Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / CucumberQuest

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Jossed. It's actually [[spoiler:Mistmaster]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Also, it's hard to notice, but you can see that Ametrine is wearing a 'f' necklace, similar to Piano's 'p' necklace. It's very likely that the 'f' stands for 'forte' (a musical term meaning 'loudly'), since the 'p' in Piano's necklace stands for her name ('piano', besides meaning the instrument, is also a musical term meaning 'softly' or 'quietly'; yes, it's an IronicName). It's possible that the matching necklaces is a symbol of their friendship, or maybe even their romantic love for each other.

to:

Also, it's hard to notice, but you can see that Ametrine is wearing a 'f' necklace, similar to Piano's 'p' necklace. It's very likely that the 'f' stands for 'forte' (a musical term meaning 'loudly'), since the 'p' in Piano's necklace stands for her name ('piano', besides meaning the instrument, is also a musical term meaning 'softly' or 'quietly'; yes, it's an IronicName). It's possible that the matching necklaces is a symbol of their friendship, or maybe even their romantic love for each other.other.

[[WMG:The Dream Oracle knows about the Nightmare Knight's HeelFaceTurn.]]
* And that's why she is so negligent. She ''knows'' that she doesn't need to put in any actual effort. She can just goof around all she wants, and the Nightmare Knight will still be defeated and the cycle preserved. As for why she has never tried to break the cycle? It's the same reason the Nightmare Knight can't. She draws power from the myths of the Legendary Hero defeating the Nightmare, so breaking the cycle would break her power.

Added: 960

Changed: 271

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None








* Jossed

to:

* Jossed
Jossed.



* Jossed, it's [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-524/ Rosemaster.]] However, the "inverse naming" theory is confirmed, as she was originally called Thornmaster (as in "every flower has its thorns").

to:

* Jossed, it's [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-524/ Rosemaster.]] However, the "inverse naming" theory is sort of confirmed, as she was originally called Thornmaster (as in "every flower has its thorns").



* Unlikely, as of 824-828. After all, [[Spoiler: they share a common weakness.]]

to:

* Unlikely, as of 824-828. After all, [[Spoiler: [[spoiler: they share a common weakness.]]



How else would a 'glitch' exist but as a malfunction in something else? In this case, inside the system of an otherwise only slightly eccentric, techno-savvy princess...who seems to have constant problems with their otherwise fine inventions constantly 'glitching'

to:

How else would a 'glitch' exist but as a malfunction in something else? In this case, inside the system of an otherwise only slightly eccentric, techno-savvy princess... who seems to have constant problems with their otherwise fine inventions constantly 'glitching'
'glitching'.




to:

* [[spoiler:The former is Jossed, since pages 714-716 show that Cosmo is working *with* Glitchmaster.]]



It's very odd that both Thebestmaster AND Steve were apparently sealed. And one had to be released before the other could be released. It's stated that the Nightmare Knight we know never had a childhood, which means he didn't came into the world by natural means (i.e. being born). Whatever powers that be that created the Knightmare Knight also created Steve, but he just wasn't villainous enough to be a real threat and his own Disaster Master, Besty, was also subpar. This might be why he was sealed, because he was too weak for the job.

to:

It's very odd that both Thebestmaster AND Steve were apparently sealed. And one had to be released before the other could be released. It's stated that the Nightmare Knight we know never had a childhood, which means he didn't came into the world by natural means (i.e. being born). Whatever powers that be that created the Knightmare Nightmare Knight also created Steve, but he just wasn't villainous enough to be a real threat and his own Disaster Master, Besty, was also subpar. This might be why he was sealed, because he was too weak for the job.



