Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / DadsArmy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RealLifeWritesThePlot: In the newsreel at the start of "Shooting Pains", Thérèse [=McMurray=] plays a woman watering a flowerbed who wears a headscarf. The headscarf was a last-minute addition to [=McMurray=]'s costume; David Croft had asked her to tone her hair before filming as it was too blonde, so [=McMurray=]'s mother had given her a bottle of ink to pour on it, which caused trouble when rain during the location filming caused the ink to run and spoil her hair, hence the need to hide her hair with a headscarf.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RevisedEnding: The ending of "Man Hunt" didn't have the German parachutist at first. The cast was unhappy with the episode's ending so Robert Aldous (who had a small appearance in the Christmas short "Resisting the Aggressor Down the Ages" that was filmed on the same day) was quickly added in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NamedByTheAdaptation: In the radio adaptation:
** The U-boat captain from "The Deadly Attachment" is called "Captain Muller".
** The two Dervish warriors from Jones' {{Flashback}} in "The Two and a Half Feathers" are called "Wazir El Frazir" and "El Hodge".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CampGay: Reverend Farthing shows signs of this; in "Time on My Hands", he tells Hodges that he got the idea to fire an arrow attached to a silk thread attached to a piece of twine attached to a rope that the stranded Home Guard can use to climb down from the Town Hall clock from a fairy story, and Hodges sneers "I expect you know all about fairies."[[note]] Actor Creator/FrankWilliams said in interviews that he played Rev. Farthing as if he were in the closet.[[/note]]

to:

* CampGay: Reverend Farthing shows signs of this; in "Time on My Hands", he tells Hodges that he got the idea to fire an arrow attached to a silk thread attached to a piece of twine attached to a rope that the stranded Home Guard can use to climb down from the Town Hall clock from a fairy story, and Hodges sneers "I expect you know all about fairies."[[note]] sneers, "Yes, I've heard you're an expert on ''fairies''".[[note]] Actor Creator/FrankWilliams said in interviews that he played Rev. Farthing as if he were in the closet.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GrievousBottleyHarm: In "Time on My Hands", the platoon find themselves stranded up a clocktower with a large group of townspeople watching them from below. Mainwaring writes a note asking, "How are we going to get down?", and Pike suggests to throw it down to them in [[MessageInABottle a bottle]], which he does and nearly hits Hodges, who complains that it could have killed him and unhelpfully chalks a message that reads, "How are you going to get down?". Annoyed, Pike sends down another bottle:
-->'''Mainwaring:''' What message was in that, Pike?
-->'''Pike:''' None at all, I was just tryin' to hit the Warden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: In "Sgt. Wilson's Little Secret" (series 2), Mrs Pike takes in an evacuee, who appears at the end of the episode. The child is never seen or mentioned again after this episode, even during the occasional scenes that take place in the Pike household.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** 1971 - "Battle of the Giants", where the platoon is challenged to a test by the Eastgate platoon, with Hodges, the vicar and the verger as judges. They seem unlikely to win and their chances worsen when Jones has a bout of malaria.

to:

** 1971 - "Battle of the Giants", where the platoon is challenged to a test by the Eastgate platoon, with Hodges, the vicar TheVicar, and the verger Verger as judges. They seem unlikely to win and their chances worsen when Jones has a bout of malaria.



** 1976 - "The Love of Three Oranges", where the vicar organises a bazaar to which each member of the platoon donates something. Hodges donates three oranges, rare due to wartime rationing. Mainwaring is determined to buy one of the oranges for his wife.

to:

** 1976 - "The Love of Three Oranges", where the vicar Vicar organises a bazaar to which each member of the platoon donates something. Hodges donates three oranges, rare due to wartime rationing. Mainwaring is determined to buy one of the oranges for his wife.



** Walker's girlfriend Edith, also known as Shirley (but played by Creator/WendyRichard regardless of what her name was), vanished from the show after Walker was PutOnABus following his actor's untimely death.
** Also happens to [[ShooOutTheNewGuy Private Cheeseman]]. The character got a mixed reception and was seen as the ReplacementScrappy in the wake of Creator/JamesBeck's death. WordOfGod also stated that some of the other actors, especially Creator/JohnLaurie, felt that Cheeseman was getting too many laughs. He disappeared after series seven without any explanation.

to:

** Walker's girlfriend Edith, also known as Shirley (but played by Creator/WendyRichard regardless of what her name was), vanished from the show after Walker was PutOnABus following his actor's Creator/JamesBeck's untimely death.
** Also happens to [[ShooOutTheNewGuy Private Cheeseman]]. The character got a mixed reception and was seen as the ReplacementScrappy in the wake of Creator/JamesBeck's Beck's death. WordOfGod also stated that some of the other actors, especially Creator/JohnLaurie, felt that Cheeseman was getting too many laughs. He disappeared after series seven without any explanation.

