Follow TV Tropes
Setting Coco aside (which I enjoyed the heck out of), and watching this special alone, I can say the story works better as a TV special than as a theatrical featurette. It apparently got a better reception when aired on TV, and it probably should have stayed there, or the theatrical version should have been edited.
Now as a TV special, it's good. It's not up there with A Charlie Brown Christmas or Mickey's Christmas Carol (that might have been a better pairing with Coco), but it's something I wouldn't mind watching again. The songs are nice, the characters are done well, and they didn't skimp on the visuals (even when this was going to be a TV special).
So I can understand if some were annoyed by having to wait longer to see the main attraction, but now that it's no longer an issue, I hope we can accept this as the harmless, simple, fun story it was meant to be.
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?