Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / TheCartoonHistoryOfTheUniverse

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Example does not sufficiently explain how it applies, Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* SpellMyNameWithAnS: The chapters on China in the second book are hit ''hard'' by this, since at the time, Asian history and philosophy were much more esoteric in the US, so romanizations are touch-and-go. The spellings he went with are generally the phonetic ones, i.e. using Chin over Qin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Less artistic license and more Gonick just getting dates wrong. One example being the Battle of Kadesh having happened in 1288 BC rather than 1274. 1288 would have been during Seti I's reign not Ramesses II's.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Less artistic license and more Gonick just getting dates wrong. One example being the Battle of Kadesh having happened in 1288 BC rather than 1274. 1288 would have been during Seti I's reign not Ramesses II's. It also gives Ramesses' date of death as 1225 BC rather than 1213 BC.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: Less artistic license and more Gonick just getting dates wrong. One example being the Battle of Kadesh having happened in 1288 BC rather than 1274. 1288 would have been during Seti I's reign not Ramesses II's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FatherIWantToMarryMyBrother: When describing how Egypt was merciful towards their conquered foes by educating them in Egyptian ways, a son asks his father to marry his sister (since Egyptian royalty practiced interbreeding to keep the bloodline "pure"). The father promptly thinks "You call this mercy?"

to:

* FatherIWantToMarryMyBrother: When describing how Egypt was merciful towards their conquered foes by educating them in Egyptian ways, a son asks his father to marry his sister (since Egyptian royalty practiced interbreeding [[RoyalInbreeding interbreeding]] to keep the bloodline "pure"). The father promptly thinks "You call this mercy?"



* NotMeThisTime: Many of Alcibiades' misdeeds are covered in the book, but the narrative goes with the theory that he had nothing to do with the mutilation of the hermae that he was historically accused of.

to:

* NotMeThisTime: Many of Alcibiades' misdeeds are covered in the book, but the narrative goes with the theory that he had nothing to do with the mutilation of the hermae [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herm_(sculpture) hermae]] that he was historically accused of.of. Deconstructed, as Alcibiades fears that going on trial would result in him getting in trouble for one or more of his ''actual'' crimes, leading him to flee and defect to Sparta.

Added: 7796

Changed: 293

Removed: 352

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking.





* ActivistFundamentalistAntics: There's a minor running gag of groups the early Muslims failed to convert dealing with missionaries making ''exactly'' the wrong pitch. Examples include trying to present monotheism as novel to Jews, pushing their own idea of modest dress in Ghana where it's extremely impractical, and promoting male dominance to a female ruler.



* AllCavemenWereNeanderthals: Gonick comments on this, observing that the term "caveman" is not wholly accurate, as many Neanderthal and Cro-Magnon communities lived in tents and other man-made shelters. The term "caveman" came from the fact that caves tend to preserve fossils better, so more fossils of primitive tribes are located in caves.



* BeliefMakesYouStupid: Gonick is quick to point out and highlight the many religious absurdities found throughout history. Explicitly invoked in a brief bit about the Indian materialists; when they say that the supernatural and afterlife are lies keeping the people ignorant and afraid, the ruler angrily points out that he likes them better that way.



* BeliefMakesYouStupid: Gonick is quick to point out and highlight the many religious absurdities found throughout history. Explicitly invoked in a brief bit about the Indian materialists; when they say that the supernatural and afterlife are lies keeping the people ignorant and afraid, the ruler angrily points out that he likes them better that way.



* BombThrowingAnarchists: ''Cartoon History of the United States'' humorously lampshades the common stereotype of anarchists as mad, bearded bombers ("smell like garlic... foreign accent... burning fuse") during the 1880s Red Scare after the Haymarket Bombing.



* ChickenJoke: In the commentary on the origin of language, which soon led to the first jokes, a caveman tells the chicken to joke to another who comments that that's old already.



* DidTheEarthMoveForYouToo: A one-panel gag has two large dinosaurs "necking" saying this while the main narrative discussed continental drift.



