Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / LostGirl

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why was the reveal that [[spoiler: Trick is Bo's grandfather]] treated as such a shock? If I remember right, in the episode that explains [[spoiler: Aife's backstory it's explicitly state that she's Trick's daughter]] so shouldn't the first relationship follow from the second?

to:

* Why was the reveal that [[spoiler: Trick is Bo's grandfather]] treated as such a shock? If I remember right, in the episode that explains [[spoiler: Aife's backstory it's explicitly state that she's Trick's daughter]] so shouldn't the first relationship follow from the second?second?
* ''I Fought the Fae (and the Fae Won)''[--s2e02--]. Quick recap: Sabine[--(''Light Fae'')--], Hamish[--(''Dark Fae'')--] [[StarCrossedLovers love each other]]. Hamish can go [[VisibleInvisibility invisible]]. Sabine is to be hunted[--(boy&arrows)--]; winner becomes the new Ash. Team Bo want to save her. Teamwork leads to Hale being one of three hunters. [[spoiler: Besides not trying to kill Sabine, he has no effect on anything after the hunt starts. Could be replaced by a puppy chasing its tail.]] If Sabine can ring the bell, she is free, and the hunters disqualified from being the Ash. Sabine and Dyson near the bell, Bo and Kenzi are behind a nearby tree. Sabine runs towards the bell, the team "can't interfere" because Tradition. The douchey hunter appears. Dyson growls; Bo tells a running Sabine to run. [[spoiler: The hunter releases his poison-tipped arrow. Invisible boyfriend invisibly deflects the arrow, so Sabine only get's impaled through the shoulder, and dies (from poison) next to the bell. Douchey hunter, now the Ash '''immediately''' threatens Bo and her Fae-independence. Lauren revives Sabine with science.]]
# Sabine and Hamish are still from opposing clans. So if the laws are sacred enough to keep a woman in prison for 80 years for loving the wrong person, and then the society is ok with hunting her as part of a ceremonial election, [[spoiler: won't they just get in trouble again now that they're back together?]]
# It's not explicitly said if Hamish was "in on the plan", [[spoiler: or if his appearance was a surprise.]]
## If unplanned, was the group just hoping Sabine would make it, [[spoiler:and then maybe be able to revive Sabine if her death was ''only'' from poisoning.]]
## If planned, [[spoiler: why was their plan so crappy?? If Sabine had reached the bell, she'd be free, and the hunter (who immediately threatens Bo) wouldn't be the Ash. Bo & Co. could have done literally something. Invisible Hamish could have done anything. Literally anything, and Sabine could've reached the bell and not have had to get arrowed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** No, being human is largely about biological systems and D.N.A. in a show like this where not every nonhuman creature is a monster. It is very speciesist of you to insist humans trump all other species, that everything has to obey human morals, or that the same morals apply to other lifeforms. Yes, humans have the right to be afraid of Fae. Any prey has the right to be afraid of their predator. Deer are afraid of humans. Humans are afraid of Fae. The Fae were afraid of the Garuda. Different levels of the food chain. And I told you why the Fae would not give humans their powers. Points which you did not address. Succubuses for better or worse are not human and feed on humans to survive. That is a better excuse than humans raping or killing other humans. Is it a good thing from a human standpoint? For most people no. There are other ways to survive without using their powers to violate others. Bo has survived through a combination of feeding on willing Fae and a few humans. The humans she feeds upon are willing and she does not kill them. We do not know enough about other succumbuses to know how they commonly feed. If they feed on willing participates or people that want to sleep with the without killing them and only feed enough to survive I see that as a good compromise that does not violate the human.

to:

*** No, being human is largely about biological systems and D.N.A. in a show like this where not every nonhuman creature is a monster. It is very speciesist of you to insist humans trump all other species, that everything has to obey human morals, or that the same morals apply to other lifeforms. Yes, humans have the right to be afraid of Fae. Any prey has the right to be afraid of their predator. Deer are afraid of humans. Humans are afraid of Fae. The Fae were afraid of the Garuda. Different levels of the food chain. And I told you why the Fae would not give humans their powers. Points which you did not address. Succubuses for better or worse are not human and feed on humans to survive. That is a better excuse than humans raping or killing other humans. Is it a good thing from a human standpoint? For most people no. There are other ways to survive without using their powers to violate others. Bo has survived through a combination of feeding on willing Fae and a few humans. The humans she feeds upon are willing and she does not kill them. We do not know enough about other succumbuses to know how they commonly feed. If they feed on willing participates or people that want to sleep with the without killing them and only feed enough to survive I see that as a good compromise that does not violate the human.human.
* Why was the reveal that [[spoiler: Trick is Bo's grandfather]] treated as such a shock? If I remember right, in the episode that explains [[spoiler: Aife's backstory it's explicitly state that she's Trick's daughter]] so shouldn't the first relationship follow from the second?

Top