Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / ThePasswordIsAlwaysSwordfish

Go To

[002] SomeGuy Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I am less than persuaded. Honestly, even the general exchange from {{Horsefeathers}} only barely qualifies as this trope- the point of the gag isn\'t \
to:
I am less than persuaded. Honestly, even the general exchange from {{Horsefeathers}} only barely qualifies as this trope- the point of the gag isn\\\'t \\\"the password is easy to guess\\\"- it\\\'s the ludicrous verbal slapstick of the MarxBrothers we all know and love. This main reason the trope has this name is because it\\\'s heavily referenced as a classic password title- it has little to do directly with the trope, which is about \\\'\\\'guessing\\\'\\\' passwords.

The MarxBrothers image may be \\\"more interesting\\\", but that\\\'s only because it\\\'s a VisualPun that has nothing to do with the trope. I\\\'m puzzled that someone can not see the joke in the {{Archer}} image- you all do realize that this trope is about characters using easily guessed passwords like \\\"Guest\\\", \\\"Password\\\", or \\\"123456789\\\", right? I mean, just the fact that we can see the words he\\\'s typing onscreen and not asterisks is proof that the image is using the trope. Cripes, it\\\'s even a [[IncrediblyLamePun pun]]! That\\\'s, like a million tv tropes funny points!

On a related note, we need to work on the definition of JustAFaceAndACaption, since people keep interpreting it literally. In the meantime, I\\\'ve changed the picture back to the {{Archer}} image. Further discussion of this issue should take place in the [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/conversations.php?topic=images image fixin\\\']] forum, where a coherent consensus is more likely to be reached.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I am less than persuaded. Honestly, even the general exchange from {{Horsefeathers}} only barely qualifies as this trope- the point of the gag isn\'t \
to:
I am less than persuaded. Honestly, even the general exchange from {{Horsefeathers}} only barely qualifies as this trope- the point of the gag isn\\\'t \\\"the password is easy to guess\\\"- it\\\'s the ludicrous verbal slapstick of the MarxBrothers we all know and love. This trope title could just as easily be ThePasswordIsAlwaysGuest or ThePasswordIsAlwaysPassword- strictly speaking those make more sense. The main reason the title of this hasn\\\'t changed is because what specific word is used really isn\\\'t all that important.

The MarxBrothers image may be \\\"more interesting\\\", but that\\\'s only because it\\\'s a VisualPun that has nothing to do with the trope. I\\\'m puzzled that someone can not see the joke in the {{Archer}} image- you all do realize that this trope is about characters using easily guessed passwords like \\\"Guest\\\", \\\"Password\\\", or \\\"123456789\\\", right? I mean, just the fact that we can see the words he\\\'s typing onscreen and not asterisks is proof that the image is using the trope. Cripes, it\\\'s even a \\\'\\\'[[IncrediblyLamePun pun]]\\\'\\\'. That\\\'s, like a million tv tropes funny points!

On a related note, we need to work on the definition of JustAFaceAndACaption, since people keep interpreting it literally. In the meantime, I\\\'ve changed the picture back to the {{Archer}} image. Further discussion of this issue should take place in the [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/conversations.php?topic=images image fixin\\\']] forum, where a coherent consensus is more likely to be reached.
Top