Gigi's already had a lot of inspiration from [[VideoGame/{{PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor}} TTYD,]] so why not add in something inspired from that and would likely cause Cucumber to embrace his role as not the Legendary Hero, but as someone fighting for Dreamside as a whole. ThePowerOfFriendship would fit in a comic like this anyway.

to:

Gigi's already had a lot of inspiration from [[VideoGame/{{PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor}} TTYD,]] TTYD]], so why not add in something inspired from that and would likely cause Cucumber to embrace his role as not the Legendary Hero, but as someone fighting for Dreamside as a whole. ThePowerOfFriendship would fit in a comic like this anyway.




to:

* Possibly Jossed; [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-857/ this page]] implied that Cucumber got his wand back from the wand cleaners themselves.



Maybe it's a little too predictable, but it could end with Peridot telling the Nightmare Knight something like "You're my ''real'' hero", which would be freakin' adorable.

to:

Maybe it's a little too predictable, but it could end with Peridot telling the Nightmare Knight something like "You're my ''real'' hero", which would be freakin' adorable.adorable.
* [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-857/ Jossed.]] The actress who played Pumice, Tephra, is actually really nice.

[[WMG:Princess Piano and Princess Ametrine will soon become lovers, or they already are.]]
In [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-501/ this page]], Piano blushes upon mentioning Ametrine (or "Ammie" as she calls her), and [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/chapter-2-bonus-2/ one of the Q&A bits]] show that their friendship goes way back.

Also, it's hard to notice, but you can see that Ametrine is wearing a 'f' necklace, similar to Piano's 'p' necklace. It's very likely that the 'f' stands for 'forte' (a musical term meaning 'loudly'), since the 'p' in Piano's necklace stands for her name ('piano', besides meaning the instrument, is also a musical term meaning 'softly' or 'quietly'; yes, it's an IronicName). It's possible that the matching necklaces is a symbol of their friendship, or maybe even their romantic love for each other.

Added: 90

Changed: 598

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Not Jossed? This seems to be in reference to the wand Cucumber got from Saturday's treasure hoard, not [[spoiler:the Pumice one.]]




to:

* Jossed




to:

* Unlikely, as of 824-828. After all, [[Spoiler: they share a common weakness.]]





to:

\n* Confirmed, though the exact details of Peridot's past are unconfirmed.





to:

* Seems to be pretty thoroughly Jossed.



* Jossed. As of Intermission 4, the Guardener's appearance seems to be just how they look.




to:

* As was pointed out on Tumblr relatively recently, the depiction of the Nightmare Knight on [[spoiler:Punisher Pumice]] has two sets of horn-like projections on the sides: one set that has a hard angle like the Nightmare Knight's, and one that's curved like Steve's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Actually confirmed! Saturday and Azalea are the same person.]]

to:

* [[spoiler: Actually confirmed! Saturday and Azalea are the same person. And Cucumber's reaction was indeed funny.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Sky Kingdom's Disaster Master is indeed named "Cloudmaster".]]
Maybe ''Punisher Pumice'' is not THAT inaccurate after all [but still very inaccurate].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Just a hunch.

to:

Just a hunch.hunch.

[[WMG:Pumice will turn out to be a NiceCharacterMeanActor, resulting in a BrokenPedestal for Peridot.]]
Maybe it's a little too predictable, but it could end with Peridot telling the Nightmare Knight something like "You're my ''real'' hero", which would be freakin' adorable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-827/ We see Peridot crying and surrounded by orbs]] when Cordelia reminisces on how they met. These could be what she believed were the dream stones, and attempted to summon the Nightmare Knight for whatever reason; when they didn't work and/or a space ship landed right in front of her, she broke down crying and Cordelia took pity.

to:

[[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-827/ We see Peridot crying and surrounded by orbs]] when Cordelia reminisces on how they met. These could be what she believed were the dream stones, and attempted to summon the Nightmare Knight for whatever reason; when they didn't work and/or a space ship landed right in front of her, she broke down crying and Cordelia took pity.pity.