* DroitDuSeigneur: Referenced the story of the Ethiopian general Abraham the Split-Face, [[NamedAfterTheInjury so named due to his taking an axe blade in the face during a duel]]. His servant saved him during the duel and helped him kill the other duelist, and Abraham offered to reward the servant anything he desired. When the servant demanded that he be allowed to exercise the Lord's Right, Abraham reluctantly agreed. However, after an irate husband murdered the servant, Abraham let the killer off and apologized for his servant's actions.



* FatherIWantToMarryMyBrother: When describing how Egypt was merciful towards their conquered foes by educating them in Egyptian ways, a son asks his father to marry his sister (since Egyptian royalty practiced interbreeding to keep the bloodline "pure"). The father promptly thinks "You call this mercy?"



* ForeignLookingFont: In the end of the first volume and the title page for the volume on early Indian history, the title is written in a pseudo-Devanagari font.



* GiveMeLibertyOrGiveMeDeath: In Part III, in the bit about the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zanj_Rebellion Zanj Rebellion]]. "Zanj" was a term for East African slaves (bought from their native rulers in what is now Kenya and Tanzania) who were employed in southern Iraq's production of sugarcane. They rose in revolt against the Arab, Persian, and Turkish rulers of the Abbasid Caliphate, and (as Gonick notes) fought ferociously for their freedom (primarily because the alternative was death). It's specifically brought up in an exchange between a Zanj and an Arab soldier where the former can settle for either his death or his foe's.
-->'''Zanj army:''' LIBERTY OR DEATH!\\
'''Frightened-looking Arab soldier:''' You lack sophistication, my dear fellow! Have you ever thought of the idea that no man is ever completely free?\\
'''Zanj soldier:''' But completely dead, yes!



%%* IdeaBulb: Lampshaded.

to:

%%* * IdeaBulb: Lampshaded.Lampshaded. A caveman having a brilliant idea has a light bulb appear above his head. When he reveals the flint knife he's created, another caveman says "Oh, I thought it was going to be a light bulb."



* InventingTheWheel: The inventor of the wheel shows it to his friend, expectantly saying "Well?" His friend says "A tray with a hole? Maybe you should see the spiritual adviser..." Gonick also observes that the earliest wheels were more likely used for making pottery.
* JesusTaboo: Most Biblical figures are referred to by their most common English names ("John" rather than "Yohanan," for instance) -- except for Jesus and Yahweh/Jehovah, invariably rendered as "Yeshua" and "Yahu-Wahu". "Yahu-Wahu" is part of a running gag; in the intro for the section that deals with Biblical times, the Professor says that they don't know the Jewish God's real name, just the consonants YHWH, and that it was eventually declared that anyone who said it would be [[BoltOfDivineRetribution struck by lightning]]. The Historian remarks that it could be anything, even "Yahu-Wahu" -- at which point he gets zapped. Thereafter, Gonick uses "Yahu" whenever he mentions the Jewish God.
* JesusWasCrazy: Jesus is depicted as woozy after being "baptized" and held under water too long. In another section he alternates (panel by panel) between thoughtful scholar, mystical parable-speaker, and fiery ranting preacher.
-->''"WOE UNTO YE, HYPOCRITES!"''



* JudgmentOfSolomon: Larry Gonick views this through the "political allegory" interpretation, where Solomon was using it as a way of telling Israel to accept his weaker claim to kingship over his brother's to avoid tearing the country apart in war.
* KangarooPouchRide: In the section about the spread of Cro-Magnons throughout the world, the map shows a woman riding in a kangaroo's pouch in Australia. The kangaroo looks a bit puzzled about this.



* LaughWithMe: Caligula, in a scene based on Suetonius's ''The Twelve Caesars'', bursts into hysterical laughter at a banquet. When a guest asks him why, the emperor says it just occurred to him that with a single word he could have the guest's throat slit. He resumes laughing, pausing briefly to say "You laugh too." The guest complies with a nervous chuckle.



* MistakenForIncest: Then-contemporary gossip suggested that the ancient Athenian politician Kimon wouldn't let his sister Elpinike marry because he had an incestuous desire for (and possibly affair with) her. In reality, it was because their father Miltiades died owing the Athenian government a large fine, leaving his family [[LandPoor rich in land but little else]]; there was no dowry for Elpinike, and since a dowry was a necessity for marriage in Ancient Athens, she couldn't get married until a wealthy man agreed to pay off the debt in exchange for her hand in marriage. This is punctuated by a two-panel sequence of Kimon telling Elpinike "I need you, sister... [[BaitAndSwitchComment I need you to get me money]]."



