Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MagnaCarta2

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* IdiotPlot: The entire plot hinges on everyone [[VillainsNeverLie immediately believing everything that the villains say without question]].



* WhatAnIdiot:
** Melissa. [[spoiler:After the Northern Forces raze her homeland and nearly kill her, she somehow believes everything they tell her about their reasons and ''joins'' them. When she finds out that they've been lying to her, she's polite enough to hand her notice into Claire first. Claire warns her that Bad Things will happen if she switches sides, pointing out Melissa's mysterious chest pains and how she miraculously became good as new after almost being killed by Elgar. Melissa ''ignores'' this, [[GuestStarPartyMember joins your party for about ten minutes]], dismisses her chest pains as "nothing" (when in the presence of the ''one'' friendly character with the experience to identify and fix the problem), and then is promptly turned into a Sentinel and forced to be put down]].
** Raud. While he has several moments showing that he is a good tactican, his status as "adviser" leaves much to be desired. [[spoiler:Even though he finds out that Alex is in cahoots with Schuenzeit and is manipulating the course of the war, he waits until ''after'' the next battle to say anything to Zephie, by which time Alex and Schuenzeit have skipped town. This is despite the fact that he is ''present'' at said battle and doesn't even ''hint'' that anything is amiss when you talk to him. Then he decides to believe what the villains say and turns on Zephie]].
** Schuenzeit has a particularly stupid moment before the game even starts. [[spoiler:Why was he so surprised that Juto fought so hard to save Zephie when ''he himself'' implanted Juto with the command that "you must not allow the princess to be killed", even going so far to add the condition, "this order supersedes all others"? You could argue that this single act is the root cause of everything that goes wrong with his plans]].
*** Then again, it's possible [[spoiler:Shuenzeit had initially planned on disposing of Elgar before sacrificing Zephie]]?

Added: 792

Changed: 787

Removed: 287

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not YMMV. Moved.


* GameBreakingBug: It's possible for an AI-controller character to get knocked off the cliff in Ruhalt Plateau and said character will not respawn properly until leaving the region or loading the save file. God help you if it happens to a character when you're fighting [[spoiler:Alex]].



* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel
* WhatAnIdiot: Melissa. [[spoiler:After the Northern Forces raze her homeland and nearly kill her, she somehow believes everything they tell her about their reasons and ''joins'' them. When she finds out that they've been lying to her, she's polite enough to hand her notice into Claire first. Claire warns her that Bad Things will happen if she switches sides, pointing out Melissa's mysterious chest pains and how she miraculously became good as new after almost being killed by Elgar. Melissa ''ignores'' this, [[GuestStarPartyMember joins your party for about ten minutes]], dismisses her chest pains as "nothing" (when in the presence of the ''one'' friendly character with the experience to identify and fix the problem), and then is promptly turned into a Sentinel and forced to be put down]].

to:

* %%* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel
* WhatAnIdiot: WhatAnIdiot:
**
Melissa. [[spoiler:After the Northern Forces raze her homeland and nearly kill her, she somehow believes everything they tell her about their reasons and ''joins'' them. When she finds out that they've been lying to her, she's polite enough to hand her notice into Claire first. Claire warns her that Bad Things will happen if she switches sides, pointing out Melissa's mysterious chest pains and how she miraculously became good as new after almost being killed by Elgar. Melissa ''ignores'' this, [[GuestStarPartyMember joins your party for about ten minutes]], dismisses her chest pains as "nothing" (when in the presence of the ''one'' friendly character with the experience to identify and fix the problem), and then is promptly turned into a Sentinel and forced to be put down]].



*** Then again, it's possible [[spoiler:Shuenzeit had initially planned on disposing of Elgar before sacrificing Zephie]]?

to:

*** Then again, it's possible [[spoiler:Shuenzeit had initially planned on disposing of Elgar before sacrificing Zephie]]?Zephie]]?
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Schuenzeit has a particularly stupid moment before the game even starts. [[spoiler:Why was he so surprised that Juto fought so hard to save Zephie when ''he himself'' implanted Juto with the command that "you must not allow the princess to be killed", even going so far to add the condition, "this order supersedes all others"? You could argue that this single act is the root cause of everything that goes wrong with his plans]].

to:

** Schuenzeit has a particularly stupid moment before the game even starts. [[spoiler:Why was he so surprised that Juto fought so hard to save Zephie when ''he himself'' implanted Juto with the command that "you must not allow the princess to be killed", even going so far to add the condition, "this order supersedes all others"? You could argue that this single act is the root cause of everything that goes wrong with his plans]].plans]].
*** Then again, it's possible [[spoiler:Shuenzeit had initially planned on disposing of Elgar before sacrificing Zephie]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GameBreakingBug: It's possible for an AI-controller character to get knocked off the cliff in Ruhalt Plateau and said character will not respawn properly until leaving the region or loading the save file. God help you if it happens to a character when you're fighting [[spoiler:Alex]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IdiotPlot: The entire plot hinges on everyone [[VillainsNeverLie immediately believing everything that the villains say without question]].

Added: 1935

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GameBreaker: The DLC weapons are the strongest weapons in the game, and can be used almost immediately.
* SurprisinglyImprovedSequel
* WhatAnIdiot: Melissa. [[spoiler:After the Northern Forces raze her homeland and nearly kill her, she somehow believes everything they tell her about their reasons and ''joins'' them. When she finds out that they've been lying to her, she's polite enough to hand her notice into Claire first. Claire warns her that Bad Things will happen if she switches sides, pointing out Melissa's mysterious chest pains and how she miraculously became good as new after almost being killed by Elgar. Melissa ''ignores'' this, [[GuestStarPartyMember joins your party for about ten minutes]], dismisses her chest pains as "nothing" (when in the presence of the ''one'' friendly character with the experience to identify and fix the problem), and then is promptly turned into a Sentinel and forced to be put down]].
** Raud. While he has several moments showing that he is a good tactican, his status as "adviser" leaves much to be desired. [[spoiler:Even though he finds out that Alex is in cahoots with Schuenzeit and is manipulating the course of the war, he waits until ''after'' the next battle to say anything to Zephie, by which time Alex and Schuenzeit have skipped town. This is despite the fact that he is ''present'' at said battle and doesn't even ''hint'' that anything is amiss when you talk to him. Then he decides to believe what the villains say and turns on Zephie]].
** Schuenzeit has a particularly stupid moment before the game even starts. [[spoiler:Why was he so surprised that Juto fought so hard to save Zephie when ''he himself'' implanted Juto with the command that "you must not allow the princess to be killed", even going so far to add the condition, "this order supersedes all others"? You could argue that this single act is the root cause of everything that goes wrong with his plans]].

Top