Added: 1041

Removed: 695

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Miss King vanishes almost without a trace after Series 1, (probably because her inclusion was purely because of ExecutiveMeddling), with the only reference to her afterward coming from the Series 4 episode, "A. Wilson (Manager)?", when she is briefly mentioned by Pike in an off-hand line of dialogue in Mainwaring's office.
** Also happens to [[ShooOutTheNewGuy Private Cheeseman]]. The character got a mixed reception and was seen as the ReplacementScrappy in the wake of Creator/JamesBeck's death. WordOfGod also stated that some of the other actors, especially Creator/JohnLaurie, felt that Cheeseman was getting too many laughs. He disappeared after series seven without any explanation.


Added DiffLines:

** Miss King vanishes almost without a trace after Series 1, probably because her inclusion was purely because of ExecutiveMeddling as it was felt that the show needed a young female character. She did appear in the 1971 movie (played by a different actress), but in the series, the only subsequent reference to her was in the Series 4 episode, "A. Wilson (Manager)?", when she is briefly mentioned by Pike in an off-hand line of dialogue in Mainwaring's office.
** Walker's girlfriend Edith, also known as Shirley (but played by Creator/WendyRichard regardless of what her name was), vanished from the show after Walker was PutOnABus following his actor's untimely death.
** Also happens to [[ShooOutTheNewGuy Private Cheeseman]]. The character got a mixed reception and was seen as the ReplacementScrappy in the wake of Creator/JamesBeck's death. WordOfGod also stated that some of the other actors, especially Creator/JohnLaurie, felt that Cheeseman was getting too many laughs. He disappeared after series seven without any explanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 916

Removed: 2317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to Dads Army 2016.


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: In the original series, Mrs. Mainwaring is a profoundly unpleasant person who makes her husband's life a misery. In [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 film]], she's a gruff but ultimately good-hearted character and she and George, while often bickering, do actually care about each other.



* BorrowedCatchphrase:
** In "The Lion Has Phones", an army officer demands to know why Mainwaring believes the inhabitants of a stranded German plane will surrender in two hours. Wilson, rather than explain that [[spoiler:the reservoir the plane landed in is being filled and the Germans will be under water in two hours]] simply replies that "See the fact is they do not like it up them."
** Near the beginning of [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 film]], we see Hitler borrow the lines from the title song.
---> ''Who do you think you are kidding, Mr. Churchill?''
** Also in the 2016 film, Mainwaring borrows Jones' "Don't panic, don't panic" when breaking the news that a Nazi spy is in Walmington.

to:

* BorrowedCatchphrase:
**
BorrowedCatchphrase: In "The Lion Has Phones", an army officer demands to know why Mainwaring believes the inhabitants of a stranded German plane will surrender in two hours. Wilson, rather than explain that [[spoiler:the reservoir the plane landed in is being filled and the Germans will be under water in two hours]] simply replies that "See the fact is they do not like it up them."
** Near the beginning of [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 film]], we see Hitler borrow the lines from the title song.
---> ''Who do you think you are kidding, Mr. Churchill?''
** Also in the 2016 film, Mainwaring borrows Jones' "Don't panic, don't panic" when breaking the news that a Nazi spy is in Walmington.
"



* ChekhovsGun:
** In the episode "Battle of the Giants", Walker mentions having made flags for both their platoon and the Eastgate platoon. They will be used at the end of a contest, in short form, whoever flies their flag first, wins. Although just a passing remark, it turns out later that Walker made both flags say "Walmington-on-Sea" so they would win whoever flew the flag first.
** In [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 movie]], the mention by Walker's girlfriend that Rose Winters's dress is Chanel. [[spoiler:This leads the men to the discovery that she is the Nazi agent they're looking for - Cissy and Dolly Godfrey contacted the Chanel company, who confirmed that Rose is a regular customer from Berlin.]]

to:

* ChekhovsGun:
**
ChekhovsGun: In the episode "Battle of the Giants", Walker mentions having made flags for both their platoon and the Eastgate platoon. They will be used at the end of a contest, in short form, whoever flies their flag first, wins. Although just a passing remark, it turns out later that Walker made both flags say "Walmington-on-Sea" so they would win whoever flew the flag first.
** In [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 movie]], the mention by Walker's girlfriend that Rose Winters's dress is Chanel. [[spoiler:This leads the men to the discovery that she is the Nazi agent they're looking for - Cissy and Dolly Godfrey contacted the Chanel company, who confirmed that Rose is a regular customer from Berlin.]]
first.



