Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I disagree with dropping the comments sections, as (at least on this page) there\'s several fics where the comments say more about the plot than the synopsis. Also, at least for me, the comments are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a fic, in the same way that reviews are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a movie. As I understand it, the Comments field is a standard formatting fixture for all the fan fic pages on TV Tropes; just dropping it arbitrarily might ruffle feathers, especially since someone created a brouhaha on the [=~Ranma 1/2~=] page simply by cutting the [=~Sturgeon\'s Law~=] comment. Off the top of my head, the only feasible replacement would be some kind of positive/negative voting system, much like that used for crowners in the forums, but I don\'t think that would work for multiple instances on a page.
to:
I disagree with dropping the comments sections, as (at least on this page) there\\\'s several fics where the comments say more about the plot than the synopsis. Also, at least for me, the comments are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a fic, in the same way that reviews are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a movie. As I understand it, the Comments field is a standard formatting fixture for all the fan fic pages on TV Tropes; just dropping it arbitrarily might ruffle feathers, especially since someone created a brouhaha on the \\\'\\\'RanmaOneHalf\\\'\\\' page simply by cutting the [=~Sturgeon\\\'s Law~=] comment. Off the top of my head, the only feasible replacement would be some kind of positive/negative voting system, much like that used for crowners in the forums, but I don\\\'t think that would work for multiple instances on a page.
[001]
Willbyr
MOD
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I disagree with dropping the comments sections, as (at least on this page) there\'s several fics where the comments say more about the plot than the synopsis. Also, at least for me, the comments are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a fic, in the same way that reviews are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a movie. As I understand it, the Comments field is a standard formatting fixture for all the fan fic pages on TV Tropes; just dropping it arbitrarily might ruffle feathers, especially since someone created a brouhaha on the [=~Ranma 1/2~=] page simply by cutting the [=~Sturgeon\'s Law~=] comment. Off the top of my head, the only feasible replacement would be some kind of positive/negative voting system, much like that used for crowners in the forums, but I don\'t think that would work for multiple instances on a page.
to:
I disagree with dropping the comments sections, as (at least on this page) there\\\'s several fics where the comments say more about the plot than the synopsis. Also, at least for me, the comments are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a fic, in the same way that reviews are a gauge as to whether or not I might enjoy a movie. As I understand it, the Comments field is a standard formatting fixture for all the fan fic pages on TV Tropes; just dropping it arbitrarily might ruffle feathers, especially since someone created a brouhaha on the [=~Ranma 1/2~=] page simply by cutting the [=~Sturgeon\\\'s Law~=] comment. Off the top of my head, the only feasible replacement would be some kind of positive/negative voting system, much like that used for crowners in the forums, but I don\\\'t think that would work for multiple instances on a page.
EDIT: Ninja\\\'d.
EDIT: Ninja\\\'d.
