Watchlisted.
Soon, the revolution shall begin.
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.Bad Faux, down. No revolutions here!
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.Of course not. I'm saving the revolution for the RP thread, Dice rolling is too time consuming.
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.Nooooo
Also, oh guys I should ask. In combat and checks, I'll ask of each of you, do you prefer to write the flourish of your attacks or let me handle it? I mean when I give the ruling for an attack or such, do you prefer to describe how you failed or succeeded or prefer me to make it up for you?
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.A bit of both. I think players should write their actions and reactions as long as they are potentially in control of them. So if I shot a goblin, missed, and it moved up and stabbed me, I'd write the parts about shooting at the goblin, (roll, miss) you'd write the parts about the goblin dodging, moving up and stabbing at me, (roll: get hit by goblin for Y damage) and then I'd write about the damage taken. We'll have to plan around attacks of opportunity though.
For clarity, should we put our proposed actions in spoiler tags at the bottom of our posts?
edited 20th Dec '14 5:01:28 AM by Pyrite
Not a substitute for a formal medical consultation.That would be good!
And yups, in other adventurers I've seen some people that prefer the DM to come up with what happens when you do an action ("And then your blade cleves the goblin in half, from the shoulder diagonally down to the groin, vanquishing him and driving fear into his remaining allies") and some that would rather direct those parts and say it.
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.Double post to ask, do you all have Dropbox? If you do, we can make a shared folder on which to have all the character sheets for easy reference and other materials. If you update the character sheet on dropbox, we'll all instantly get the updated version so its pretty convenient.
If not, well... everyone give me a link to your character sheets here, cause I'm going to many different places to find the links and it's dizzying @-@
Oh by the way, the check to know of giantkin is a nature knowledge check. If you wish, to do the roll to see how much your character knows of them I'll send you info. Faux has already done the roll privately.
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.I used Dropbox, as you are no doubt aware, and the link to my character sheet is up there. I should probably have uploaded a non-editable version.
Also, since the option was available: Sanna was not present at the negotiations and the rest of the party should be aware of this.
edited 21st Dec '14 1:36:13 AM by Pyrite
Not a substitute for a formal medical consultation.Alternatively, you could compile everybody's stats and proficiencies on your computer and keep track of them there.
I myself don't have dropbox, so I don't think I could really go along with that.
"And then the dead man of the dead did dead things to all the dead people."-Two Best Friends Play Dark SoulsYou have my file but I don't have a dropbox; so you could upload it. Obviously the inventory updates would be trickier or at least no longer on me.
Alternatively, I could maybe convert it to Myth Weavers's online character sheet if you'd be alright with that being the standard.
Edit: Also, Melon, my character addressed yours specifically with an invitation to go drinking. This is a thing because I am the tank and I need to get to know my healer.
edited 21st Dec '14 6:48:27 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.As probably one of the highest CHA characters and definitely the most outgoing one, I probably should have gone to meet the gnome... But then, there's no guarentees Oisín would have been as friendly if you deprived him of his drinks for the sake of rushing things unnecessarily.
edited 22nd Dec '14 7:06:06 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.I kind of assumed our characters were already acquainted with one another to an extent.
edited 22nd Dec '14 7:24:38 PM by SonofMelonHead
"And then the dead man of the dead did dead things to all the dead people."-Two Best Friends Play Dark SoulsWe are! Casually drinking would be a way for me to get to know your character so Oisín can come off as knowing him and being used to bleeding alot in front of him when actual battle comes.
Hell, improvising stories of their past adventures in the guise of "Yeah, well remember the time I saved your ass from X" would be a good way to build on our still somewhat vague history and would blend seemlessly with casual drinking.
Edit: Here is my Mythweavers Sheet: http://www.myth-weavers.com/sheet.html#id=72993
edited 22nd Dec '14 11:24:00 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.Is everyone (aside from Oisin) okay with finishing up at the tower, or is there any more stuff that you feel like discussing? Sanna's done for now.
Not a substitute for a formal medical consultation.Oisín is in the Townsquare, so this is a handy moment for reunion.
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.Somehow I missed this thread entirely!
