Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / ShakuganNoShana

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Totally missed the point of the first season.


* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

to:

* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

Changed: 520

Removed: 1250

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed natter


* If any evidence that you ever existed is deleted when your existence is devoured, what happens to any children you may have had?
** They stay, but lose all their memories about you. Except when someone takes your place like Shana does once, which seems a good way to easily get a family.
*** But if everything about you was erased from existence, why are people like Shana or even her enemies able to remember them at all? If you ate someone by wiping them out from existence such that even their past is gone, ''you'd forget that you'd just ate somebody!'' There'd also be nothing left in the universe for you to even BASE a torch on, and people would immediately forget about the person even WITH a torch. It's logical snarls like that that had me call bullshit on the entire series.
*** Knowledge of the Crimson World is apparently enough of a buffer to remember people who've lost their existence. But by all means, get indignant about things you haven't bothered to learn.
* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool. The series having a central character who isn't even really a person is one of the ''other'' reasons I call bullshit on the whole series.
** The relevance of "isn't really a person" was discussed. ''Very early on.''

to:

* If any evidence that you ever existed is deleted when your existence is devoured, what happens to any children you may have had?
** They stay, but lose all their memories about you. Except when someone takes your place like Shana does once, which seems a good way to easily get a family.
*** But if everything about you was erased from existence, why are people like Shana or even her enemies able to remember them at all? If you ate someone by wiping them out from existence such that even their past is gone, ''you'd forget that you'd just ate somebody!'' There'd also be nothing left in the universe for you to even BASE a torch on, and people would immediately forget about the person even WITH a torch. It's logical snarls like that that had me call bullshit on the entire series.
*** Knowledge of the Crimson World is apparently enough of a buffer to remember people who've lost their existence. But by all means, get indignant about things you haven't bothered to learn.
* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool. The series having a central character who isn't even really a person is one of the ''other'' reasons I call bullshit on the whole series.\n** The relevance of "isn't really a person" was discussed. ''Very early on.''\n
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Power of Existence is a metaphor for influence upon reality. Being from another world, the Denizens cannot influence the human world unless they obtain influence from those who exist. Everything has an impact upon reality, so everything has the Power of Existence. Because living things can influence their world more than dead and static objects, living things have more Power of Existence. The Unrestrained Spells accomplish their amazing feats by influencing reality at large. The summoning of a god within the human world requires massive amounts of influence upon reality.

to:

* Power of Existence is a metaphor for influence upon reality. Being from another world, All the Denizens cannot influence magic of the human world unless they obtain influence from those who exist. Everything has an impact upon reality, so everything has the Power of Existence. Because living things can influence their world more than dead and static objects, living things have more Power of Existence. The Unrestrained Spells accomplish their amazing feats series is accomplished by influencing reality at large. The summoning of a god within reality. Love is the human world requires massive amounts of strongest Unrestrained Spell because when present in a person, love has unlimited influence upon reality.on their being!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During Yuji's fight against Shana, he reveals the nature of "Silver" to Margery Daw to stop her from breaking through his barrier. At first it appears as a generic KickTheDog BreakTheHaughty moment, but when you think about it, she would've found about "Silver" later anyway, and her contract would've ended then because she would've been devoid of purpose; that way, she can continue without pursuing Silver. Granted, he still did KickTheDog, and [[BreakTheHaughty break her he did]], but it wasn't really the worst thing he could've done, which reveals the high probability that Snake of the Festival isn't as bad as he appears.

to:

* During Yuji's fight against Shana, he reveals the nature of "Silver" to Margery Daw to stop her from breaking through his barrier. At first it appears as a generic KickTheDog BreakTheHaughty moment, but when you think about it, she would've found about "Silver" later anyway, and her contract would've ended then because she would've been devoid of purpose; that way, she can continue without pursuing Silver. Granted, he still did KickTheDog, and [[BreakTheHaughty break her he did]], but it wasn't really the worst thing he could've done, which reveals the high probability that Snake of the Festival isn't as bad as he appears.appears.
* Power of Existence is a metaphor for influence upon reality. Being from another world, the Denizens cannot influence the human world unless they obtain influence from those who exist. Everything has an impact upon reality, so everything has the Power of Existence. Because living things can influence their world more than dead and static objects, living things have more Power of Existence. The Unrestrained Spells accomplish their amazing feats by influencing reality at large. The summoning of a god within the human world requires massive amounts of influence upon reality.

Added: 192

Changed: 77

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Knowledge of the Crimson World is apparently enough of a buffer to remember people who've lost their existence. But by all means, get indignant about things you haven't bothered to learn.




to:

** The relevance of "isn't really a person" was discussed. ''Very early on.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

to:

* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to take the MacGuffin away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.
fool. The series having a central character who isn't even really a person is one of the ''other'' reasons I call bullshit on the whole series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Since living forever just gives the universe more opportunities to kill you, eventually something will happe to his MacGuffin and he will vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

to:

* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Since living forever Even if his MacGuffin allowed him to live forever, that just gives the universe more opportunities to kill you, eventually something will happe to his take the MacGuffin and he will away. He WILL vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

Added: 350

Changed: 497

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** But if everything about you was erased from existence, why are people like Shana or even her enemies able to remember them at all? If you ate someone by wiping them out from existence such that even their past is gone, ''you'd forget that you'd just ate somebody!'' There'd also be nothing left in the universe for you to even BASE a torch on, and people would immediately forget about the person even WITH a torch. It's logical snarls like that that had me call bullshit on the entire series.
* Yuji isn't real. He doesn't exist. Since living forever just gives the universe more opportunities to kill you, eventually something will happe to his MacGuffin and he will vanish from the world. No one will remember him. Shana KNOWS that he's not a real person, but just a convincing shadow, and yet she allows herself to forget this. What a fool.

Added: 306

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


FridgeBrilliance:

to:

FridgeBrilliance:!!FridgeLogic
* If any evidence that you ever existed is deleted when your existence is devoured, what happens to any children you may have had?
** They stay, but lose all their memories about you. Except when someone takes your place like Shana does once, which seems a good way to easily get a family.

!!FridgeBrilliance

Top