[002]
Numberguy6
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
This example, added by me, was hidden:
* QuestionableCasting: Creator/ArianaGreenblatt as Young Ahsoka. Her voice sounds nothing like that of Ashley Eckstein. As for her physical appearance: she was 14–15 years old during filming, the same as Ahsoka at the beginning of the Clone Wars, so her portrayal Siege-of-Mandalore Ahsoka (age 17) looked very strange and uncanny.
The reasons given for the removal:
* Style/tone of writing
* Vocal dissonance is to be expected
* Physical appearance dissonance may be intentional, to support ChildSoldier depiction
My rebuttal to these reasons:
* Many entries on this wiki are written in a less-neutral tone. See [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=16831914870.12652800]] for a list of examples.
* This series (and for that matter, Dave Filoni \'\'Star Wars\'\' as a whole) contains several characters carried between animation and live action. All of them – Adult Ahsoka, Sabine, Hera – do a far better job with the voices than Young Ahsoka.
* There is no direct evidence to suggest that the physical-appearance dissonance was intentional.
* QuestionableCasting: Creator/ArianaGreenblatt as Young Ahsoka. Her voice sounds nothing like that of Ashley Eckstein. As for her physical appearance: she was 14–15 years old during filming, the same as Ahsoka at the beginning of the Clone Wars, so her portrayal Siege-of-Mandalore Ahsoka (age 17) looked very strange and uncanny.
The reasons given for the removal:
* Style/tone of writing
* Vocal dissonance is to be expected
* Physical appearance dissonance may be intentional, to support ChildSoldier depiction
My rebuttal to these reasons:
* Many entries on this wiki are written in a less-neutral tone. See [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=16831914870.12652800]] for a list of examples.
* This series (and for that matter, Dave Filoni \'\'Star Wars\'\' as a whole) contains several characters carried between animation and live action. All of them – Adult Ahsoka, Sabine, Hera – do a far better job with the voices than Young Ahsoka.
* There is no direct evidence to suggest that the physical-appearance dissonance was intentional.
to:
[Reply deleted]