[[WMG: Pumice has Cucumber's wand.]]
Just a hunch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Gigi's already had a lot of inspiration from [[VideoGame/{{PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor}} TTYD,]] so why not add in something inspired from that and would likely cause Cucumber to embrace his role as not the Legendary Hero, but as someone fighting for Dreamside as a whole. ThePowerOfFriendship would fit in a comic like this anyway.

to:

Gigi's already had a lot of inspiration from [[VideoGame/{{PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor}} TTYD,]] so why not add in something inspired from that and would likely cause Cucumber to embrace his role as not the Legendary Hero, but as someone fighting for Dreamside as a whole. ThePowerOfFriendship would fit in a comic like this anyway.anyway.

[[WMG: Peridot was the one who told Cordelia of the Nightmare Knight myth, and tried to summon him first.]]
[[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-827/ We see Peridot crying and surrounded by orbs]] when Cordelia reminisces on how they met. These could be what she believed were the dream stones, and attempted to summon the Nightmare Knight for whatever reason; when they didn't work and/or a space ship landed right in front of her, she broke down crying and Cordelia took pity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the first book, the [[https://comicscube.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/cucumber_quest_donut_kingdom_map.png map]] of the Donut Kingdom shows the strange platform in the middle of it. The flavor text mentions that it's rumored to be a portal to an "alternate world" of Dreamside. The platform itself is noticeably the kind of purple associated with the Nightmare Knight, and Besty outright mentions a "portal" on page 813. Steve seems to be the outright opposite of the NK, from being shorter and skinny to outwardly nicer, possibly indicating he's an alternate counterpart.

to:

In the first book, the [[https://comicscube.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/cucumber_quest_donut_kingdom_map.png map]] of the Donut Kingdom shows the strange platform in the middle of it. The flavor text mentions that it's rumored to be a portal to an "alternate world" of Dreamside. The platform itself is noticeably the kind of purple associated with the Nightmare Knight, and Besty outright mentions a "portal" on page 813. Steve seems to be the outright opposite of the NK, from being shorter and skinny to outwardly nicer, possibly indicating he's an alternate counterpart.counterpart.

[[WMG: Near or during the final battle, Cucumber and co. will be cheered on by their allies from previous chapters.]]
Gigi's already had a lot of inspiration from [[VideoGame/{{PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor}} TTYD,]] so why not add in something inspired from that and would likely cause Cucumber to embrace his role as not the Legendary Hero, but as someone fighting for Dreamside as a whole. ThePowerOfFriendship would fit in a comic like this anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


...seen [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-728/ here]], is ''not'' Quakemaster, and they are not in the Crystal Kingdom. Instead, they reign over the Sky Kingdom. Going by the "inverse naming" theory, their name would be "Stormmaster" or something like that.

to:

...seen [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-728/ here]], is ''not'' Quakemaster, and they are not in the Crystal Kingdom. Instead, they reign over the Sky Kingdom. Going by the "inverse naming" theory, their name would be "Stormmaster" or something like that.that.

[[WMG: Steve is from the rumored alternate universe accessable from the Donut Kingdom. ]]
In the first book, the [[https://comicscube.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/cucumber_quest_donut_kingdom_map.png map]] of the Donut Kingdom shows the strange platform in the middle of it. The flavor text mentions that it's rumored to be a portal to an "alternate world" of Dreamside. The platform itself is noticeably the kind of purple associated with the Nightmare Knight, and Besty outright mentions a "portal" on page 813. Steve seems to be the outright opposite of the NK, from being shorter and skinny to outwardly nicer, possibly indicating he's an alternate counterpart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At least partially jossed, Steve's friendliness to Thebestmaster seems genuine. It remains to be seen how he'll act towards the heroes, but at this point this theory seems unlikely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Jossed. Turns out it was just a [[spoiler: TV show prop.]]

Added: 887

Changed: 882

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The "Disaster Master in disguise theory" is Jossed. [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-714/ These]] [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-715/ three]] [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-716/ pages]] show [[spoiler:Cosmo working ''with'' a Disaster Master, not ''as'' a Disaster Master.]]



