[001]
NubianSatyress
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The entire point of the scene was that Tyrion was speaking for the group. The argument of \
to:
The entire point of the scene was that Tyrion was speaking for the group. The argument of \\\"no one also said so\\\" is countered by the fact that no one \\\'\\\'spoke against it either\\\'\\\', and then did exactly what he suggested. Trying to pretend that because no one voiced active agreement that they must have disagreed is incredibly dishonest, in context with how the scene unfolds.
Some fans disagreeing with whether or not the scene is heartwarming is irrelevant, because the Heartwarming trope/page is YourMileageMayVary. So naturally, yes, this is a case of mileage varying. We don\\\'t NEED to agree. We only need to decide \\\"Do people hold this opinion? (Whether in universe or out.) And if the answer is \\\"yes\\\", then it is a clear example.
And again, inviting Tony makes ZERO sense because again, he has demonstrated again and again that he has no intention of cooperating with an opposing opinion. If you\\\'re trying to reach \\\"consensus\\\" by inviting him, the effort is questionable.
Some fans disagreeing with whether or not the scene is heartwarming is irrelevant, because the Heartwarming trope/page is YourMileageMayVary. So naturally, yes, this is a case of mileage varying. We don\\\'t NEED to agree. We only need to decide \\\"Do people hold this opinion? (Whether in universe or out.) And if the answer is \\\"yes\\\", then it is a clear example.
And again, inviting Tony makes ZERO sense because again, he has demonstrated again and again that he has no intention of cooperating with an opposing opinion. If you\\\'re trying to reach \\\"consensus\\\" by inviting him, the effort is questionable.
