.

to:

::Shortly ** Shortly after that, they run into Digger, whose face fur has turned from black to white with shock.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In an early '80s ''ComicBook/XMen'' story, ComicBook/IllyanaRasputin is pressing her best friend ComicBook/KittyPryde for details regarding Kitty's teenage romance with Illyana's brother [[ComicBook/{{Colossus}} Piotr]], commenting, "Juliet was younger than you when she met Romeo." Kitty countered, "And look what happened to her!"

to:

* In an early '80s ''ComicBook/XMen'' story, ComicBook/IllyanaRasputin [[ComicBook/{{Magik}} Illyana Rasputin]] is pressing her best friend ComicBook/KittyPryde for details regarding Kitty's teenage romance with Illyana's brother [[ComicBook/{{Colossus}} Piotr]], commenting, "Juliet was younger than you when she met Romeo." Kitty countered, "And look what happened to her!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In one ''Comicbook/Superboy1994'' storyline, S-Boy's friends are worried about how much he's hanging out with Knockout, a former Female Fury who has been implicated in a murder. When Tanya remonstrates with him, she calls him "kid", and he angrily responds that Knockout is the only person who doesn't call him that, or think of him as being one. He then flies off before Tanya can point out that Knockout's name for him is "pup", which doesn't exactly imply she thinks of him as an adult.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
typo


-->'''Red Skulll''': So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.

to:

-->'''Red Skulll''': Skull''': So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/BeastsOfBurden'': In "Grave Happenings", Pugsley talking about how he doesn't trust Dymphna.
-->'''Pugsley:''' Now she's supposed to be all okay an' crap. Well, ''I'' ain't buying it. Animals don't change their markings.\\
'''Whitey:''' Some lizards can ch--\\
'''Pugsley:''' Oh, ''shut up'', Whitey! You know what I mean.
::Shortly after that, they run into Digger, whose face fur has turned from black to white with shock.
-->'''Whitey:''' So weird. And Pugs was just saying animals can't change--\\
'''Pugsley:''' Would you ''shut up?'' I was talkin' 'bout that no-good ''witch cat!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AnalogyBackfire Analogies backfiring]] in comic books.
----

