Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekS1E16TheGalileoSeven

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This is not exactly correct. Most orbits will eventually decay. This is especially the case with objects below geosynchronous orbit. A combination of pressure from the solar wind and atmospheric drag (the atmosphere doesn't just stop at a particular altitude, but thins out) will gradually reduce orbital velocity. Satellites and space stations at lower orbits have required periodic burns to boost their velocity back up and reverse orbital decay. The shuttle has simply achieved a low and/or unstable orbit, might make it around the planet a few times, but isn't going fast enough to achieve a stable orbit at sufficient altitude.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content


* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack'', a film which involved an airliner crashing in the South American jungle and the survivors being attacked by territorial natives. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)

to:

* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack'', a film which involved an airliner crashing making a forced landing in the South American jungle and the survivors being attacked by territorial natives. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack', a film which involved an airliner crashing in the South American jungle and the survivors being attacked by territorial natives. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)

to:

* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack', ''Film/FiveCameBack'', a film which involved an airliner crashing in the South American jungle and the survivors being attacked by territorial natives. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content


* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack''. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)

to:

* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack''.''Film/FiveCameBack', a film which involved an airliner crashing in the South American jungle and the survivors being attacked by territorial natives. (The film was also an inspiration to ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content


** She says "It's getting hot in here!" when the shuttle starts burning up on re-entry and the shuttle's interior starts smoking.

to:

** She says "It's getting hot in here!" when the shuttle starts burning up on re-entry and the shuttle's its interior starts smoking.

Added: 129

Changed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing indentation, General clarification on works content


* CaptainObvious: Mears' only purpose seems to be pointing out the obvious like "It's getting hot in here!" when the shuttle starts smoking.
** And, for some [[MsFanservice unfathomable reason]], flopping onto the floor and shouting "We're moving!" when the shuttle--get this!--starts moving.

to:

* CaptainObvious: Mears' only purpose seems to be pointing out the obvious like obvious.
** For some [[MsFanservice unfathomable reason]], she flops onto the floor and shouts "We're moving!" when the shuttle--get this!--starts moving.
** She says
"It's getting hot in here!" when the shuttle starts smoking.
** And, for some [[MsFanservice unfathomable reason]], flopping onto
burning up on re-entry and the floor and shouting "We're moving!" when the shuttle--get this!--starts moving.shuttle's interior starts smoking.



* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: Yeoman Meares fills the role meant for Yeoman Rand.

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute: Yeoman Meares Mears fills the role meant for Yeoman Rand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Series/GilligansIsland The electrical interference started getting rough. The shuttle, it was tossed.]] If not for the courage of the fearless crew, ''Galileo'' would be lost. (''Galileo'' would be lost.) The ship set ground on the shore of this lone planet Taurus II. With [[TheSpock Mr. Spock!]] [[TheMcCoy The Doctor too!]] TheEngineer! [[TokenMinority And Boma!]] [[BridgeBunny The Yeoman!]] [[RedShirt And the rest!]] Are here on Taurus II!

to:

[[Series/GilligansIsland The electrical interference started getting rough. The shuttle, it was tossed.]] If not for the courage of the fearless crew, ''Galileo'' would be lost. (''Galileo'' would be lost.) The ship set ground on the shore of this lone planet Taurus II. With [[TheSpock Mr. Spock!]] Spock]]! [[TheMcCoy The Doctor too!]] too]]! TheEngineer! [[TokenMinority And Boma!]] Boma]]! [[BridgeBunny The Yeoman!]] Yeoman]]! [[RedShirt And the rest!]] rest]]! Are here on Taurus II!






Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MildlyMilitary: It's been noted that the shuttlecraft characters were being grossly insubordinate to Spock and the one of the few moves done that was in the spirit of a proper military mindset is his fuel igniting stunt at the end, considering it was a worthwhile option given the situation.

to:

* MildlyMilitary: It's been noted that the shuttlecraft characters were being grossly insubordinate to Spock Spock, and the that one of the few moves done that was in the spirit of a proper military mindset is his fuel igniting stunt at the end, considering it was a worthwhile option given the situation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Charges may not have been necessary if [=McCoy=] had reprimanded Lt. Boma after his derisive comment about Spock's brain (no not [[Recap/StarTrekS3E1SpocksBrain that one]]), instead of condoning and/or supporting it. Even Kirk publicly teases Spock about the incident at the end, prompting Boma to join the others in an EverybodyLaughsEnding, which makes the court-martial idea seem like something of an AssPull.

to:

