Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / PokemonSunAndMoon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


** That's less a moral and morea facet of growing up. The real moral could be closer to just because you are growing up doesn't mean you have to give up your passions completely, just adapt around them.

to:

** That's less a moral and morea facet of growing up. The real moral could be closer to just because you are growing up doesn't mean you have to give up your passions completely, just adapt around them.them.
-----
* Why back to Pokédex save data on obtained Pokémon?

Added: 203

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One of the morals is GrowingUpSucks because you'll have to get a job and/or basically give up your dreams of becoming a Pokémon trainer as seen with Team Skull and the Eeveeolution users. Yet, there's several trainers such as Bellhops and Firefighters who have jobs but still do Pokémon battling on the side. Does anyone else think the moral is lost because of this?

to:

* One of the morals is GrowingUpSucks because you'll have to get a job and/or basically give up your dreams of becoming a Pokémon trainer as seen with Team Skull and the Eeveeolution users. Yet, there's several trainers such as Bellhops and Firefighters who have jobs but still do Pokémon battling on the side. Does anyone else think the moral is lost because of this?this?
** That's less a moral and morea facet of growing up. The real moral could be closer to just because you are growing up doesn't mean you have to give up your passions completely, just adapt around them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Cubone only evolves into Alolan Marowak at night in Alola, then what is stopping it from evolving into regular Marowak during the daytime? It's very odd that during a whole stretch of the day Cubone just doesn't evolve when it would in any other region; even odder that taking it to Ultra Space is what allows it to evolve into regular Marowak instead of just the absence of night. This could've been avoided if Gamefreak just created Alolan Cubone.

to:

* If Cubone only evolves into Alolan Marowak at night in Alola, then what is stopping it from evolving into regular Marowak during the daytime? It's very odd that during a whole stretch of the day Cubone just doesn't evolve when it would in any other region; even odder that taking it to Ultra Space is what allows it to evolve into regular Marowak instead of just the absence of night. This could've been avoided if Gamefreak just created Alolan Cubone.Cubone.
-----
* One of the morals is GrowingUpSucks because you'll have to get a job and/or basically give up your dreams of becoming a Pokémon trainer as seen with Team Skull and the Eeveeolution users. Yet, there's several trainers such as Bellhops and Firefighters who have jobs but still do Pokémon battling on the side. Does anyone else think the moral is lost because of this?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More corrections.


* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[VideoGame/{{PokemonSwordAndShield}} Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRomance a gap relation]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

to:

* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are introduced to [[VideoGame/{{PokemonSwordAndShield}} Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRomance a gap relation]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More corrections.


* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

to:

* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield [[VideoGame/{{PokemonSwordAndShield}} Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship [[AgeGapRomance a gap relationship]].relation]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

Added: 458

Changed: -24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

to:

* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.shows.
----
* If Cubone only evolves into Alolan Marowak at night in Alola, then what is stopping it from evolving into regular Marowak during the daytime? It's very odd that during a whole stretch of the day Cubone just doesn't evolve when it would in any other region; even odder that taking it to Ultra Space is what allows it to evolve into regular Marowak instead of just the absence of night. This could've been avoided if Gamefreak just created Alolan Cubone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting grammar and adding new scratcher.


** Speaking of Sandshrew/Sandslash, why does an Alolan sandshrew need an Ice Stone to evolve into a sandslash when its more common countrpart just needs to reach a certain level?

to:

** Speaking of Sandshrew/Sandslash, why does an Alolan sandshrew Sandshrew need an Ice Stone to evolve into a sandslash Sandslash when its more common countrpart just needs to reach a certain level?



——
* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe [[MandelaEffect]]. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

to:

——
----
* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe [[MandelaEffect]].MandelaEffect. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.

Added: 1075

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correct


** Speaking of Sandshrew/Sandslash, why does an Alolan sandshrew need an ice stone to evolve into a sandslash when its more common countrpart just needs to reach a certain level?

to:

** Speaking of Sandshrew/Sandslash, why does an Alolan sandshrew need an ice stone Ice Stone to evolve into a sandslash when its more common countrpart just needs to reach a certain level?