* ''ComicBook/TheAvengers'': In the opening issue of ''ComicBook/UltronForever'', ComicBook/BlackWidow and ComicBook/TheVision are talking about the latter's synthezoid nature, and he remarks he's no more programmed than Black Widow, to which she points out she spent her youth as a brainwashed assassin.
* Creator/PeterDavid's comment on [[ComicBook/{{Shazam}} Captain Marvel]]'s Wisdom of Solomon: "God directly commands you to build no temples to other gods. Do you build temples to other gods? If you said "yes", congratulations! You have successfully displayed the Wisdom of [[TooDumbToLive Solomon!]]"
* ''ComicBook/TheDeathOfCaptainAmerica'': After ComicBook/RedSkull ends up trapped in [[RenegadeRussian Aleksander Lukin]]'s mind, the two trade blows verbally and [[BattleInTheCenterOfTheMind mentally]].
-->'''Lukin''': This isn't what we agreed on, Skull. Our pact was highly specific in the details.
-->'''Red Skulll''': So was the pact between Stalin and Hitler, and we know how ''that'' ended.
-->'''Lukin''': Yes, with the death of [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler your master]] and the rise of the Motherland.
-->'''Red Skull''': You call that rising, do you? Slowly losing a war for five decades while your entire country crumbles at your feet?
-->'''Lukin''': And how is your Glorious Thousand-Year Reich faring, then?
* In the ''ComicStrip/KnightsOfTheDinnerTable'' strip ''Java Joint'', Tank says that he is "as serious as Garrison Keillor", apparently not realising that Garrison Keillor is a humorist.
* ''Comicbook/{{Lucifer}}'' has a scene wherein the titular character has a philosophical debate about determinism with Destiny of the Endless. In this, Lucifer compares God's creation to a prison; Destiny, in turn, compares Lucifer's own creation to an asylum, and says that a prison would be preferable. Lucifer responds violently to this.
* Inverted in Creator/PhilFoglio's adaptation of ''ComicBook/MythAdventures''. Aahz tells Skeeve, "We'll be '''famous''' for this! Like Napoleon at Waterloo - Custer at the Little Big Horn - the Light Brigade at Balaclava..." The inversion is that Aahz presumably ''knows'' that those battles didn't end well for the named person, and thus is fully aware of what he's saying, but Skeeve doesn't know, and is genuinely encouraged by the analogy.
* In the ''Magazine/{{MAD}}'' parody of ''Film/HeavenCanWait1978'', Tony Abbott (no, not [[UsefulNotes/AustralianPolitics that one]]) claims that he would never hurt Farnsworth because he loved him like a brother. Like Cain loved Abel.
* ''ComicBook/SpiderMan'':
** One issue had Hammerhead comment on how he'd "Go out in a blaze of glory. Just like the real Scarface." It was later pointed out that Al "Scarface" Capone died in prison of complications due to syphilis.
** In another issue, Peter, who's been through hell lately, angrily tells Mary Jane that he feels like "that guy from ''Film/{{Network}}''". [[spoiler:After he hangs up, MJ quietly observes to herself that the character he's talking about died in the end.]]
* In ''Flight 714'', Rastapopoulos swears to Franchise/{{Tintin}} that he will crush him "like I crush an insignificant spider!" Unfortunately, the spider in question proves quite adept at dodging Rastapopoulos's foot blows.
* ''ComicBook/UltimateMarvel''
** ''ComicBook/UltimateGalactusTrilogy'': When Reed says [[IWorkAlone he works alone]], Fury mentioned that it was a team work, and compared it with playing ball at school. Reed pointed that no, he didn't play much ball at school, he was a nerd reading books inside... and that's how he got to be a genius, with the guy who played lots of ball at school now asking for his help.
** ''ComicBook/UltimateVision'': Tarleton mentioned that those in the satellite live like monks. He then had to clarify that they are not motivated by religion, that he only made the monk comparison because of the reclusion.
* ''ComicBook/{{Watchmen}}'': Rorschach named himself after the Rorschach inkblot test. He chooses the name because of what it represents, that there is no meaning beyond what we ourselves impose, just as the patterns of an inkblot are open to interpretation. Somewhat of a backfire in that he's named after a psychological test, and decidedly psychologically [[AxCrazy unsound]] later on his career after he crosses the DespairEventHorizon.
* In a ''ComicBook/WhatIf'' issue in which the Avengers disband rather than be seen as supporting an increasingly corrupt US government, ComicBook/CaptainAmerica tries to appeal to [[ComicBook/TheIncredibleHercules Hercules]]' honor to convince him to stay with the team. Hercules glances at Cap and sadly quips, "When in Rome, eh? Rome fell, you know."
* The ComicBook/XMen, who were famously built around the FantasticRacism trope, were created in the '60s but never took off until Creator/ChrisClaremont [[MyRealDaddy heavily revamped the franchise in the '70s]]. Writer Jesse Schedeen pointed out one of the big reasons why the premise didn't work up until that point:
--> It wasn't until the 1970's that someone looked up from the drawing table and said, "You know, maybe if we're trying to sell the idea of the X-Men being hated and feared for being different, we shouldn't have a team [[MonochromeCasting made up entirely of young, handsome, middle class white people]]."
* In an early '80s ''ComicBook/XMen'' story, ComicBook/IllyanaRasputin is pressing her best friend ComicBook/KittyPryde for details regarding Kitty's teenage romance with Illyana's brother [[ComicBook/{{Colossus}} Piotr]], commenting, "Juliet was younger than you when she met Romeo." Kitty countered, "And look what happened to her!"
* In the mini-series ''X-Men: True Friends'', Kitty and ComicBook/RachelSummers find themselves transported to 1930s Great Britain, at the start of the Blitz. At one point, a handsome German officer chats up a skeptical Kitty, saying in regard to the Nazi party that she shouldn't "judge a book by its cover." Kitty answers, "I read the book. ''Literature/MeinKampf''. Still gives me nightmares."

----

Top