A good game that could have been great with some more polish.
Given that Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
is one of my favorite games ever
, this one really had a lot to live up to.
Did it make it? Not quite. It's not a bad
game, by any means, but it lacksthe touches that made the previous entries in the series so great. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to pull a "It sucks because it's not Thousand Year Door
" review. TYD just had two main elements that Super Paper Mario
didn't quite manage effectively: gameplay focus and unique aesthetics.
Gameplay-wise, TYD had a focus; it decided to be an RPG first and foremost. SPM, on the other hand, never makes up its mind on whether it wants to be an RPG, a platformer, or a puzzle game. It has elements of all three genres, but they aren't really developed. TYD gave you a small-ish set of abilities to use, and then spent the rest of the game trying to make you use them in ways that you wouldn't have thought of. SPM doesn't have that variety. The hammer pixl: smashing blocks and nothing else. Nearly every pixl has that issue: Cardboard Obstacle
. Rather than get inventive with the powers, it's "crack in the wall: use bomb". It's also an issue with the "party" set up. Each character has a unique ability, but all this does is force you to waste time switching. In practical terms, you'll play as Mario (who has the most useful power) and only switch to the others for obstacles.
In terms of aesthetics, it also falls a bit short. While TYD had interesting and unique settings, SPM just sort of has "generic desert", "generic clouds", and "generic hallways." Even the hub level has far less character to it than Rogueport did. There are
interesting artistic concepts scattered around, but they get overused so much it gets kinda old. The Very Definitely Final Dungeon
is a good example: it has a neat glowy monochrome style... that looks almost exactly the same in each of the four levels. The worlds generally aren't memorable.
Now, the game is not
bad. The writing is hilarious as always, the story is interesting, and the main power (flipping) is very unique and interesting (though underused). If they had focused
on making a "flipping puzzle platformer" rather than bloating the game with pixls and exploration, this would've been an instant classic. As is, it's merely good.