Here's the thing with Suburban Knights: if you are an avid Channel Awesome follower (The entirety of the site and not just one or two reviewers) you will throughly enjoy it and look past the (Many, many) flaws.
However, if you watch maybe one reviewer or see one or two videos here and there, I will bet that you will hate it.
True, the more popular reviewers are emphasized a bit more, but just liking Critic or Spoony won't get you far. I'd say I watch about half of the cast a lot (Sadly, most of Inked Reality were missing), and a bit of the rest, and I found it fun.
I think the most likable thing was to see everyone dressed up. And if you don't watch everyone that will get old fast.
I enjoyed it. I really did, but once you get past the fangirl squee (THE SIGHT OF SUEADE MADE ME NEARLY FAINT.) there are a lot of problems.
1) The acting was very bad. I expect it, seeing as the cast was not made of actors, but notwithstanding nearly everyone
had this very emphasized, awkward and forced way of delivering. It felt like a cold read, to put it bluntly. Best acting was probably done by Critic and Cinema Snob, which is totally expected.
2) The jokes were lame. That's probably the best way to explain it. Lame and boring. The delivery didn't help the cause at all, either. All the good ones were beaten to death (Joe's and Lindsey's probably win that award) and the rest were lackluster. This was a disappointment, y'know since everyone has fantastic humor. I suspect it has to do with clashing styles and the need to follow a plot.
3) Plot? It was there, I'll give it that. Didn't go anywhere, but it existed.
If you love yourself some channel awesome and you have 2 hours to spare, watch it. If you don't, you won't miss anything.
(BUT IF YOU ARE A SUADE FANGIRL YOU WILL LOVE IT FOREVER)