History YMMV / Horimiya

** [[Main/JustForPun HorniMiya]][[labelnote:Explanation (SPOILER WARNING)]]A pun on the OfficiallyShortenedTitle, used after Hori and Miyamura finally had TheirFirstTime.[[/labelnote]]

** The resolution of the Tooru/Yuki romantic subplot. Some readers found [[spoiler:Yuki avoiding Yanagi's confession by [[TheBeard fake dating]] Tooru, and how she and Tooru used the fake relationship to dissuade Sakura from pursuing him]], as unfair to both suitors and make Tooru and Yuki look cruel to them [[spoiler:without actually having to address their romantic status]]. On the other hand, other fans were happy with the development, as it helped Tooru and Yuuki grow closer, and said suitors eventually got over their crushes and became friends with them.

* UnnecessaryMakeover: Miyamura eventually cuts his shoulder-length hair into a shorter, more boyish do. He says it's because he wants to fit the image of what Hori's boyfriend should look like and avoid her being teased because of his meek looks, with several people commenting that the new haircut looks much better on him. The fans tend to disagree, stating that the change was unnecessary and looked better beforehand. Funnily enough, ''in-universe'', both Hori and Watabe have a similar reaction to most fans and want Miyamura to let his hair grow again. After he reveals that some of his piercings are closing up and he doesn't have any intention of opening them again, more complaints followed. [[spoiler:When ''both'' of them eventually get a shorter haircut and keep their hair that way in adulthood, even ''more'' of the fanbase had frqctueed opinions about it.]]

* UnnecessaryMakeover: Miyamura eventually cuts his shoulder-length hair into a shorter, more boyish do. He says it's because he wants to fit the image of what Hori's boyfriend should look like and avoid her being teased because of his meek looks, with several people commenting that the new haircut looks much better on him. The fans tend to disagree, stating that the change was unnecessary and looked better beforehand. Funnily enough, ''in-universe'', both Hori and Watabe have a similar reaction to most fans and want Miyamura to let his hair grow again. After he reveals that some of his piercings are closing up and he doesn't have any intention of opening them again, more complaints followed.

** Hori's ClingyJealousGirl antics evolving to the point where she's jealous of him getting close to other guys as well. In the manga, Miyamura actually ''did'' have a male admirer in class, and Hori learning this combined with Miyamura being AmbiguouslyBi is what leads to her paranoia. This character never appears in the anime, so it makes her ranting about Miyamura leaving her for guy come completely out of the blue.

** Yuki became one as a result of being the center of the LoveQuadrangle dilemma between herself, Toru, Sakura and Yanagi. Yuki starts to develop feelings for Toru but CannotSpitItOut, but opts to fake date him to both give her an out to turn Yanagi down while also discourage Sakura from pursuing Toru. Yuki's indecisiveness and jealousy ends up being the major driving point on this storyline. Some found this to make Yuki one of the most relatable characters in the story while others despised the fact that she both held the ConflictBall and ultimately got off scot-free without ever really being called out for it.

* MisaimedFandom: Based on the implication that [[AmbiguousDisorder Miyamura's body piercings were a sign of self-harm]], it makes it all the more ironic that there a segment of fans who still decry his removing of his piercings as an UnnecessaryMakeover.