[005]
Wyldchyld
Current Version
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* The \
to:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for objective tease within the canon, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* The \
to:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for objective tease within the canon, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n These entries in particular have the following problems:
* The \
to:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for canon tease, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans. Again, HoYay.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link. Again, HoYay.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon. Again, HoYay.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The reason for bringing them here:
* The \
* The \
to:
The creators, song composer and main singer have all repeatedly warned the fandom not to use the songs as canon, and that the fandom is free to interpret their lyrics however they please. As a result of this, interpreting song lyrics goes on the RWBY YMMV page. There are only a very rare few cases where songs become part of objective tropes -- and those are the songs Weiss sings in-universe about her canon life, and a couple of VillainSongs whose lyrics have been directly tied to villain dialogue in the show.
These entries in particular have the following problems:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for canon tease, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon.
These entries in particular have the following problems:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for canon tease, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope like HoYay.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" does have lyrics that relate to events of the show, but interpreting it a shipping way is left to the fans.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", especially the final sentence, which is a fan-made link to another show, and not a confirmed link.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
* The \
to:
* The \\\"Red Like Roses\\\" section is a case of fans seeing what they want to see. ShipTease is for canon tease, not for what fans want to see. This needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" is as close to canon as we\\\'ve got in this song list, but the creators, song creator and singer have all warned the fandom multiple times not to use the songs as canon, which is why interpreting them gets done on the YMMV page except for the very rare instances where a couple of songs can be troped with an objective trope. Since this is neither a song Weiss sings in-universe or a confirmed VillainSong, this isn\\\'t one of those instances.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", with the exception of the final sentence, which is fan interpretation and needs to be moved to a fan interpretation trope.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon.
* \\\"Armed and Ready\\\" is clearly prematurely troped, given that Volume 5 revealed the person whose side Yang was racing to was Ruby\\\'s -- as revealed by that volume, she was still feeling angry and rejected about Blake at this point in time and was displaying no desire to go chasing after her. If fans want to see the song as being about Blake, that\\\'s fan interpretation, which isn\\\'t the ShipTease trope and needs to go under a subjective/YMMV trope.
* \\\"All That Matters\\\" is as close to canon as we\\\'ve got in this song list, but the creators, song creator and singer have all warned the fandom multiple times not to use the songs as canon, which is why interpreting them gets done on the YMMV page except for the very rare instances where a couple of songs can be troped with an objective trope. Since this is neither a song Weiss sings in-universe or a confirmed VillainSong, this isn\\\'t one of those instances.
* \\\"Nevermore\\\" is in the same position as \\\"All That Matters\\\", with the exception of the final sentence, which is fan interpretation and needs to be moved to a fan interpretation trope.
* Bmblb has been confirmed to not be a nod and tease by the creators. The composer of the song came up with it by himself, both he and song\\\'s singer have warned the fandom not to use this song as canon because it\\\'s a song that Jeff Williams decided he wanted to do and would have some fun doing. It therefore shouldn\\\'t be on the page as representative of canon.