* MouthfulOfPi: Discussed in a footnote. Gonick believes that the accuracy of Pi is a pretty good indicator of a civilization's general mathematical and scientific ability. He then goes on to point out that Literature/TheBible specifies that the dimensions of the bronze basin for the Temple should be ten cubits across and thirty around, putting the value of Pi at '''exactly''' three.
-->'''Solomon:''' And now you know why I hired outside contractors as the architects!



* PyramidPower: The chapter on Ancient Egypt briefly mentions the concept of pyramids being built using alien knowledge, with an alien asking "Why build a pyramid when you can sharpen a razor blade in five minutes on a wet rock?"



** Muslim missionaries making exactly the wrong pitch to Sub-Saharan African rulers: arguing for modesty of dress in Ghana (where dressing less was an asset) or for the sequestration of women (not really a Muslim doctrine, but it had become part of the package by that time) to a woman ruler.

to:

** Muslim missionaries making exactly the wrong pitch to Sub-Saharan African rulers: potential converts, such as depicting monotheism as a novel concept to the Jews, arguing for modesty of dress in Ghana (where dressing less was an asset) or asset), and proposing for the sequestration of women (not really a Muslim doctrine, but it had become part of the package by that time) to a woman ruler.


Added DiffLines:

* TastyGold: Mentioned in the leadup to Archimedes' famous discovery: the king needed a way to determine whether his crowns were counterfeit without having to rely on biting them, since they were getting bent out of shape.


Added DiffLines:

* WomensMysteries Parodied. In a sequence depicting the Neolithic Agricultural Revolution (which women are widely thought to have initiated), an exhausted woman farmer tells a man the women could use some help and asks if he'd like a job. He covers his ears and says, "[[LazyBum Silence!]] These mysteries are not for the ears of men."


Added DiffLines:

* YouCantMakeAnOmelette: This line is "You can't make a country without breaking a few eggheads," spoken by the Chinese Communists in an aside about how UsefulNotes/QinShiHuangdi (a tyrannical historic ruler) is a role model for the current government.

Added: 2263

Changed: 539

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: While King David [[UriahGambit deliberately getting Uriah killed in battle]] after impregnating the man's wife Bathsheba so they can be together is straight out of the Bible, he comes off as somewhat worse here. The comic omits David's initial plan to have the baby passed off as Uriah's by calling him home in the hopes that he would sleep with Bathsheba, instead having him skip right to having Joab arrange his death. David's [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone remorse]] after being [[WhatTheHellHero scolded by the prophet Nathan]] also gets left out.



** During a section discussing stone age technological progress, a caveman is shown carrying a TV set.
** Joab tells the future King David that he's like the Little John to David's Myth/RobinHood, referencing folk heroes that wouldn't exist for over a thousand years. This is lampshaded when David admits he has no idea what Joab is talking about.



** It's claimed that the Samaritans were descended from people transported to the Kingdom of Israel by the Assyrians. This was a popular theory once, but it's since fallen out of favor due to DNA evidence indicating that the Samaritans are actually an offshoot of the Ancient Hebrews.



* DudeNotFunny: One of the Israelites forcibly transported by the Assyrians quips that "it's just like the Exodus all over again!" Another responds with "that's not funny!"



* MarkOfShame: When not enough citizens appeared for Athenian civic duties, state-owned slaves would pull them in with ropes dipped in red paint. The resulting "vermillion stripe" was considered deeply embarrasing.
-->'''Athenian passerby:''' What's the matter, Euphronion? [[RussianReversal Slave put his brand on you]]?



* SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in his sermons, which is actually [[TruthInTelevision true to history]]!

to:

* SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther RussianReversal: Subtly done in Volume 7. An Athenian man who was forcibly pulled in for jury duty by a state-owned Scythian slave is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in taunted for the stripe left on his sermons, which clothes by the paint-dipped rope the slave used to drag him along, with one man rhetorically asking if a slave put his brand on him. Remember that Scythian territory included part of what is actually [[TruthInTelevision true to history]]!now Russia...



