Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / FooFighters

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized albums in years. In fact, unlike the predecessors, which as mentioned above are their lowest rated, it has the highest score in [=RateYourMusic=], ''and that somehow includes their most popular albums''.

to:

** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized albums in years. In fact, unlike the predecessors, which as mentioned above are their lowest rated, it has the highest score in [=RateYourMusic=], ''and that somehow includes ''somehow surpassing their most popular albums''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized albums in years.

to:

** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized albums in years. In fact, unlike the predecessors, which as mentioned above are their lowest rated, it has the highest score in [=RateYourMusic=], ''and that somehow includes their most popular albums''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Foo Fighters vs. the Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being the Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of the Foo. Coincidentally, on ''Series/TheDavidLettermanShow'', the band [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2PR2_Zw5PE did a similar joke themselves before the meme gained popularity, albeit in a slightly different fashion,]] and before that, ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqrG6JXsPPw did a skit of their own.]][[/note]]

to:

** The Foo Fighters vs. the Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being the Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of the Foo. Coincidentally, on ''Series/TheDavidLettermanShow'', ''Series/TheLateShowWithDavidLetterman'', the band [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2PR2_Zw5PE did a similar joke themselves before the meme gained popularity, albeit in a slightly different fashion,]] and before that, ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqrG6JXsPPw did a skit of their own.]][[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Foo Fighters vs. the Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being the Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of the Foo. Coincidentally, the band [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2PR2_Zw5PE did a similar joke themselves before the meme gained popularity, albeit in a slightly different fashion.]] [[/note]]

to:

** The Foo Fighters vs. the Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being the Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of the Foo. Coincidentally, on ''Series/TheDavidLettermanShow'', the band [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2PR2_Zw5PE did a similar joke themselves before the meme gained popularity, albeit in a slightly different fashion.]] [[/note]]fashion,]] and before that, ''WesternAnimation/RobotChicken'' [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqrG6JXsPPw did a skit of their own.]][[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Foo Fighters vs. Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of Foo.[[/note]]
* MisattributedSong: The disco song "Kung Fu Fighting" is often credited to the Foo Fighters on file-sharing sites. The song was actually performed by Carl Douglas.

to:

** The Foo Fighters vs. the Foo[[note]]February 2020 saw a rise in memes pitting the band against their supposed arch-nemesis, the Foo. Jokes range from the fighting of the Foo being the Foo Fighters' major contribution to society to the Foo Fighters having a BerserkButton that snaps at the very presence of Foo.the Foo. Coincidentally, the band [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2PR2_Zw5PE did a similar joke themselves before the meme gained popularity, albeit in a slightly different fashion.]] [[/note]]
* MisattributedSong: The disco song "Kung Fu Foo Fighting" is often credited to the Foo Fighters on file-sharing sites. The song was actually performed by Carl Douglas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab

Added DiffLines:

* IKnewIt: Without a permanent drummer announced, fans suspected that Dave Grohl had recorded drum tracks on ''But Here We Are'' in Taylor Hawkins' absence, something proven correct during a conversation with Grohl and new drummer Josh Freese during a Veeps livestream.
-->'''Freese''': When you explained the beat on the record and you're like, "I think I played it with one hand," and I'm kinda doing the same thing. It feels good and sounds cool, you know?\\
'''Grohl''': It was unintentional; I did it when I demoed it at my house, and I'd just woken up and I was tired. But on the shitty drum set at my house, it just kinda sounded better. You're not hitting the hi-hat and the snare at the same time, so it sort of has more space.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The progression of "The Pretender" also sounds a bit like "[[Music/AFeverYouCantSweatOut I Write Sins Not Tragedies]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicRiff: The talk box intro of "Generator", "Good Grief", "Everlong", "The Pretender", "All My Life", "Stacked Actors", "Hey, Johnny Park!", "Rope", and the ever popular "Best of You".

to:

