[002]
quirkygenius
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Good work with these edits. In case you're wondering why I'm commenting on this, I am the troper that SpectralTime had a vendetta against and the one who made the edits you've discussed.
to:
Good work with these edits. In case you\'re wondering why I\'m commenting on this, I am the troper that SpectralTime had a vendetta against and the one who made the edits you\'ve discussed.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Let me set the record straight, I did not add those tropes and am not sure about the shoehorning issue. The tropes were already on the page, I merely edited the descriptions to include observations of mine or elaborate on existing views. On Broken Base it was a mistake for me to cite Return of Kings. I did so because I didn't know they were a hate group or that examples in Broken Base do not need citation at the time. While I re-examined their website and realized my mistake, the points presented remain valid. It was my own observation of the film that, to borrow this thread's wording,
to:
Let me set the record straight, I did not add those tropes and am not sure about the shoehorning issue. The tropes were already on the page, I merely edited the descriptions to include observations of mine or elaborate on existing views. On Broken Base it was a mistake for me to cite Return of Kings. I did so because I didn\'t know, at the time, they were a hate group or that examples in Broken Base do not need citation.
While I re-examined their website and realized my mistake, the points presented remain valid. It was my own observation of the film that, to borrow this thread\'s wording, \"the film\'s treatment of male characters (is) problematic\". As far as I know, I was the first to point out on the YMMV page that all the bad guys are men, that all women in the film are heroic and question the morality of the Vuvalini, albeit with different words.
I was uncertain about the exact use of the trope Draco In Leather Pants so I put it on the YMMV page just in case as they have received such treatment by the fanbase. Going by this thread, I wasn\'t the only one unsure of the term\'s applicability. I had also forgotten about the trope DesignatedHero, or I would\'ve used that instead. I also appreciate that when you inferred that my deliberate misspelling of Vuvalini was juvenile, you didn\'t make it a personal attack; I did it as a tongue-in-cheek way to point out the fact, but I won\'t use such methods in the future.
Now the air has been cleared on the issues and they have been fixed. Once again, great work everyone involved.
While I re-examined their website and realized my mistake, the points presented remain valid. It was my own observation of the film that, to borrow this thread\'s wording, \"the film\'s treatment of male characters (is) problematic\". As far as I know, I was the first to point out on the YMMV page that all the bad guys are men, that all women in the film are heroic and question the morality of the Vuvalini, albeit with different words.
I was uncertain about the exact use of the trope Draco In Leather Pants so I put it on the YMMV page just in case as they have received such treatment by the fanbase. Going by this thread, I wasn\'t the only one unsure of the term\'s applicability. I had also forgotten about the trope DesignatedHero, or I would\'ve used that instead. I also appreciate that when you inferred that my deliberate misspelling of Vuvalini was juvenile, you didn\'t make it a personal attack; I did it as a tongue-in-cheek way to point out the fact, but I won\'t use such methods in the future.
Now the air has been cleared on the issues and they have been fixed. Once again, great work everyone involved.