%%* SlaveMooks: The Athenian police.

to:

%%* * SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in his sermons, which is actually [[TruthInTelevision true to history]]!
*
SlaveMooks: The Ancient Athenian police.police were made up of Scythian archers owned by the state. One of their duties was pulling citizens in for civic chores on days when not enough showed up to carry them out.


Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: Gonick takes a shot at people who try to come up with "naturalistic" explanations for Old Testament accounts of miracles, openly referring to them as "nuts". [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immanuel_Velikovsky Immanuel Velikovsky]] and his bizarre theories are singled out by name, probably due to him being a prominent and controversial figure at the time.

Added: 606

Changed: 23

Removed: 299

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalConsent: The Biblical story of David and Bathsheba leaves a question mark over [[QuestionableConsent whether Bathsheba truly consented to the affair]]. Here, it's all but stated that Bathsheba was deliberately trying to seduce him, so this version of the story has no such potential for dubcon.



** Gonick puts far more stock the historicity of certain Biblical stories than more recent historians (and when it comes to early Christianity, his AuthorAvatar all but nervously admits that much of its material had to be taken straight from the New Testament due to the paucity of other accounts).



** Gonick puts far more stock the historicity of certain Biblical stories than more recent historians (and when it comes to early Christianity, his AuthorAvatar all but nervously admits that much of its material had to be taken straight from the New Testament due to the paucity of other accounts).



* LanguageEqualsThought: Lampshaded when the narrative mentions how Romans decimated (i.e., killed every tenth person -- though in actual Roman times this was reserved for executing deserters, but RuleOfFunny reigns in this case) Athens.

to:

* LanguageEqualsThought: Lampshaded when the narrative mentions how Romans decimated (i.e., killed every tenth person -- though in actual Roman times this was reserved for executing deserters, disobedient military units, but RuleOfFunny reigns in this case) Athens.

Added: 530

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CuriosityCausesConversion: Noted in several instances, but particularly when it comes to the history of UsefulNotes/{{Christianity}} (where it is emphatically TruthInTelevision). For instance, in one panel, a pagan Roman couple in the arena watch with fascination as a Christian martyr enthusiastically welcomes death by lion ("C'mon! What are you waiting for?"):

to:

* CuriosityCausesConversion: Noted in several instances, but particularly when it comes to the history of UsefulNotes/{{Christianity}} (where it is emphatically TruthInTelevision). For instance, in one panel, a pagan Roman couple in the arena watch with fascination as a Christian martyr enthusiastically welcomes [[FedToTheBeast death by lion lion]] ("C'mon! What are you waiting for?"):



* DatedHistory: There are some parts of these comics that haven't aged well.

to:

* DatedHistory: There are some parts of these comics that haven't aged well.well, factually speaking.



** Neanderthals being driven extinct due to conquest and extermination by the Cro-Magnons has been increasingly challenged by archaeological and genetic evidence. While not ''completely'' discredited, it's generally believed in the scientific community that it was, at most, one of multiple factors.

to:

** Neanderthals being [[ClashOfEvolutionaryLevels driven extinct to extinction due to conquest and extermination by the Cro-Magnons Cro-Magnons]] has been increasingly challenged by archaeological and genetic evidence. While not ''completely'' discredited, it's generally believed in the scientific community that it was, at most, one of multiple factors.



** Accounts of a Sumerian ritual where the king would engage in ritual sex with the high priestess of Inanna are presented as unambiguously true, since in the 20th century, historical consensus took these claims at face value. However, the 21st saw the rise of a competing theory, one that claimed the unions were mere embellishments designed to add to the king's image; proponents of this hypothesis point to how those exact same claimed outright impossible feats from these kings, such as them running 200 miles in a single day.