* EpicRiff: The "Monkey Wrench", the talk box intro of "Generator", "Good Grief", "Everlong", "The Pretender", "All My Life", "Stacked Actors", "Hey, Johnny Park!", "Rope", and the ever popular "Best of You".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EpicRiff: The talk box intro of "Generator", "Good Grief", "Everlong", "All My Life", "Stacked Actors", "Hey, Johnny Park!", "Rope", and the ever popular "Best of You".

to:

* EpicRiff: The talk box intro of "Generator", "Good Grief", "Everlong", "The Pretender", "All My Life", "Stacked Actors", "Hey, Johnny Park!", "Rope", and the ever popular "Best of You".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No Real Life


* NeverLiveItDown:
** William Goldsmith, largely due to his inability to accept his drumming wasn't right for the group and tendency to blame Dave Grohl. In fairness, Grohl gave him the opportunity to do plenty of takes to get it right.
** A ''very'' VocalMinority will never forget the fact the Foo Fighters supported the "AIDS isn't a real disease" movement, despite the band having long moved on from it (it only ended among the causes they supported due to Nate Mendel) and has not shown support for it in years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
First bullet is covered under I Am The Band. Second can probably be rewritten as a Retroactive Recognition entry for Nirvana.


* FaceOfTheBand:
** Music/DaveGrohl. In fact, the first album was [[IAmTheBand made almost completely by him]], with the help of a producer and only the guitar part in "X-Static" played by another musician (Greg Dulli of Music/TheAfghanWhigs).
** Dave himself was on the other side of this trope with Music/{{Nirvana}}. Nirvana was Music/KurtCobain. Many people wouldn't even know Dave Grohl was part of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized album in years.

to:

** ''But Here We Are'' became this for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized album albums in years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''But Here We Are'' became this after for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized album in years.

to:

** ''But Here We Are'' became this after for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized album in years.

Added: 270

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WinBackTheCrowd: ''Wasting Light'' finished the winning back that ''Echoes'' started after ''One by One'' and ''In Your Honor'' lost some fans.

to:

* WinBackTheCrowd: WinBackTheCrowd:
**
''Wasting Light'' finished the winning back that ''Echoes'' started after ''One by One'' and ''In Your Honor'' lost some fans.fans.
** ''But Here We Are'' became this after for the SeasonalRot mentioned above, deemed one of their most inspired and energized album in years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BuryYourArt: The band seemed to take this approach with "The One", a non-album track that was done for the Orange County soundtrack. Even though it received a lot of radio airplay and its video was often played on music channels, they cancelled its full release as a single (except in Australia) and did not include it on "One By One" (despite the similar title), burying it on the b-side to "All My Life" in the UK and Europe. Also, they passed it up for both their compilations Greatest Hits and The Essential Foo Fighters, and don't play it live. It was a very popular song at the time, and so this is particularly odd to fans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SignatureSong: "My Hero" (it's used in a hundred movies, TV shows and commercials), "Everlong" (their most streamed song), "Learn to Fly", "Best of You", "The Pretender" and "All My Life".

to:

* SignatureSong: "My Hero" (it's used in a hundred movies, TV shows and commercials), "Everlong" (their most streamed song), "Learn to Fly", "Best of You", "The Pretender" and Pretender", "All My Life".Life", "Times Like These" and "The Sky is A Neighborhood".

Added: 279

Changed: 1232

Removed: 620

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BuryYourArt:
** The band seemed to take this approach with "The One", a non-album track that was done for the Orange County soundtrack. Even though it received a lot of radio airplay and its video was often played on music channels, they cancelled its full release as a single (except in Australia) and did not include it on "One By One" (despite the similar title), burying it on the b-side to "All My Life" in the UK and Europe. Also, they passed it up for both their compilations Greatest Hits and The Essential Foo Fighters, and don't play it live. It was a very popular song at the time, and so this is particularly odd to fans.

to:

* BuryYourArt:
**
BuryYourArt: The band seemed to take this approach with "The One", a non-album track that was done for the Orange County soundtrack. Even though it received a lot of radio airplay and its video was often played on music channels, they cancelled its full release as a single (except in Australia) and did not include it on "One By One" (despite the similar title), burying it on the b-side to "All My Life" in the UK and Europe. Also, they passed it up for both their compilations Greatest Hits and The Essential Foo Fighters, and don't play it live. It was a very popular song at the time, and so this is particularly odd to fans.



