Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / BeautyAndTheBeast2017

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: LeFou is dyslexic.]]
The village has a schoolhouse for boys, yet LeFou is illiterate. Why is that? Well, maybe when he was a boy, he tried to learn to read, but could never get the hang of it. Since the village's culture is so small-minded, the schoolmaster likely didn't realize he had a disability, but just dismissed him as stupid and gave up trying to teach him.

to:

[[WMG: LeFou Lefou is dyslexic.]]
The village has a schoolhouse for boys, yet LeFou Lefou is illiterate. Why is that? Well, maybe when he was a boy, he tried to learn to read, but could never get the hang of it. Since the village's culture is so small-minded, the schoolmaster likely didn't realize he had a disability, but just dismissed him as stupid and gave up trying to teach him.

Added: 372

Changed: 234

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** How would this work? Belle and the Beast's romance arc in this version takes place over just five days in June. Would Belle decide to take advantage of the EndlessWinter and have a [[ChristmasInJuly Christmas in June]] celebration?

[[WMG: LeFou is dyslexic.]]
The village has a schoolhouse for boys, yet LeFou is illiterate. Why is that? Well, maybe when he was a boy, he tried to learn to read, but could never get the hang of it. Since the village's culture is so small-minded, the schoolmaster likely didn't realize he had a disability, but just dismissed him as stupid and gave up trying to teach him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[WMG: The sequel will be an adaptation of ''WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeastTheEnchantedChristmas''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Bimbettes In this film are Belle’s paternal half-sisters]]
While we know Maurice is a widower, we don’t see the Bimbettes’ father, only their mother. You COULD make the argument that he divorced her for bearing girls, but if that were the case, wouldn’t they be beggars, like Agathe? Also, the mother dotes on Belle.

Maybe when Maurice first moved to the village, he met the mother of the Bimbettes (who I’m gonna call Rosalind for this theory) and they had a secret affair which resulted in the birth of the triplet girls.

As for how they aren’t beggars, it may be a similar situation to Clothilde (who also isn’t a beggar herself).

And after the spell was lifted, maybe Maurice married Rosalind and Belle invited her half- sisters to live in the castle as her royal ladies-in-waiting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil FusionDance of Dragon Maleficent and Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', but taken UpToEleven as it would take influences from ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths, with the characters included being:

to:

The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil FusionDance of Dragon Maleficent and Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', but taken UpToEleven up to eleven as it would take influences from ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths, with the characters included being:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Belle's the village weirdo, despite being the town's "most beautiful woman". She can read, has mechanical inclination (anticipating her father's next needed tool/component, designing, prototyping, and constructing a churning clothes washer), has pro-education sentiments, and asserts herself rationally towards Beast's and Gaston's obstinacy. However, she has a romantic streak when it comes to reading stories (as per the "Prince Charming" part of her IAmSong at the beginning and her love for ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet''). Beast, conversely, has had his broodiness dialed up to eleven, and now a dyed-in-the-wool Byronic Hero. However, he had his pick of beautiful debutantes as shown in the prologue; he's attracted to Belle ''because'' of her enlightened intellect ("[[Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream Love looks not with the eyes but with the mind]]"), shares her dislike of rustic life ("Your village sounds terrible"), and has an initial dislike of silly romance stories (until he catches the bug from Belle). Belle is Enlightened with a Romantic streak, Beast is Romantic with an Enlightened streak.

to:

Belle's the village weirdo, despite being the town's "most beautiful woman". She can read, has mechanical inclination (anticipating her father's next needed tool/component, designing, prototyping, and constructing a churning clothes washer), has pro-education sentiments, and asserts herself rationally towards Beast's and Gaston's obstinacy. However, she has a romantic streak when it comes to reading stories (as per the "Prince Charming" part of her IAmSong at the beginning and her love for ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet''). Beast, conversely, has had his broodiness dialed up to eleven, and now a dyed-in-the-wool Byronic Hero. However, he had despite having his pick of beautiful debutantes as shown in the prologue; he's attracted to Belle ''because'' of her enlightened intellect ("[[Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream Love looks not with the eyes but with the mind]]"), shares her dislike of rustic life ("Your village sounds terrible"), and has an initial dislike of silly romance stories (until he catches the bug from Belle). Belle is Enlightened with a Romantic streak, Beast is Romantic with an Enlightened streak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The Cursed Child actually undoes all those arguments. There are more time turners in it and they travel back years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The Enchantress's life as "Agathe" was meant as a punishment[[labelnote:*]]While there is a tie-in novel that explains the Enchantresses actions, I'm choosing to ignore it as [[SchrodingersCanon it's not in the movie.]][[/labelnote]].]]

