Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Timeline / Homestuck

Go To

[008] Katana Current Version
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all. While there\'s nothing against it, there\'s not really anything for it either.
to:
*A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all. While there\\\'s nothing against it, there\\\'s not really anything for it either. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however. On the other hand the general forum response you mentioned seemed to be to not create a new namespace when none existed previously, simply because it might just be unneeded.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken about feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
*D) These pages function more as direct recaps rather than timelines; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further decreases it\'s resemblance to a timeline.
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*D) This page currently functions more as a direct recap rather than a timeline; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further decreases its resemblance to a timeline.
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however. On the other hand the general forum response you mentioned seem to be to not create a new namespace when none existed previously, simply because it might just be unneeded.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken about feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all. While there\'s nothing against it, there\'s not really anything for it either.
to:
*A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all. While there\\\'s nothing against it, there\\\'s not really anything for it either.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however. On the other hand the general forum response you mentioned seem to be to not create a new namespace when none existed previously, simply because it might just be unneeded.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken about feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken about feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
*D) These pages function more as direct recaps rather than timelines; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further descreases the timeline comparison.
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*D) These pages function more as direct recaps rather than timelines; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further decreases it\\\'s resemblance to a timeline.
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*B) There are already existing resources on the internet that already provides a better functioning example of a timeline; that\'s the major reason that there are not Analysis, Synopsis, or Recap pages for Homestuck on TvTropes in the first place.
to:
*B) There are already existing resources on the internet that provide a better functioning example of a timeline; that\\\'s the major reason that there are not Analysis, Synopsis, or Recap pages for Homestuck on TvTropes in the first place.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\" however.

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all.
B) There are already existing resources on the internet that already provides a better functioning example of a timeline; that\'s the major reason that there are not Analysis, Synopsis, or Recap pages for Homestuck.
C) There seems to be no need for such a timeline page beyond your own desire for it; there\'s no indication other than your own opinion that the recaps are inadequate. Based on my personal experience, few fans seem to have trouble comprehending Homestuck\'s timeline, and what little questions there are are easily cleared up.
D) These pages function more as direct recaps rather than timelines; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further descreases the timeline comparison.
E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \
to:
*A) The addition of multiple pages to categorize a timeline has no precedent at all. While there\\\'s nothing against it, there\\\'s not really anything for it either.
*B) There are already existing resources on the internet that already provides a better functioning example of a timeline; that\\\'s the major reason that there are not Analysis, Synopsis, or Recap pages for Homestuck on TvTropes in the first place.
*C) There seems to be no need for such a timeline page beyond your own desire for it; there\\\'s no indication other than your own opinion that the recaps are inadequate. Based on my personal experience, few fans seem to have trouble comprehending Homestuck\\\'s timeline, and what little questions there are are easily cleared up.
*D) These pages function more as direct recaps rather than timelines; by splitting the sections into other pages that just further descreases the timeline comparison.
*E) As much as you point out my own points are based largely in opinion, yours are almost equally so. I cannot point to any protocol or rule and say \\\"No this violates that\\\"

To me this page seems unnecessary, unfocused, and uncompromising, as we\\\'ve been speaking for a couple weeks now and for all the effort I put in, it feels like I\\\'m debating a brick wall, as pretty much everything I have suggested or spoken feels like it has been shut down regardless of any merit it might have.
Top