* Looks pretty unlikely at this point, since [[spoiler: Azalea was confirmed to be the Flower Kingdom princess.]] Unless she happened to have a renegade sister, which is unlikely. [[spoiler: Actually confirmed! Saturday and Azalea are the same person.]]

to:

* Looks pretty unlikely at this point, since [[spoiler: Azalea was confirmed to be the Flower Kingdom princess.]] Unless she happened to have a renegade sister, which is unlikely. unlikely.
*
[[spoiler: Actually confirmed! Saturday and Azalea are the same person.]]]]



They both seem have crushes on each other, due to how often they end up helping each other out. Either that, or Peridot's love in unrequited.

to:

They both seem have crushes on each other, due to how often they end up helping each other out. Either that, or Peridot's love in is unrequited.



* Jossed, it's [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-524/ Rosemaster.]] However, the "inverse naming" theory is confirmed, as she was originally called Thornmaster (as in "ever flower has its thorns").

to:

* Jossed, it's [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-524/ Rosemaster.]] However, the "inverse naming" theory is confirmed, as she was originally called Thornmaster (as in "ever "every flower has its thorns").



Taking into account the Knightmare Knight's jaded attitude, how he's doing everything like he's going through the motions to the point of almost looking tired of it, like he's acting out a role in a play he hates. Consider how he straight up saved the Melody Kingdom when it came into ''real'' danger, or even how he actively helped Cucumber past the magical locked door. Consider their surprisingly similar personalities, and how Cucumber showed instant proficiency in using the magic of the disaster stones. [[spoiler: It's not impossible the Knightmare Knight was the previous hero, having defeated his predecessor and forced into taking the mantle, ''just as his predecessor had''. He may be jaded because he knows Cucumber will succeed, only to be become the next Knightmare Knight and continue the cycle.]]



to:

Taking into account the Knightmare Nightmare Knight's jaded attitude, how he's doing everything like he's going through the motions to the point of almost looking tired of it, like he's acting out a role in a play he hates. Consider how he straight up saved the Melody Kingdom when it came into ''real'' danger, or even how he actively helped Cucumber past the magical locked door. Consider their surprisingly similar personalities, and how Cucumber showed instant proficiency in using the magic of the disaster stones. [[spoiler: It's not impossible the Knightmare Nightmare Knight was the previous hero, having defeated his predecessor and forced into taking the mantle, ''just as his predecessor had''. He may be jaded because he knows Cucumber will succeed, only to be become the next Knightmare Nightmare Knight and continue the cycle.]]


]]
* [[spoiler:Jossed; NK's backstory (in Interlude 3) shows that he and the Legendary Heroes are different people, and that the heroes do not take his place.]]




* Cosmo's gender hasn't really been specified. The reason why s/he isn't in the Space Kingdom is because s/he is in Dreamside, trying to escape the dastardly Glitch Master (Mentioned [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-508/ here, as Glitch----]]). Another great twist would be for Cosmo to be a boy-making him a Prince-which would create a whole new set of problems stemming from how there is no princess, a princess needs to sign the sword, etc.

to:

* Cosmo's gender hasn't really been specified. The reason why s/he isn't in the Space Kingdom is because s/he is in Dreamside, trying to escape the dastardly Glitch Master Glitchmaster (Mentioned [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-508/ here, as Glitch----]]). Another great twist would be for Cosmo to be a boy-making him a Prince-which would create a whole new set of problems stemming from how there is no princess, a princess needs to sign the sword, etc.




[[WMG: The reason why everyone is CONTANTLY forcing for Cucumber to be a hero is because....]]

to:

\n* But Almond's never been to an adventure before...?

[[WMG: The reason why everyone is CONTANTLY CONSTANTLY forcing for Cucumber to be a hero is because....]]



* Jossed; [[spoiler:Rosemaster is the one who manipulated everyone's memories, using flowers that bear their names (that's why there are bubbled flowers in the dungeon). Nautilus, Caboodle and Peridot are not named after flowers, so they're captured by the Roselings beforehand. Also, Aster [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-717/ here]] explicitly stated that the whole memory-erasing mess is Rose's doing.]]




to:

* Jossed; the kingdom and its royalty are totally fine. However, the kingdom is actually divided into two parts (the ice lands and the lava lands), and we haven't seen the latter part yet...