It's been fun.Ok, my players, I feel increased tension on the RP and between the characters. Please, let us speak stuff here and try to get into accord as I know that there are players here that are getting some measure of irritation. Lets try to discuss this stuff OOC before it boils over.
So please, if you have a request, something you want to understand of another player, or something that bothered you about what happened with yours, please, do air them.
edited 25th Dec '14 9:12:45 PM by daltar
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.Right, I assume at least in part this is because of Oisín who seems surprisingly controversial with the party. I've not been playing him as the most articulate or serious person, and I think a few points have been misinterpreted;
- The Porter thing was in order to turn the game to "we all meet in an inn". Once I realized the party prefered to hurry to interaction rather than wait for Melon to submit his sheet, I followed along then went for a drink afterwards as that seemed to be the plan, except no one followed then either. I've decided to play up this part of Oisín's character but he had two pints of porter which isn't too much to drink (you'd have to be a bit of a lightweight for that to hit you, Oisín meanwhile is a seasoned drinker) and I mostly had him drink that much so as to have what was left in the gallon fit into his waterskin.
- Squire Subplot/Aldrik: I made a point of hitting what looked like a couple of plothooks in the opening post when we were in the city. One of these was a boy enthusiastic to join the fight. I talked with Dalt and this character is essentially going to be an apprentice who can eventually take on PC levels. Fifteen was both historically and in this setting an appropriate age for someone to begin their training as a Squire (which means weapon bearing and generally assistance, not necessarily combat). Oisín isn't the wierd reckless one here, he's doing what is standard practice.
- Chronology: I tried to make light of the sudden rush in character, but there really isn't any reason for your characters to be looking down on Oisín in or out of character:
- Firstly; both in and out of character, I beat you to the town square. Oisín was technically waiting on your guys and him coming along wouldn't have sped things up much.
- Secondly; The attack was three days ago. To set an appointment we must have sent someone ahead (realistically, we'd have had to seek our and hire a courrier from a nearby village as we hadn't arrived in Riltplait yet) which would have taken a fair time as well, far more than two hours.
Finally, as a personal note; the majority of my D&D experience has been done under highly murderous D Ms. Daltar is not one, none the less the habits are in place; Oisín's departure was in large part to satisfy my need to be fully prepared to murder Giantkin.
Oisín definitely has the passion and stubbornness which Melon described but he keeps it in place mostly with common sense which I feel a lot of other players have over looked to portray him as a reckless drunk, rather than someone who's light hearted but has done more than the rest of the party (except Sanna, depending on what was bought) to prepare for this attack.
edited 25th Dec '14 9:32:23 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.I'm sorry for my part in ramping up tensions in the RP so far; I just feel like I'm having a bit of a hard time grasping Oisin's character. I can't really be sure how much of it is my own misinterpretations, but he seems too flippant about things, like he's a notch or two higher on the low-high fantasy scale than I've been reading the RP as. That's probably all on me, but the subtle disconnect is what's been rubbing me the wrong way, I think.
It's been fun.Oisín has a low wisdom score and is a Paladin, I've played this into a self-aware idealism which is itself invested in very low fantasy concepts (I've cited "the Wanderer" as a source of inspiration to Dalt). Even then, he's acutely aware of his own failures and is keenly aware that sometimes pragmatism is the best option, though he's slow to take that path.
He definitely tries to take things lightly, but that's a part of his character and I thought it suited his oath; to spread light and to be light. As someone who's really messed up in the past (returned to find his friends dead and home lost) and hasn't forgiven himself for it, the flippancy is his way of trying to hide that.
Meanwhile, he's been pretty pragmatic in this game. He's done everything quickly and by the book; his Squire as I said before is about the right age for it, I've bought a lot of things that I didn't have originally which should slow the Giant down, if we meet him in the right circumstances and I have plans for how we should do that.
edited 25th Dec '14 9:45:23 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.I actually updated my sheet with the items, but I'm still new at this so I don't really know what's useful. I heard good things about a ten-foot pole, but I have no idea where to keep it.