* HistoricalInJoke: In [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 film]], after the group are tricked into [[NiceJobBreakingItHero destroying Britain's invasion force]], the General in charge (Creator/IanLavender in a RemakeCameo) admonishes them, saying that now they have to move their invasion back to June, when it happened in real life.



* HonestJohnsDealership: Private Walker's black market goods include plenty of items of dubious quality; in the first episode, he sells a watch to a fellow Home Guard member with the stock "waterproof, shockproof" spiel given by hundreds of dealers in stolen or counterfeit watches in film in television.

to:

* HonestJohnsDealership: Private Walker's black market black-market goods include plenty of items of dubious quality; in the first episode, he sells a watch to a fellow Home Guard member with the stock "waterproof, shockproof" spiel given by hundreds of dealers in stolen or counterfeit watches in film in television.



* PhonyVeteran:
** Captain Mainwaring had a habit of exaggerating his military service.
--->'''Mainwaring:''' I served in France ''[quietly]'' during the whole of 1919.\\

to:

* PhonyVeteran:
**
PhonyVeteran: Captain Mainwaring had a habit of exaggerating his military service.
--->'''Mainwaring:'''
service:
-->'''Mainwaring:'''
I served in France ''[quietly]'' during the whole of 1919.\\



** This trope is also invoked in [[Film/DadsArmy2016 the 2016 movie]] when Jones reveals that he doesn't actually have any combat experience, having served in the Army's ''catering'' section in the Sudan campaign, the Boer War and WWI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImpromptuFortress: In "The Battle Of Godfrey's cottage" due to a misunderstanding Captain Mainwaring is left believing the invasion has begun, and that the majority of the platoon are out of Warmington-On-Sea. Having only Jones and Frazer (as well as Godfrey as he later discovers) to hand and realising they have no hope of repelling any invasion force on the beaches, they resort to setting up an improvised base at Godfrey's cottage due it being in a key strategic point on the main crossroads out of town, hoping they will be able to at least hold the invading Nazi's off long enough for General HQ to organise a proper counterattack (and them all openly acknowledging they will certainly die in the process). This leads to them setting up the Lewis gun out the living room's window, and resort to using Godfrey's pillows filled with crockery as makeshift sandbags.

to:

* ImpromptuFortress: In "The Battle Of of Godfrey's cottage" due to a misunderstanding Captain Mainwaring is left believing the invasion has begun, and that the majority of the platoon are out of Warmington-On-Sea.Walmington-On-Sea. Having only Jones and Frazer (as well as Godfrey as he later discovers) to hand and realising they have no hope of repelling any invasion force on the beaches, they resort to setting up an improvised base at Godfrey's cottage due it being in a key strategic point on the main crossroads out of town, hoping they will be able to at least hold the invading Nazi's off long enough for General HQ to organise a proper counterattack (and them all openly acknowledging they will certainly die in the process). This leads to them setting up the Lewis gun out the living room's window, and resort to using Godfrey's pillows filled with crockery as makeshift sandbags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: Frazer mistreats Godfrey when he is revealed to have been a conscientious objector in WW1 and knocks Pike's cake out of his hand. At the end of the episode Frazer claims to have been on Godfrey's side all along and suffers no repercussions.

to:

