Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Characters / VoltronLegendaryDefenderTeamVoltron

Go To

[010] AlleyOop Current Version
Changed line(s) 5 from:
to:

The fact that Shiro\\\'s time as the former Black Paladin seemed {{Retgone}} in favor of Keith who only assumed the position out of necessity seems like the larger problem and the source of the dropped ball when it came to his friendship with Keith (and the others for that matter).
Changed line(s) 6 from:
n

The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious dropped ball due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only one. That Shiro\'s position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin was forgotten entirely while Keith who\'d only been promoted out of necessity was treated as the only one who mattered reeks of {{Retgone}}. Likewise the cast had a major case of selective amnesia , even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.

to:
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yeah that tweet definitely reads as cheap PR speak to me. The fact that Shiro couldn\'t be friends with anyone male did indeed stick out to me like a sore thumb given his focus in the previous seasons, and it is something I pointed out in the forum thread, but I doubted it had anything to do with the fact that Shiro is gay. Seasons 7 and 8 were written and animated before they got the go-ahead to confirm him as such so that wasn\'t a motivator.
to:
I do concede that their relationship is written kind of strange (hence why a RelationshipWritingFumble entry is worth considering) and that tweet made me do a double take as to whether they might consider it, but as it was likely made by an intern I figured it was likely cheap PR speak similar to the comments about seeing more of Adam.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
to:
The fact that Shiro couldn\\\'t be friends with anyone male did indeed stick out to me like a sore thumb given his focus in the previous seasons, and it is something I pointed out in the forum thread, but I doubted it had anything to do with the fact that Shiro is gay. Seasons 7 and 8 were written and animated before they got the go-ahead to confirm him as such so that wasn\\\'t a motivator.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s general decrease in writing quality such as its ignoring of major plot threads or how sterile the relationships feel between \'\'anyone\'\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo (besides, Keith always came off to me as a character unfit for romance in general, hence why I reiterate that Shiro is TheNotLoveInterest, because he\'s the closest anyone can come in light of Keith\'s inability to retain a traditional one). The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s general decrease in writing quality such as its ignoring of major plot threads or how sterile the relationships feel between \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo (besides, Keith always came off to me as a character unfit for romance in general, hence why I reiterate that Shiro is TheNotLoveInterest, because he\\\'s the closest anyone can come in light of Keith\\\'s inability to retain a traditional one).
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
to:
The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious dropped ball due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only one. That Shiro\\\'s position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin was forgotten entirely while Keith who\\\'d only been promoted out of necessity was treated as the only one who mattered reeks of {{Retgone}}. Likewise the cast had a major case of selective amnesia , even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.

Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \'\'anyone\'\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo (besides, Keith always came off to me as someone who can\'t handle romance in general). The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s general decrease in writing quality such as its ignoring of major plot threads or how sterile the relationships feel between \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo (besides, Keith always came off to me as a character unfit for romance in general, hence why I reiterate that Shiro is TheNotLoveInterest, because he\\\'s the closest anyone can come in light of Keith\\\'s inability to retain a traditional one). The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \'\'anyone\'\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo (besides, Keith always came off to me as someone who can\\\'t handle romance in general). The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
to:

Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \'\'anyone\'\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia, even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia (selective recycling of scripts from other), even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yeah that tweet definitely reads as cheap PR speak to me. The fact that Shiro couldn\'t be friends with anyone male did indeed stick out to me like a sore thumb given his focus in the previous seasons, and it is something I pointed out in the forum discussion threads on the forum, but I doubted it had anything to do with the fact that Shiro is gay. Seasons 7 and 8 were written and animated before they got the go-ahead to confirm him as such.
to:
Yeah that tweet definitely reads as cheap PR speak to me. The fact that Shiro couldn\\\'t be friends with anyone male did indeed stick out to me like a sore thumb given his focus in the previous seasons, and it is something I pointed out in the forum thread, but I doubted it had anything to do with the fact that Shiro is gay. Seasons 7 and 8 were written and animated before they got the go-ahead to confirm him as such so that wasn\\\'t a motivator.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s writing problems regarding the oddly sterile relationship between \'\'everyone\'\' aside from Lance and Allura, not malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s writing problems with ignoring major plot threads or relationships between \\\'\\\'anyone\\\'\\\' save for Lance and Allura, rather than malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}. Like the cast had a major case of selective amnesia, even when it came to recent plot points such as the Entity.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
It\'s more of a symptom of the last season\'s writing problems regarding the oddly sterile relationship between everyone in general, not malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}.
to:
It\\\'s more of a symptom of the last season\\\'s writing problems regarding the oddly sterile relationship between \\\'\\\'everyone\\\'\\\' aside from Lance and Allura, not malice or any attempt at a shut-down due to fear of no-homo. The fact that Shiro is not treated as an ex-paladin but an unrelated character to any of his former Castle comrades save for a few scenes is the greater issue here. While his friendship with Keith is the most obvious due to all the prior screentime dedicated to it it\\\'s not the only dropped ball regarding Shiro, whose position as a member of Team Voltron and its former Black Paladin seemed almost entirely {{Retgone}}.
Top