Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / PermissionToSpeakFreely

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'':
** Riker has a tendency to invoke this with various Special Guest Captains on the ''Enterprise'' when Picard got temporarily replaced for various reasons. This is usually because said temp captains almost always ''are'' [[TyrantTakesTheHelm complete dicks]], who either don't know anything about the ''Enterprise's'' usual group dynamics, or don't care. I
** Riker even once said it to himself, after it is discovered that the transporter created a duplicate of him eight years previously when he was still a Lieutenant, and Lt. Riker didn't like Commander Riker's command style.

to:

* ** ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'':
** *** Riker has a tendency to invoke this with various Special Guest Captains on the ''Enterprise'' when Picard got temporarily replaced for various reasons. This is usually because said temp captains almost always ''are'' [[TyrantTakesTheHelm complete dicks]], who either don't know anything about the ''Enterprise's'' usual group dynamics, or don't care. I
** *** Riker even once said it to himself, after it is discovered that the transporter created a duplicate of him eight years previously when he was still a Lieutenant, and Lt. Riker didn't like Commander Riker's command style.

Added: 939

Changed: 3256

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), Fixing indentation


* A variation in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' episode "Obsession" in which it is shown that the First Officer and Medical Officer have the right to formally approach the Captain when they observe him acting in ways that they feel are harmful to the ship and her crew. Starfleet regulations even set out the words that must be used when making this approach.
* ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'': Riker has a tendency to invoke this with various Special Guest Captains on the ''Enterprise'' when Picard got temporarily replaced for various reasons. This is usually because said temp captains almost always ''are'' [[TyrantTakesTheHelm complete dicks]], who either don't know anything about the ''Enterprise's'' usual group dynamics, or don't care. In fact, this comes up all the time in the ''Franchise/StarTrek'' franchise. Speaking your mind to a superior officer without asking this first is insubordination and can be punished appropriately and the senior officer can also revoke it at any time. A variant, "permission to speak frankly," also exists. The superior officer may also choose to deny the request, or may reply "Always," indicating an apparent blank check that they prefer for their subordinates to always speak their mind and they will not be punished for insubordination if they do so. It's also worth noting that many officers within the series have simply made this request then gone ahead and started speaking their minds without waiting for the requested permission.

to:

* A variation in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' episode "Obsession" in which it is shown that the First Officer and Medical Officer have the right to formally approach the Captain when they observe him acting in ways that they feel are harmful to the ship and her crew. Starfleet regulations even set out the words that must be used when making this approach.
* ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'': Riker has a tendency to invoke this with various Special Guest Captains on the ''Enterprise'' when Picard got temporarily replaced for various reasons. This is usually because said temp captains almost always ''are'' [[TyrantTakesTheHelm complete dicks]], who either don't know anything about the ''Enterprise's'' usual group dynamics, or don't care. In fact, this
*This comes up all the time in the ''Franchise/StarTrek'' franchise. Speaking your mind to a superior officer without asking this first is insubordination and can be punished appropriately and the senior officer can also revoke it at any time. A variant, "permission to speak frankly," also exists. The superior officer may also choose to deny the request, or may reply "Always," indicating an apparent blank check that they prefer for their subordinates to always speak their mind and they will not be punished for insubordination if they do so. It's also worth noting that many officers within the series have simply made this request then gone ahead and started speaking their minds without waiting for the requested permission.permission.
** A variation in the ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries'' episode "Obsession" in which it is shown that the First Officer and Medical Officer have the right to formally approach the Captain when they observe him acting in ways that they feel are harmful to the ship and her crew. Starfleet regulations even set out the words that must be used when making this approach.
* ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'':
** Riker has a tendency to invoke this with various Special Guest Captains on the ''Enterprise'' when Picard got temporarily replaced for various reasons. This is usually because said temp captains almost always ''are'' [[TyrantTakesTheHelm complete dicks]], who either don't know anything about the ''Enterprise's'' usual group dynamics, or don't care. I



** One memorable example also occurs on ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', where Kira, wanting to discuss the possible replacement of Odo as security chief with a Starfleet officer, asks Sisko for permission to speak freely, and once, granted, ''erupts'' in frustrated rage at Starfleet's cluelessness.
** Worf does this when going to have a private discussion with Kurn over why he's being constantly patronised by the Klingon commander. However, it's only when Worf loses his temper and challenges his superior that they ''really'' start speaking freely, as Kurn was just doing a SecretTestOfCharacter to find out if Worf shared his Klingon values.
* Something of a StockPhrase for Chakotay towards Captain Janeway on ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. It may be that as a Maquis leader he has a hard time gauging the Starfleet-appropriate level of formality.
** Chakotay is former Starfleet, so it's more likely a reflection on the notorious stubbornness of his captain.

to:

** ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'':
***
One memorable example also occurs on ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'', where when Kira, wanting to discuss the possible replacement of Odo as security chief with a Starfleet officer, asks Sisko for permission to speak freely, and once, granted, ''erupts'' in frustrated rage at Starfleet's cluelessness.
** *** Worf does this when going to have a private discussion with Kurn over why he's being constantly patronised by the Klingon commander. However, it's only when Worf loses his temper and challenges his superior that they ''really'' start speaking freely, as Kurn was just doing a SecretTestOfCharacter to find out if Worf shared his Klingon values.
* ** Something of a StockPhrase for Chakotay towards Captain Janeway on ''Series/StarTrekVoyager''. It may be that as a Maquis leader he has a hard time gauging the Starfleet-appropriate level of formality.
**
formality, although Chakotay is former Starfleet, so it's more likely could also be a reflection on the notorious stubbornness of his captain.captain.
** In the ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery'' episode "Jinaal", Tilly asks for permission to speak freely to Commander Rayner before criticising him for prioritising his own mission goals (which someone else is already working on anyway) over the crew bonding exercise he's been directly ordered to do. After she's finished, Rayner points out he ''didn't'' actually grant her permission. Later, after growing increasingly frustrated with his approach to the bonding exercise, she tells him she's going to speak freely whether she has permission or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Jean'': [[SarcasmMode Oh, how can I help but like a man who takes his mother out for the evening?]] That ''was'' your mother out there, wasn't it?\\

to:

'''Jean'': '''Jean''': [[SarcasmMode Oh, how can I help but like a man who takes his mother out for the evening?]] That ''was'' your mother out there, wasn't it?\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the film version of ''Literature/TheCaineMutiny'', Willie is called into Lt. Commander De Vriess' office, where he gets reprimanded for several lapses of duty. Willie, who already had a family member attempt to pull a ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections on his behalf, is resentful for being stuck on a ship like the Caine, but is reluctant to say so until he asks, "Permission to speak freely, sir," and the lieutenant says, "Speak your mind, Keith."


Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/StageDoor'' has a variation. Anthony Powell, who arranged for Jean to get a job in the club he owns part of, visits Jean in her dressing room, but she doesn't like him because he's seeing Linda, whom she hates.
-->'''Powell''': You don't like me, do you?\\
'''Jean'': [[SarcasmMode Oh, how can I help but like a man who takes his mother out for the evening?]] That ''was'' your mother out there, wasn't it?\\
'''Powell''': No, no, that was my friend's mother.[[note]]Powell is referring to Harcourt, his valet, who is serving as TheBeard[[/note]]\\
'''Jean''': Oh, then I can speak freely then.\\
'''Powell''': Please do.\\
'''Jean''': I think your friend shows very bad taste in picking mothers.
** Powell agrees, and ends up asking Jean out on a date.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Fan Works]]
* ''Fanfic/LittleHandsBigAttitude'': After Agent Stone informs the GUN leadership that the latest incident at Green Hills was ''not'' caused by the aliens being aggressive but instead because Commander Walters tried to kidnap a baby, he asks permission to speak freely. When they grant it, he expresses his opinion that Commander Walters is too much of a ImproperlyParanoid [[FantasticRacism racist]] to be assigned on any cases involving aliens, and that the mission parameters are wrong in the first place; if they want to learn the aliens' behavior, they should observe them in the environment they're comfortable instead of capturing them by force. He also volunteers himself for the mission, since it's easy for him to move to a new address. To his shock, GUN leadership actually follows his suggestion.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Cowley:''' Not so much of the old, sonny.

to:

--->'''Cowley:''' [[ITakeOffenseToThatLastOne Not so much of the old, old]], sonny.



* The captain of ''Yakamoz.S-245'' makes civilian engineer Arman a replacement for the deceased Chief Engineer of the eponymous submarine. When an agitated Arman complains to the captain about the attitude of the crew (who blame him for his predecessor's death), the captain insists on being addressed with the proper respect, so Arman then asks for permission to speak.

to:

* The captain of ''Yakamoz.S-245'' makes civilian engineer Arman a replacement for the deceased Chief Engineer of the eponymous submarine. When an agitated Arman complains to the captain about the attitude of the crew (who blame him for his predecessor's death), the captain insists on being addressed with the proper respect, respect as Arman is now an officer on his ship, so Arman then asks for permission to speak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->''An uncomfortable silence fills the room. Everyone looks at Donna.''

to:

--->''An -->''(An uncomfortable silence fills the room. Everyone looks at Donna.'')''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The captain of ''Yakamoz.S-245'' makes civilian engineer Arman a replacement for the deceased Chief Engineer of the eponymous submarine. When an agitated Arman complains to the captain about the attitude of the crew (who blame him for his predecessor's death), the captain insists on being addressed with the proper respect, so Arman then asks for permission to speak.

Top