Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Film / CaptainAmericaCivilWar

Go To

[004] SonicLover Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I don't think this page was cutlisted for anything resembling a good reason. The literal side of it probably falls under JustForFun, and is an excellent illustration of the various methods of PlayingWithATrope to boot, while the figurative side does a pretty good job of playing with something that allegedly can't be played with.
to:
I don\'t think this page was cutlisted for anything resembling a good reason. The literal side of it probably falls under JustForFun, and is an excellent illustration of the various methods of PlayingWithATrope to boot, while the figurative side does a pretty good job of playing with something that allegedly can\'t be played with.

And on a sidenote, it says on the cutlist to \"click the wait button\" in order to challenge a deletion, but I haven\'t found any wait button, just a \"see discussion\" button.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I don't think this trope was cutlisted for anything resembling a good reason. The literal side of it probably falls under JustForFun, and is an excellent illustration of the various methods of PlayingWithATrope to boot, while the figurative side does a pretty good job of playing with something that allegedly can't be played with.
to:
I don\'t think this page was cutlisted for anything resembling a good reason. The literal side of it probably falls under JustForFun, and is an excellent illustration of the various methods of PlayingWithATrope to boot, while the figurative side does a pretty good job of playing with something that allegedly can\'t be played with.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Personally, I'm inclined to be on Team Iron Man, but I feel that Tony does take some things too far in the film. Sure, he truly wants to help reduce the collateral damage and keeps the Avengers as a team instead of breaking off into two sides, but keeping Wanda locked inside the Avengers Facility is, to me, kind of unnecessary, which is why I think he fits in the WellIntentionedExtremist trope. He means well, but he just wants everyone to agree with his decision whether they like it or not, just as Hawkeye claimed when they meet in the Raft.
to:
Personally, I\'m inclined to be on Team Iron Man, but I feel that Tony does take some things too far in the film. Sure, he truly wants to help reduce the collateral damage and keeps the Avengers as a team instead of breaking off into two sides, but keeping Wanda locked inside the Avengers Facility is, to me, kind of unnecessary, which is why I think he fits in the WellIntentionedExtremist trope. He means well, but he just wants everyone to agree with his decision whether they like it or not, just as Hawkeye claimed when they meet in the Raft.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
But yeah, looking back, his good qualities do outshine the bad (aside from that moment regarding his parents and Bucky thing in the finale...). He's willing to make compromise where he can (ironically, what Sharon tells Steve to do during Peggy's funeral) and uses violence as a last resort. So it's up to people to see if it disqualifies him of being a WellIntentionedExtremist or not.
to:
But yeah, looking back, his good qualities do outshine the bad (aside from that moment regarding his parents and Bucky thing in the finale...). He\'s willing to make compromise where he can (ironically, what Sharon tells Steve to do during Peggy\'s funeral) and uses violence as a last resort. So it\'s up to people to see if it disqualifies him of being a WellIntentionedExtremist or not.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
to:
As for the LawfulStupid trope...well, I have no idea about that. Just gotta wait for the troper who added it in.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Personally, I'm inclined to be on Team Iron Man, but I feel that Tony does take some things too far in the film. Sure, he truly wants to help reduce the collateral damage and keeps the Avengers as a team instead of breaking off into two sides, but keeping Wanda locked inside the Avengers Facility is, to me, kind of unnecessary, which is why I think he fits in the WellIntentionedExtremist trope. He means well, but he just wants everyone agrees with his decision whether they like it or not, just as Hawkeye claimed when they meet in the Raft.
to:
Personally, I\'m inclined to be on Team Iron Man, but I feel that Tony does take some things too far in the film. Sure, he truly wants to help reduce the collateral damage and keeps the Avengers as a team instead of breaking off into two sides, but keeping Wanda locked inside the Avengers Facility is, to me, kind of unnecessary, which is why I think he fits in the WellIntentionedExtremist trope. He means well, but he just wants everyone to agree with his decision whether they like it or not, just as Hawkeye claimed when they meet in the Raft.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
But yeah, looking back, his good qualities do outshine the bad (aside from that moment regarding his parents and Bucky thing in the finale...). He's willing to make compromise where he can (ironically, what Sharon tells Steve to do during Peggy's funeral) and uses violence as a last resort. So it's up to people to see if it disqualifies him of being a WellIntentionedExtremist or not.
to:
But yeah, looking back, his good qualities do outshine the bad (aside from that moment regarding his parents and Bucky thing in the finale...). He\'s willing to make compromise where he can (ironically, what Sharon tells Steve to do during Peggy\'s funeral) and uses violence as a last resort. So it\'s up to people to see if it disqualifies him of being a WellIntentionedExtremist or not.
Top