* During one of the plot beats when you reach the third island, you visit the Aether House and meet two kids who say that they live in here. My question is- why? We don't know who their parents are, because they're never mentioned. At first I thought that they're orphans or were taken from their parents for whatever reason, but the Aether foundation helps pokemon, not people. So why do they live in an Aether facility? My only guess is that maybe their parents are Aether workers, but there's no word on that in game.

to:

* During one of the plot beats when you reach the third island, you visit the Aether House and meet two kids who say that they live in here. My question is- why? We don't know who their parents are, because they're never mentioned. At first I thought that they're orphans or were taken from their parents for whatever reason, but the Aether foundation helps pokemon, not people. So why do they live in an Aether facility? My only guess is that maybe their parents are Aether workers, but there's no word on that in game.game.
——
* Mallow says that once Trial Captains turn 20, they move on. This is probably an In-Universe [[MandelaEffect]]. I say it’s one big timeline with just different universes. Watch [[https://youtu.be/OfAmiJbe3tQ this video]] and you might get a better definition. I could theorise that Mina got sent back in time from on of the Wormholes. Her parents are way too old to be like in their 30s-40s age gap. Her father is the Gentleman sprite (which seems like 60s-70s gap) but don’t know how old her mother’s sprite is due to it not being a trainer. But we are [[PokemonSwordAndShield Mustard in the Isle of Armor with a son who’s like a little younger than the protagonist]]. Perhaps Hyde is [[OlderThanTheyLook older than he looks]]. Honey, Mustard’s wife, is like in her 40s so she and Mustard have an [[AgeGapRelationship a gap relationship]]. If Mina is around 11-19 in 2016 then she must’ve got sent back in time or Mallow has a Mandela Effect or mean they need to have new jobs. I, for example, am [[Film/TheSoundOfMusic 20 going on 21]] and I still watch childhood shows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's probably because Oranguru is its version-exclusive counterpart. It would be "unfair" for one of them to be SOS-able and not the other, so they likely decided to have them both behave the same way. They must've judged that it was less out-of-character for Passimiam to avoid SOS-ing than it would be for Oranguru (who don't get along with each other) to start doing it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

--------
* During one of the plot beats when you reach the third island, you visit the Aether House and meet two kids who say that they live in here. My question is- why? We don't know who their parents are, because they're never mentioned. At first I thought that they're orphans or were taken from their parents for whatever reason, but the Aether foundation helps pokemon, not people. So why do they live in an Aether facility? My only guess is that maybe their parents are Aether workers, but there's no word on that in game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So mareanies prey upon corsolas, they're even based on a species of starfish that eats coral. Then why aren't they of a typing with an offensive advantage against a water/rock-type pokemon?

to:

* So mareanies Mareanies prey upon corsolas, Corsolas, they're even based on a species of starfish that eats coral. Then why aren't they of a typing with an offensive advantage against a water/rock-type pokemon?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fixed in ''VideoGame/PokémonUltraSunAndUltraMoon'': There are lots of very strong trainers on Mount Lanakila in that game. Some of them say they're there because they heard about Professor Kukui starting a Pokémon League and want to check it out.

to:

** Fixed in ''VideoGame/PokémonUltraSunAndUltraMoon'': ''VideoGame/UltraSunAndUltraMoon'': There are lots of very strong trainers on Mount Lanakila in that game. Some of them say they're there because they heard about Professor Kukui starting a Pokémon League and want to check it out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fixed in ''VideoGame/UltraSunAndUltraMoon'': There are lots of very strong trainers on Mount Lanakila in that game. Some of them say they're there because they heard about Professor Kukui starting a Pokémon League and want to check it out.

to:

** Fixed in ''VideoGame/UltraSunAndUltraMoon'': ''VideoGame/PokémonUltraSunAndUltraMoon'': There are lots of very strong trainers on Mount Lanakila in that game. Some of them say they're there because they heard about Professor Kukui starting a Pokémon League and want to check it out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----

Added: 12

Changed: 208

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----



----




to:

----



----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----




to:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Similarly, in Ultra, said encounter is a Grubbin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Additional idea, "protect" just means that she, as a Frontier Brain, "protected" the tower from trainers. It's entirely possible that, since she had amnesia, she misinterpreted her job from "battle trainers" to "protect battle tower from things". It wouldn't be that hard to mix up since both of thise things involved battling and her memory was real addled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Speaking of Sandshrew/Sandslash, why does an Alolan sandshrew need an ice stone to evolve into a sandslash when its more common countrpart just needs to reach a certain level?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yes, a desert located on a ''volcanic island''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* Sandshrew, and by extension Sandslash, are said to have adapted to their Ice/Steel Alolan forms due to volcanic activity near their former habitat forcing them to flee to the icy mountains of Alola. What volcanic activity? It lives in the DESERT!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* So the SOS mechanic was established as a means for hunting down pokemon with hidden abilities as well as having an improved chance of finding shiny pokemon. [[ScrappyMechanic Tediousness aside]] when one's team is worn down and you need to get them to a pokemon center, did anyone at Game Freak consider how [[UnfortunateImplications cruel it would be]] [[VideoGameCrueltyPotential to take advantage of this mechanic]]? Your pokemon would literally be beating on a wild pokemon until they're hurt enough to wanna cry for help, then if help comes, they have to watch as your pokemon takes out the other pokemon who came to help them. This whole cycle will likely continue until a pokemon of desired quality arrives, which could probably take a while...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
headscratchers is not to complaining