** Gonick ascribes more geopolitical importance to the Battle of Talas than 21st century historians generally do, claiming that it marked the end of Chinese hegemony over Central Asia. To his credit, he says Tang influence in the region ''could'' have recovered if not for the An Lushan rebellion, but the narrative that the battle marked a turning point is no longer taken seriously since evidence suggests Chinese control there actually ''increased'' between the battle and the rebellion.

to:

** Gonick ascribes more geopolitical importance to the Battle of Talas than 21st century historians generally do, claiming that it marked the end of Chinese hegemony over Central Asia. To his credit, he says Tang influence in the region ''could'' have recovered if not for the outbreak of the An Lushan rebellion, but the narrative that the battle marked a turning point is no longer taken seriously since evidence suggests Chinese control there actually ''increased'' between the battle and the rebellion.



* VillainHasAPoint: Salome, Herod the Great's sister, uses some very underhanded and even malicious tactics to try and maneuver one of her sons into becoming King of the Jews. However, when she insists to Augustus that putting Archelaus on the throne would be a bad idea, she turns out to be right: his rule is plagued by controversy and unrest, forcing Augustus to depose him and impose direct Roman rule over his territory.

to:

* VillainHasAPoint: Salome, Herod the Great's sister, uses some very underhanded and even malicious tactics to try and [[MotherMakesYouKing maneuver one of her sons into becoming King of the Jews.Jews]]. However, when she insists to Augustus that putting Archelaus on the throne would be a bad idea, she turns out to be right: his rule is plagued by controversy and unrest, forcing Augustus to depose him and impose direct Roman rule over his territory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Dorian Chief:''' (''doting over his wife while being surrounded by piles of corpses'') Oh, did you cut your finger, dear?

to:

-->'''Dorian Chief:''' (''doting over his wife while being surrounded by piles of corpses'') corpses, and carrying a spear upon which is impaled the body of a BABY'') Oh, did you cut your finger, dear?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilroyWasHere: A Greek mercenary is shown leaving his name on an Egyptian building. Gonick did not make this up, incidentally. Said graffiti is a documented historical artifact.

to:

* KilroyWasHere: A Greek mercenary is shown leaving his name on an Egyptian building. Gonick did not make this up, incidentally. Said graffiti building, which is a documented historical artifact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KilroyWasHere: A Greek mercenary is shown leaving his name on an Egyptian building.

to:

* KilroyWasHere: A Greek mercenary is shown leaving his name on an Egyptian building. Gonick did not make this up, incidentally. Said graffiti is a documented historical artifact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's claimed that Neanderthals couldn't articulate many sounds, so they probably used a language consisting of grunts and gesticulation. This hypothesis was based on assumptions about Neanderthal physiology that were later proven incorrect; the current belief is that while Neanderthals probably couldn't produce as many sounds as modern humans, they could still produce enough of them to have a spoken language.



** On the topic of Thutmose III and his predecessor Hatshepsut, Gonick runs with the then-mainstream theory that Hatshepsut tried to keep Thutmose out of power, leading him to try and [[{{unperson}} erase her from Egyptian history]] after she died out of revenge when he became pharaoh. This account has been discredited; it's now known that Thutmose held a lot of support in the military and could probably have overthrown Hatshepsut if he wanted to, so it's more likely that the two shared power and may even have been co-rulers. Furthermore, Thutmose kept religious and administrative leaders appointed by Hatshepsut in their positions and had his mortuary temple built next to hers, both of which he was unlikely to have done if he really did have a grudge against her. As for the defacing of her monuments, it's now known to have happened much later than previously thought and is believed to have been done by either a very old Thutmose or his son and coregent Amenhotep II to prevent one of Hatshepsut's relatives from being elevated to the throne.

to:

** On the topic of Thutmose III and his predecessor Hatshepsut, Gonick runs with the then-mainstream theory that Hatshepsut tried to keep Thutmose out of power, leading him to try and [[{{unperson}} erase her from Egyptian history]] after she died out of revenge {{revenge}} when he became pharaoh. This account has been discredited; it's now known that Thutmose held a lot of support in the military and could probably have overthrown Hatshepsut if he wanted to, so it's more likely that the two shared power and may even have been co-rulers. Furthermore, Thutmose kept religious and administrative leaders appointed by Hatshepsut in their positions and had his mortuary temple built next to hers, both of which he was unlikely to have done if he really did have a grudge against her. As for the defacing of her monuments, it's now known to have happened much later than previously thought and is believed to have been done by either a very old Thutmose or his son and coregent Amenhotep II to prevent one of Hatshepsut's relatives from being elevated to the throne.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAbridgedHistory: Gonick takes creative liberties with some aspects of history. However, his facts are mostly accurate, and not strictly parodic.
* AllCrimesAreEqual: Discussed in the sections covering the invention of laws and legal systems. He takes particular aim at Han Feizi and the the Chinese Legalists, who advocated this policy, showing exactly how well it worked for the Qin Dynasty (it led directly to their destruction).
* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Averted, but frequently joked about, particularly through use of YiddishAsASecondLanguage:

to:

* TheAbridgedHistory: Gonick takes creative liberties with some aspects of history. However, his {{Downplayed}}. Although it does go quite a bit into actual history and facts and dates, the panels and commentary are mostly accurate, drawn in a way that is meant to be both humorous and not strictly parodic.
educational.
* AllCrimesAreEqual: Discussed in the sections covering the invention of laws and legal systems. He takes particular aim at Han Feizi and the the Chinese Legalists, who advocated this policy, showing exactly how well it worked for the Qin Dynasty (it led directly to their destruction).
* AllJewsAreAshkenazi: Averted, but frequently joked about, particularly through the use of YiddishAsASecondLanguage:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not really a pun


** Carlos V is portrayed with an ever increasing stack of crowns to show just how much of the European world he ruled.

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllCrimesAreEqual: Averted in the sections covering the invention of laws and legal systems. He takes particular aim at Han Feizi and the the Chinese Legalists, who advocated this policy, showing exactly how well it worked for the Qin Dynasty (it led directly to their destruction).

to:

* AllCrimesAreEqual: Averted Discussed in the sections covering the invention of laws and legal systems. He takes particular aim at Han Feizi and the the Chinese Legalists, who advocated this policy, showing exactly how well it worked for the Qin Dynasty (it led directly to their destruction).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorAvatar: Gonick's authorial voice is provided by "the Professor," who uses a library he calls a "time machine" to read history books and imagine the events they describe, showing the reader the events in comic book format. He is represented both in the narration and also appears directly in the events he describes, speaking to historical characters or [[BreakingTheFourthWall directly to the reader]].

to:

* AuthorAvatar: Gonick's authorial voice is provided by "the Professor," who uses a library he calls a "time machine" to read history books and imagine the events they describe, showing the reader the events in comic book format. He is represented both in the narration and also appears directly in the events he describes, speaking to historical characters or [[BreakingTheFourthWall directly to the reader]]. The Professor's appearance is obviously based on Albert Einstein.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At the end of Volume 1 of ''Modern World'', Gonick asks point blank how historians can be expected to remain impartial and unbiased in the face of the horrific atrocities committed by the Spanish conquistadors against America's natives.

Added: 566

Changed: 235

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* AnachronismStew: Frequently used for comedy.

to:

%%* * AnachronismStew: Frequently used for comedy.comedy. One common form this takes is [[YiddishAsASecondLanguage the use of Yiddish words and phrases]] by Jewish characters, even millennia before the Yiddish language existed.



* AuthorTract: Gonick manages to not rant too much except in occasional circumstances, but his political leanings are pretty impossible to miss.

to:

* AuthorTract: Gonick manages to not rant too much except in occasional circumstances, but his political leanings are pretty much impossible to miss.miss if you're paying attention.



** Neanderthals being driven extinct due to conquest and extermination by the Cro-Magnons has been increasingly challenged by archaeological and genetic evidence. While not ''completely'' discredited, it's generally believed in the scientific community that it was, at most, one of multiple factors.
** Speaking of Cro-Magnons, they're universally depicted as having light skin; it's now largely accepted that early European modern humans were almost all dark-skinned until around 30,000 years ago, and many Europeans still had dark skin until around 5,000 years ago.



