Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History MassEffect / MassEffectRaceTropes

Go To

Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Okay, so if we\'re going to disregard EVERYONE as an UnreliableNarrator, even though they have no reason to get something of such a large scale wrong... why listen to Legion? Why is everything the geth claim taken as the gospel, and stated as fact on this page? Oh yeah, and that martial law crap is never confirmed to have happened, all we know is that the geth TOLD US that\'s what happened. I find this kind of funny actually.
to:
Okay, so if we\\\'re going to disregard EVERYONE as an UnreliableNarrator, even though they have no reason to get something of such a large scale wrong... why listen to Legion? Why is everything the geth claim taken as the gospel, and stated as fact on this page? Oh yeah, and that martial law crap is never confirmed to have happened, all we know is that the geth TOLD US that\\\'s what happened. Aside from the death one of one single geth sympathizer- presented to use through very easy to fake footage- we have absolutely nothing but the word of the geth supporting that this happened; that the quarians did this to any more than one or two people, that the quarians did it throughout the war, that the geth \\\'appreciate\\\' them, etc.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
\
to:
\\\"Geth do not experience fear\\\". Also, several lies of omission that Shepard gets pissed about in ME3. Oh, and IIRC Gerrel never said he would pull back.

If there\\\'s no evidence putting one account above the other, why are you taking all the geth claims as fact?

And no, none of that is proof. This is where you\\\'re showing your bias; the geth CLAIMED these things. You have nothing but Legion\\\'s/the VI\\\'s word that the geth ceased the attack, rather than some other factor preventing them from finishing the quarians off. And nothing but one grainy 20 second video to support the quarians shooting each other over the geth issue, showed to you by someone who has every reason to lie, who is known to commit lies of omission, and who lives in a universe where doctoring footage is very, very easy even for a putz like Kai Leng. At the very least, what Tali and Anderson said should be on the page, and every geth claim should be prefaced with \\\"the geth claimed\\\" or \\\"according to the geth account\\\" if you\\\'re truly going for the \\\"facts only\\\" approach.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
\
to:
\\\"Geth do not experience fear\\\". Also, several lies of omission that Shepard gets pissed about in ME3. Oh, and IIRC Gerrel never said he would pull back.

If there\\\'s no evidence putting one account above the other, why are you taking all the geth claims as fact?

And no, none of that is proof. This is where you\\\'re showing your bias; the geth CLAIMED these things. You have nothing but Legion\\\'s/the VI\\\'s word that the geth ceased the attack, rather than some other factor preventing them from finishing the quarians off. And nothing but one grainy 20 second video to support the quarians shooting each other over the geth issue, showed to you by someone who has every reason to lie, who is known to commit lies of omission, and who lives in a universe where doctoring footage is very, very easy even for a putz like Kai Leng. At the very least, what Tali and Anderson said should be on the page, and every geth claim should be prefaced with \\\"the geth claimed\\\" or \\\"according to the geth account\\\" if you\\\'re truly going for the \\\"facts only\\\" approach.
Top