** Charges may not have been necessary if [=McCoy=] had reprimanded Lt. Boma after his derisive comment about Spock's brain (no not [[Recap/StarTrekS3E1SpocksBrain that one]]), instead of condoning and/or supporting it. Even Kirk publicly teases Spock about the incident at the end, prompting Boma to join the others in an EverybodyLaughsEnding, which makes the court-martial idea seem like something of an AssPull.[[invoked]]AssPull.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDissenterIsAlwaysRight: A shuttlecraft commanded by Mr. Spock crashes on an alien planet. Spock finds many of his subsequent decisions are contested by his companions. The most evident is his decision to burn off the remaining fuel to create a flare to attract the "Enterprise's" attention so they can be rescued. Despite objections, his plan works.

to:

* TheDissenterIsAlwaysRight: A shuttlecraft commanded by Mr. Spock crashes on an alien planet. Spock finds many of his subsequent decisions are contested by his companions. The most evident is his decision to burn off the remaining fuel to create a flare to attract the "Enterprise's" ''Enterprise's'' attention so they can be rescued. Despite objections, his plan works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawVulcan: Mr. Spock, of course. Spock determines that a display of superior force will logically frighten away these aliens while the crew make repairs to the shuttle. Instead, as Bones points out, the aliens have an emotional reaction and become angry and attack, something Spock did not anticipate. In the end, Spock's desperate act of igniting the fuel from the shuttle to create a beacon proves to be the correct action since it gets the attention of the Enterprise and allows for a rescue. When called on this "emotional" act, Spock replies that the only logical course of action in that instance was one of desperation.

to:

* StrawVulcan: Mr. Spock, of course. Spock determines that a display of superior force will logically frighten away these aliens while the crew make repairs to the shuttle. Instead, as Bones points out, the aliens have an emotional reaction and become angry and attack, something Spock did not anticipate. In the end, Spock's desperate act of igniting the fuel from the shuttle to create a beacon proves to be the correct action since it gets the attention of the Enterprise and allows for a rescue. Plus, if it was indeed futile, it would have [[MercyKill shortened their inevitable suffering]]. When called on this "emotional" act, Spock replies that the only logical course of action in that instance was one of desperation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope def-only


** And, for some [[MsFanservice unfathomable reason]], [[PantyShot flopping onto the floor]] and shouting "We're moving!" when the shuttle--get this!--starts moving.

to:

** And, for some [[MsFanservice unfathomable reason]], [[PantyShot flopping onto the floor]] floor and shouting "We're moving!" when the shuttle--get this!--starts moving.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In [[Literature/FortunesOfWar a follow-up novel]] (non-canon though), Boma was court-martialed for his insubordination. The charges were brought by [=McCoy=] and Scotty, not Spock.
** Charges may not have been necessary if [=McCoy=] had reprimanded Lt. Boma after his derisive comment about Spock's brain (no not [[Recap/StarTrekS3E1SpocksBrain that one]]), instead of condoning and/or supporting it.

to:

** In [[Literature/FortunesOfWar a follow-up novel]] (non-canon though), Boma was court-martialed for his insubordination. The charges were brought by [=McCoy=] and Scotty, not Spock.
Spock. A [[Literature/StarTrekNovelVerse different (non-canon) follow-up novel]] merely had Boma transferred to another ship because of the clash of personalities and ultimately working well with Spock when they meet up again.
** Charges may not have been necessary if [=McCoy=] had reprimanded Lt. Boma after his derisive comment about Spock's brain (no not [[Recap/StarTrekS3E1SpocksBrain that one]]), instead of condoning and/or supporting it. Even Kirk publicly teases Spock about the incident at the end, prompting Boma to join the others in an EverybodyLaughsEnding, which makes the court-martial idea seem like something of an AssPull.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added to Streaming Stars


* StreamingStars: Rushing past the ''Enterprise'' when it's ''in orbit around a planet''.

to:

* StreamingStars: Rushing past the ''Enterprise'' when it's ''in orbit around a planet''. And by the ''Galileo'' while it is in a ''decaying'' orbit around a planet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheDissenterIsAlwaysRight: A shuttlecraft commanded by Mr. Spock crashes on an alien planet. Spock finds many of his subsequent decisions are contested by his companions. The most evident is his decision to burn off the remaining fuel to create a flare to attract the "Enterprise's" attention so they can be rescued. Despite objections, his plan works.

Added: 559

Changed: 264

Removed: 1380

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse of logic is covered under Straw Vulcan, and it's the concept no the word that is misunderstood. And this aversion does not look notable.


* ArtisticLicenseSpace: Once in orbit, it does not take a whole lot of energy to remain there. Not even the orbit of a pebble around a super-massive black hole will decay that fast.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseSpace: ArtisticLicenseSpace:
** They state that the shuttlecraft is in orbit, but it rapidly decays.
Once an object is in orbit, it does not take a whole lot of energy to remain there. Not even will stay there unless there is significant air resistance. Though it might be supposed that they were being loose with terms and they had only cleared the orbit atmosphere while being short of a pebble around orbital velocity, in which case falling down again makes sense.
** The "quasar-like formation" is nothing like what we now know quasars to be,
a super-massive black hole will decay that fast.at the center of a very young galaxy, spewing enormous amounts of energy as material falls into it.



