Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / AndAnotherThing

Go To

Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi! Or Boba Fett on the Army page, because he is a clone of Jango Fett as well!\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. However he \\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'was not\\\'\\\'\\\' portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\\\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi! Or Boba Fett on the Army page, because he is a clone of Jango Fett as well!\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi! Or Boba Fett on the Army page, because he is a clone of Jango Fett as well.\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\\\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi! Or Boba Fett on the Army page, because he is a clone of Jango Fett as well!\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\\\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi! Or Boba Fett on the Army page, because he is a clone of Jango Fett as well.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series\\\' page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on the Jedi Order page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on this page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\\\\\
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
Qui-Gon \'\'\'was\'\'\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \'\'\'this series\'\'\'. He was portayed as a \'\'\'Force\'\'\'-ghost here, and it\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on the Jedi Order page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\
to:
Qui-Gon \\\'\\\'\\\'was\\\'\\\'\\\' a Jedi in ThePhantomMenace. He was not portrayed as one in \\\'\\\'\\\'this series\\\'\\\'\\\'. He was portayed as a \\\'\\\'\\\'Force\\\'\\\'\\\'-ghost here, and it\\\'s always the portrayal that primarily counts. Since he wasn\\\'t a Jedi in the series, he has nothing to do on the series page for Jedi. Following your argument Dooku should be listed on the Jedi Order page as well, simply because years before the series he too was a Jedi.\\\\\\\\
Top