Character-wise, uh... It's a bad sign when the Paladin's cheery and the Bard's angry, for one, but I'm with Red on the Paladin, of all people, seeming a little too flippant about the loss of human life, even if subsequent actions prove otherwise. Bear in mind that in-character, none of the other characters know what Oisin's done to prepare so far. All they know is that he went drinking and picked up a boy along the way, which is as bad as it sounds.
I will admit that I personally missed the timings for the attacks, because who leaves dead bodies out three days after a monster attack anyway?
Also, I seem to be the only one who's submitted his sheet for you all to view, so there's no way of telling if everyone else bought their items before the start of the RP - if you did, that's probably why we're so keen to skip that stage.
Squire: I figured you'd taken the Knight background (variant Noble). I suspect that our concern in-character is that the learning curve is a little steep for a complete novice, but Sanna is probably okay with that. ("Kids these days.")
edited 25th Dec '14 10:04:53 PM by Pyrite
Not a substitute for a formal medical consultation.It's in post 14: http://www.myth-weavers.com/sheet.html#id=72993
It's also odd that one criticism is that Oisín is too high fantasy and the other is that he is jaded to death.
Again; He's doing everything he can to make sure Aldrik is safe (while Squiring at 15 is standard practice and GM approved) and also beat you guys to the square. I just don't see how he's being flippant here except that he's not panicking as he heads out.
Also, Oisín explained his plan to Melonhead's character; he didn't originally have all of the traps on this sheet (which I thought you guys were able to view by now) and they should be pretty clearly visible on the horse as something not there before.
Edit; I thought about it, but Oisín's flavour is more dark ages, predating Knights so it felt out of place. Also, Folk Hero was more fun. But yeah, as I said, in the Middle Ages 15 was pretty standard for your first dip into the battlefield as a complete novice, carrying weapons and shields. It's been made very clear to Aldrik by Oisín and the rest of the party that he's not to risk his life here. But il the long run, while he isn't likely to level up to be a full GMPC party member, but could get a few levels of a PC class and definitely do some auxiliary stuff for us and enrich the setting a little.
For now, it's more something I thought would be interesting and I didn't expect this reaction to it as Dalt (see below) liked the idea.
edited 25th Dec '14 10:13:57 PM by Fauxlosophe
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.Faux actually got the timeline wrong.
The first attack was a week ago on the keep by the river. Three days ago, the party learned of it as it took four days in between the town deciding to send a call for help and for the news to carry away from Riltplait to where our adventurers were. Now, today as you reach the city, you learn that the night that just passed hours ago there was the new attack on the town walls and the abduction of Ria.
As for things... it's obvious that the party wanted to move quickly on with the adventure and that Faux took some extra time. The extra time is actually not wrong to take, as a few hours more or less won't change the fate of Ria and it may be good to prepare for the adventure. Taking into account that I'm your GM I won't punish you if, as players, you want to prepare and interact in the city before heading off for the rescue. I actually do like what Faux did with the recruiting of the squire, as he took a part of the game that was window dressing and integrated it into the adventure, creating a new character. However, seeing as the rest of the party preferred to move, I tried to make this delay and sidetrack go as fast as possible, replying to Faux as quickly as I ca so we could all march together.
As for Oisin's character, it seems like he is divisive with the flippancy of his attitude though the urgency the party was on may be somewhat overstated. Still, as my players, I wish we can truly overcome this and meaningfully iron out the differences and what may grieve us out here before it affect the game and worse, it may sour the fun we're trying to have with one another.
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.My apologies there; I assumed that we were responding to a message about both attacks and thus it must have taken place before we had the news three days ago, with the first attack happening a week ago.
Mé féin ag daṁsa faoin ngealaċ seanrince gan ċeol leis ach ceol cuisle. DS FC: 4141-3472-4041, feel free to add me.
Discussion for the game, of Grunwich can happen here!
Structure.
Gatehouse repaired, basic gate on it. All walls are up though some are in disrepair.
The Inner Keep◊ so far.
Room breakdown:
edited 8th Mar '15 11:07:02 PM by daltar
If I'm sure of something it's that I'm not sure of anything.