Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Characters / DragonAgeInquisitionNonPlayableCharacters

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she actually \\\"hand them over\\\" or did they just get beguiled away by Corypheus without her knowing and then die in the Breach and ensure she\\\'d never know? Honestly, her knowledge of the freedom/involvement of Corypheus isn\\\'t \\\"story logic\\\", it\\\'s crucial to your point.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she actually \\\"hand them over\\\" or did they just get beguiled away by Corypheus without her knowing and then die in the Breach and ensure she\\\'d never know? Honestly, her knowledge of the freedom/involvement of Corypheus is crucial to your point.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she actually \\\"hand them over\\\" or did they just get beguiled away by Corypheus without her knowing and then die in the Breach and ensure she\\\'d never know?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she actually \\\"hand them over\\\" or did they just get beguiled away by Corypheus without her knowing and then die in the Breach to be sure she\\\'d never know?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she actually \\\"hand them over\\\" or did they just get beguiled away by Corypheus?
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \
to:
Clarel is a Warden, not a Circle mage. They get their hands dirty. Fiona wanted to protect her people; Clarel\\\'s goal is to defeat the Blight no matter what. Of course it sounds horrible and stupid when you compare those two, because they\\\'re completely different people with completely different goals. \\\"In war, victory. ... In death, sacrifice.\\\" The whole point of the quest is to prove how a group prepared to do \\\'\\\'anything\\\'\\\' to win might be manipulated to...do anything.

I concede she may indeed have been Genre Blind, but it wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'pure stupidity\\\'\\\', which is how the entry makes it sound. It may have been short-sighted, but she was thinking in the short-term because she thought that was all she had. She didn\\\'t look at a bunch of slack-jawed Warden mages and a pile of Warden corpses and say \\\"Yep, this was definitely a good idea. More blood!\\\" She \\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\' suspicious and doubtful. She \\\'\\\'did\\\'\\\' question Erimond\\\'s motives. It just wasn\\\'t \\\'\\\'enough\\\'\\\'. She\\\'s better compared to Alexius - using insanely dangerous magic out of desperation with a very dubious ally because the alternative is allowing what she values most to be destroyed, except in her case, it was the whole world and her whole order was hearing \\\"YOU\\\'RE ALL GOING TO DIE ANYWAY\\\" in their heads. Loghain/Alistair/Stroud are single Wardens, and only one of them is of any rank. We\\\'re inclined to trust them because they\\\'re familiar characters. She is not. (Plus, Alistair is templar-trained to be suspicious of any magic and Loghain is disgraced and shunned.)

\\\'\\\'\\\"...handing over several mages to be mind-controlled into helping Corypheus kill the Divine...\\\"\\\'\\\' Did she hand them over or did they just go rogue? We really don\\\'t know the whole story behind that.
Top