* BlackDudeDiesFirst: Averted! Lt. Boma makes it out of here alive! Which means he gets to keep being a jerk the whole episode!



* SciFiWritersHave/NoSenseOfMass: The image on the main screen was clearly of an artist's rendition of a quasar. Today, we know that a quasar is the super-massive black hole at the center of a very young galaxy, spewing enormous amounts of energy as material falls into it. The implications are either of a galaxy-like phenomenon within a galaxy (?!), or that the Enterprise was at the far reaches of the universe studying a quasar with a very, very small number of worlds therein. [[ScienceMarchesOn Fixed somewhat with the remastered effects to look like one, at least.]]
** Kirk, does state, in his log, that Murasaki 312 is a quasar-like formation, not an actual quasar.




** Although Trek tends to play fast and loose with both physics and terminology, and it's perfectly possible the Galileo achieved altitude enough to clear the atmosphere while still being below actual orbital velocity, meaning what they've achieved is a "hop into space" and will be coming right back down again.



* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack''.
* YouKeepUsingThatWord: The script clearly has no idea what the word "logical" means. Spock dumping and igniting the fuel is a gamble, but not an emotional one, and is a logical risk under the circumstances. The script appears to believe "logical" means "unemotional".

to:

* WholePlotReference: Writer Oliver Crawford conceived this episode as a science fiction retelling of ''Film/FiveCameBack''.
* YouKeepUsingThatWord: The script clearly has no idea what the word "logical" means. Spock dumping and igniting the fuel is a gamble, but not
''Film/FiveCameBack''. (The film was also an emotional one, and is a logical risk under the circumstances. The script appears inspiration to believe "logical" means "unemotional". ''Series/GilligansIsland'', hence its similarities to this episode.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removed attempted joke that's just a digression


The ''Enterprise'' is on their way to Makus III with medical supplies when they come across Murasaki 312, a quasar-like formation. Much to the objection of Galactic High Commissioner Ferris, Kirk sends a party to investigate. After all, there might be a planet of space babes out there! (There is, Jim, but you'd probably get lost inside one!)

to:

The ''Enterprise'' is on their way en route to Makus III with medical supplies when they come across Murasaki 312, a quasar-like formation. Much to the objection of Galactic High Commissioner Ferris, Kirk sends a party to investigate. After all, there might be a planet of space babes out there! (There is, Jim, but you'd probably get lost inside one!)
investigate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merged per TRS


* ArtisticLicenseSpace: Once in orbit, it does not take a whole lot of energy to remain there. Not even the orbit of a pebble around a super-massive black hole will decay that fast.



* SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay: Once in orbit, it does not take a whole lot of energy to remain there. Not even the orbit of a pebble around a super-massive black hole will decay that fast.

to:

* SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay: Once in orbit, it does not take a whole lot of energy to remain there. Not even the orbit of a pebble around a super-massive black hole will decay that fast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EveryoneHasStandards: Bones and Scotty ''eventually'' call out Boma for insubordination, even if Bones and his temper definitely enabled the guy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouKeepUsingThatWord: The script clearly has no idea what the word "logical" means. Spock dumping and igniting the fuel is a gamble, but not an emotional one, and is a logical risk under the circumstances. The script appears to believe "logical" means "unemotional".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


'''Original air date:''' January 5, 1967
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Series/GilligansIsland The electrical interference started getting rough. The tiny shuttle was tossed.]] If not for the courage of the fearless crew the ''Galileo'' would be lost. The ''Galileo'' would be lost. The ship set ground on the shore of this lone planet Taurus II. With [[TheSpock Mr. Spock!]] [[TheMcCoy The Doctor too!]] TheEngineer! [[TokenMinority And Boma!]] [[BridgeBunny The Yeoman!]] [[RedShirt And the rest!]] Are here on Taurus II!

to:

[[Series/GilligansIsland The electrical interference started getting rough. The tiny shuttle shuttle, it was tossed.]] If not for the courage of the fearless crew the crew, ''Galileo'' would be lost. The ''Galileo'' (''Galileo'' would be lost. lost.) The ship set ground on the shore of this lone planet Taurus II. With [[TheSpock Mr. Spock!]] [[TheMcCoy The Doctor too!]] TheEngineer! [[TokenMinority And Boma!]] [[BridgeBunny The Yeoman!]] [[RedShirt And the rest!]] Are here on Taurus II!

Top