The Enchantress, or "Agathe" is a member of some sort of magical coven/fae realm/whatever; powerful in her own right, but bound by the laws that govern her particular group. Unfortunately, cursing the entire castle/the town nearby broke those rules. No one would have objected if she had cursed the prince alone, and maybe those who actually had a hand in raising him to who he was, but ''everyone'' else ''as well as'' removing the memories of the people in castle from those in the town? That was too much, and as a result, the Enchantress was forced to take the form of "Agathe" and live within the town without powers until the curse broke or the last petal fell. That's why she never did anything about Gaston, or the insane asylum, and why she couldn't cast any magic until the very end.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil FusionDance of Dragon Maleficent and Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', but taken UpToEleven as it would take influences from {{ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths}}, with the characters included being:

to:

The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil FusionDance of Dragon Maleficent and Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', but taken UpToEleven as it would take influences from {{ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths}}, ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths, with the characters included being:



* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[film/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.

to:

* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[film/TheJungleBook2016 ''[[Film/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[Disney/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.

to:

* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[Disney/TheJungleBook2016 ''[[film/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** LeFou helps Gaston to control himself by reminding him of the violence and bloodshed (and the widows).

to:

** LeFou Lefou helps Gaston to control himself by reminding him of the violence and bloodshed (and the widows).



* Inability to reconnect with loved ones (LeFou and Belle in the mob scene)

to:

* Inability to reconnect with loved ones (LeFou (Lefou and Belle in the mob scene)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


C
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It makes sense to have the wolves be a part of the curse in general. The wolves seem to herd Maurice to the castle at the beginning of the film and when Belle flees from the castle they give chase. . .''as if to take her back.''

to:

** It makes sense to have the wolves be a part of the curse in general. The wolves seem to herd Maurice to the castle at the beginning of the film and when Belle flees from the castle they give chase. . .''as '' As if to take her back.''

Added: 17

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Oh, that's an actor reference!


[[foldercontrol]]



The propensity of magic in the story makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter universe. Hermione decided to take a year off after the Battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of Belle, but forgot her wand. Both characters are played by Creator/EmmaWatson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. This is a 'sequel' to Harry Potter's experiences with TheWomanInBlack.

to:

The propensity of magic in the story makes me want to connect it to the HarryPotter Franchise/HarryPotter universe. Hermione decided to take a year off after the Battle of Hogwarts, went on a time travel vacation, and assumed the identity of Belle, but forgot her wand. Both characters are played by Creator/EmmaWatson, love reading, and are in excessively magical circumstances at a castle. This is a 'sequel' to Harry Potter's experiences with TheWomanInBlack.''Film/TheWomanInBlack''.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: The finale was setting up another curse.]]
The reason The Enchantress was present for the final battle was to see if a new curse would be placed, this time on the villagers. However, when Gaston died and Belle announced her love for the Beast, the original curse was lifted instead. If Gaston had succeeded in killing the Beast and then claiming/killing Belle, he would become the next Beast and the villagers would also be cursed in poetically appropriate ways.

Added: 36

Changed: 129

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', with the characters included being:

to:

The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil FusionDance of Dragon Maleficent and Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', but taken UpToEleven as it would take influences from {{ComicBook/CrisisOnInfiniteEarths}}, with the characters included being:


Added DiffLines:

*Maleficent: TBD.
*Christopher Robin
C
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 1837

Changed: 993

Removed: 1380

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Had the curse's stipulations been the same as in this film, Forte would've been a much more dependable protagonist.]]
The animated Forte wanted the curse to never break as he felt he performed his role much better as an organ. This film adds in the complication that if the time limit expires and the curse remains unbroken, the servants will become inanimate objects forever. Had this been in play in the animated film, Forte would've actively tried to help break the curse since he will die with the others if it isn't broken. In other words, Cadenza is a look at what a hero Forte could've been had the circumstances (and Forte's personality) been different.

to:

[[WMG: Had the curse's stipulations been the same as in this film, Forte would've been a much more dependable protagonist.]]
The animated Forte wanted the curse to never break as he felt he performed his role much better as an organ. This film adds in the complication that if the time limit expires and the curse remains unbroken, the servants will become inanimate objects forever. Had this been in play in the animated film, Forte would've actively tried to help break the curse since he will die with the others if it isn't broken. In other words, Cadenza is a look at what a hero Forte could've been had the circumstances (and Forte's personality) been different.
[[folder:Jossed Theories]]



Looking at the ruined family portrait, the Beast is depicted as a child wielding a scepter, indicating royal authority or sovereignty. In this version, the Beast lost his father at a young age and is actually the King.

