Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / CultClassic

Go To

[006] berr Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic YMMV... If something isn\'t widely considered cult (by critics), it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic YMMV... If something isn\\\'t widely considered cult (by critics), it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" by Madrugada, but not in a YMMV sense. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic YMMV... If something isn\'t widely considered cult (by critics), it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic YMMV... If something isn\\\'t widely considered cult (by critics), it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" by Madrugada, but not in a YMMV sense. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is before I resume active editing. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... If something isn\'t widely considered cult by those who\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic YMMV... If something isn\\\'t widely considered cult (by critics), it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" but not meant as YMMV. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is before I resume active editing. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for several months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... If something isn\'t widely considered cult by those who\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for six months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... If something isn\\\'t widely considered cult by those who\\\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" but not meant as YMMV. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is before I resume active editing. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for several months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... There are so many fandoms that if something isn\'t widely considered cult by those who\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for several months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... If something isn\\\'t widely considered cult by those who\\\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" but not meant as YMMV. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is before I resume active editing. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I\'ve been gone from TVT for several months (I\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\'s an index). I don\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... There are so many fandoms that if something isn\'t widely considered cult by those who\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \
to:
I\\\'ve been gone from TVT for several months (I\\\'m a perfectionist and it got too stressful active-editing pages) but I extensively cleaned up the page when I indexified it. I can see this issue both ways (whether or not it\\\'s an index). I don\\\'t really consider Cult Classic all that YMMV... There are so many fandoms that if something isn\\\'t widely considered cult by those who\\\'ve heard of it, it probably isn\\\'t. :-) I think people who classified it as YMMV got hung up on the word \\\"classic\\\" but that\\\'s really just an idiomatic phrase, not an objective description of quality. Similar example would be when BFM (a genre) was renamed \\\"Epic Movie\\\" but not meant as YMMV. Anyway I\\\'ve been out of touch, so I\\\'ll have to look up what the latest consensus is before I resume active editing. One of the things I found stressful is that I think YMMV tropes should be put in a separate dropdown on the main page, not segregated in a different namespace... :-)
Top