* [[ScrappyMechanic Disregarding how tedious the S.O.S. mechanic can be when you're just trying to get through a pokemon-populated area]], the idea behind said feature was established as a means of letting players seek out pokemon with hidden abilities, increased chances of encountering shinies, and certain pokemon only being encountered by way of S.O.S. However, did none of the developers consider [[UnfortunateImplication how cruel it sounds]] to have players force a beaten-up pokemon to cry out for help just to watch your pokemon take out the pokemon who came to help and then you force them to cry out for help and start the cycle again until the kind of pokemon you want finally arrives?

to:

* [[ScrappyMechanic Disregarding how tedious the S.O.S. mechanic can be when you're just trying to get through a pokemon-populated area]], the idea behind said feature was established as a means of letting players seek out pokemon with hidden abilities, increased chances of encountering shinies, and certain pokemon only being encountered by way of S.O.S. However, did none of the developers consider [[UnfortunateImplication how cruel it sounds]] to have players force a beaten-up pokemon to cry out for help just to watch your pokemon take out the pokemon who came to help and then you force them to cry out for help and start the cycle again until the kind of pokemon you want finally arrives?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*[[ScrappyMechanic Disregarding how tedious the S.O.S. mechanic can be when you're just trying to get through a pokemon-populated area]], the idea behind said feature was established as a means of letting players seek out pokemon with hidden abilities, increased chances of encountering shinies, and certain pokemon only being encountered by way of S.O.S. However, did none of the developers consider [[UnfortunateImplication how cruel it sounds]] to have players force a beaten-up pokemon to cry out for help just to watch your pokemon take out the pokemon who came to help and then you force them to cry out for help and start the cycle again until the kind of pokemon you want finally arrives?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** To be fair, this generation wasn't the first to clue us in that Mega Evolution isn't all it's cracked up to be; between Korrina's Lucario going berserk in the anime, Mega Evolutions losing control quickly in ''VideoGame/PokemonSuperMysteryDungeon'', and the emergence of concerning 'dex entries in ORAS (Glalie's broken jaw, Lopunny's anger issues, Sableye's gem tearing straight out of its chest, etc). This generation also shows us that Mega Evolution ''is'' beneficial to some Pokémon (Ampharos being able to regrow its wool, Pinsir enjoying its wings, etc) and, being an entire species of {{Blood Knight}}s, perhaps the other Pokémon are willing to put up with a moment of pain in order to win a battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The theory seems to have originated from [[https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/187276-pokemon-sun/74535483 this post]] on Website/''GameFAQS'', and many fans (admittedly, including myself) took it as fact. The fact that she said "''protect'' the Battle Tower" instead of something else might provide some evidence, but it is still very, very, scanty.

to:

** The theory seems to have originated from [[https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/187276-pokemon-sun/74535483 this post]] on Website/''GameFAQS'', ''Website/GameFAQS'', and many fans (admittedly, including myself) took it as fact. The fact that she said "''protect'' the Battle Tower" instead of something else might provide some evidence, but it is still very, very, scanty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In Ultra, when Mina hears about Hapu becoming the Kahuna, she mentions that they did used to call Nanu over to Poni Island to perform the Grand Trials.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's a legitimate query



to:

* Was there a reason to establish Mega Evolution as something horrible and abusive to the Pokemon that undergo it? Mega Evolution was a popular feature from the previous games, with a lot of Mega Evolutions becoming complete fan favorites for all involved, and the feature is still very much beloved, even in the wake of Z-Moves. So why go through all this effort to create Pokedex entries to establish that Mega Evolution is, in fact, evil, when the previous games preached it at a bond phenomenon between Pokemon and trainer?

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If one goes for in-universe logic then one possibility is the Raticate/Gumshoos would eventually get tired of switching holes and just come out and fight.


to:

** If one goes for in-universe logic then one possibility is the Raticate/Gumshoos would eventually get tired of switching holes and just come out and fight.

fight. Or if the trainer has enough pokemon then they could send them out to do the same thing the Grunts do in the game.

Top