The man and woman are his uncle (possibly the late King's younger brother who was pushed down the line of succession following the Beast's birth) and mother and respectively, the Beast's prince and queen regents. Maybe it was the Prince Regent who turned away the Enchantress.

to:

Looking at the ruined family portrait, the Beast is depicted as a child wielding a scepter, indicating royal authority or sovereignty. In this version, the Beast lost his father at a young age and is actually the King.

King. The man and woman are his uncle (possibly the late King's younger brother who was pushed down the line of succession following the Beast's birth) and mother and respectively, the Beast's prince and queen regents. Maybe it was the Prince Regent who turned away the Enchantress.
Enchantress.




[[WMG: The film will be successful to the point that Disney will make plans to do a CrisisCrossover film for it and some of the other live-action remake films, both previous and upcoming ones.]]
The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', with the characters included being:
* Yen Sid: Introduced in the crossover film.
* The Beast: The one from this film of course.
* Belle: Of course she would be part of it too.
* Mulan: From the upcoming 2018 film adaptation.
* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[Disney/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.
* Alice: From the two previous films... but only so they can still profit from the character without having to give [[Film/AliceThroughTheLookingGlass her previous film]] after it was a BoxOfficeBomb.
* And possibly more, but that'll have to wait until more is known about the upcoming films.

to:

\n[[WMG: The film will be successful to the point that Disney will make plans to do a CrisisCrossover film for it and some of the other live-action remake films, both previous and upcoming ones.]]\nThe films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', with the characters included being: \n* Yen Sid: Introduced in the crossover film. \n* The Beast: The one from this film of course.\n* Belle: Of course she would be part of it too.\n* Mulan: From the upcoming 2018 film adaptation.\n* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[Disney/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.\n* Alice: From the two previous films... but only so they can still profit from the character without having to give [[Film/AliceThroughTheLookingGlass her previous film]] after it was a BoxOfficeBomb.\n* And possibly more, but that'll have to wait until more is known about the upcoming films.\n[[/folder]]

[[folder:Confirmed Theories]]



----




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Other Theories]]
[[WMG: Had the curse's stipulations in the animated film been the same as in this film, Forte would've been a much more dependable protagonist.]]
The animated Forte wanted the curse to never break as he felt he performed his role much better as an organ. This film adds in the complication that if the time limit expires and the curse remains unbroken, the servants will become inanimate objects forever. Had this been in play in the animated film, Forte would've actively tried to help break the curse since he will die with the others if it isn't broken. In other words, Cadenza is a look at what a hero Forte could've been had the circumstances (and Forte's personality) been different.

[[WMG: The film will be successful to the point that Disney will make plans to do a CrisisCrossover film for it and some of the other live-action remake films, both previous and upcoming ones.]]
The films used will be shown to be part of a SharedUniverse, albeit in varying time periods. Yen Sid uses his magic to bring some of the characters from the previous films together in order to create a team to help him defeat the evil Chernabog. Yes, it would essentially be a Disney version of ''Film/{{The Avengers|2012}}'', with the characters included being:
* Yen Sid: Introduced in the crossover film.
* The Beast: The one from this film of course.
* Belle: Of course she would be part of it too.
* Mulan: From the upcoming 2018 film adaptation.
* Mowgli: From the live-action ''[[Disney/TheJungleBook2016 Jungle Book]]'' film.
* Alice: From the two previous films... but only so they can still profit from the character without having to give [[Film/AliceThroughTheLookingGlass her previous film]] after it was a BoxOfficeBomb.
* And possibly more, but that'll have to wait until more is known about the upcoming films.



