Of course it's possible for Elmo to be both The Scrappy and an Ensemble Dark Horse. The reason why both pages are on the YMMV tab is because he can be seen as each to some portion of the population, even if he can't logically be both in the mind of any one person.
Of course it's possible for Elmo to be both The Scrappy and an Ensemble Dark Horse. The reason why both pages are on the YMMV tab is because he can be seen as each to some portion of the population, even if he can't logically be both in the mind of any one person.