Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / HumanSacrifice

Go To

[004] Str8taim Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Should we consider a NoRealLifeExamplesPlease rule fornthis one?
to:
Should we consider a NoRealLifeExamplesPlease rule for this one?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
No, it doesn\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \'\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\'\'. The explanation was right there if you would actually look for it. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she would be doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). One translation reads, \
to:
No, it doesn\\\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \\\'\\\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\\\'\\\'. The explanation was there all along. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she would be doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\\\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). One translation reads, \\\"From year to year, the young women of Israel would go to \\\'\\\'give commendation to\\\'\\\' the daughter of Jephthah the Gileadite four days in the year.\\\" (Italics mine.) They can\\\'t do that if she\\\'s dead. You can\\\'t just check translations, you have to dig deeper.

If you are really that skeptical, I can just include both interpretations.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
No, it doesn\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \'\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\'\'. The explanation was right there if you would actually look for it. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she was doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). One translation reads, \
to:
No, it doesn\\\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \\\'\\\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\\\'\\\'. The explanation was right there if you would actually look for it. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she would be doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\\\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). One translation reads, \\\"From year to year, the young women of Israel would go to \\\'\\\'give commendation to\\\'\\\' the daughter of Jephthah the Gileadite four days in the year.\\\" (Italics mine.) They can\\\'t do that if she\\\'s dead. You can\\\'t just check translations, you have to dig deeper.

If you are really that skeptical, I can just include both interpretations.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
No, it doesn\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \'\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\'\'. The explanation was right there if you would actually look for it. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she was doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). You can\'t just check translations, you have to dig deeper.
to:
No, it doesn\\\'t. The reprieve is for her to mourn for two months until she is \\\'\\\'devoted to the temple sanctuary\\\'\\\'. The explanation was right there if you would actually look for it. She would not be mourning her virginity after that because she was doing her job as a Nazirite. Additionally, everywhere else in TheBible God condemns human sacrifice, so it doesn\\\'t make sense for it to be allowed here. Additionally, Judges 11:40 can imply that she lived out her life as a virgin depending on the translation ([[http://biblehub.com/commentaries/judges/11-40.htm see commentary here]]). One translation reads, \\\"From year to year, the young women of Israel would go to \\\'\\\'give commendation to\\\'\\\' the daughter of Jephthah the Gileadite four days in the year.\\\" (Italics mine.) You can\\\'t just check translations, you have to dig deeper.
Top