She has amazing magical powers, her curse has arbitrary rules that have to be followed and she seems to follow a BlueAndOrangeMorality where punishing the staff fits into the plan to make the Beast find love but she feels no need to punish Gaston despite his rather worse crimes. She's also quite the shape-shifter and quick to take offense. Seems very Fae to me.

to:

She has amazing magical powers, her curse has arbitrary rules that have to be followed and she seems to follow a BlueAndOrangeMorality where punishing the staff fits into the plan to make the Beast find love but she feels no need to punish Gaston despite his rather worse crimes. She's also quite the shape-shifter and quick to take offense. Seems very Fae to me.me.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Of course this isn't really feasible, given the different time periods. Both Maurice and Phoebus are Kevin Kline in Paris, and Belle's mother was vaguely Romani looking, with long, luxuriant dark hair, and is said to have been "fearless," so let's just pretend. Even with Frollo dead, Phoebus was still technically a deserter, so he changed his name to Maurice to evade the law and became an artist. He and Esmeralda then settled down and had a daughter, but sadly [[spoiler: Esmeralda caught the plague, Maurice was forced to flee with baby Belle, etc.]] Where Quasimodo is during all this, and if he's still alive during the main ''Beauty and the Beast'' timeline, is [[FanficFuel an open question.]]

to:

Of course this isn't really feasible, given the different time periods. Both But both Maurice and Phoebus are Kevin Kline in Paris, and Belle's mother was vaguely Romani looking, with long, luxuriant dark hair, and is said to have been "fearless," so let's just pretend. Even with Frollo dead, Phoebus was still technically a deserter, so he changed his name to Maurice to evade the law and became an artist. He and Esmeralda then settled down and had a daughter, but sadly [[spoiler: Esmeralda caught the plague, Maurice was forced to flee with baby Belle, etc.]] Where Quasimodo is during all this, and if he's still alive during the main ''Beauty and the Beast'' timeline, is [[FanficFuel an open question.]]



Belle's the village weirdo, despite being the town's "most beautiful woman". She can read, has mechanical inclination (anticipating her father's next needed tool/component, designing, prototyping, and constructing a churning clothes washer), has pro-education sentiments, and asserts herself rationally towards Beast's and Gaston's obstinacy. However, she has a romantic streak when it comes to reading stories (as per the "Prince Charming" part of her IAmSong at the beginning). Beast, conversely, has had his broodiness dialed up to eleven, and now a dyed-in-the-wool Byronic Hero. However, he had his pick of beautiful debutantes as shown in the prologue; he's attracted to Belle ''because'' of her enlightened intellect ("[[Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream Love looks not with the eyes but with the mind]]"), shares her dislike of rustic life ("Your village sounds terrible"), and has an initial dislike of silly romance stories (until he catches the bug from Belle). Belle is Enlightened with a Romantic streak, Beast is Romantic with an Enlightened streak.

to:

Belle's the village weirdo, despite being the town's "most beautiful woman". She can read, has mechanical inclination (anticipating her father's next needed tool/component, designing, prototyping, and constructing a churning clothes washer), has pro-education sentiments, and asserts herself rationally towards Beast's and Gaston's obstinacy. However, she has a romantic streak when it comes to reading stories (as per the "Prince Charming" part of her IAmSong at the beginning).beginning and her love for ''Theatre/RomeoAndJuliet''). Beast, conversely, has had his broodiness dialed up to eleven, and now a dyed-in-the-wool Byronic Hero. However, he had his pick of beautiful debutantes as shown in the prologue; he's attracted to Belle ''because'' of her enlightened intellect ("[[Theatre/AMidsummerNightsDream Love looks not with the eyes but with the mind]]"), shares her dislike of rustic life ("Your village sounds terrible"), and has an initial dislike of silly romance stories (until he catches the bug from Belle). Belle is Enlightened with a Romantic streak, Beast is Romantic with an Enlightened streak.



In France, back in the day, it was not unusual for "prince" to simply be an aristocratic title, of someone with a high rank of nobility, but without ruling any actual territory and without any link to the royal family.
Think about it, not once, are the prince's parents referred to as "King" or "Queen" (except for in the credits). In the prologue it's mentioned that the prince heavily taxed the village, but how if he didn't actually rule the village? Simple! It's an isolated provincial town, he (or his father) just made them believe he was royalty (he sure seemed to be).

to:

In France, back in the day, it was not unusual for "prince" to simply be an aristocratic title, of someone with a high rank of nobility, but without ruling any actual territory and without any link to the royal family.
family. Think about it, not once, are the prince's parents referred to as "King" or "Queen" (except for in the credits). In the prologue it's mentioned that the prince heavily taxed the village, but how if he didn't actually rule the village? Simple! It's an isolated provincial town, he (or his father) just made them believe he was royalty (he sure seemed to be).
be). Alternately, he could be a relative of the royal family (possibly a nephew or cousin), just not in direct line for the throne.

Top