Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / IKnewIt

Go To

[001] Xtifr Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I think it\'s pushing it to call it a shout out. I admit that it \'\'might\'\' be--in fact, I recognized the echo when I first read it--but it\'s also just something you might expect the character to say in that circumstance. Without WordOfGod to back it up, it seems too speculative. (It\'s also not a particularly well-known Holmes line, unlike, say, comments about dogs and nights.)
to:
I think it\\\'s pushing it to call it a shout out. I admit that it \\\'\\\'might\\\'\\\' be--in fact, I recognized the echo when I first read it--but it\\\'s also just something you might expect the character to say in that circumstance. Without WordOfGod to back it up, it seems too speculative. (It\\\'s also not a particularly well-known Holmes line, unlike, say, comments about dogs and nights.)

eta: at the \\\'\\\'very\\\'\\\' least, I disagree with the \\\"not-so-subtle\\\" part; I think it\\\'s so subtle that I can\\\'t be sure it\\\'s there! ;)
Top