* NeverLiveItDown: William Goldsmith, largely due to his inability to accept his drumming wasn't right for the group and tendency to blame Dave Grohl. In fairness, Grohl gave him the opportunity to do plenty of takes to get it right.
** A ''very'' VocalMinority will never forget the fact the Foo Fighters supported the "AIDS isn't a real disease" movement, despite the band long moved on from it (it only ended among the causes they supported due to Nate Mendel) and has not shown support for it in years.

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: NeverLiveItDown:
**
William Goldsmith, largely due to his inability to accept his drumming wasn't right for the group and tendency to blame Dave Grohl. In fairness, Grohl gave him the opportunity to do plenty of takes to get it right.
** A ''very'' VocalMinority will never forget the fact the Foo Fighters supported the "AIDS isn't a real disease" movement, despite the band having long moved on from it (it only ended among the causes they supported due to Nate Mendel) and has not shown support for it in years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BuryYourArt:
** The band seemed to take this approach with "The One", a non-album track that was done for the Orange County soundtrack. Even though it received a lot of radio airplay and its video was often played on music channels, they cancelled its full release as a single (except in Australia) and did not include it on "One By One" (despite the similar title), burying it on the b-side to "All My Life" in the UK and Europe. Also, they passed it up for both their compilations Greatest Hits and The Essential Foo Fighters, and don't play it live. It was a very popular song at the time, and so this is particularly odd to fans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: After ''Wasting Light'' was deemed their best album since the first three, the general consensus is that [[ToughActToFollow the follow-ups weren't as good]], with ''Concrete & Gold'' in particular being their lowest rated on [=RateYourMusic=].

to:

* SeasonalRot: After ''Wasting Light'' was deemed their best album since the first three, the general consensus is that [[ToughActToFollow the follow-ups weren't as good]], with ''Concrete & Gold'' ''Medicine at Midnight'' in particular being their lowest rated on [=RateYourMusic=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MisattributedSong: The disco song "Kung Fu Fighting" is often credited to the Foo Fighters on file-sharing sites. The song was actually performed by Carl Douglas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Pat Smear was a member of Music/TheGerms, a punk rock band who were around during the time when the DiscoSucks mindset was prominent amongst rock fans. Fast-forward to 2021 where Pat participated in the creation of the disco cover album ''Hail Satin''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeasonalRot: Aside from ''Wasting Light'', the general consensus is that the albums usually trended downward in quality after ''The Colour and the Shape''. Either the subsequent ''Sonic Highways'' or ''Concrete & Gold'' are their nadir, the former being lower rated on [=RateYourMusic=] than any of the other Foo albums.

to:

* SeasonalRot: Aside from After ''Wasting Light'', Light'' was deemed their best album since the first three, the general consensus is that [[ToughActToFollow the albums usually trended downward in quality after ''The Colour and the Shape''. Either the subsequent ''Sonic Highways'' or follow-ups weren't as good]], with ''Concrete & Gold'' are in particular being their nadir, the former being lower lowest rated on [=RateYourMusic=] than any of the other Foo albums.[=RateYourMusic=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Music/DaveGrohl. In fact, the first album was [[IAmTheBand made completely by him]], with the help of a producer and only the guitar part in "X-Static" played by another musician (Greg Dulli of Music/TheAfghanWhigs).

to:

** Music/DaveGrohl. In fact, the first album was [[IAmTheBand made almost completely by him]], with the help of a producer and only the guitar part in "X-Static" played by another musician (Greg Dulli of Music/TheAfghanWhigs).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----

Top