Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / BeautyAndTheBeast2017

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
TheNerfGuy, I'd be happy to discuss a consensus, but given how many potshots EdwardDavies has taken, and how he's even taken them in the individual tropes, I'd like to see some consideration of a consensus from him, as well. From the edits he's made, I get the impression that he is uninterested in any consensus that does not establish his view as the correct view and disagreeing views as wrong. I'm trying to stay away from changing anything while this is going on.
to:
TheNerfGuy, I\'d be happy to discuss a consensus, but given how many potshots EdwardDavies has taken, and how he\'s even taken them in the individual tropes, I\'d like to see some consideration of a consensus from him, as well. From the edits he\'s made, I get the impression that he is uninterested in any consensus that does not establish his view as the correct view and disagreeing views as wrong. I\'m trying to stay away from changing anything while this is going on, but I could not rise above removing said potshots.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
crazysamaritan, well, we don't know Gaston's opinion on adventure (which is not antithetical to a simple life, after all), since Belle never gives him a chance to voice his opinion on it. Belle tells him flat out that 'no one can change that much' (which goes entirely against the theme of the movie, but never mind that). And it is that unwillingness to even give him a chance, on both her part and Maurice's part, that causes me to interpret their treatment of him as DesignatedVillain. I'd be open to discussing changing the trope to DesignatedMonkey.
to:
crazysamaritan, well, we don\'t know Gaston\'s opinion on adventure (which is not antithetical to a simple life, after all), since Belle never gives him a chance to voice his opinion on it. Belle tells him flat out that \'no one can change that much\' (which goes entirely against the theme of the movie, but never mind that). And it is that unwillingness to even give him a chance, on both her part and Maurice\'s part, that causes me to interpret their treatment of him as DesignatedVillain. I\'d be open to discussing changing the trope to DesignatedMonkey.
Top