Follow TV Tropes

Following

History VideoGame / WhatRemainsOfEdithFinch

Go To

OR

Added: 802

Changed: 460

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FlippingTheBird: Gus to his father when ordered to join the group photo at the wedding.



** [[spoiler: By simply looking down, you can see Edith's protruding round belly. To observant players, the confirmation that she is pregnant will not be much of a surprise.]]
** The organ music in the beginning could possibly be [[spoiler: music at Edith's own funeral]]. It's also surprisingly cheery, hinting [[spoiler: at the [[BittersweetEnding bittersweet nature]] of the ending, along with Edith facing her future DeathByChildbirth with grace]].

to:

** [[spoiler: By [[spoiler:By simply looking down, you can see Edith's protruding round belly. To observant players, the confirmation that she is pregnant will not be much of a surprise.]]
** The organ music in the beginning could possibly be [[spoiler: music [[spoiler:music at Edith's own funeral]]. It's also surprisingly cheery, hinting [[spoiler: at the [[BittersweetEnding bittersweet nature]] of the ending, along with Edith facing her future DeathByChildbirth with grace]].



** One framed headline in Edie's room addresses the rumor of a "mole man" living under the Finch home, which Edie jokingly went along with. [[spoiler:This rumor was a way for Edie to help Walter stay hidden from the outside world and the curse by extension, since he was in fact living in a secret bunker beneath the house.]]



** In Edith Sr's room, next to the door leading to the pink bathroom, there's a picture of a baby being bathed. [[spoiler: It's likely that this is a picture of Gregory, who drowned in that bathroom.]]
** When leaving Calvin's room, Edith mentions that the secret passages were built "for smaller hands and bellies". [[spoiler: It's a hint that Edith is pregnant at the time of the narration.]]
** There is also a line of narration after Walter's death scene where Edith says that there is only one "or maybe two" members of the Finch family left. While it would be reasonable for the player to assume she is referring to her brother, Milton, whose body was never found and therefore could still be alive, later events imply she is [[spoiler: actually referring to her unborn child]].

to:

** In Edith Sr's room, next to the door leading to the pink bathroom, there's a picture of a baby being bathed. [[spoiler: It's [[spoiler:It's likely that this is a picture of Gregory, who drowned in that bathroom.]]
** When leaving Calvin's room, Edith mentions that the secret passages were built "for smaller hands and bellies". [[spoiler: It's [[spoiler:It's a hint that Edith is pregnant at the time of the narration.]]
]]
** While following the path from the train tunnel to the shore, a folding chair can be seen stuck in a tree. [[spoiler:It's one final reminder of the storm that tore up Sam's wedding and toppled a totem pole onto Gus.]]
** There is also a line of narration after Walter's death scene where Edith says that there is only one "or maybe two" members of the Finch family left. While it would be reasonable for the player to assume she is referring to her brother, Milton, whose body was never found and therefore could still be alive, later events imply she is [[spoiler: actually [[spoiler:actually referring to her unborn child]].



** Sam's attempt to combat the family curse was to become knowledgeable about survival and be prepared for anything. [[spoiler: His death happened in the one moment he decided to let his guard down, when he ignored Dawn's claims that the deer she just shot was {{Not Quite Dead}}.]]

to:

** Sam's attempt to combat the family curse was to become knowledgeable about survival and be prepared for anything. [[spoiler: His death happened in the one moment he decided to let his guard down, when he ignored Dawn's claims that the deer she just shot was {{Not Quite Dead}}.NotQuiteDead.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On the mundane side, the Finches are somewhat prone to melodrama and risk-seeking, and their belief in the curse explicitly affects their decision-making; see Odin putting his house on a barge and sailing it across the Atlantic ''and'' up the Pacific in a desperate hope that this would shake the curse. It's also easy to read most of the deaths being caused by poor decisions and dramatic gestures made in the hopes of escaping a curse that never existed ([[spoiler: i.e. Walter hiding underground in fear of the curse until he died in his desperation to see the sun again, Sam becoming a survivalist hoping to overcome the curse and being killed on a hunting trip]]), instead of merely living their lives out as best they could.