** What destroys the Indus Valley Civilization in Volume 8 is conquest by the Indo-Aryans, based on a now-discredited theory formulated by Sir Mortimer Wheeler. Since the supposed evidence of violence has since been ascribed to other factors, it's now believed that changes in climate and a series of earthquakes were responsible for the civilization's decline and eventual collapse.

to:

** What destroys the Indus Valley Civilization in Volume 8 is conquest brutal invasion and subjugation by the Indo-Aryans, based on a now-discredited theory formulated by Sir Mortimer Wheeler. Since the supposed evidence of violence has since been ascribed to other factors, it's now believed that changes in climate and a series of earthquakes were responsible for the civilization's decline and eventual collapse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PyrrhicVictory: Aside from the TropeNamer appearing during the segment on Rome, this is how Liu Bang's triumph in the Qin civil war is portrayed. He defeated Xiang Yu, became Emperor, and formed a new, succesful dynasty, but his wife and concubines are at each other's throats, his children despise, and his realm is becoming increasingly unstable. He himself lampshades this shortly before his death, wondering if becoming Emperor was worth it in the end.

to:

* PyrrhicVictory: Aside from the TropeNamer appearing during the segment on Rome, this is how Liu Bang's triumph in the Qin civil war is portrayed. He defeated Xiang Yu, became Emperor, and formed a new, succesful dynasty, but his wife and concubines are at each other's throats, his children despise, despise him, and his realm is becoming increasingly unstable. He himself lampshades this shortly before his death, wondering if becoming Emperor was worth it in the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PyrrhicVictory: Aside from the TropeNamer appearing during the segment on Rome, this is how Liu Bang's triumph in the Qin civil war is portrayed. He defeated Xiang Yu, became Emperor, and formed a new, succesful dynasty, but his wife and concubines are at each other's throats, his children despise, and his realm is becoming increasingly unstable. He himself lampshades this shortly before his death, wondering if becoming Emperor was worth it in the end.

Added: 1263

Changed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Right before nailing Goliath with his sling, David says he's gonna give him a "zetz".



* CategoryTraitor: Parodied early on, where a couple of wolves contemptuously refer to a domestic dog as an "Uncle Tom".



** He puts far more stock the historicity of certain Biblical stories than more recent historians (and when it comes to early Christianity, his AuthorAvatar all but nervously admits that much of its material had to be taken straight from the New Testament due to the paucity of other accounts).

to:

** He Gonick puts far more stock the historicity of certain Biblical stories than more recent historians (and when it comes to early Christianity, his AuthorAvatar all but nervously admits that much of its material had to be taken straight from the New Testament due to the paucity of other accounts).



** On the topic of Thutmose III and his predecessor Hatshepsut, Gonick runs with the then-mainstream theory that Hatshepsut tried to keep Thutmose out of power, leading him to try and [[{{unperson}} erase her from Egyptian history]] after she died out of revenge when he became pharaoh. This account has been discredited; it's now known that Thutmose held a lot of support in the military and could probably have overthrown Hatshepsut if he wanted to, so it's more likely that the two shared power and may even have been co-rulers. Furthermore, Thutmose kept religious and administrative leaders appointed by Hatshepsut in their positions and had his mortuary temple built next to hers, both of which he was unlikely to have done if he really did have a grudge against her. As for the defacing of her monuments, it's now known to have happened much later than previously thought and is believed to have been done by either a very old Thutmose or his son and coregent Amenhotep II to prevent one of Hatshepsut's relatives from being elevated to the throne.



** Gonick ascribes more importance to the Battle of Talas than 21st century historians generally do, claiming that it marked the end of Chinese hegemony over Central Asia. To his credit, he says Tang influence in the region ''could'' have recovered if not for the An Lushan rebellion, but the narrative that the battle marked a turning point is no longer taken seriously since evidence suggests Chinese control there actually ''increased'' between the battle and the rebellion.

to:

** Gonick ascribes more geopolitical importance to the Battle of Talas than 21st century historians generally do, claiming that it marked the end of Chinese hegemony over Central Asia. To his credit, he says Tang influence in the region ''could'' have recovered if not for the An Lushan rebellion, but the narrative that the battle marked a turning point is no longer taken seriously since evidence suggests Chinese control there actually ''increased'' between the battle and the rebellion.