* KarmaHoudini: Frazer mistreats Godfrey when he is revealed to have been a conscientious objector in WW1 [=WW1=] and knocks Pike's cake out of his hand. At the end of the episode Frazer claims to have been on Godfrey's side all along and suffers no repercussions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImpromptuFortress: In "The Battle Of Godfrey's cottage" due to a misunderstanding Captain Mainwaring is left believing the invasion has begun, and that the majority of the platoon are out of Warmington-On-Sea. Having only Jones and Frazer (as well as Godfrey as he later discovers) to hand and realising they have no hope of repelling any invasion force on the beaches, they resort to setting up an improvised base at Godfrey's cottage due it being in a key strategic point on the main crossroads out of town, hoping they will be able to at least hold the invading Nazi's off long enough for General HQ to organise a proper counterattack (and them all openly acknowledging they will certainly die in the process). This leads to them setting up the Lewis gun out the living room's window, and resort to using Godfrey's pillows filled with crockery as makeshift sandbags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Corporal Jones also tends to get subject to a lot of physical humiliation over the course of events. Similarly to Pike, he was actually played by one of the younger actors despite the character's age, meaning he could safely be subjected to a lot more physical comedy.
** Hodges also suffers his fair share of misfortune, though in his case it's because [[KickTheSonOfABitch he's so annoying the audience would no doubt approve]].

to:

** Corporal Jones also tends to get subject to a lot of physical humiliation over the course of events. Similarly to Pike, he was actually played by Creator/CliveDunn, one of the younger actors despite the character's age, meaning he could safely be subjected to a lot more physical comedy.
** Hodges also suffers his fair share of misfortune, though in his case it's because [[KickTheSonOfABitch he's so annoying the audience would no doubt approve]].approve.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Miss King vanishes without a trace after series one, probably as her inclusion was purely because of ExecutiveMeddling.

to:

** Miss King vanishes almost without a trace after series one, probably as Series 1, (probably because her inclusion was purely because of ExecutiveMeddling.ExecutiveMeddling), with the only reference to her afterward coming from the Series 4 episode, "A. Wilson (Manager)?", when she is briefly mentioned by Pike in an off-hand line of dialogue in Mainwaring's office.



** Private Bracewell, a character who appears only in the first episode. WordOfGod has it that Bracewell was intended to be a recurring character but was cut because the producers felt his character was too much like Godfrey's.

to:

** Private Bracewell, a character who appears only in the first episode. WordOfGod has it that Bracewell was intended to be a recurring character but was cut because the producers felt his character was too much like Godfrey's. The second episode, "Museum Piece", has Mainwaring and Wilson briefly mention his golf club, but that's as good as Bracewell got for the rest of the series.



** John Laurie as Private Frazer. The actor was somewhat bitter about being best remembered for this role rather than his theatrical work (not that this stopped him from cashing his pay cheques for the series).

to:

** John Laurie Creator/JohnLaurie as Private Frazer. The actor was somewhat bitter about being best remembered for this role rather than his theatrical work (not that this stopped him from cashing his pay cheques for the series).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* OneDimensionalThinking: In "The Royal Train", the Vicar, the Verger, the Mayor and Hodges are on a handcar following the home guard in a train, when the train goes into reverse. To avoid the train hitting them, they try to outrun it by reversing the handcar, rather than jumping off the handcar and out of the way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudini: Frazer mistreats Godfrey when he is revealed to have been a conscientious objector in WW1 and knocks Pike's cake out of his hand. At the end of the episode Frazer claims to have been on Godfrey's side all along and suffers no repercussions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FrozenInTime: The series started in 1940, went through 1941, and then 1942 [due to the inclusion of American troops in the episode 'My British Buddy']. Justified, in that after 1942 it became increasingly clear that the Germans weren't going to win, Britain wasn't going to be invaded, and there was less overall need for the Home Guard.

to:

* FrozenInTime: The While running from 1968 to 1977, the series started in 1940, went through 1941, and then 1942 [due to the inclusion of American troops in the episode 'My British Buddy']. Justified, in that after 1942 it became increasingly clear that the Germans weren't going to win, Britain wasn't going to be invaded, and there was less overall need for the Home Guard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** In "Room at the Bottom", General Headquarters realises that Mainwaring simply gave himself the rank of Captain. He's first demoted to Lieutenant and then later to Private. By the end of the episode, he's restored to Captain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one episode, an army officer demands to know why Mainwaring believes a stranded German pilot will give himself up any minute. Mainwaring, in no mood to explain that [[spoiler:the reservoir he landed in is being filled and the German will be under water in ten minutes]] simply replies that "It seems that they really don't like it up 'em."

to:

** In one episode, "The Lion Has Phones", an army officer demands to know why Mainwaring believes the inhabitants of a stranded German pilot plane will give himself up any minute. Mainwaring, surrender in no mood to two hours. Wilson, rather than explain that [[spoiler:the reservoir he the plane landed in is being filled and the German Germans will be under water in ten minutes]] two hours]] simply replies that "It seems that "See the fact is they really don't do not like it up 'em.them."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking


Other significant characters were the rather effete local vicar, Timothy Farthing (Creator/FrankWilliams), whose church hall the platoon made use of; the pompous verger Maurice Yeatman (Edward Sinclair), who tended to act as Hodges' fawning lackey; Mrs. Pike (Creator/JanetDavies), Pike's neurotic and overbearing mother who was heavily implied to be having an affair with Wilson; Private Sponge (Creator/ColinBean), another member of the platoon who would often be called upon whenever a supporting role was needed; Mrs. Fox (Creator/PamelaCundell), an overbearing local lady "of a certain age" with a bit of a thing for Corporal Jones; and Captain Square (Geoffrey Lumsden), the commanding officer of the nearby Eastgate platoon with a rivalry towards Mainwaring.

to:

Other significant characters were the rather effete local vicar, Timothy Farthing (Creator/FrankWilliams), whose church hall the platoon made use of; the pompous verger Maurice Yeatman (Edward Sinclair), (Creator/EdwardSinclair), who tended to act as Hodges' fawning lackey; Mrs. Pike (Creator/JanetDavies), Pike's neurotic and overbearing mother who was heavily implied to be having an affair with Wilson; Private Sponge (Creator/ColinBean), another member of the platoon who would often be called upon whenever a supporting role was needed; Mrs. Fox (Creator/PamelaCundell), an overbearing local lady "of a certain age" with a bit of a thing for Corporal Jones; and Captain Square (Geoffrey Lumsden), the commanding officer of the nearby Eastgate platoon with a rivalry towards Mainwaring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking


** Private Cheeseman (played by Talfryn Thomas) was added to the cast in Series 7 after the death of Creator/JamesBeck, but David Croft and Jimmy Perry thought he was "irritating without being funny", while Creator/JohnLaurie, who had already cornered the "eccentric Celt" role in the series, resented the number of funny lines Cheeseman was given, so he was quietly dropped for Series 8.[[note]] Although Croft claimed that he liked Cheeseman in at least one interview and dropped him mostly because of Laurie's complaints, and he and/or Perry evidently liked Talfryn Thomas enough to cast him in the ''Series/HiDeHi'' episode "Stripes".[[/note]]

to:

** Private Cheeseman (played by Talfryn Thomas) Creator/TalfrynThomas) was added to the cast in Series 7 after the death of Creator/JamesBeck, but David Croft and Jimmy Perry thought he was "irritating without being funny", while Creator/JohnLaurie, who had already cornered the "eccentric Celt" role in the series, resented the number of funny lines Cheeseman was given, so he was quietly dropped for Series 8.[[note]] Although Croft claimed that he liked Cheeseman in at least one interview and dropped him mostly because of Laurie's complaints, and he and/or Perry evidently liked Talfryn Thomas enough to cast him in the ''Series/HiDeHi'' episode "Stripes".[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking


Other significant characters were the rather effete local vicar, Timothy Farthing (Creator/FrankWilliams), whose church hall the platoon made use of; the pompous verger Maurice Yeatman (Edward Sinclair), who tended to act as Hodges' fawning lackey; Mrs. Pike (Creator/JanetDavies), Pike's neurotic and overbearing mother who was heavily implied to be having an affair with Wilson; Private Sponge (Colin Bean), another member of the platoon who would often be called upon whenever a supporting role was needed; Mrs. Fox (Creator/PamelaCundell), an overbearing local lady "of a certain age" with a bit of a thing for Corporal Jones; and Captain Square (Geoffrey Lumsden), the commanding officer of the nearby Eastgate platoon with a rivalry towards Mainwaring.

to:

Other significant characters were the rather effete local vicar, Timothy Farthing (Creator/FrankWilliams), whose church hall the platoon made use of; the pompous verger Maurice Yeatman (Edward Sinclair), who tended to act as Hodges' fawning lackey; Mrs. Pike (Creator/JanetDavies), Pike's neurotic and overbearing mother who was heavily implied to be having an affair with Wilson; Private Sponge (Colin Bean), (Creator/ColinBean), another member of the platoon who would often be called upon whenever a supporting role was needed; Mrs. Fox (Creator/PamelaCundell), an overbearing local lady "of a certain age" with a bit of a thing for Corporal Jones; and Captain Square (Geoffrey Lumsden), the commanding officer of the nearby Eastgate platoon with a rivalry towards Mainwaring.

Top