to:

** On the mundane side, the Finches are somewhat prone to melodrama and risk-seeking, and their belief in the curse explicitly affects their decision-making; see Odin putting his house on a barge and sailing it across the Atlantic ''and'' up the Pacific in a desperate hope that this would shake the curse. It's also easy to read most of the deaths being caused by poor decisions and dramatic gestures made in the hopes of escaping a curse that never existed ([[spoiler: i.e. Walter hiding underground in fear of the curse until he died in his desperation to see the sun again, Sam becoming a survivalist hoping to overcome the curse and being killed on a hunting trip]]), and then blaming the curse for their misfortune instead of merely living their lives out as best they could.learning from it.

Added: 1055

Changed: 441

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Curse}}: The Finch family believes themselves to have a death curse. [[spoiler: It's left ambiguous whether they really are supernaturally cursed, or whether the belief in the curse just leads them to dangerous acts of recklessness and magical thinking.]]

to:

* {{Curse}}: The Finch family believes themselves to have a death curse. [[spoiler: It's left ambiguous whether curse, which kills most family members as children, but leaves one alive to have kids of their own and continue the family before they themselves die ironically weird deaths. However, it's never actually made clear if the curse is really a thing or if the [[SelfFulfillingProphecy mere idea of the curse propagates itself]] by driving the Finches to do dangerous things out of the ''belief'' that they're cursed. The game goes out of its way to make both versions plausible:
** On the supernatural side, the curse is ''extremely'' consistent with how it strikes multiple people over the generations, and as some of the trope entries on this page attest, it's easy to read a narrative of a curse killing the Finches by [[JackassGenie maliciously granting their desires]] and preying on their fears.
** On the mundane side, the Finches
are supernaturally cursed, or whether the somewhat prone to melodrama and risk-seeking, and their belief in the curse just leads them to dangerous acts of recklessness explicitly affects their decision-making; see Odin putting his house on a barge and magical thinking.]]sailing it across the Atlantic ''and'' up the Pacific in a desperate hope that this would shake the curse. It's also easy to read most of the deaths being caused by poor decisions and dramatic gestures made in the hopes of escaping a curse that never existed ([[spoiler: i.e. Walter hiding underground in fear of the curse until he died in his desperation to see the sun again, Sam becoming a survivalist hoping to overcome the curse and being killed on a hunting trip]]), instead of merely living their lives out as best they could.

Added: 1055

Changed: 441

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Curse}}: The Finch family believes themselves to have a death curse. [[spoiler: It's left ambiguous whether they really are supernaturally cursed, or whether the belief in the curse just leads them to dangerous acts of recklessness and magical thinking.]]

to:

* {{Curse}}: The Finch family believes themselves to have a death curse. [[spoiler: It's left ambiguous whether curse, which kills most family members as children, but leaves one alive to have kids of their own and continue the family before they themselves die ironically weird deaths. However, it's never actually made clear if the curse is really a thing or if the [[SelfFulfillingProphecy mere idea of the curse propagates itself]] by driving the Finches to do dangerous things out of the ''belief'' that they're cursed. The game goes out of its way to make both versions plausible:
** On the supernatural side, the curse is ''extremely'' consistent with how it strikes multiple people over the generations, and as some of the trope entries on this page attest, it's easy to read a narrative of a curse killing the Finches by [[JackassGenie maliciously granting their desires]] and preying on their fears.
** On the mundane side, the Finches
are supernaturally cursed, or whether the somewhat prone to melodrama and risk-seeking, and their belief in the curse just leads them to dangerous acts of recklessness explicitly affects their decision-making; see Odin putting his house on a barge and magical thinking.]]sailing it across the Atlantic ''and'' up the Pacific in a desperate hope that this would shake the curse. It's also easy to read most of the deaths being caused by poor decisions and dramatic gestures made in the hopes of escaping a curse that never existed ([[spoiler: i.e. Walter hiding underground in fear of the curse until he died in his desperation to see the sun again, Sam becoming a survivalist hoping to overcome the curse and being killed on a hunting trip]]), instead of merely living their lives out as best they could.

Top