* TheGhost: UsefulNotes/TheProphetMuhammad and certain other figures from Muslim history, out of respect for mainstream Islam's prohibition on visual representations of them. This decision was made well before the international Mohammed cartoon controversy. The one main figure in that section he does show, Abu Sufyan, tells the reader that he never really bought the religion and doesn't actually care if he's shown.

to:

* TheGhost: UsefulNotes/TheProphetMuhammad and certain other figures from early Muslim history, out of respect for mainstream Islam's prohibition on visual representations of them. This decision was made well before the international Mohammed cartoon controversy. The one main figure in that section he does show, Abu Sufyan, tells the reader that he never really bought the religion and doesn't actually care if he's shown.



** Drawing Robert Guiscard, a Norman lord, [[FurriesAreEasierToDraw as a weasel]] ("Guiscard" means "weasel" in French).

to:

** Drawing Robert Guiscard, a Norman lord, lord famed for his conquests in Italy, [[FurriesAreEasierToDraw as a weasel]] ("Guiscard" means "weasel" in French).



* SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in his sermons, which is actually true to history!

to:

* SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in his sermons, which is actually [[TruthInTelevision true to history!history]]!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Carlos V is portrayed with an ever increasing stack of crowns to show just how much of the European world he ruled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Byzantine Empire had a policy of [[EyeScream gouging out the eyes]] of incompetent or otherwise failed Emperors, claiming it to be more "civilized" than simply executing them. Naturally, given the history of the Empire, Gonick has a field day with this concept.


Added DiffLines:

* SirSwearsALot: Martin Luther is portrayed as being ''very'' foul mouthed in his sermons, which is actually true to history!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope split


* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: Parodied with the etymology of the word slave (derived from Slav).

to:

* PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad: PoliticalOvercorrectness: Parodied with the etymology of the word slave (derived from Slav).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Dorian Chief:''' (''doting over his wife while being surrounded by piles of corpses'') Ooh, honey, did you hurt your finger?

to:

-->'''Dorian Chief:''' (''doting over his wife while being surrounded by piles of corpses'') Ooh, honey, Oh, did you hurt cut your finger?finger, dear?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bald Of Awesome is being renamed and redefined per TRS decision


%%* BaldOfAwesome: Quite a few people, including Moses and Elisha.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also ''WebVideo/CrashCourse World History'' which has a similar attitude towards more or less the same subject matter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AquaticSauropods: As it was written at a time when evidence and arguments against the idea of aquatic sauropods were being debated, the first issue alternates between showing sauropods in the water and on land (albeit usually on very muddy ground).

Added: 107

Changed: 308

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: Frequently used for comedy.

to:

* %%* AnachronismStew: Frequently used for comedy.



** Gonick sticks a number of critical references to the administration of George W. Bush in ''The Cartoon History of the Modern World.''
* BaldOfAwesome: Quite a few people, including Moses and Elisha.

to:

** Gonick sticks a number of critical references to the administration of George W. Bush in ''The Cartoon History of the Modern World.''
*
World''.
%%*
BaldOfAwesome: Quite a few people, including Moses and Elisha.



'''Pagan Woman:''' [[CreepyMonotone Must...find...out...]]

to:

'''Pagan Woman:''' [[CreepyMonotone Must...find... find... out...]]



* DeadpanSnarker: A lot of people.

to:

* %%* DeadpanSnarker: A lot of people.



* EyepatchOfPower: Lykurgos from Spartan history/legend, described as "great and mysterious", is drawn with one.

to:

* EyepatchOfPower: Lykurgos from Spartan history/legend, described as "great and mysterious", is drawn with one.an eyepatch.



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Obviously.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Obviously.With the exception of Gonick's own avatar, all characters in the books are either historical individuals or figures from myth and religious texts.



* IdeaBulb: Lampshaded.

to:

* %%* IdeaBulb: Lampshaded.



* RussianBear: Russia in the late 19th century is shown as a menacing bear from the Japanese point of view.



* SlaveMooks: The Athenian police.

to:

* %%* SlaveMooks: The Athenian police.



* WhatsAHenway: This exchange when King Solomon meets Hiram, king of the "sophisticated seaport" of Tyre:

to:

* WhatsAHenway: This exchange when When King Solomon meets Hiram, king of the "sophisticated seaport" of Tyre:Tyre, the latter responds to the former's inquiry as to whether he's Hiram with a crack about how he hires 'em and fires 'em too.

Top