History YMMV / SilentHillRevelation3D

** Likewise, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bF35I8KXXMY "Silent Screams"]] is an amazing song, with Mary Elizabeth [=McGlynn=] returning to sing for Silent Hill.

** Akira Yamaoda's AlternativeMetal [[SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic forays on the soundtrack]] is also considered one of the few highlights.

* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** Pyramid Head is stated to be [[spoiler: Alessa/Heather's guardian and executioner, in a sense taking Valtiel's role from [[VideoGame/SilentHill3 SH3]]]], largely [[VoodooShark justifying]] complaints of his [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment unexplained presence]] in the first movie.
** Roughly the first thirty minutes or so pretty much try to excuse all the changes from the first movie and find ways to make them fit into the games' universe, like Chris changing his and Sharon's names to Harry and Heather respectively, explaining ([[VoodooShark Or trying to, at least]]) how Sharon returned to the normal world, and reestablishing Harry's role in the story [[spoiler:(and then ruining it again by killing Douglas in his place)]], and tying up the PlotHole of Rose being stuck in Silent Hill after the first movie's GainaxEnding.

** The "poptart jumpscare". To elaborate, it's a strange moment of editing where after Heather's opening NightmareSequence there's a sudden cut to a close-up of a poptart inside a toaster. Needless to say, WebVideo/{{Phelous}} has made this into a RunningGag in his reviews.

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Uses this to justify Pyramid Head's existence in the movie continuity.

** On a related note, it's Jon Snow and Ned Stark, and they both survive to the end of the movie!
* ItsNotSupposedToWinOscars: The common defense for the movie whenever anyone tries to point out it's countless flaws and systematic destroying of the source material.

** Akira Yamaoda's AlternativeMetal [[AweseomeMusic forays on the soundtrack]] is also considered one of the few highlights.