[[WMG: Cordelia is a vampire]].

to:

[[WMG: Cordelia is a vampire]].vampire.]]



* As a side note, it's likely that NK, after sealing away Steve in Drain World, impersonated Steve and tried to get Besty to be scary; when that proved impossible, he just sealed Besty away too.

to:

* As a side note, it's likely that NK, after sealing away Steve in Drain World, impersonated Steve and tried to get Besty to be scary; when that proved impossible, he just sealed Besty away too.too.

[[WMG: The cloud-like Disaster Master...]]
...seen [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-728/ here]], is ''not'' Quakemaster, and they are not in the Crystal Kingdom. Instead, they reign over the Sky Kingdom. Going by the "inverse naming" theory, their name would be "Stormmaster" or something like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's very odd that both Thebestmaster AND Steve were apparently sealed. And one had to be released before the other could be released. It's stated that the Nightmare Knight we know never had a childhood, which means he didn't came into the world by natural means (i.e. being born). Whatever powers that be that created the Knightmare Knight also created Steve, but he just wasn't villainous enough to be a real threat and his own Disaster Master, Besty, was also subpar. This might be why he was sealed, because he was too weak for the job.

to:

It's very odd that both Thebestmaster AND Steve were apparently sealed. And one had to be released before the other could be released. It's stated that the Nightmare Knight we know never had a childhood, which means he didn't came into the world by natural means (i.e. being born). Whatever powers that be that created the Knightmare Knight also created Steve, but he just wasn't villainous enough to be a real threat and his own Disaster Master, Besty, was also subpar. This might be why he was sealed, because he was too weak for the job.job.

[[WMG: Steve and Nightmare Knight are two halves of a LiteralSplitPersonality.]]
Steve is the fun side and Nightmare Knight is the fear side (since Steve is a more legit name, that was probably the name of the original). The two each went on to create their Masters, likely using a similar but fundamentally different method than the personality split did. It's also likely that NK sealed away Steve and Besty so that no one would see them and stop fearing him (so the Forsaken Master being the most terrible Master wasn't from the world's perspective but from NK's). He just decided to let Besty out this time because he is slowly accepting that it's okay for him to not be feared by everyone.
*As a side note, it's likely that NK, after sealing away Steve in Drain World, impersonated Steve and tried to get Besty to be scary; when that proved impossible, he just sealed Besty away too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


We're on strip [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-811/ 811]] as of this writing. Steve seems to be the exact opposite of the Nightmare Knight, so since Nighty seems imposing but is actually tragic, maybe Steve's seemingly friendly behavior is just a facade. Maybe ''that's'' why Thebestmaster is afraid of him! Look how Steve's smile falters in the last panel. Maybe he's just trying to reassure Thebestmaster, but maybe he's going to fly into a rage in the next strip.

to:

We're on strip [[http://cucumber.gigidigi.com/cq/page-811/ 811]] as of this writing. Steve seems to be the exact opposite of the Nightmare Knight, so since Nighty seems imposing but is actually tragic, maybe Steve's seemingly friendly behavior is just a facade. Maybe ''that's'' why Thebestmaster is afraid of him! Look how Steve's smile falters in the last panel. Maybe he's just trying to reassure Thebestmaster, but maybe he's going to fly into a rage in the next strip.strip.

[[WMG: Steve is a FlawedPrototype.]]
It's very odd that both Thebestmaster AND Steve were apparently sealed. And one had to be released before the other could be released. It's stated that the Nightmare Knight we know never had a childhood, which means he didn't came into the world by natural means (i.e. being born). Whatever powers that be that created the Knightmare Knight also created Steve, but he just wasn't villainous enough to be a real threat and his own Disaster Master, Besty, was also subpar. This might be why he was sealed, because he was too weak for the job.

Top